MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm April 2021 Full Spoilers

BoxyCharm September 2019 Brand Spoilers!


We have spoiler brands for the September 2019 BoxyCharm box! FYI – these are variation brands, so you will not receive all 3 in your box.

The spoiler brands are:

  • tarte
  • Violet Voss
  • Too Faced

What do you think of the September brand spoilers? Which one is your favorite?

(If you aren’t familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $21. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)

If you haven’t signed up for Boxycharm yet:

Now through August 31st (or while supplies last), use this link when you sign up for a Boxycharm subscription to get a free Butter London Palette ($32 Value) AND a free Luxie Brush Set ($30 Value) with your first box!

*Valid for new subscribers or those who canceled before July 1, 2019. Expires August 31, 2019, at 11:59 pm ET or while supplies last.

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Click here to sign up. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 49 comments

Comments (49)

  1. Does anybody know, is the vairant for REGULAR BC? Not the luxe vs. ??? Im dying to know.

  2. I hope I don’t get that MAC lipstick. What a garish color! I don’t mind variations of colors, as long as they are universally flattering, and copper most definitely is not!

    • I agree!

  3. V9 is what I got it was horrible it was the worst box I ever got thinking of cancelling it . I seem to always get the worst box. It is unfair

    • What did u get? I got V7 with some 5$ black eyeliner lolol 😕 . Everything else was good though! The powder, wander, mascara and the pink n silver eyeshadows.

  4. I would enjoy anything other than Mascara. I agree that Ipsy Plus is knocking Boxycharm out. Y’all gotta get on board and send some new stuff

    • I’m a new member of Ipsy, as of last night. I signed up for both BOXYCHARM & BOXYLUXE on the same day-on 7/15/19. I love 💕 Boxycharm so far. But, I really was not at all keen on the Steve Laurant liner. I love the color, but I just did not like the way it felt-as I applied it on my lips — It tugged at my skin & felt pretty dry to me. I’d love to receive some magnetic eyelashes or some really good face lashes that I could use several times-I’ve never tried putting on eyelashes before, which is why I’d like to try the magnetic lashes & some good black eyeliner for the magnetic lashes. I’d also like some Foundation & good concealer & a foundation & fanned Makeup brush, from Luxie & more of that face masks-like the veggies face mask that I receive in July, & some great lip liner that glides on smoothly & stays on & matches the lip gloss, or lip paint, or lipstick-that last & smells good, & some really good hydrating serum to go on under my foundation, & their this collagen peel off facemask that I’ve been hearing about. I don’t know who makes it where they get it from, but I’ve heard many great things about it and I would love a great eyebrow pencil that with one stroke it looks like you’ve left for five little bitty lines and it feels in the thin areas real good & all. I’m a sucker for blushes & Luxie & Clinique Makeup brushes, too.

  5. I hate how there’s variation boxes. And how not everyone gets the same thing. I’m always getting the 2nd box. I might just cancel!

  6. Hi my name is Mrs. Lizette Martinez and I would love ❤️ to get Violet Voss hoping is a Pallet. Also don’t mind in getting Tarte hoping also it would be a Pallet. Thank you so much 😊.

  7. Make up removers or brush cleaners would be cool to

  8. I’m new to Boxy…if you get the Luxe do you also get the items in the regular box for September? Or do you just get a different box with a higher value and different products?

    • You will never get the regular items of boxycharm box in a boxy luxie boxycharm box. It’s a slue of other products equaling $250+ value. With that being said it has way more than 5 full sized items in the box. Skin care, makeup, hair care, and serums!
      I’m looking forward to the clipless iron being I don’t own one.

    • You get the three spoiler items from the regular box, but the other items are all different for the Lux box.

  9. I’d rather see some other things than eye shadow colors, mascara, pencils, brushes, cleasning creams, better colored lip gloss than the awful colors I’ve been getting. How about some skin care products and neutral tone makeup.

  10. I think I saw something on Instagram with one of the too faced face palettes. I think the natural face one.

  11. I just cancelled my Boxycharm. They sent me all of the makeup options in my August box when my profile quiz is filled out as “all skincare, no makeup”. They have been saying on their social media that they’re using our profiles to determine our boxes, and I refuse to pay them $21 + tax per month for them to send me all the options I have indicated I do NOT want.

    • The August box gets a thumbs down. I may cancel if they don’t step up. I am mature[ older].I donot wear false eyelashes and this was not a spoiler for this box. I have enough eyeshadow for 6 months or more. This does not fit my profile for sure.

  12. Sorry for typo I meant not another tarte palette.. they aren’t always pigmented..

  13. I hope that we fonr get another Tarte palette… Tarte Mascara is okay, but I already have 1 on my September box. Violet Voss yes.. Too faced would be fine as long as they are new products that I can use and won’t have to giveaway… I cant wait to see more spoilers for the boxyluxe and regular box…

  14. After seeing surveys on MSA stating that Boxycharm has repeatedly been ranked as subscribers favorite box, I checked out the latest box which was July.
    I really just wanted the brushes & the Butter London palette, so I went ahead and signed up.
    THEN I see a promo code for the August box to get the brushes and palette for free w/new subscription. Grrrr😠
    Hope the box lives up to the reputation and high standard that MSA is pushing.

    • Hi! 😄. Just send them an email and they’ll add it for you. That happened to me when I signed up last month. They get right back to you are are really nice.

  15. Great brands…. Now lets hope its something good!!!

  16. How much do you want to bet it’s the Too Faced mascara everyone’s complaining about in the Ipsy bag for September? 😂😂 You can’t escape it!

    • Is that the new Damn Girl one? If so, I freaking love it. I got it as a free deluxe sample with my Sephora purchase and it’s seriously one of my new favorites. I would LOVE to get a full size.

      Though I admit, the brush was intimidating at first. Felt like I was going to toothbrush my eyeball if I wasn’t careful.

      • Lol, I too would actually love to get that one I’ve heard amazing results on it I’ve been wanting to buy it but Ipsy and boxycharm sends me so much mascara I couldn’t justify spending the money on it. I know I love the better than sex mascara and this one looks like a hybrid of it

    • You read my mind!

  17. So we know the tarte Park ave princess (for people who didn’t get it) and I’d bet another variation is the VV HG palette (same deal) (and although I wasn’t subbed, pleeeease don’t let me get this one – I already own it!)

  18. Just wondering where is BoxyCharm and Ipsy located in the country?

    • I think I read Boxycharm is in Georgia and my Ipsy package is shipping from Harrisburg NC.

      • Boxycharm ships from Kennesaw, Georgia but I believe they are based out of Florida.

      • Yes they are based in South Florida near Miami

      • Ipsy also ships from Texas and I’m pretty sure the billing comes from California.

      • Ipsy also ships from Hebron, Kentucky. Every month, my regular Glam Bag comes from North Carolina and my Glam Bag Plus comes from Kentucky

  19. I like Tarte I hope I get something from them. I didn’t get the Tarte Pallet in my Ipsy box

  20. 1 110% agree!! I HATE the variations!!

  21. I canceled today. When I canceled it said I would miss out on these brands and also Hank and Henry, MAC and Dr. Brandt products also. I am not sure if this means these brands will also be in the September box but I canceled anyway. I don’t want the clip less curling iron, the pineapple serum or a water bottle. I really only want the Sunday Riley but it’s not worth the risk of missing out.

    • I’m feeling the exact same way. If I cancel it will be too avoid the same stuff.

      Probably not bad stuff but nothing I need. I already don’t use either of my hand burning clipless curling irons. The tiny flat iron and baby hair dryer I’ve gotten in Luxe boxes haven’t been great.

      • Best comment ever I enjoyed getting it and looking at it but I don’t use it I don’t need it and I am so sick and tired of getting pencils in my box every single month and then every other month mascara and it’s usually not even good mascara and the pencils are normally Dusty or they break as soon as you push down on them

    • I think some of those products or for the Boxycharm snot the boxyluxe, they stilll haven’t showed everything for boxyluxe. I want to cancel to I still haven’t got my box for the first time and I know I’m going to be disappointed.

    • I saw a comment on Reddit that said a Hank and Henry (eye?) liner or a Mac cb96 lipstick. It’s a frost lipstick in a coppery orange shade.

  22. They all sound good…hope they are not variations…I’d Love to get some sigma brushes to try out before I’d invest in them….that would be a great boxy item.

    • U can sometimes find sigma brushes at tj max and marshals

  23. Variations!!!!! 😠 Too many the last year! I’ve stuck with Boxy because of Luxe, but these variations are really starting to get to me. The main reason is the best of the variants, usually are unicorn items that very few get or that influencers get.

    • Yes, the serum this month definitely seems to be a unicorn item!

  24. I’m pretty psyched about the brand spoilers. I’d love to get a primer from Too Faced, especially the eyeshadow insurance or the peach one.
    From Tarte I would love to see one of their newer skincare products like the Knockout Tingling Treatment, Marajuka Neck Treatment, or Baba Bomb moisturizer, all of which are Clean Beauty products. If it had to be a palette I’d very pleased to get the super gorgeous, inside and out High Tides & Good Vibes (also Clean Beauty) or the Pro Remix Amazonian Clay one.
    As far as Violet Voss, the Sugar Crystals, Flamingo Pro, or one of the smaller Rainbow palettes would be amazing.
    I think sending something they don’t often send like clean beauty products, especially skincare would be fantastic. I don’t think we’ve ever received a neck moisturizer or anything like the Knockout Tingling Treatment. I know some people don’t want any skincare at all. If they’re happy with what we get now, cool. But if they complain about too many mascaras or highlighters or even palettes, what do they expect? There are only so many types of makeup products that can be sent month after month. Throwing in a skincare product or two, especially new-to-the-market ones, would at least provide some variety and a source of nice gifts for friends and family of the folks that only use the makeup.
    Ipsy Plus has been beating Boxy in a few ways, including the number of very new brands and products. I hope Boxy will start doing the same, especially if they continue not to use our profiles or any kind of customization.

    • I too agree that some skin care creams, moisturizers, foundation makeup would be great.

      • You get regular box plus 3 or 4 more. I have never regretted a lux

    • It would be nice if there are skin care items from Tarte of Too Faced. But most likely they are more eyeshadow palettes. Just got the Butter London in July which will last me close to a year and then the ACE Beaute cute one in AUgust which I gave away bc I dont need more eyeshadows. I wish no more mascara ( I do not use it) or eyeshadows (have plenty with Butter London palette)

    • Does anybody know, is the vairant for REGULAR BC? Not the luxe vs. ??? Im dying to know.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.