FabFitFun Upcoming Box Poll – Pick This or That Round #19!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

If you aren’t familiar, Katie Kitchens is the Co-Founder of FabFitFun, and she often shares potential future products on her Instagram feed to get feedback! Here are some of the latest potential future box items. (FYI – these are not confirmed products, they may or may not be in future boxes, and they also may not be in the same box.)

And, if you aren’t familiar with FabFitFun, it’s a quarterly subscription box for women that costs $49.99 a box and sends you over $200 worth of items.

Which would you prefer in an upcoming FabFitFun box:

Source: Katieakitchens

Beauty Bakerie Proof is in the Puddin’ Eyeshadow Palette OR Paper Source 12 Month Floral Planner

Let us know which item you would prefer in the comments!

(FYI – FabFitFun transitioned to a new Warehouse Management System in the past few months and there have been some issues in shipping since then. Some readers have reported not receiving their Summer Box or Summer Edit sale items yet. We’ll update when we have more information, but please keep in mind that shipping may be delayed with FabFitFun orders currently.)

If you haven’t signed up for FabFitFun yet, use this link and coupon code FALL50 to get the Fall box for just $24.99! (See my review of this box here.)

How do subscribers rate FabFitFun?

924 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to FabFitFun? Add your rating now!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in FabFitFun Box News, Subscription Box News| Tags: fabfitfun | 190 comments


  1. I need a planner, so yeah, planner.

    • I need a planner

      • Definitely the planner

      • I also need a planner!!! Definitely!!

        • Definitely the palette… so pretty.

      • El planificador o agenda me parece la mejor opción 💖


      • Good choice, the planner is really cute!

    • PLANNER! 😊

  2. Ugh don’t love either, but would pick the planner even though I find the design to be too much. I like simple designs on things I carry in my bag.

    • Agree. Planner, but with design choices. 🙂

      • I collect and never use both, so either will do 🤣

    • Planner!

      • neither

  3. Planner please!

    • This is the first This or That that I’ve actually been excited about. I love both of these options!

      • I’m not sold on either of these….but I would probably go with the planner

  4. None of the above.

  5. Planner – I agree with most, I get beauty subs and lots of palettes that way so would prefer the lifestyle product. Even if you don’t use them this is much more giftable then the palette.

  6. Planner! I already have a dozen eye shadow palettes from makeup sub boxes. Definitely don’t want it in a lifestyle box too.

  7. Planner!!!

  8. Planner, but I would be happy with either one.

    • I would rather have the planner. I have other subscription boxes that I get for makeup specifically. So I would like things like this in my Fab Fit Fun Box. Thanks y’all.

      • Me too, I love to receive lifestyle item rather than beauty stuff, because I already have ipsy and boxycharm

        • Me too Ive had both those and now I have the boxy luxe and ipsy plus . Lol soooo yea don’t need another makeup subscription.

  9. Palette – so cute! I’d love to have both though!

  10. Both are cute!

  11. I love the shadows colors in the pan but these look like pretty bad quality. Each swatch was gone over at least twice and isn’t that great and I’ve got three planners because I can’t resist buying them and use 0 anyway.

  12. Haha, I would like both if the planner had a more appealing cover, this one is so.. average.

  13. I’m the odd man out….. I like them both!

  14. Planner

    • Planner

    • I hope there is a 3rd option.

  15. Neither.. I don’t wear that much eye shadow, and I keep my calendar on my phone.
    No use for either.
    Would love to see a mixed box of lip paint or glosses.

  16. Planner. I subscribe to a lot of beauty boxes so I have my share of palletes as well as beauty products. I wanted to try this brand but I love warmer colors like the two faced pumpkin spice pallete or the gingerbread spicy. Why can’t we add the the two instead of having a mystery item.

  17. Most definitely the eyeshadow! I don’t intend to plan.

  18. I will likely use neither but the palette has slightly better odds of being tried or even regifted.

  19. Neither – palette is WAY too warm toned for me and I have a specific planner I use each year.

  20. The eyeshadow qualify looks atrocious, and the planner is extremely boring. I say neither, wow, I hope this is not what we get!

  21. Planner!

    • Planner

  22. Planner 🙂 No more palettes!!!

  23. Neither – there was just another warm-toned palette a few boxes ago and with their shipping I wouldn’t expect a 2020 planner to be on time for the new year.

    • Ditto this.

  24. I have a stack of palettes very similar to that one. The colors are way too warm for me. I would definitely choose the planner.

  25. I already have a planner for the upcoming year & I don’t wear eyeshadow. I *DO* love the Beauty Bakerie brand though, so perhaps the eyeshadow palette – but really, I’d love a setting powder, face palette, blush, ANY other product from Beauty Bakerie the most 💗

  26. Eyeshadow

    I don’t plan

  27. Love the colours in the palette! 😀

    • Love the colors in the palette! I have a planner already!

    • Planner!

  28. Planner, I am so over palettes.

    • Ditto!

      • Proof Is In The Pudding palette

    • Planner please

  29. Neither (palette shades are too warm and digital/app-based planners are more versatile).

  30. Planner

  31. Neither. I don’t use paper planners, and though I’m in favor of Beauty Bakerie as a brand, I neither need nor am excited by eyeshadow palettes.

  32. The eyeshadow palette, definitely. I wouldn’t use a paper planner, I do all of my scheduling online.

  33. Planner!

    • The planner for sure

  34. planner!

    • Planner also!

  35. Usually I’d say eyeshadow and I’ve always wanted to try BB but is it me or do those swatches look patchy? So I’d vote planner.

  36. Planner!

  37. Not liking the colors on that palette. But definitely open to the Planner!!

  38. Palette

  39. Planner. The colors are too warm for me in the palette.

  40. Planner if it’s in the Winter box.

  41. Neither . Use online/app planners now and I’ve had enough of the generic eye palettes.

  42. Beauty Bakerie is an independent woman- and black-owned makeup company (with adorable packaging), I’d love to see them supported and in a box!

  43. NEITHER! I’ve got more eyeshadow palettes than I know what to do with. And I haven’t carried around a paper planner since college. That’s what phones are for! Totally useless item for anyone who’s not in school anymore.

    • ….A planner would be a particularly terrible option, since with all the shipping issues FFF winter boxes often don’t arrive until sometime in January, after the year has already started. So we couldn’t even gift them.

    • I know-phones are great-However I work in a secure environment where we are discouraged from carrying a phone, so while I am not in school I find an old fashion planner a must.

      • I work from home so I use a planner. I use my phone for calling and texting.

    • Planner please!! 😁

  44. No more palettes, and I don’t like the layout of the agenda. Mystery item.

  45. Don’t go by the picture above for accuracy of the eyeshadow palette. Look at company website. The shades are completely different.

    For this or that: Both

  46. Paper Source Calendar. May assist in my constant struggle to stay on top of my family’s schedule.

  47. The eyeshadow palette. At least I might use that or would be able to gift it. I never use planners and no one I know would want it either.

  48. Planner!

  49. Beauty Bakery palette for me but it would be nice to be able to buy both

  50. beauty bakerie

    • Same. I don’t use planners as they can’t send me notifications to do something and am in palette overload. Same with scarves, hats, and throws. I could cover my whole living room with throws from boxes.

      • Planner

      • These options scream “unsubscribe” to me. Who still uses a paper planner?

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!