BoxyCharm November 2019 Choice Time!


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

It’s time to pick one of the items for your November 2019 BoxyCharm box!

First, all subscribers will receive:

Dominique Cosmetics Celestial Thunder Eye Shadow Palette

AND now you can pick between:

Your Choice of Juice Beauty Stem Cellular Anti-Wrinkle Eye Treatment or Kypris Antioxidant Dew Quench & Glow Serum for your November Box.

Click here to make your selection! (You have until October 9th, to make your selection.)

Which item are you picking?

Now through 10/31, click here and use coupon code TRICKORTARTE to get a free Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette OR Tarte Tarteist™ PRO Glow Cheek Palette (each valued at $45) with your first BoxyCharm box!

*Valid for new subscriptions or those who canceled before September 1, 2019. Valid for the month of October 2019, or while supplies last.
(If you aren’t familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $21. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

How do subscribers rate BOXYCHARM?

1721 subscribers rated this subscription
4.4
out of 5 stars
Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to BOXYCHARM? Add your rating now!


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Boxycharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 410 comments

410 Comments

  1. So my October box was 1lb. No dimensions and I got :

    – DOC palette in baked Browns – happy with bc the colors are great for fall/winter
    – TIS – glassy skin balm happy to try out
    – Iconic London- in barely Nude – probably use as a dab in middle of my lips for a dimension of color over a darker matte lipstick
    – Paula’s choice – so glad I got this cant wait to use it
    -Jonteblu lip liner pencil – in hot red – blah

    Overall very happy with BC this month 🥰🥰

    Hope you all got what ya want !!!

    • Wow you must have been a very good girl this year!! You got the elusive Paula’s choice and you aren’t even a influencer (or are you🤨😜) lol. Congrats to you 👍👍

      • Lol 😂😂 thanks Denise – made me laugh – yeah I couldn’t believe it either – I usually get everything I never wanted lol

  2. I got my box today, variation 17. I got the Blushing Berries palette and Iconic gloss in Sex Kitten. They don’t look bad together. I also received the Iconic setting spray which to be honest smells like my Grandma. I also got a cruddy black pencil liner and the mellow brow gel in dark brown. I’m strawberry blonde… I tried it out just to be funny and I look like I have clown eyebrows. 😫 Better than my broken water bottle last month? idk idk

  3. My email spoilers were correct but during Addons the mascara and original spray said box items under Oct box so I didn’t order them in addons… Well my 4th and 5th items were actually a Laura Geller Baked Gelato Swirl Illuminator in Diamond Dust and a black Illuminati Cosmetic Sponge. I’m definitely not mad about it. I have plenty of mascara , and I did add on the Iconic spray in Glow. Almost ordered a makeup sponge earlier today and now I don’t have to. 🙂

  4. I received my box variation 27❤️ And it contains Paulas Choice!!
    My DoC is covered in shadow. The brush is brown, the palette is covered inside and out, the inside of the box is dirty, and the outside of the box has shadow. Did anyone else notice this?

    • What was your weight?

    • What was your weight

    • Same with mine but nothing was broken. I thought the brush was used it was so dirty. Oh well

  5. Imagine how much happier people would have been if they just did the DOC palettes and the customization was to choose your colors. Everyone would get the same thing and a customization at the same time.

    I am new to this, but I don’t understand all of the variables. Pick the products, hit the value mark, and make customizations simple – same type of product/value and customize brand, type or color.

    • See, but that makes too much sense, though! 😉

  6. Hi everyone, I’m looking to trade my baked Browns palette for any of the others! Let’s swap

    • I have blushing berries to trade.

      • Hi heather do you still have blushing berries?

        • I do still have blushing berries

  7. My Mother In Law received her tracking with box weight (1.65 ). She signed up for the Tarte promotion.
    She did not get the spoiler email with a Dose pallete so we assume she will not get one. I’m thinking she will receive the Tarte Blush pallete, which would be fine by me. I received Clay Play last month and I gave her my Dose Blushing Berries Pallete. Whichever free pallete that comes she is giving to me.

  8. I emailed BC and they told me everything I’m getting in my October box

    DOC blushing berries palette (so excited it’s the one I wanted)

    Touch in Sol balm (my choice)

    Iconic London gloss in love struck

    Smashbox always on eyeliner (excited for this but would’ve loved Paula’s Choice)

    Black makeup sponge (would’ve preferred the tweezers but as long as the quality is good I can always use more makeup sponges)

    Happy with my box and it shipped out yesterday! Can’t wait to get it

  9. Wait what, we will not get DOC if we used Tarte code? What a joke. If I resubbed today will I get a spoiler email? I only signed back up hoping for Marvelous Mauves

    • I’m getting the Tarte palette and a DOC palette.

      • Are you new or resubbing? I haven’t subbed to them in about a year and I finally caved for DOC and thought the Tarte was a nice extra. I will be disappointed for sure.

        • I unsubbed around June of this year, so I am considered a new subscriber.

  10. So some company OnTrac is delivering mine , wth? Company is this lol
    Anyway my dimensions per their tracking is 0x0x0
    And 1lb 🙄🤔
    No dimensions what in the world am I getting ? Now I’m really curious lol

  11. I just received another email from them stating I will be receiving my Nov choice item, the Kypris.

  12. I received an email from Boxy stating I would be receiving the Tarte palette. The DOC palette was also one of my spoilers. I know some people were saying they get one or the other. The fact I received an email makes me think it might ship separately like the IT moisturizer promo they had back around June.

    • I subbed last month with a free gift and everything came at once. It was luxe though so it might have been easier to put everything in the larger box.

  13. I got the purple eyeliner if any one wants to trade.

  14. I received my box today.
    The 3 spoiler items emailed to me on Monday was included in my box.
    I received Blushing Berries eyeshadow pallete (OMG it is absolutely gorgeous!)
    The Iconic London lipgloss in Lovestruck,
    Setting spray in Original, Purple eyeliner and Mellow brow tamer.
    Box #17 and weight was 9.1 oz.

  15. Just received my box today! My box weighed 0.93lbs.

    – DOC marvelous mauves
    – Touch in sol
    – Illuuminati sponge
    – Iconic London in nearly nude
    – Elemis face mask

    Hope this helps someone

  16. Received my box today. I got version 25 and I signed up using the Tarte promo. Box weight 1.7lbs.

    Glamglow Cleanser
    Touch-in-Sol Glassy Balm
    Iconic London Lipgloss in Nearly Nude -rather had Lovestruck
    Becca Anti-Fatigue Under Eye Primer
    Jonteblu Lip Liner
    Tarte Clay Play Palette

    Wish I had got a DOC palette too but all in all I’m okay with my box. I’m happy I got the Becca.

    • Thanks for sharing. I resubbed with the Tarte promo and am resigned to the fact that Boxy scammed us but hopefully I’ll get the Clay Play palette instead of the blush one. Someone needs to explain the definition of “free gift” to Boxy.

      • I signed up for the Tarte palette one of my three spoilers was the DOC Sassy Sienna’s. Now I still have to wait and see if I actually get the Tarte palette but I am supposed to.

      • The Tarte Pallet IS a Free gift, it is a 6th item in a box that promises 4-5 full size.

        • True. But if they had just added one line to the Tarte offer announcement saying “if you use this code for the Tarte palette, you will not receive the Dose of Colors”, then we would not have been surprised and it would have been clear to everyone.

          • I signed up for the Tarte palette and one of my spoilers is the DOC palette. Hopefully I actually receive both. My box weight is 1.6lbs, but it might ship separately. The IT moisturizer back around June shipped separately.

          • Some folks who subbed using the promo code ARE getting Dose palettes. But the spoiler was very confusing, by saying subscribers would “Get a Dose of Colors OR (emphasis mine) Tarte palette in October.” That sure makes it sounds like Boxy thinks the free Tarte palettes are equivalent to the Dose palettes!

          • I’m getting both. Ironically, I would have much preferred the glam glow over the Sassy Siennas. My whole box is makeup even though I chose all skincare as my preference. Oh well, I am happily with the play clay, and I have been wanting to try Boxy out.

    • I’m sure this is the box I’m getting. I’m happy to get the Becca, but yeah, this was NOT the box that was advertised, nor the box I signed up for. I’m canceling (and emailing Boxy to tell them WHY).

    • I also signed up with TrickorTarte code and my box weighs 1.6 lbs. My three preview items include the glassy balm, glamglow cleanser and lip gloss in nearly nude. Expected arrival date is 10/12.

      My other boxycharm subscription arrived 10/9 and weighed 1.0 lbs. I’m hoping the extra 0.6 oz of weight is my DOC and Tarte palette!!!

  17. Got my box today it was Variation #2 and weighed 1.1 pounds

    Sneak peak was:
    *DOS Baked Browns
    *Touch in Sol Glassy Skin Balm (choice from email pick)
    *Iconic London Nude Lipgloss

    Other two items:
    *Chella Tweasers
    *Skin&Co Truffle Therapy Radiant Dew Mist

    Overall I am happy with what I received. My top choice for palette was the Blushing Berries but Baked Browns was my second

  18. I haven’t seen anyone post that they are receiving the Pretty Cool palette yet – and that’s the one I REALLY wanted.

    It says I’m getting Marvelous Mauves.

    Anybody getting Pretty Cool???

    • I’m pretty sure I’ve seen someone post that the are receiving Pretty Cool. I wish I knew what I was receiving, I still haven’t received an email.

  19. Newbie here: Is it normal for boxy to ship without sending an email or updating the tracking. ? when do they normally sip, around the 10th? Im tired of stalking the website and i havent received an email yet, not even for the choice. =)

    • Mine will be here on Thursday. I received an email that it shipped on the 5th, but not one that shows spoilers/choice.

    • Sometimes I get a shipping notice, sometimes I don’t. I setup a fedex account that gives me notifications though so I can always track it that way.

  20. Has anyone received the Paula’s choice with a box weight of 1.03lbs?

  21. I got variation #27
    1.1 lbs
    First 3 spoilers in an email:

    DOC Baked Browns
    IL prep set glow spray in original
    IL lip plumping gloss in sex kitten

    Then in box today:
    Paulas choice exfoliant *was my choice item
    Hollywood n vine kohl liner

    🤗🥰

  22. I’m getting Marvelous Mauve and Iconic Nude, anyone interested in swap of for blushing berries and anything else but nude to swap

  23. I’m getting the Dose of Colors Snow Angel palette if anyone is looking to swap. I already have Marvelous Mauves and Blushing Berries…would be very interested in any of the others.

    • Interested in the Siennas?

  24. Sorry to break it to anyone, but it was just posted on boxycharm’s most recent ig post. That the dose of colors Pallete is only for “some” charmers. So if you got a preview with a cleanser for your October box, your box isn’t coming with a dose palette.

  25. To those saying that new subscribers are going to get a Tarte face palette instead of a Dose of Colors palette: no, that is NOT how it is supposed to work. The Tarte palette is supposed to be our free gift. The description of the coupon code, as written in the above post, is “use TRICKORTARTE to get a free Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette OR Tarte Tarteist™ PRO Glow Cheek Palette.” The key word here is FREE. NOT in place of another palette. If Boxy has decided to substitute a Tarte palette they promised us for FREE in place of a DoC palette, then that is wrong and blatant false advertising, and they deserve to be called out on it. It may well be that not everyone will get a DoC palette, but the argument that the Tarte palette somehow replaces it is false and gaslighting. New subscriber bonuses have never counted towards the box before, and Boxy shouldn’t be allowed to get away with it now.

    Liz, I would honestly appreciate if you would get some clarification from BoxyCharm on this, since it IS a coupon code that was advertised on MSA. I think I speak for a lot of new subscribers when I say I would not have used that coupon code if I thought it meant that I would be getting one of those two Tarte palettes in place of a DoC palette.

    • They aren’t replacing the Dose of Colors palette with the Tarte palette. You will get the Tarte palette plus 5 other products. Keep in mind that the Dose of Colors palettes are variants, not everyone is getting one, most people are getting the Glamglow cleanser as their variant item instead of the Dose. So the Tarte palette MAY be the only palette in your box but you will get a total of 6 items.

      • Also, just wanted to note that I resubscribed in October with the code after cancelling for September. I got both the Tarte Clay Play and a Dose palette in my box today, so they’re not replacing the Dose palette with the Tarte. It appears that new subs and people who cancelled quite a while ago are getting the cleanser in place of the Dose. They did say on the spoiler posts on FB, IG, and on here that ‘some charmers’ would receive the Dose…

        • I don’t follow Boxy on Instagram, so I was going off of spoilers here. The spoiler posted to MSA said “Get a Dose of Colors or Tarte palette or October.” Which would indicate an either-or proposition. However, the Tarte palette was supposed to be a free promo. It’s one thing to say “not everyone will get the Dose palette” – that’s disappointing, but understandable. But the way the spoiler was worded made it seem as though Boxy thought the free Tarte palette was a replacement for the Dose palette, and that’s not how free promos are supposed to work.

      • Michelle, this was my understanding of the promo, too, I’ve been seeing folks in the comments here tell new subscribers that they are getting the Tarte palette IN PLACE OF the DoC palette, and I wanted to make it clear that would not be acceptable behavior by Boxy. I don’t think Boxy would do that, but I also don’t want people to accept being scammed.

        • People are spreading misinformation. You will get a total of 6 products, one of which will be one of the Tarte palettes that you signed up for with the promo.

    • If you look at the first October Boxycharm spoiler, it says Charmers would either get a DOC palette or a Tarte palette, so I’m assuming all the people who signed up this month is getting the Tarte and 5 other items, just not the DOC.

      • Yeah the key here is reading and understanding the promo! I’ve seen boxycharm respond to multiple people from their account on Instagram, “only some charmers” will receive the dose Pallete. Other commenters Getting passive aggressive and mad toward other people posting on here trying to help isn’t the solution.

        • I didn’t read the fine print myself. I should have and that is on me. I just assumed I would get the Doc and Tarte when I signed up. I’m okay with the Glamglow Cleanser though. I got it in my BC box on my other account and I enjoy it, so I don’t mind a second one.

          • Ashley, there was no fine print saying that subscribing using this promo meant you wouldn’t be eligible for a Dose palette. I DO read fine print, and it wasn’t there. And some people who subscribed with the promo ARE getting a Dose palette.

        • AK, I did read and understand the promo, and I am not trying to be passive aggressive. If you read my entire comment, you would see that I acknowledge not everyone will get a DoC palette. I am upset with some other commenters telling new subscribers that they are getting the Tarte palette IN PLACE OF the DoC palette (aka, as one of their regular five items, not a bonus item), because that is spreading misinformation.

        • AK, I’m just trying to clear up misinformation I’ve seen in other parts of the comments. I’ve seen folks in the comments here tell new subscribers that they will be getting a Tarte face palette *in place of* the Dose palette, and that’s false. Boxy doesn’t get to take away an item because you used a promo code. That’s not how promo codes work.

          I don’t follow Boxy on Instagram, so I was not aware of their messaging on this subject.

      • My comment was specifically addressing the rumors that new subscribers will be receiving the free Tarte face palette from the promo *in place of* a DoC palette. To reiterate, I’m aware it’s a possibility not everyone will receive a DoC palette.

      • It does not say that. The promo code was for either a Tarte clay Play OR Tarte blush palette. FREE item for new subscribers separate from the BOX items. The BOX spoiler said ALL subscribers would receive one of the DOC palettes shown OR the ilovesarahii palette. MSA silence here disturbs me.

        • Hi Iris,

          Sorry I can reach out to Boxycharm on this. Just to confirm – you signed up with this promo and should have received the tarte palette in addition to your 5 box items, for a total of 6 items, but instead received in place of one of the 5 box items, and only received 5 items total?

    • I have to agree with you. The offer was not for an undisclosed free cleanser plus opt for a Tarte palette instead of a Dose of Color palette. If boxy was looking for a batch of one-and-done customers, I believe they have met their goal

      • They certainly lost this subscriber. I was ready to make the switch from Ipsy GBP, too. Too bad, so sad, Boxy.

      • Me too. i emailed boxy and *crickets* I didn’t even get spoilers since i cancelled before choice. way to lose someone who was willing to be a re-subscriber.

    • Agree. MSA/Liz hold some responsibility here because they are part of 5his advertising and do make a profit from this site. We deserve full disclosure and explanation.

      • Liz is only posting the information that she received initially. if boxycharm later switched it up then that’s boxycharm changing from what they had initially said this site posts spoilers as they get them and if boxycharm leader of decided to put Glam glow instead of a dose palette there’s no way for her to know that until they start sending amount and everyone starts finding out they got screwed over the only way to save yourself from this is to screenshot boxy charms exact spoilers to hold them accountable not the messenger

        • Sorry for the typos it’s early and I’m talking into my phone, but my point is this has happened before with them and other boxes, and unless she states it’s an exclusive message from boxycharm or whichever box there’s no way to hold this site accountable for reposting information that whatever box has changed down the line. it does seem like a bait and switch since they didn’t have full disclosure at the very beginning but there’s no way to know. we are having more and more issues with the sub boxes switching things, I mean just look what if she did with their ultimate box what a fiasco that was all she could do was show the spoilers that they gave her but there is no way for her to know it was going to turn into the big crap show that it did that was on Ipsy not on Liz

        • I totally agree with Denise. Liz can’t control what BoxyCharm does and she just posts the information she gets. Liz has no responsibility or liability in BoxyCharms actions. MSA is amazing and my go to for everything subscription box related and it’s not fair to jump on Liz because of something BC did. She doesn’t work for them she just posts sub box spoilers and info.

  26. I’m getting the Sassy Siennas, would have loved the baked browns marvelous mauves or pretty cool pallette. Anyone want to trade?

  27. Anyone wants to trade their October eyeshadow for mine? i am getting snow angels!

    • ill trade my baked browns 🙂

      • I’ll trade with you, I got the Sassy Siennas

        • i’m totally okay with that! how do we trade? 🙂

          • So I just saw we can’t post our email,hmm. I’m new to something like this, but I’m sure we can figure something out. Any ideas?

          • Find me on fb or ig, my name shows up.

  28. I don’t know why but my box came by FedEx today which never happened before, but anyway, I got the baked Browns palette , the touch in Sol ,that I picked, and the darker nude lip gloss that I would really be interested in but I’m not even going to open it as I know the color will not work on me. That stinks because I was dying to try the formula I never had anything from them before. now for the part we all want to know my box was 1.3 and I got the skin Roma spray which was a nice surprise because I was expecting crap .. now anyone that does not like smelly stuff don’t even bother trying because although I love it -it would be very cooling for the summer months – and it says it makes your skin glow but they mean overtime. there is no Shimmer or anything like that in the spray so that’s a plus for me but it smells heavily of peppermint Rosemary and Botanicals which may bother some people . the other product I got was a Chella tweezers. So I must say I didn’t get screwed over with the fillers like I thought I was going to but I had so many of the fillers already I didn’t know if I would get doubles or if I actually we’ll get things I never had like I did so that was a pleasant surprise good luck everyone

    • Thank you for letting everyone know what you got and your review! Looking forward to seeing what I’m getting.

    • You should try the lipgloss… even though the color looks dark, it’s a sheer formula

  29. I needed the Iconic Spray in Glow and I am getting the Original on Friday. Don’t know how It will look on my brown skin ugh do they even follow the profile? why have it!

    • I got the glow spray, was hoping for the original, ya wanna trade?!

  30. Can new subscribers choose the Kypris? Thanks in advance!

    • I subbed at the beginning of October and I was able to choose it.

      • Thank you, I’ll go for it!

  31. Seems like the variation with the baked browns, touch of sol and the nude lip plumper is pretty popular. Those were my sneak peeks too.

  32. I haven’t seen anyone say they are getting the Pretty Cool palette. I’m getting Baked Browns, which I’m happy with. They others I wanted are Pretty Cool and Marvelous Mauves.

    Getting the Glassy Balm and the nude gloss, so I’m pretty happy. Will be SUPER happy if I get the Paula’s Choice, too.

  33. For the first time I am disappointed with Boxy, I am getting the browns Palette and the nude lip gloss. I will use neither. I hate nudes and can not stand Brown eyeshadow. I can see they did not look at profiles 🙁

    • I was thinking for once that they are looking at profile preferences.
      I have mine set to plums for eyeshadows and I’m receiving “Blushing Berries” and for Lip glosses I have set for pinks and I’m receiving Lovestruck.
      Maybe it’s just coincidence, luck or just being hopeful.

    • I’m getting the sassy sienna’s and nowhere on my profile do I have anything even close to that. I would be stoked with both of those, I hated my eyeshadow last month too. I also put that I wanted eyeshadow like as little as possible. I’m over boxycharm.

  34. After the IPSY ultimate letdown I just signed up for the standard Boxycharm. Can anyone tell me if you get to choose the Tarte palette or do they just randomly send one of the two.

    Also is there some way to see the products that will be included in your monthly box before it arrives (like IPSY does on the 2nd of the month)

    • It’s random.

    • It’s random, Idk which one I’m getting. I signed up early this month and I’ll be able to pick one item for November. So first month you don’t get to choose but sneak peek show you 3 items for this month when you get a email for the choice window is up for next month.

  35. I’m getting the berries palette but wanted the browns or sienna if anyone wants to swap let me know!! I’m on swap site if it’s easier🌸

    • I have Sienna and would love to trade!

    • Agh. Boxycharm is back on their bs train-choo choo! They removed the serum in the shop, this my bag. Don’t offer current box products in the shop if you don’t have enough to offer! Now I’m stuck between the random product or definitely getting the serum but not both.

  36. I’m getting Sassy Siennas, was really hoping for Pretty Cool…tradesies anybody?

    • Agh. Boxycharm is back on their bs train-choo choo! They removed the serum in the shop, this my bag. Don’t offer current box products in the shop if you don’t have enough to offer! Now I’m stuck between the random product or definitely getting the serum but not both.

      • Well it does say while supplies last. You have to be quick. Imagine all the people who are subbed to BC who sign on right when it opens and buy that product, it has to sell out at some point.

      • I mean the Choice opened yesterday (late morning for me, MST) and you wrote this almost a day later. It’s only while supplies last. I did an add-on the serum yesterday without issue. Of course they don’t have an infinite amount of product.

  37. Does anyone know if my add on will come in my box or separately? Thanks 😊

    • Add ones will ship separately 🤗

      • Thanks so much! Boxycharm has fast shipping though, should I be worried that I ordered my add on on September 24th? Or are they just now going to start sending them? Has anyone here received their add ons? Thanks guys!!!!

        • It said that add ons could take up to a month to ship so I wouldn’t worry too much!

  38. I was disappointed at first to be receiving Baked Browns but I searched some looks using the palette and it is fire!!!

    • YAY! 🙂 I am hoping to get that one or the mauves.

  39. My box just shipped – it’s 1.7 lbs?! I know there’s an extra Tarte palette in there as my sign-up bonus, but that seems really heavy.

    I’m getting really worried I won’t get an eyeshadow palette. My spoilers were for the Touch in Sol, the Glamglow cleanser and a lipgloss. Under the “October 2019 Boxycharm Products” both the Iconic spray and the Hank and Henry mascara have the label “October box” in addition to the Touch in Sol and gloss (but NOT the Glamglow cleanser). I don’t want either of those items. I want a palette. I subbed for the palette. Stupid me, I guess, taking a risk. But I really did think they would put a palette in every box. I’m so disappointed.

    • I’m sure you will get a palette. I don’t think I’ve ever heard of anyone not getting one. If you just re-subbed recently like I did (3 days ago) there’s a good chance you’re going to get the Sienna palette that was available as an add-on. I think that’s the only one they had left. But if you signed up closer to a week ago it might be a different (better) one. I’ve been with Boxy almost five years except a month or two break here and there and although there were many times I got terrible product variations, they never once failed to send me a palette, even if it had the worst possible shades for me. Like the Sienna one I’m getting. 😄
      So don’t stress. At least you’re not super pale and getting the dark Iconic spray like I am. 😉

  40. My box is 1lb.
    Getting :
    Baked Browns
    Touch in Sol
    Lip plumping gloss

    What could be my fillers at 1lb ?

    Thanks 🙂

    • There’s a reddit post of someone who had a 1lb 8×4 box that also got the Skin & Co Truffle Therapy Radiant Dew mist and a Luna by Luna eyeliner in “Asteroid” (blue) There are at least 24 variations though so who knows 🤷🏻‍♀️

      • Thanks Nina for the input – I already got that truffle spray and hate it in a previous boxy so I probably won’t get it again , hoping for Paula’s choice 🤞🤞🤞

        Hope you get what you want to !

      • I just got variation 27 🙄

        • Which one is that variation ?

  41. First time, long time, y’all. I’ve finally felt compelled to comment for the first time for two reasons: 1) it has been really entertaining watching the comments on this post all day and seeing everyone’s reactions to their box spoilers; 2) I want to chime in that I’m surprisingly pleased with mine (I got the glassy balm, plumping gloss, mascara, prep set glow, and DoC in sierras, which actually works well with my coloring), and I’m usually pretty meh on BC. That puts me on the luckier end of the spectrum of commenters today, by my estimation, but it’s all been a delight to follow. 😀

    • Are you looking on the website at the products list and assuming those marked “Oct Box” are the items in your box? Because those show like that for everyone. You won’t get both the Glassy balm and Iconic spray, or both the Iconic gloss and the mascara- those will be either or variations. Your spoilers will be sent in an email.

  42. Baked Browns (yay!)
    Pretty Filter Balm (as requested)
    Iconic London plumbing gloss (not thrilled)
    Box weight 1.03 pounds.

    • Box twins 🙂 except mine is 1lb.

  43. My email says I’m getting the Marvelous Mauves palette I wanted the blushing berries if anyone wants to swap. I’m also getting the iconic lipgloss and the glassy skin balm yay.

  44. Has anyone been able to sign up for the Premium box yet?

    • It’s not available yet. It’s wait list only as of now.

      • How do you even get on the waitlist? I just saw where you could sign up to be notified by email.

        • That is the wait list for now. They are supposed to send them out to the people who signed up for the email notification first.

  45. I picked Kypris as my choice. Pretty excited for that. I can’t put anything under my eyes bc they are too sensitive so definitely didn’t pick juice beauty. That would’ve been the only thing I picked up in add ons.

    ¤Marvelous mauves
    ¤Touch in sol which I chose
    ¤Iconic lippie in Nude something

    I’m ok with everything so far, I love plumping glosses and nude is right up my ally, but I own the snow angels palette and I hate it so much. So patchy dusty and muddy. Its horrible. I wanted the iluvsarahii palette. Did anyone get that? So I’m glad I got the color story I got if I had to receive one of these palettes. I’m pretty sure I’ll feel the same about it as the snow angels but I may give it a try or gift it.

    So did anyone receive the iluvsarahii palette?

    • I was wondering if new subscribers are getting the iluvsarahii pallete?
      It seems a lot of new subscribers did not get spoilers of a pallete and I haven’t seen anyone say here that they are receiving that pallete.

      • I’m new (well kind of. I was subbed for over 4 years, left briefly and signed back up a few days ago) and got a palette spoiler. The oh-so-unflattering on me Sienna one. I know everyone complained and worried about getting that collab palette (I think that’s the one you mentioned) but I would’ve loved trying that one. I was actually hoping it would be the newer subscribers that got it since it sounded so unpopular. 😄

        • I guess I wanted it bc I have the snow angels and hate the formula. Its been sitting tucked away in my vanity ever since they came out with these. The colors looked so pretty but its just a dusty muddy mess in my opinion. I even pulled it out the other day just to see if maybe I was a little too harsh and no it still sucks! Haha. I’d love to know who actually receives that palette! 😊

      • Me either! I looked through some unboxing videos and didn’t see anyone with that either. Hmm…

  46. I am getting:
    *Marvelous Mauves
    *TOS Pretty Filter
    *Iconic London – Nearly Nude

    I am happy with my palette. I didn’t want the collab or pretty cool but was okay with the others. I’d i had to pick favorites, I actually wanted Mauves or Snow Angel most. 🙂

    I picked Juice Beauty for next month.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

*