My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm November 2019 FULL Spoilers!

ByMSAOct 28, 2019 | 178 comments


4.3 overall rating
1980 Ratings | 226 Reviews

We have full spoilers for one variation of the November 2019 BoxyCharm box thanks to boxypreview!

One variation of the November box includes:

Source: boxypreview

In case you missed the previous spoilers:

BoxyCharm 2 Piece Brush Set

According to Yosef, if you are a BoxyCharm Premium subscriber, you will not get the brush set (The Premium box includes a 5 piece brush set). Instead, you may receive:

Farsali Rose Gold Skin Mist

In case you missed the previous spoilers:

Dose of Colors Liquid Lipstick


BECCA Shimmering Skin Perfector


Dominique Cosmetics Celestial Thunder Eye Shadow Palette


Juice Beauty Stem Cellular Anti-Wrinkle Eye Treatment or Kypris Antioxidant Dew Quench & Glow Serum

What do you think of the November spoilers? 

(If you aren’t familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $25. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

BoxyCharm ($25 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 4-5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and established brands, with a total retail value of over $100 in every box. The beauty item... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Since canceling all my Ipsy Subs I decided to give Boxy another chance. The last couple months I’ve kept my eyes on spoilers and unboxings and I’m personally liking what I’ve seen. I’m excited for the Dominique Cosmetics palette and even more excited for what I’ve seen for next months boxyluxe. I end up getting on the waitlist for premium and luxe. Hope that I get to come off for Dec. We shall see! I really hope to not he let down again by Boxy.


Well I just came back after a year break. I like the new profile but why can you only click one shade you like on liner, lipstick, and blush colors? I see wild card but what if I like 2 or 3 outta 4? It’s almost there, just needs a little tweeking.


I always end up giving away or throwing out a color I can’t get to pick. It’s always: too light or too pink. I wear a burgundy red.


If anyone wants the entire box minus the eye cream I’ll sell it strait across or on swap?


Boxypremium box? Is that what you would sell?


Well I didnt get billed for premium so no ND or Farsali for me. Bummer.


Me either. So pissed off.


Me too! No Premium so I will just opt out. I can’t afford all three boxes. I was just hoping to get the first one.


Really ??? They took it out my account at 12:01 am. I got an email.


Me either I’m so bummed

Mizz RoRo

Right!! they bill me on the last day of the month and i need to be billed on the first so im never ganna get the premium box!! Sucks!!😞


Too bad the palette wasn’t included in the October box….it’s perfect for Halloween! Can’t wait to try the Krypris though, great reviews! I’m ready to move on from highlighters, I have a drawer full from Boxy that I couldn’t possibly use in a lifetime.

Alice R

You’ll love the Kypris. I got my add on and have been using it. I really like the formula.


November 2019 will be my second box.
I’m not thrilled about the Dominique Cosmetics Celestial Thunder Eye Shadow Palette. I don’t gravitate towards an unseemly color scheme. I know I will not use this but will pass it along to my teenage niece.


Same. I’m just not really a “fun” eyeshadow wearer except for purples and the occasional glitter thing. I don’t mind if they are warm, cool, or neutral, but I just don’t like the look of reds, oranges, greens, or blues as eyeshadows.


You should go to ipsy….that’s where I get the “neutral ” pallettes . I love playing with color and formulas….so it always irks me getting 100 shades of brown and neutral pallettes from them lol but I love and collect pallettes, so I’m happy


Me also. I wish the colors were more neutral on the palettes

Alice R

Mine is going to a niece as well. I could only see myself using a couple of the shades.


Same! Top row looks beautiful. Bottom row is eh… for me.

Nanny Nancy

Ooooh weeee! I am so excited to try the Kypris serum. So happy it was an option. I tried the Juice Beauty eye stuff and not only does it have a disgusting scent, it did nothing for my eyes. I actually thought it was drying my delicate eye skin. The only thing I don’t need or want are the brushes. Everything else sounds great. I’m happy with my regular Boxycharm subcription. No need to upgrade.

Alice R

You’re going to love the Kypris! I feel the same about JB. Have tried several products and didn’t care for any. I really disliked the scent. I cancelled Luxe. Not upgrading anything.

Tammi Tarvin

I have received several full size Juice Beauty products specifically targeted for the eye area and fine lines and wrinkles, used the entire container with absolutely no benefits. And, as Alice R stated, it actually had a drying effect for me as well. No more JB for me.

Crystal M Z

This will be my November box and I am so freaking excited. Ahh cannot wait.

1. DC Celestial Thunder Eye Shadow Palette…(For Every Current Subscriber) 💖😍💖

2. Farsali Rose Gold Skin Mist…(Hopefully i will be getting the Premium Box) 😍

3. DOC lip product… (I picked this item from an email I was sent) 😁😍

4. Juice or whatever that product was called 😬😑🤷…(My selection)

5. 5th Item which will probably be sheet masks or a pencil something but with everything else I am good with that or just being short one item. I still win with these amazing products 😍

I absolutely LOVE BoxyCharm. They have not once let me down or disappointed me. I cannot find another better option then to pay, previously $21 and now $25 per month and get all of this. It is just a no brained box. I am so happy and excited to get my box. There isn’t one item I am not over the moon to get.

olivia mendoza

is there a way to see whats in my box before delivery?


I must say, the more I see the palette the more I am NOT feeling it. There are maybe three shades I would use. I am excited to get my second bottle of Kypris – that stuff is lovely! I picked up a bottle in add-ons and have been using it for about two weeks. Very nourishing and perfect for this time of year when my skin gets dry and itchy.


Agreed, sister.

Alice R

Ssme. I’m hanging on for that second bottle of Kypris!


I agree with you that’s exactly the case


After seeing the DOSE & ICONIC spoilers for October box, I had to resub after a year hiatus (due to the never-ending number of repeat eyeliners and lip glosses) and I’m so happy I did! I got the Sassy Siennas palette, which is a dream AND the freebie TARTE clay palette. Ole! I was pretty happy with the glow set mist as well but didn’t care at all for the Hank & Henry mascara nor the Chella tweezers. For one, the mascara was pretty crappy imo and the tweezers are well…tweezers. The last item I got was the Smashbox liquid eyeliner, which is another item I just really wasn’t impressed with. So in all, not a bad box and with $167 bucks worth of goodies inside for a whoppin’ 21 bucks, who can complain right? I’ll just gift the two items I won’t be using this Holiday. As I’m currently in sub overload, idk yet if I” get Dec’s box or pause.

Jennifer Orenstein

I got the exact same box as you, and also ersubscrib4d for Octa nd recieved the Tart Clay Play, I feel pretty much exactly the same about the products…except I don’t love the spray either,…smells funny and feels sticky. Love the Sassy Siennas palette!


I always tell people to retake the beauty quiz, it’s easier than re subscribing.


they do NOT use your beauty quiz answers. they admitted it. they just sent out random boxes from 3 variations they create. thats it. nothing customized about it


Can anyone tell me how do I customize my boxyluxe box?


Products to choose from are up on website just log in

Tanya M.

I”ve been away since December 2018 but I am caving for November 1st. Can not wait. I only didn’t get boxy one time due to a palette that wasn’t warm enough for my complexion. I really got to play with shadows and update my look. I always got at least a couple of items I was pleased with in my boxes and good gosh, palette overload. It’s a good thing. I am going to try to not go past December .. no matter how tempting .. but I am giving myself a pat on the back (er, wallet) for not caving until now.. lol


Hope I get a DOC lipstick 💄 And not the shimmer thing 🤣

Alice R

I need advice about one of the October products, the Glassy Skin. How is it supposed to be used, as a moisturizer or makeup primer? I tried it and used just a light application. It seems awfully shiny and sticky, and didn’t ever fully absorb. I had to wash it off. I have combination light skin. Help, lol.


I use it as a moisturizer. I have oily skin, but it’s getting cold here. I just put on a super light layer and it makes my skin soft. I was a bit scared of it at first, but I love it now.

Alice R

Maybe I’ll just use it on elbows, knees, hands.


I use it as a morning moisturizer/primer. I watched a youtube video where she did the same, I was super intimidated of it at first as well, but it’s really nice

Sylvia Garcia

I had the same issue. It felt really heavy on the skin and tacky/sticky. It says it is a moisturizer and a primer. Definately not for me. Maybe better to use in the winter months? 🤷🏽‍♀️

Alice R

I agree, Sylvia. Maybe I’ll hang on to it and use as a winter moisturizer. I tried it a gain this morning with a tiny amount and still got the same results…sticky and tacky feel, and my face looked like I had sprayed it with baby oil. A shiny mess, lol. Had to wash it all off and start my morning routine over. There is no way I could use this as a makeup primer. It just sits on my face as a sticky, shiny, oily mess. 🙂

Carol Ann

it’s both! 🙂

Alice R

Maybe it’s just too shiny for me? 🙂


I am not looking forward to this box. These spoilers seem meh to me. Really not excited about that palette.

Denise Atkinson

I know people hate waitlists, but back in the day when they had one it was so much better. There were very few variations, if any, and they were able to provide what they had due to the amount of customers for that coming month. Every since it seems they just want all the subscribers they can get and spread themselves too thin. When you got a box you knew what you were getting. And ipsy also. I just ordered the Macy box which has a waitlist but when I see those spoilers I KNOW that’s what’s going to be in my box. If you want certainty this is not the box for you.

Alice R

That’s why I love Beautyfix so much. Everyone gets the same box. No scams. No shams. Superb customer service, too. If Boxycharm would go to a set box, they wouldn’t believe how fast they would grow.


You’re exactly right. I’ve been with Boxy going on five years and while I’ve always been aware of how much better and more consistent boxes used to be, I hadn’t made the connection you just pointed out. That waitlist was probably the main reason almost everyone got the same products, or very close to them, month after month. Not only did you not have one subscriber getting a $30 highlighter and another getting a $6 lip liner, no one ever really ever got $6 lip liners and all the other cheap crap that gets thrown in boxes these days. They bought a certain number of products to put together a set number of boxes and that was it until the next month. You hit the nail on the head. Their massive growth just wasn’t enough I guess. They’re pretty much hyper-focused on obtaining new customers now, no matter what it takes. Crappy, unequal variations, false/misleading advertising, customer service support for current/older members virtually non-existent, etc. It’s so infuriating but I don’t have the willpower to take away my business based on principal. I really wish I did.


But back in the day, the quality and name brands were not like they are today. I’d take name brands and good quality for them to branch out and be able to sample more then just drug store brands.

So I love boxy and the value it does provide, because I’ve found brands I live and products I’ve bought over and over (that farmacy being one I’ve bought 4 times since we’ve got that) so yeah, I’d rather get things I would invest my money on to sample and try vs junk I wouldnt buy or want to check out..


My thoughts exactly! It used to be so much more consistent, and I did not feel as if I was constantly being mislead! Spoilers were never you “will get either Item A or Item B” (but not mentioning that you may receive other items for which there are not enough letters in the English alphabet). It took me until I received a 37 cent item from Allure that I finally cancelled. The repeat and LONG EXPIRED item I received in my October Box has finally given me the resolve to cancel. After over 2 1/2 weeks, I received a “boilerplate” email from Boxy indicating that they sometimes included “returning favorites” in boxes and offering me 1000 charms for the oversight. Boxy went onto say this represented the “full value” of the item I was sent (a Tarteist ProGlow Liquid Highlight which their card valued at $29). It’s been 3 days and I’ve not received the charms (I don’t think it’s a coincidence that I will not receive and be able to redeem charms in time to cancel my November box).


Wow!! I never realized this you guys. I just miss the old boxycharm 🙁


The last two boxes I received really weren’t that great, but I’m really looking forward to November’s box, and I’m really hoping I get the premium box. I’m most excited about the Becca product! Praying I get it! I absolutely love the set and refresh powder so I would love to try another one of their products.


If anyone wants it, they can buy my box. If you haven’t already signed up, do yourself a favor and DON’T DO IT. I am seriously never one to complain. If I had a problem with a sub box, I just unsubbed. HOWEVER I have never experienced such false advertising with any box! Also, boxycharm used to have amazing customer service, but I’ve been going back and forth with customer service for 2 weeks and I have to send multiple emails and hope for a response 5 days later? Then, they don’t even answer my question. It just seems like canned responses. Oh man. Just awful awful awful experience.


You are absolutely correct. We have all dealt with being shown three shades of a lipstick and knowing it will be a surprise (one is always dreadful, if not all the ones nobody would buy with their money at full price), but it is getting unreliable, to put it extremely kindly, to have a clue. I have gotten lucky and gotten some good boxes and found the value to be very high for what I paid, but it is a gamble every month. It always seems like a better value when one considers the price it might have been to list, but in reality, not such a great value when one realizes that if one searched at TJ Maxx or Marshall’s, and some drugstore brands like Flower Beauty, the Ordinary, Inkey List, etc, we pay enough that the company is probably making millions, if not billions, and they just keep stretching out and never turning away people like they used to, with a waitlist to keep quality consistent and fair for all of their subscribers. It seems like they are becoming greedy and lazy, by not even sending an email for choice, which would have been free to them. I suppose that was to avoid them having to spend profits upgrading and having reliable computer software and gear to prevent the previous inevitable crashes. If so, that keeps more money for them, but less regard for the customer. The variants are so strange lately. To introduce new variants after payment processes or even a day or two prior, in case people haven’t been glued to their Insta or FB is really low. For the record, I do not need anyone telling me to unsubscribe, because I know how to change a channel on my television or radio and how to unsubscribe if I don’t feel like any company that I trust doing business with is not being a good steward with the money that their customers entrust to them for a specific product. The owner needs to step up and consider the consumer instead of all the profits. A waitlist and getting back to exactly how they curated their boxes a couple years ago for their extremely Charmers might do them good. I have faith that they can get back to their glory that garnered such loyalty. Reading all of the comments over the past month, the charm is tarnishing.


Boxes back then didnt have the name brands and quality they do now. I’m sure by doing what they do with variations its allowed them to have name brand companies , instead of drug store or unknown brands all the time. I’d rather then expand because some months the quality wasnt there most months…real her pallettes and bella pierre no one wanted?!?!

I think the majority that cares about value are resellers, andbthose people bring down anything anyway. Value to me is trying GOOD quality named brands I will go out and invest in and try other things from their company vs just getting them 1 time in a box and be done.

Just my .02

Alice R

Hear, hear! Exactly.


My thoughts exactly. It is really disappointing. I hope they get enough complaints (if they even care?) to turn things around. In reality, I could FEEL the “I only care about my bottomline” attitude. The canned responses and blatant disregard was my tipping point. Not even a valid explanation. I would probably have been happier to hear “YES we know there is a problem and we are working to fix it please bear with us”. *sigh*

Alice R

I feel your pain, too. It’s a crap shoot if you hope to get a prompt, accurate answer from customer service. For me, Boxycharm has been the worst subscription experience. All other boxes have been wonderful for me relative to CS. I’m staying for November because I got an extra choice because of what they did to me in October. I’ve got to see this through. After that, I’m gone pecan.


I know!! I have never had to cancel a box EVER due to Customer Service or bait and switch. I have had every box under the sun for several years. It was just mind boggling to me how they can have so many subscribers. I just want people to know what they’re signing up for! They wouldn’t even let me cancel the remainder of my 3 month despite the numerous documented issues. Oh well! Hopefully others will catch on, and not a huge deal for me personally because I will just cancel my sub. So glad I was not the only one!!

tammy g.

Kris..this is the reason I cancelled boxycharm..i never got what I wanted..always the crappy stuff..i emailed them several times… I cancelled..sometimes this is just what you have to do..sorry, but I feel your pain.


That’s too bad! It seems like a lot of people are saying that now. I wish I would have read into it more before I resubbed. I will definitely be cancelling, and I hope others do some research before they spend their money to boxy 🙁


Didn’t like the October box but really want this one 🙂 can’t wait till friday so I can sign up


ND? Since when did they say Natasha demons palette. Did you mean DC as in Dominique Cosmetics? 😕


The Natasha Denona palette is going to be in the November premium box.


I’m hoping for the DOC lip instead of the Becca. I don’t use any highlighters, ever.


I am also hoping to get the DOC lip in one of the nudes instead of highlighter! I don’t use highlighter at all!

Mary M

I would also trade you the lipstick! (:


I will trade you if I get the DOC. I don’t wear lipstick.


What’s the point of the sneak peeks and spoilers anyway? They’ll pull a bait and switch and send a Jonteblu piece of crap!


I know, right? One thinks one’s 50th Eyeko liner or mascara will be in the box, or maybe even a Manna Kadar highlighter, but nooooo, it’s some Jontbleau! 🙂

Alice R

I would have been thrilled with an Eyeko mascara instead of those stupid pencils. Lol


I know, right?! Those liners sucked. Lol. Brow gel stank, too.


That ain’t no damn lie

Alice Pate

Becca Shimmering Highlighter ♥️♥️♥️. Love Boxycharm 💋

Michelle Bauknecht

My October box was the worst ever and missing items…I’ve noticed a decline plus at least my box has been arriving really late, smashed etc. NOW they up the cost, hard pass for premium but I’ll keep Luxie box and the regular one for a while longer to see if things improve overall, it’s a lot of $$$ especially when they don’t follow your profile and they constantly mess up!


They’ll never change, sad to say but it’s true because Boxy knows that FOMO is real. So they keep doing what their doing (people have complained about CS for Boxy for years, and they started all of these crazy variations a year ago also).

And if people actually do cancel they entice them to come back with products (such as the becca powder or tarte palette) that some people don’t get and then they say “oops, it will be in your box next month “.
So they already got you for 2 boxes, when they promised the gift with only 1 box.

Shady, shady.

Alice R

Indeed! The only reason I stayed for November is they promised my missing Tarte palette from October. After this month, I’m gone.


I have to agree with this, I usually don’t conplain but canceling Boxy might be in the future for me, Oct was the worse month ever! They are putting out far to many bad variations and most people get the ones not even shown! I think they are trying to do to many things at once. They shouldn’t show great variations and the send a crap lip liner we have got a million time. The only thing I kept from Oct was the palette. And Nov is not looking good to me at all!


i renewed for 3 months and somehow got the butter palette again, NO dose of colors in any way shape or form in October. ridiculous.

You Might Also Like

What I’m Wearing This Week: Armoire
What I’m Wearing This Week: Armoire
September 10, 2021
AIA Beauty Bundle: October 2021 Box Will Feature Full-Size ColourPop Products
AIA Beauty Bundle: October 2021 Box Will Feature Full-Size ColourPop Products
September 17, 2021
Essentials Crate August 2021 Subscription Box Review + Coupon
Essentials Crate August 2021 Subscription Box Review + Coupon
September 12, 2021
The MSA Team’s Subscription Box BEAUTY Favorites for August 2021!
The MSA Team’s Subscription Box BEAUTY Favorites for August 2021!
September 18, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.