MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Last Call To Make POPSUGAR Fall Box Customization Choices!

Reminder! Current subscriberes have until the 21st to make/edit your customization choices for the Fall POPSUGAR Must Have box!

New subscribers can use coupon code MSA20 to save $20 off of their first POPSUGAR Must Have box, too! (Regularly $75 a box.) (The fall box has sold out, but if you sign up now you will get on the waitlist.

Here are the customization options:

The Cambridge Satchel Company Push Lock Purse 

Your choice of Putty, Dapple or Stone

Your most versatile accessory is here: this 100 percent leather push-lock crossbody bag, handmade in Great Britain. The modern design can be easily dressed up or down, so you’ll find yourself reaching for it all season long. Choose from three different Fall-inspired shades — Putty, Dapple, or Stone.




Here’s the second spoiler:

Tai Jewelry Adjustable Ring with Labradorite and Dark Blue Opaque Stone

Your choice of Gold or Silver

Add a touch of metallic to your outfit with this chic ring, handmade in Thailand by skilled artisans. The featured stone is Labradorite, which is thought to protect against misfortune and negativity. We love that the design is adjustable, so it can fit any finger. It’s the perfect addition to your jewelry collection.



Here’s the third spoiler:

Charlotte Tilbury Matte Revolution Lipstick

Your choice of Pillow Talk or Walk of Shame

All beauty-lovers should have a Charlotte Tilbury Matte Revolution Lipstick in their makeup arsenal. The smooth formula never dries your mouth out; a blend of oils, triglycerides, and waxes glide long-lasting color onto the lips. Choose between celebrity favorite Pillow Talk, a cult classic, or Walk of Shame, the bestselling berry-rose hue from the brand.

Walk of Shame

Here’s Walk of Shame shown on different models from Charlotte Tilbury’s site:

Pillow Talk

Here’s Pillow Talk shown on different models from Charlotte Tilbury’s site:

What do you think of the spoilers? Which items are you picking? Let me know if you have any questions about the items – I have them all in hand!

And there are Add-Ons available, too! If you aren’t familiar, you can log in to your account and select any/all of these to add to your box at a discount:

Shashi Bengali Headband

Ettika Lots of Love Resin Heart Hoop Earrings

Shashi Set of 2 Triangular Grey Lucite Hair Clips

Ettika Split Heart Sparkle Earrings

One Love Organics Skin Savior Balm

One Love Organics Botanical E Youth Serum Roller Ball

Let me know if you have any questions about the Add-On items or the spoilers!

New subscribers can use coupon code MSA20 to save $20 off of their first POPSUGAR Must Have box, too! (Regularly $75 a box.)

Check out all of my POPSUGAR Must Have reviews and POPSUGAR Must Have Box spoilers to see what you can expect from this women’s lifestyle subscription box!


How do subscribers rate POPSUGAR Must Have?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about POPSUGAR Must Have!

Enable notifications () to get the latest POPSUGAR Must Have spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in POPSUGAR Must Have Box, POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 63 comments

Comments (63)

  1. Honestly, I hope I do not get off the waitlist – I just checked – still says winter 2019. I am not overly thrilled with the fall box. Fingers crossed that I skip this and get winter!!!

  2. Dying for spoilers.

  3. Anxiously awaiting full spoilers ☺️

    • Me too! My box says tracking is processing. I don’t know why PS won’t just release spoilers esp. if it is sold out!

      They are pretty late shipping I think.

    • Is anyone’s box moving yet? So ready for spoilers. Where is the review???😜

      • My box is moving! I’m in NJ and it shipped from NY. Says it will be here Friday 🙂

      • I’m glad I’m not the only one anxiously awaiting full spoilers! I’ve become way less patient about spoilers since they went quarterly lol.

      • I’m anxious too! Since the boxes are all ready shipping out, it seems like they should have revealed the other spoilers by now. Hopefully it will be a great box…I like the first 3 items.

      • Please let us know what is in it when it arrives! My box is still processing and the anticipation is killing me!

  4. I can no longer select or change my items, processing still. @Liz, when will you post a review for the fall box. Can’t wait to see spoilers.

    • I just got shipping confirmation, label created, delivery date pending. So full spoilers should be in the next few days, right?

      • I just received shipping also. Hope these go out tonight but will probably be tuesday. So ready for some spoilers.

      • Oh that’s good to know! Mine is still processing, and since this is my first box I wasn’t sure how long into September I will have to wait 🙂

  5. The putty and dapple colors for the Cambridge satchel are sold out. The gold ring is sold out but both lipsticks are still available.

  6. I was billed on 8/23, there’s no ship date and under tracking it says, “processing”. Hopefully shipping will be soon.

    • Mine doesn’t say processing yet but I no longer have any choice to edit my selections. I don’t want to edit them. I just want to see the full spoilers!

      For the first time in my life I am looking forward to fall!

  7. The website says that this box ships out Aug. 20th. Has anyone received shipping confirmation?

    • Really? Well, it’s the 23rd and I’m super excited to see else is going to be in this box and for it to ship out to me!😍
      Just loving this Fall box do far and cant wait to see everything! Soooo glad I bought this one!

    • Just received shipping confirmation.

  8. Anxiously awaiting full spoilers and checking back several times a day lol

  9. I got off the wait list just in time for my birthday on Sunday!!!

    • I chose putty, walk of shame and gold.

      • Yay! I just got off too! Picked dapple, pillow talk and gold 🙂

      • Putty, Pillow Talk & Gold here😍

    • Happy Birthday and enjoy your box!

  10. I just got off the waitlist. Finally! All options were still available.

  11. i’m SO torn between stone and putty… but will probably go for putty? I don’t even know! (silver and walk of shame for the other choices though!)

    • I’m torn between Stone and Putty too!!! But likely going to land on Stone.

  12. I keep checking my account every day to see if I’m off the waitlist, but no such luck yet! I hope 🤞🏼 I can find out soon because if winter really is my first box, I want to jump on BOS which I think is another beautifully curated fall box! I cancelled fff when I saw the fall spoilers, nothing fall about it. Fall is my absolute favorite season (even named my daughter, Autumn 😊). Thanks guys for the heads up to keep checking my account because emails aren’t be sent! Fingers crossed over here!

    • Same! And some people seem to be off of it…I wonder if there is any rhyme or reason to why some people are off of it and some not? And if customization closes tomorrow does that mean if we are not off the list by tomorrow we won’t get the box, or might get the box but won’t be able to customize? What a weird and opaque system.

  13. I am really curious to what else this box is going to have. My credits ran out before this one, and I didn’t spend the money on it even though Fall boxes are usually my favorite. So far this one looks better than any of the quarterly boxes so far…….. of course.

  14. Same! I saw MSA’s customize notice and decided to check my account to see if perhaps something had changed with the waitlist and noticed I was now getting the fall box. But no notice or email from PS. I’m so glad MSA had the notice!

    I was so torn between the Putty and the Dapple, but I opted for the Putty, even though I already have a brown Fossil crossbody. If the Dapple were more of a true black, I probably would’ve gone for it. So, …dapple, walk of shame, and silver for me!

  15. Still can’t decide between Putty or Dapple!!

    • I know! The struggle is real! I finally opted for the putty though. It looked better on the model in my opinion. If only the other was more black…

    • I’m team dapple! You can’t really go wrong, though. All the options are gorgeous.

      • Team putty!!!

      • Mine’s shipped. Desperately searching the Internet for full spoilers!!

  16. Have people been billed yet? I have not…….

  17. When is shipping expected?

    • They said end of August/early sept

  18. Everyone seems to be raving over this season’s box, and I do think it’s a very nice box, but I don’t like the unfinished interior of the bag. I wouldn’t myself purchase a bag without a finished interior and especially without a separate zippered pocket. It’s cute on the outside but I just wouldn’t buy it. The bag in the Box of Style for this season – which I think is more attractive, but that’s just my taste – has an interior zippered pocket, so that one works much better for me.

    • I used to think that, but I’ve found over the years the interior pockets inevitably end up being too small, or too large for my needs, and it’s easier for me to toss in little pouches (Ipsy bags, anyone? :D) for organization.

      As for the lining, we’ll see, this will be a first for me.

      • I agree

    • I have a Zac Posen bag with an interior like the Cambridge Satchel one and It was different at first, but I like it. I think it’s much easier to clean out the inside. This bag is a small crossbody, there won’t be room or need for zippered compartments. This is a throw your phone, keys, wallet, lipgloss and sunglasses in and go run errands bag.

  19. still not able to decide.
    Putty was the one that got be hooked. Just love that color(and I don’t have any brown-ish bag). But I accidentally subscribed for BoxOfStyle which has the deep orange toned brown.
    So now I may have to change to dapple or stone.
    Stone seems to be too cool-toned for me, but dapple seems too close to black which I already have like hundreds in my closet. If Putty is that bright near ivory brown showing in MSA picture, then I might as well get two browns for this fall, but the picture in PSMH looks almost identical to BOS.

    What should I do… Two browns or not two browns. That is the question.

    • I’m in the same boat because the two brown purse choices from PS & BOS. But ones a darker cognac and ones lighter & more khakhi.

    • I decided to stay with Putty, but I haven’t bought BOS yet. Like you, putty was really calling my name. 😉

  20. I just went to their website and they said the fall box was sold out.

    • It’s been sold out for awhile but some people are still getting off the wait list.

  21. Dying for full spoilers. I jumped on this box after not having purchased it for some time. Popsugar is pretty good about keeping things secret!

  22. Full spoilers PLEASE!!

    • Yes please!🥰

  23. PS used to be my favorite box. I cancelled last year and haven’t looked back. Two thumbs down.

    • 😂😂😂

    • 😂 right!!

  24. If you were on the waitlist, check your account. I just looked at mine and found that I am getting the box and was able to customize. I hadn’t gotten any emails telling me.

    • Thanks for the heads up MJ! I just checked my account and same thing, I’m off waitlist and was able to customize. No emails at all from Popsugar.

    • Me too!

    • No such luck for me yet😪😪

    • When did you sign up?

      • So far, no luck. I signed the waitlist early on the 2nd. I’m beginning to think I’m not going to get the fall box.

      • I just got in today! I also signed up on the 2nd so sign in and check. 🙂

      • August 10th

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.