MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm Premium January 2020 Spoiler #1!

BoxyCharm Premium November 2019 Spoiler #1!

We have the first spoiler for the November 2019 BoxyCharm Premium thanks to Yosef! (Thanks for the heads up, Jennifer!)

The November 2019 BoxyCharm Premium will include:

Natasha Denona Bloom Blush & Glow Palette – $55

What do you think of the spoiler?

Here’s everything you need to know about BoxyCharm Premium:

  • It’s $35 a month
  • 6-7 beauty items a box
  • $175+ Value
  • You get to pick one of the items
  • The items will be different from BoxyCharm/BoxyLuxe – you can subscribe to both with no product overlap.

Sign up for the waitlist here!

Here are all the details from BoxyCharm about this new Premium subscription and changes they are making to the BoxyCharm/BoxyLuxe subscriptions:

Last year we brought you BoxyLuxe. This November we’re introducing BoxyCharm Premium, a
NEW and BIGGER monthly beauty box valued at a minimum of $175 for only $35 a month!

Quantities will be limited. Be sure to sign-up to the interest list here.

That’s not all
You asked. We listened!
(For ALL Charmers – BoxyCharm, Premium and Luxe)

CUSTOMIZATION – Now, this one is huge! From the first beauty subscription that
brought you full-size products, we’re bringing complexion customization out of the store
and into your home. In November, you will receive a complexion pack to test and select
your perfect shade for future Boxys. Stay tuned for more details!
CHOICE – Now, the power is yours! You get the chance to choose one product in your
box each month. You don’t have to wait. Choice for October will OPEN TODAY! Follow
our Instagram Stories to know when it opens. @boxycharm
ADD-ONS – Now, you can have it all! We’re introducing Add-Ons at member-exclusive
prices with free shipping. But hurry! Quantities are limited and will be available first
come, first served. Add-On your favorite products starting Thursday, September 19th,
2019. Follow our Instagram Stories to know when it opens. @boxycharm
BOXYPOPUP – Now, back by popular demand, BoxyPopUp is here to stay! Starting this
November (just in time for Holiday shopping) and returning every 3 months, indulge in
up to 80% off top makeup, skincare and lifestyle products.

VALUE – Now, your BoxyCharm is even bigger and worth even more! We are increasing
the minimum value of each BoxyCharm from $100 to over $125 starting this November.

To Charm you with Customization, Choice, Add-On, BoxyPopUp, and over $125 Value (up from
$100), we’re updating the BoxyCharm subscription price to $25 per month starting November
1, 2019. The price of BoxyLuxe will remain the same.

We hope you’re as excited as we are about BoxyCharm Premium and the Charmer benefits
we’ve been working on just for you. We can’t wait to keep Charming you!

Your BoxyCharm Team

What do you think of these new changes? Are you going to sign up for BoxyCharm Premium?

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm boxes, and our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more about this subscription.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, BoxyCharm Premium Spoilers, BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 136 comments

Comments (136)

  1. Waitlist is open!!!!

    • Yes but it says you have to be active subscriber to get premium. I don’t want to sign up for October regular box so I can get premium next month.

    • Yesssss! Crossing my fingers. So am I only way to find out if they charge me extra $35 on Nov 1st?

      • Omg I think I’m on premium list. I just got confirmation email from BC. Yay!

      • Go to My account > account preference. You will see the status under Boxycharm Premium. Mine is waitlist now. It will change to Active if you are going to get the box. I just dont know if its going to change after I got charged on Nov 1st or before if we are assigned to one.

      • I see my status as waiting. 😅
        I was so exciting for min I thought I was in.

      • I was the same way! So disappointed. I signed up immediately after it was announced.

      • Susan- What time did you sign up exactly?

    • I signed up for the waitlist the second I saw the email! So excited, hopefully I signed up fast enough to get the November premium. I want the Natasha Denona blush palette so bad

      • I love love everything about all my boxes’. RW

  2. Oh my 🤯🥰🥰🥰 Boxy Gods please 🙏🏻 Take me off the waitlist!!!!

    • Does anyone know when they are going to open the waitlist? I’m scared that it is going to be like the Boxyluxe release and I don’t wanna miss this one. I’m on the interest list, but I still haven’t seen anything about when the waitlist opens.

      • I just got off the waitlist today…I just signed up in late September and got my September and October Box the same day. I was honestly surprised to get off the list this fast.

  3. I am so fed up with Boxy. Too much bait and switch. But…damn FOMO. Sometimes its a great value, but when I really look at what products I actually end up using vs just buying what I really want it’s not so great. My last few boxes were SO awful. The most recent box went straight in the trash. The constant bait and switch has infuriated me to to no end as well. I am sure it will be the same with the Premium, flash some amazing products then – oh wait, we don’t have enough so you’ll get this $7 eyeliner instead. Part of me is like “YOU MUST GET THIS” and then my BRAIN asks, “Are you really that stupid?” I hope I end up not being that stupid LOL.

    • Yes, the FOMO is real! Yesterday, Joe answered someone’s doubts about getting the ND palette by saying “why do negative. Every Premium Box will get the ND”. The lack of any acknowledgement of WHY someone would doubt what the would ACTUALLY receive was enough to keep me strong!

    • Haha, I got the $7 liner in my Sept box, and the never mentioned black sponge (claims to be $40, are you kidding me??) this month. Both very disappointing items. I understand that we cant expect to like all 5 items every month. However getting my least preferable selection month after month accompanying with low quality item is a bit too much. Luckily I was able to ‘control’ 🙂 myself in only getting BC a few boxes a year. Then most of the items are ‘new’ to me. I also find cancelling and re-subscribing after when wanted helps. I am starting to donate my untouched items, which is a lot, to my local community. At least put the products in use or to make someone happy.

  4. Hi Liz…. There is charms in the boxycharm room at this time. They have a elemis oil for $55.00 in charms and 2 touch in sol eyeliners, the Dominique cosmetics peach tea lip gloss and the alamar tesoro lip gloss as well…

    • Elemis oil sold out 🙁

  5. I’m so lost. If I only get Boxy Premium, would I get the ND palette as well as the Dose of Colors lipstick (or Becca powder)? Or will I only get both if I order both Boxy Premium and Boxy Charm?

  6. I would rejoin the Boxy family in a snap if I could get the Premium and have this palette. The first time I saw it was love. Unfortunately, my expectations are low after my invitation to Luxe was botched last year. Since then, this is the first item that has been so tempting I’d consider going back.

  7. I really want that Natasha Denona face palette a lot of my fav influencers on yotube have it and love it. I already signed up to be notified when the waitlist opens I hope I see the email in time to get it though. I have been on the list for Fashionsta for a while and have not heard a thing from them. I love Boxcharm and will gladly pay for all three boxes and for Ipsy I will stickwith the regular glam bag and GBP, I cancelled Ultimate at the last minute and boy am I glad I did! I watched some unboxings and it was a lot of brands I never heard of before.

    • I have gotten an email around the first of the month every month to get off the wait list and sign up. They open it up monthly at that time so you may want to check it out. I’ve chosen to not sign up since asking to be notified so I get the emails monthly

  8. I hope I make it off the waitlist for November because I want this so bad. I signed up the second they announced Premiun so fingers crossed

  9. Is this guaranteed for all premium members?

    • Yes. Joe said so in a message to Yari G.

  10. When does boxyluxe spoilers come out?
    When is the next boxyluxe?
    And how much would it cost to get both boxyluxe and premium in same month ?

    And if you subbed to all three regular BC, premium and luxe that be a lot money for one month and probably some similar items does that sound right

    Thanks 🥴

    • Luxe isn’t until December. You can’t get Luxe without having the base box so you would have to get all 3 if you want to have both Premium and Luxe. That would cost $60 on non-Luxe months and $85 on Luxe months. If you have all 3 under the same account you are not supposed to get any duplicates.

  11. It says that I’m on the list for the premium box, when does boxy take out the first payment? At the same time it’s takes out for the regular box, and I thought we get a choice item with the premium as well? Also when does boxy take out for the Luxe box… I’m confused

    • You are just on the interest list. You will still have to sign up when they make it available. They bill on the 1st every month.

  12. Is there a waitlist available or a list to be notified when the waitlist is available?

  13. I’ve been wanting to try an ND product but that dark red blush makes me nervous 😬

    • The blush actually sheers out nicely, watch her videos using it on Sephora’s website. Her products are amazing. This was on my wishlist so I’m excited. I have 4 of her eyeshadow palettes and her highlight palette as well.

  14. Exactly!

  15. Okay, they got me. I am going to stick with Boxy and drop Ipsy except maybe the basic bag. I canceled my BoxyLuxe for September and regret it so much after seeing my Ipsy Ultimate. So now I am resubscribed to Boxy and Luxe, and on the wait list for Premium. I want a few awesome things like this palette instead of a bunch of okay but not so exciting stuff. Premium seems like it should be for those who have been getting lots of subs for a while and want something more, higher end items. Please Boxy, don’t let me down!

  16. When I first saw this I just about squealed with delight because I had just discovered it and added it to my Sephora wishlist this very morning. But then reality started sinking in. Will I even get this first Premium box? I signed the waitlist the minute Liz posted it but I wasn’t actually subscribed then. I’d just left after nearly 5 years because of all of Boxy’s shenanigans. I have since rejoined thanks to my intense addiction, but I imagine I wasn’t truly put on the list until I resubbed, if then. So many things they do seem totally random with no rhyme or reason and definitely little to no fairness/equality.

    After reading all these comments I see most people feel the same about not trusting anything that’s said, even if it’s presented with what appears to be certainty.

    Yosef can put out all the videos he wants but let’s face it. If he wasn’t so (knowingly) attractive and frighteningly convincing and sincere sounding, people wouldn’t be as quick to believe him when he’s got such a terrible track record. After all…
    He’s been known to say lots of “nice” things, particularly nice promises after major disasters that set records for sub box public outcries of anger and frustration. After what happened when BoxyLuxe went live and SO many people got completely cheated, and spent several hours for the privilege, he swore he’d do something to make it up to us. He was just so contrite and and almost tearful about how upset his Charmers were. Especially those of us that had been subscribed for years that got bumped by someone that just joined right before the launch due to his massive advertising blitz that reeled in probably five times more people than he actually had product for.
    Of course…he never did a thing. Just didn’t mention it counting on people to forget about or just tolerate it because the reality is that Boxy is a good deal value-wise, particularly for young people who would otherwise not be able to grow their makeup arsenal so quickly and successfully without it.

    Then there’s the promise made over and over that they’re starting customization this month, no that month (and ends up being the next year but with only one product which turns out to be another epic failure.)
    And of course the many advertised products mentioned here where he promotes the heck out of exciting brands/products he knows everyone wants knowing full well he will only deliver to Influencers, Vloggers and maybe a tiny percentage of regular members. But oh well, you have to do what it takes to entice new business and scare frustrated customers into staying for fear of missing out on these amazing products.

    So I don’t just take what he says with a grain of salt. I unscrew the top of the shaker and throw back a big ‘ol mouthful. And guess what. I’m exactly the kind of person that will do just that. I desperately want to avoid getting my hopes up given past experiences, but I also REALLY want that palette! 🤦‍♀️😁

    • I love that you describe my thoughts perfectly. When I saw this the temptation was soooo strong I almost broke..

      then I closed my eyes, backed away slowly while whispering my new mantra ‘Not today, satan, not today…’

      • Same here. I’m tempted to resubscribe, but I was just saved from doing so.

    • Am I the only one who doesn’t think he’s cute? I see women swooning all the time over him but I’m not on board lol. I dont think hes badlooking, I’m just not gaga crazy holy cow hes hot about him . Your comment amused me.

      • You’re not the only one. He might not be bad looking, but then again, he’s not really my type either. I don’t really go for the douchy pretty boy type. 🤮
        He’s also the reason why I’m still mulling whether or not I should resubscribe to Boxycharm (I cancelled in August). The boxes may be good most of the time (even if I don’t get the variation/product(s) I was hoping to get), but the fact that Boxycharm’s CEO is a total prick makes my stomach churn. Right now I’m sticking with Ipsy.

      • No, same. I don’t see the appeal.
        But then again, I’m thankfully not into men.

      • Haha! Some times I wish I wasn’t into them. They are real “spina nel culos” as my Italian friends would say.

      • I don’t think he’s attractive in the least and I don’t fall for his charm either. I’ve never felt that he’s honest or really cares about Boxy subscribers. I think he’s full of it and full of himself.💁

      • Ugh. The FOMO and frustration is so real. I would love to get all three. But after my last few boxes and even my last couple luxe boxes were total letdowns and complete garbage that I will never use, I’m not prepared to hand over that much money every month yet. I told myself I’m gonna wait and see a few premium boxes before I even think about allowing myself to go there. My mom and my sister just cancelled completely after these terrible quality dose of colors palettes and dollar store sponges and five dollar lip pencils for October. I’m using one item from my box this month. Just one. And that one item isn’t even that great. There’s no value in that for me and it’s insulting to have been a costumer for so long and feel like I see everyone else getting better items. The bait and switch someone else in this thread mentioned is very real. They suck you in with the first few boxes you’re thrilled with, and then it just feels like they are throwing old random leftovers at you after that. I keep getting the variations I always want the least. My family members cancelled because the quality has gone way down and the repeated items and useless things just became too much. They are convinced that now all the good items will be going to premium and luxe and the regular boxes will be even worse now. Just random and old news items used as filler to keep you coming back. And no matter how much I like and want this palette, or any product really, I think it’s ridiculous that you have to get all three. I don’t see any real reason they can’t let you subscribe to premium and luxe without the regular if you so choose. That’s one of the things my mom was upset about. She said she’ll think about coming back when they make it an option for you to get regular and luxe or premium and luxe, but forcing you to have all three so you don’t miss out feels like highway robbery. Especially when he comes up with excuses and tries to schmooze people and gloss it over every time a launch doesn’t go as planned and he’s got angry customers and explaining to do. I need to see how this all plays out before I make myself even more angry at handing over another $35 for things I’m just gonna be disappointed in. There’s so many subs out there now and up and coming ones that I have my eye on as well that I’m not sure how long they’ll be able to keep me if things don’t start looking up.

  17. Nice spoiler. But, I’m sure they will make a great first box since people have to purchase base and premium the first month. And then only open 50 spots for waitlist And then like everything else it will be bait and switch the next month. When everyone gets off the waitlist.

  18. Does anyone know what day we can subscribe to this box?

  19. Is anyone actually subscribed to Boxy Premium yet or its still on waitlist mode for everyone?

    • It’s new and is starting in November and yes I am signed up for it

      • I dint think anyone is actually signed up. There’s only a wait list.

  20. Super excited for the premium box, since this is a confirmed 1st spoiler and it’s for everyone. Can’t wait for the waitlist to open! You rarely see ND in sub boxes.

  21. Hmmmmm….That’s nice, if EVERYONE is going to receive it! We all know that Boxy is famous for the bait and switch and 50 variations!! So, we’ll see.

    • People’s tolerance for that bait & switch mess will lessen the more they’re paying for these boxes. So what people might be willing to let slide at $21 is not gonna fly at higher price ranges. Boxy is going to learn that the hard way if cheap wooden pencils and cheap subscription box brands start showing up in these higher tier boxes. Case in point- Ipsy GBU.

      • I just cancelled all of my ipsy subscriptions.. (And i had all 3!) Bc of that BS they pulled this month! I’m getting the same cheesy “Betty Boop” palette in my $50 box, and the $25 one.. Along with a bunch of leftovers! Booo to Ipsy! Im still annoyed!

  22. Boxy Premium is not playing! If this is what we can expect I’m really excited. That palette is drop dead gorgeous!

  23. Agreed Boxy is famous for BAIT SND SWITCH. If you’re one of the lucky ones to get this congratulations on you’re YouTube channel!

    • 😂😂😂
      OMG that was priceless! Made my day.
      But sadly, so true.

    • Agree. Not falling for it. I was cheated out of DOC for October. They must really think I’m stupid if I were to fall for Premium ads. Goid luck to those of you willing to give him your money. I work so hard for mine I’m not going to gamble it away on this conpany. I could go to a casino for that and have better chances to be a winner .

  24. Wowzers!!!! 🤯🤪😁👍😍

  25. Nice spoiler but I’m not biting, nope. Baited and switched too many times.
    Based on past evidence Natasha Denona will go to 3 selected subscribers and my ‘variation’ will have another black eyeliner instead.

    Also, all ‘announcements through Instagram stories’, really? I have a job, a family and a life and do not spend my days glued to Instagram watching brands’ stories.

    • What she said!!

    • No lies detected!

    • If they don’t send this to all subscribers after using it to hype the new box Boxycharm Premium will be dead in the water. Boxy is on a lot of people’s (including mine) chopping blocks because of increasingly deceptive spoilers and B&S tactics using high value/desirable items that few people actually receive. They need to deliver a great box that is fair to all customers if they are going to make this work. So I guess we’ll just stay tuned and see how it works.

    • Right? Who wants to sit around watching to see what they’re going to do? Nobody has time for that. I have MSA notifications on so I can find out what my subs are doing, because I’m not gluing myself to social media all day.

  26. I totally want this pallet!! I signed up for premium but they have yet to confirm that I will be getting it! They feed us these amazing spoilers and half the time we dont even get the items that we want! I’m going to give it a try next month but if it doesnt deliver then I’m definitely canceling. I’m also upset that they are throwing in past items in the box along with TWEEZERS!! LIKE REALLY COME ON!!

  27. I signed up for the waitlist, but not sure I’ll actually do it. This is a great star item, but I don’t use blush much at all. I’ll eagerly be waiting for more spoilers before I try it. Either way, I’ll keep the base box so I can keep Luxe!

  28. Okay, I am interested. Hopefully they have enough boxes for the demand. I signed up for the wait list, so we will see.

  29. I would sign up if it was guaranteed everyone would receive this palette but it’s always bait and switch 😡

  30. I have this palette and love it. Great spoiler!

  31. Can’t wait to get my hands on the premium box

  32. Not even going to get a bit excited about this. Boxy pulls the bait and switch like no other. 🤦🏻‍♀️ By the time launch hits there will be 44 other variations only of which 1 or 2 will probably contain this spoiler. Hope I’m wrong…. but their record kinda speaks for itself 🤷🏻‍♀️

    • Agreed. They have burned us time and again. I will be waiting to see how this turns out. Would I like the palette? Yes. Do I need the palette and the do I want the inevitable stress that signing up for this box entails? Nope. I’ll stick with the regular Boxy for now, and watch the circus unfold.

      • Same. I’m still waiting to see of I’m getting what was advertised for my October BC box. Not falling for any bait and switch.

      • Just got my box, variation 38! No Paula’s Choice, but no eyeliner either ( or mascara it’s a box miracle!). So not what was spoiled and kept my interest.

      • Interesting! I hope mine arrives by Saturday.

      • 38? That’s a new record I think 🤔

      • I got variation 39! It included a Tarteist Proglow item I received in a box about a year and a half ago. HATED it then (patchy, pure glitter with no glow) and am not about to try it now. The product has no safety seal and shows it expires 6 months after opening (where do they store all this expired junk??)

      • Does that mean you got different products from what they sent to your email showing your spoilers? Oh if that’s true there may be hope for my box yet! 😄

      • I just saw a video of variation 40. It also had a variation item I had not seen in the spoilers or other videos until today – the Illuminati Cosmetic sponge.

    • Except that he already did a video story that said all premium members will get it and their wont be too many variations in the premium box..

      • There*

      • Yeah, but point to the month that Boxy hasn’t pulled a pretty massive slick one once everyone’s billing has gone through. I’m subscribed to Boxy right now too, but I fully recognized the fast ones they pull for what they are. I never stay subscribed for too long of a stretch because I get tired of the old bait and switch routine.

        I just wonder if Yosef sits back and laughs at what a bunch of suckers we all are, lol. Pretty sure he does.

      • I sincerely doubt that. I think he does actually care about his subscribers. I do think people have some unrealistic expectations. There are a million plus subscribers now, there are bound to be variations. Should they be more transparent? Yea, they should. Are they perfect? Far from it. But to say that he does it intentionally? That’s pretty unfair. Honestly, if it were my company and something ran out, I’d say tough tata, sub is closed for the month instead of substituting. But, that’s why I walk dogs and am not running a customer service based business anymore. Dogs appreciate every single thing you do for them which is something that is virtually impossible in a business model like sub boxes, where products are, technically, supposed to be a mystery.

      • Thanks for the info. That’s good that he did that. But I’d like to know what he thinks is too many variations? It’s pretty subjective. And unfortunately I think there are a lot of us that are distrustful of what they say given their past behavior. I just can’t take their word for it anymore. But hopefully they are listening to their subscribers and will make real changes. Enjoy your box if you’re getting one! I’ll definitely be keeping an eye out on this one.

      • I haven’t decided what I’m going to do yet. I have enough stuff to open up a mall kiosk, but I also have an addiction to boxes. It could be a lot worse things for sure lol. The way I justify it is that I dont buy a lot of clothes, purses and jewelry [I’m a dog walker and they are seriously unimpressed with any kind of style] and I can do some good by donating what I cant use to shelters, my friends and family or do giveaways for the FB groups I run. For the majority of my life I was extremely poor so I remember what it was like to have next to nothing. I am very working class living in the most expensive area in the US [bay area]. We have some of the richest people in the world living here and also a huge homeless population. Being homeless is incredibly hard on your body so I give away skin care and body products [along with dog food, toiletries etc] to them. It’s usually a huge sob fest but it feels really good to do. Maybe that’s why I am so unbothered by variations and other issues that happen with boxes? I mean, sometimes I wish i did get the variation i wanted, but it really isnt that important in the end, ya know? Anyways, I got side tracked…

        I am not sure what I will do. I love blush, so its tempting. But I also signed up for british beauty [yay CF and organic skincare!], bijou beauty box [cruelty free, mostly vegan and indie brands with quirky paskaging?! Yes,please!] and fashionsta a few months ago, so I kind of want to see what those bring to the table. My ipsy gbp has been lackluster the past few months so maybe I’ll skip that for a few months to check out premium

      • I love your attitude about boxes and your generosity. Thanks for sharing! 🐕 ❤️

      • Thanks Stephanie! ❤💛💚 I do try to be positive, especially about the little pleasures like makeup, because life is just a little easier when you see the good instead of the bad. And i

        It makes me feel really good giving back where I can because i know that that little bottle of high end shampoo and conditioner or lipstick would have really brought a smile to my mom’s face all those years ago when she was a single mom and had to get aid to make sure us kids were fed. She gave up a lot for us and I will always be grateful for that, because of the perspective on life it gave me. I think anyone who knows struggle can feel what I am saying. If boxes ever start making me annoyed, instead of happy, I’ll move on to something else.

      • How do you like Fashionsta? I’m on the waitlist for it and I might dump Boxy in flavor of it. I keep hearing about it on reddit but I don’t think MSA reviews it. And I totally understand about product overload. I’ve got enough stuff to last through a zombie apocalypse. I give a lot as gifts, and I have a donation pile too. But the addiction is real, and I just can’t give up my boxes. Though I have unsubscribed from a lot and only get Boxy, Ipsy and plus and Margot Elena now. But I skipped this months plus because I wasn’t thrilled with the boop stuff. But the Fashionsta box looked intriguing.

      • @julia for some reason I cannot respond to your other comment. I have only gotten one box from Fashionsta so far so I think it’s too soon for me to judge but I did enjoy my first box. I got the Melanie Mills body gleam (body highlighter), Teami matcha mask (huge tub and what I am most excited about), A serum for your Va jay jay that is supposed to help give you a closer shave and prevent knicks and bumps, a super jumbo Cailyn felt lip liquid eyeliner and a super gorgeous palette from The Beauty Crop. It’s called Dawngazing and it is in plum tones. TBC are super ingredient conscious (no talc is a big yay from me), CF and vegan. The RV of the box was $144.49 and each of the items exceeded the cost of the box (with the exception of the eyeliner which is $18 RV) . Customer service is good and the CEO is interactive with the subbers. Another plus for me is that they are very small and only sell so many boxes so that they can make sure the experience is a good one for us. They haven’t released any spoilers yet for this month (they ship at the end of the month) but I am excited to get my next box!

      • I forgot to say that I do understand the distrust [especially with the doc for glamglow substitution]. Even though I see it differently, it doesnt mean that the complaints are invalid.

      • Thanks for the Fashionsta review! It won’t let me reply directly to you either. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I might have to check it out!

      • Sure thing! We just got our first spoiler for October Fashionsta. It’s the Sigma kabuki bake brush #f89. Yay!

      • They’ve said that before. All members get “this or that” item… then they’ve snuck a third item in at last minute. You don’t recall the Tula mask fiasco back in February?

      • I do remember and I chose not to get upset about it. I am hoping they only allow a certain number of boxes to accommodate the product they have on hand and close the sub.
        Plain and simple: if you are that distrustful and set on one specific item and will be mad if you dont get it, dont take the risk. Or take the risk and find the joy in what you end up with.

    • Agree., I will not even subscribe to the new boxycharm upgrade , I’ll be happy with my regular boxycharm and boxyluxe in December then I’m cancelling and I will be subscribed to FFF instead at least it’s a quarter box which I’m sure I’ll enjoy more than boxy with all the change in price thing.

  33. I hope this is not a variant item. Im a boxy subscriber for 3 months, never received the item that Im excited to have. I already have a stash of random things that they sent to me.

    • This is for boxy premium, not regular boxycharm fyi

    • Joe said in a message to Yari G that ND palette is NOT a variant and EVERYONE with Premium will be getting it.

  34. Ok. Now I’m going to resub for sure!
    Pausing or cancelling IGBU.

  35. Now that’s a brand I want in my box! Uhhhhh “that’s what she said” 😬

    Seriously awesome looking though!

  36. did they just steal this idea from Ipsy…..hummm.

    • I think they are just back and forth. BC came out with Luxe, then Ipsy came out with Plus, then I think I got the BC email first to have Premium, then Ipsy came out with Ultimate.

      But really, Look Incredible (UK) did the multilevel box thing years earlier. They have standard, deluxe, and secret (which is luxury, like Gucci makeup). Only Deluxe is (was?) monthly. The other two were bimonthly.

      I had all three for a while but had to cut back due to $$$ and these are pretty expensive for America. Also, while the items were great, many were discontinued things from brands like Too Faced. Things I either already had or hadn’t bought because I didn’t want to.

  37. My first thought was “This is better than all of the Ultimate products combined!” and I don’t really even use blush or highlighter, so yeah. This is definitely more along the lines of what people expect and it’s what Ipsy should have done. If cost of doing so was an issue than they should have rolled out Ultimate with less quantity and higher quality, it’s pretty much been proven through the comments that quality is what we are all looking for.💁 Ipsy simply went to big. I wish they would keep the bags too, I don’t want a bag I want great products, it’s a waste of resources.

    • When they stopped putting the bags in the Plus Boxes, they said it was because they were “listening to the feedback of our customers, and we are going to out the value back into the products.” Ok, so what changed, and why did they start with the bags again? Hmmmmm?

      • They brought them back because people pitched a royal fit when they took the bags away. Moral of the story: you can’t please everyone.

    • Perfect comment!!!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 this spoiler truly is better than ALL the Ipsy ultimate products combined 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  38. I really wish we knew when the waitlist was gonna open up. That’s my only thing I have an issue with for BC. They always make us wait without a date or time for things. Not everyone can be in their phones 24/7 to be notified. Same thing with the pop up sale. I was in a meeting at the time of that opening up and by the time I got to the sale everything was gone. So now, when they open up the waitlist on a first come first serve basis, I will probably be doing something else lol

  39. Okay, are we just supposed to sign up with our email and that’s how we get on the waitlist?

    • No, we are signing up to get notified of the waitlist opening up as far as I know.

    • Is this going to be also in regular box or just in Premium box ????

      • Just the premium box

  40. Great spoiler. Here comes a Body site crash for sure

    • Boxy*

  41. I hope this isn’t gonna be like when they first rolled out BoxyLuxe, where some of us had been on the waitlist since it opened, yet almost no one got to have the first sub. Yes, I got in on the second box, but I had really wanted the first. I remember being at breakfast and trying for over an hour to get through on the Boxycharm site, only to have it crash repeatedly, then miss out.

    • Hmmm I might just pause my ipsy glam plus again to see how this subscription might go… depending on what the spoilers are. This is a good contender for the premium… I’m hoping that they have better products to follow up and that there is not a bunch of variations along with Influencers getting the better boxes, because that isnt fair. I noticed alot of influencers got the Paula’s exfoliate solution…

    • Yep. I tried that whole morning for Luxe! Literally like 4-5 hours and not only was I on the waitlist for it – but they said you HAD to be subscribed for August, to be eligible. (with the first one being in Sept 2018). Found out that was a flat out lie, since people who literally signed up that morning were able to get Luxe! I cancelled in October. (I wasn’t excited about that August box and the ONLY reason I hadn’t cancelled was to be eligible for Luxe)
      I couldn’t get past the BS they told and how badly the website was, that morning. After their first LE box fiasco, they promised they had that fixed, before the Luxe roll out. Nope.

      • Omg it was awful wasn’t it? I tried for hours before I just gave up. I got the second and third luxe before I just cancelled and kept the regular Boxy. I’m not signing up for this one until we know for sure what’s in it, and not 87 variations where maybe some get the first spoiler. Plus I’m on major product overload anyway, so I don’t really neeeeed it.

  42. Wowza! Yay. I hate that there is a wasit list I get boxy reg wonder if this will be in there as well? I hope we don’t see a huge mess up like we did when luxe first launched

    • Boxy premium is a completely separate box than regular and luxe with no overlap in products, so no, you wouldn’t get it in regular.

  43. Go ahead take my money.

  44. Do we need to subscribe to the regular Boxycharm in order to get Premium?

    • No. The way I understand it boxycharm regular and luxe are remaining the same but the premium is a separate subscription altogether. So if you want premium you don’t need regular, but if you want luxe AND premium you’d have to get regular with the upgrade to luxe plus the premium box.

    • Yes, for the 1st month. After that? You can cancel the regular and just keep the premium.

    • Yes, as someone else said, Boxy informed everyone that you must be signed up for the regular box in order to get the premium box just for the first month and then you can cancel the regular box after that.

  45. Yay!!!!!!! I only get boxy now after the ipsy fiasco!!! Really excited!!

  46. This is awesome – just hope they are not throwing out the best product we’re ever going to get to lure us in LOL. I also don’t like that I have to buy both the regular Boxy and the Premium if I want to keep Luxe (with Premium.) We should be able to do Luxe and Premium without the extra regular Boxy. I only want the Premium monthly and the Luxe, not all three.

    • Im kinda not too impressed. I think the original boxycharm almost always had a value over 100 dollars. More like 125, i thought. Natasha denona is a cool brand but i can use only so much highlighter and blush. Im really curious about what they meant by foundation swatches though. Does that mean full sized foundations are on their way or that theyre just gonna send foundation samples? Im more curious about that..

      • I’m with you – I don’t wear powder highlighters and although I’d love to try a Natasha Denona product, this isn’t it for me. Well, because I’m in Canada I can save $53 CDN now after shipping & exchange since I won’t want the Premium so my wallet is happy.

      • They are sending small testers in different colors so you can match your skin tone and they are going to start adding foundations and things like that.

    • I agree and that’s most likely what’s going to stop me from getting the premium. That Luxe box is amazing, but I’m not spending $60 a month on boxycharm. That’s crazy talk!!

  47. Ohhh my Got!!!! I like it!!!

    • Yaaaassss!

    • Hmmm I might just pause my ipsy glam plus again to see how this subscription might go… depending on what the spoilers are. This is a good contender for the premium… I’m hoping that they have better products to follow up and that there is not a bunch of variations along with Influencers getting the better boxes, because that isnt fair. I noticed alot of influencers got the Paula’s exfoliate solution…

    • Is this going to be also in regular box or just in Premium box ????

  48. One single spoiler and it Is so much better than all the products from the ipsy Ultimate and for 15 DLLs less???!!

    • Presuming this isn’t a total bait and switch and Premium actually represents an upgrade in the brands, this is knocks IPSY Ultimate completely out of the running.

      The only time I’ve ever seen Natasha Denon in a beauty box is Beautylish’s Lucky Boxes and they are at a significantly higher price point.

      While blushers themselves aren’t what I need – Hell I don’t “need” anything based on what I have stashed (e.g. hoarded) away but if one isn’t willing to deal with getting stuff in beauty categories then subscribing to any beauty box makes no sense. Spend your money on exactly what you need :-).

      I would rather have five high premium “rarely” sampled brands versus a quantity of middle range PLUS Deluxe Samples.

      I would expect that Deluxe Samples are probably free to the Beauty Box anyway.

    • Right?! Omg, I got mine yesterday and it was worse in person. The only nice thing was that the farmacy was the big 3.4oz and not the smaller 1.7 like boxy sent out.

  49. YESSSSSSS! Now that’s what I am talking about. Ipsy Ultimate….take note!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.