MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm April 2021 Full Spoilers

BoxyCharm September 2019 Spoilers Round #3!


We have another spoiler for the September 2019 BoxyCharm box!

We’re not sure yet if this is a variant item, but at least some subscribers will receive:

Dr. Brandt Hydro Biotic Recovery Sleeping Mask

And in case you missed the previous spoilers, the September BoxyCharm box will include:

Violet Voss Essentials Eyeshadow Palette


Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette


Too Faced Natural Face Palette

The September brand spoilers are:

  • dr. brandt
  • tarte
  • Violet Voss
  • Too Faced
  • M·A·C Cosmetics
  • Hank & Henry Beauty

The September box will also include:

Image: hankandhenrybeauty

Hank & Henry Beauty Liquid Liner in Blickity Black


M·A·C Cosmetics Frost Lipstick in CB 96

What do you think of the September spoilers? Which one is your favorite?

(If you aren’t familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $21. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)

If you haven’t signed up for Boxycharm yet:

Now through August 31st (or while supplies last), use this link when you sign up for a Boxycharm subscription to get a free Butter London Palette ($32 Value) AND a free Luxie Brush Set ($30 Value) with your first box!

*Valid for new subscribers or those who canceled before July 1, 2019. Expires August 31, 2019, at 11:59 pm ET or while supplies last.

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Click here to sign up. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 46 comments

Comments (46)

  1. I got that ugly VV pallet. I’ll never use the colours, it sucks because it’s a nice big pallet. I would have LOVED to get one of the other ones

  2. I got the bc palette and don’t see myself using those colors but once, maybe twice. Anyone want to swap with me?

  3. Is anyone else having issues with their subscription renewing? I have tried two different cards and have called my provider but they say Boxy isn’t even attempting to charge my card. When I’ve contacted customer service they say it’s on my end.

  4. I ended up cancelling my Boxyluxe at the last minute. My brothers getting married a few states away this weekend and I had to pony up gas money and half the cash on a hotel room. I’m still getting the regular box because I’d be thrilled with any one of those pallets(fingers crossed for too faced I don’t own any pallets from them yet) As far as getting things I don’t like or can’t use I have a basket i put everything in and I give them away to friends and family for birthdays and holidays. The price of the box is definitely worth the value of the products we get by far so even if I only get lie to or three things I will use it’s still a great value. I can’t even remember the last time I actually spent money on makeup except for foundation , concealer and setting powder. Other than the a year of boxy has provided me with enough eyeshadows, blushes, highlighters, and makeup brushes to last forever. I have enough pallets to make just about any look I want.

  5. I have the opposite problem, I have highlighter marked always and have only gotten 1. I marked lashes never and I have gotten them twice.

  6. So I went to Sephora inside JCP and I got the Top faced natural matte for 19$ and they had the gingerbread and chocolate (good and another bone) for 35% off so if your looking for too faced palettes check your Sephora (JCP() bc I’m not sure if they have that same at regular Sephora.

  7. I better not get that VV I don’t wear eyeshadows. Omg that’s one thing about boxy too many variations and also they don’t let you opt out of categories like Ipsy even if you have a health. Reason , they said maybe sometime in the future when I emailed them.. when 2036? Lol

    • I emailed regarding an item in BoxyLuxe for September that I’m allergic to one of the main ingredients, and they said I will get the other option instead.

  8. Is the VV or Tarte or Too Faced palette that we’re talking about here for the regular BoxyCharm or for BoxyLuxe only? Can someone please confirm? This will determine whether I continue my subscription.

    • All from the Boxycharm honey

      • Do you know if there is a way to see what’s coming in the box before it arrives, like with iPsy?

  9. At least there’s no water bottle in the regular boxycharm box, but is going to be a variation in the luxe box, so mad, should of just got a regular box

    • I agree no offense but I am particular on water bottle and I didn’t want to pay all that money for boxyluxe for them to throw a stupid water bottle in the mix . This is not FFF which I do not like. I signed up for this for skincare/makeup/tools for beauty not a dang water bottle what a waste and stupid filler 😡

      • Agreed!!!

      • I cancelled Luxe as the water bottle was just the last straw for me. Even if I don’t like a color of something I’ll still try it and sometimes I’m wrong and it turns out to be great. I have water bottles that are so much cuter than that one.

    • I know! I can’t believe that the regular box gets the Too Faced face palette as a variant item and the Boxyluxe got a choice of the Tarte PAP palette (which I already received last year) or a stupid water bottle! They didn’t add the Too Faced palette until after they sent the email asking us to make a selection. The base box looks better than Boxyluxe IMO. Maybe it’s time for Ipsy Ultimate.

  10. Finally think I’m canceling Boxy. I switched from 3-mo or MTM so I could cancel when the feeling struck. I am so overloaded with product right now.

    • I just started with August and I subscribed late. My box actually just shipped. I keep waiting to see if I will continue with September but these reveals are not doing it for me. I will skip September and hope for a good October box.

  11. I hope that’s in my luxe box!

  12. I don’t want V V palette and will be so frustrated if I get it. My profile says NO to those kinda colors. I’m in my 50’s and that is not complimentary on me at all. I like the Dr Brandt cleanser and would welcome the night mask. I’d prefer the Too Faced over the Tarte palette but will be grateful with either. As long as it isn’t the V V one I’m golden. No to the water bottle for sure. I am new to BC/BL so hopefully they will send a palette. I’d also according to my profile prefer the peach lipstick to the black eye liner. I don’t wear black eyeliners at all. To dark for my fair skin.

    • Hi, check out the boxy facebook pages. I know that if I got either palette I’d swap for the vv.

    • I can almost assure you that the only thing they use our preferences for is to color match our skin. I say no eyeliner, especially not black and I receive them all the time. If your looking for a sub that really caters to your preferences, boxy isn’t for you. Great box but alot of us have to trade out to get what we want. Or we just sell or gift what we don’t use. When you get alot of value for little, you can’t expect it to be exactly how you want and you gotta roll with it or cancel. The chances of getting all items you want are slim to none. I’ve been with Boxy for 4 yrs and it’s happened maybe 3 times. But when you know you like more then $21 retail value worth of stuff, you can’t complain too much so I don’t.

      • I completely share your view on subscription boxes.

        I receive more than the value of the box all the time – there are always at least one if not two items that I genuinely like and find use for.

        The boxes also provide me with the fun of discovering stuff and opening boxes in general :-). What doesn’t get used or wanted provides me with the joy of being able to gift to friends. In my circle of friends everything is happily used as I have a wide swath of ages, tastes, style and complexions.

        When a subscription stops providing me with even the value of the cost, I drop it as I did with Allure, Play and BeautyFIX.

        I really don’t understand the moaning about not getting exactly what you want. If you want exactly what you want use the money to buy it. Nobody actually NEEDS the amount of product that is received in boxes – unless you are getting fun from the element of surprise and discovery , they are not a rational economic choice versus using the money to purchase fewer items but exactly what you need when you need it.

      • I just said in my post that apparently boxycharms motto is that you can’t have too many black eyeliners or mascara lol! Guess what it looks like another black eyeliner is coming my way (I know it’s an either or with the lipstick but I end up with the eyeliner every time) it’s fine cause a new palette always makes me happy and in almost 4 tears I’ve only had more products I didn’t like that did 3 times so I’ll give boxycharm their credit too (not with boxyluxe, it sucks and I canceled just now)

    • Carla…we are in the same boat sister..i am with you all the way on these items..good to know someone else see’s the same way I do.. oh yea..58 here..

      • 51 😊. Love this value! Would never try lots of these products otherwise Have tried and enjoyed stuff I would have left set on the shelf before. Surprised at all the products I do like! I keep telling my husband “Feel my skin! Isn’t it soft? Now tell me I’m pretty! 😉”

      • OMG Geri that is so funny BUT TRUE!!! I also love most of what we get.

    • Hey I can’t do Tarte palettes because the scent in them makes my eyelids swell, so I’d love to get the VV palette. If you get the VV and I get the Tarte id be happy to swap!

      • I wish I had better luck with Ipsy. I’ve had highlighters marked as rarely but have received them 6 times in the 7 months I’ve been a member. I’ve tried telling customer service but they aren’t always helpful.
        They did send me a replacement box for August. But every single item except one (the Suva highlighter drops) was different than the one I was meant to get. Instead of the IT foundation i got a Wander highlighter project. And they sent me the same eyeshadow pallete as last month. It was kinda frustrating.
        All that being said its always a great deal and worth the $25💜

    • I would swap you for the VV in a hot minute.

    • Hi Carla, Boxycharm is definitely not known for going by profiles. It’s the luck of the draw with Boxycharm and Luxe unless they let us customize for Boxyluxe one item or a couple item like they did for the upcoming luxe box. If you are looking for a sub that is gonna listen to and go by your profile and preferences then Ipsy Glam Bag Plus is the best one out there in my opinion. BC has been saying they are going to start using our profiles for about a year now and still hasn’t except for skin tones.

      • They have updated a bit. I’m really hoping it makes a difference.
        I think that’s been done recently. Fingers crossed.
        The VV would make the box for me. Most everything is
        great except for blasted water bottle!

    • I saw that and wondered exactly who the VV would be good for? I sincerely hope they read our profiles and realize that is NOT complimentary to a 50+ year-end lady😉

      • If you get it and would like to swap for a face palette just let me know!!

    • If you get it and would like to swap for the face palette just let me know!

  13. Apsoloutly love the makeup primers gloss everything but 1 the fake lashes will be great for Halloween thanks lol but would love some more close to natural ones… I thought I was buying great makeup already but after using the different ones from boxy charms never had so many compliments… Sooooo just keep on sending thanks boxy charm 😘

  14. Reg. BC has no chance of the waterbottle! Lol. I’m debating if I want to stay for the Luxe skincare or taking my chances with 2 BC boxes. I think the majority will be the VV palette since it’s the cheapest/lowest rv.

    • The Skincare box is back ?

  15. I love all dr.brant products but I really don’t need another sleeping mask… wish it was moisturizer or even a cleanser… but I’m not complaining though Boxyluxe is awesome period.

  16. Hope it doesn’t smell like the cleanser in that line that we got in the luxe a few months ago! Barf

    • I definitely don’t want a sleeping mask with yogurt in it. Yuck! Yogurt on my pillow? No thanks! That’s probably why the cleanser smelled bad.

      I hope this isn’t in Luxe.

    • OMG! Lol I know that smelt so so bad like old man smell like the original old spice for older men but a superfood mask! It was so hard getting that smell off my face when I tried it I literally showerd 2 times plus scrubbed my face a few times before that

  17. I don’t really want that,hope it’s not in my luxe box

    • I wish I had better luck with Ipsy. I’ve had highlighters marked as rarely but have received them 6 times in the 7 months I’ve been a member. I’ve tried telling customer service but they aren’t always helpful.
      They did send me a replacement box for August. But every single item except one (the Suva highlighter drops) was different than the one I was meant to get. Instead of the IT foundation i got a Wander highlighter project. And they sent me the same eyeshadow pallete as last month. It was kinda frustrating.
      All that being said its always a great deal and worth the $25💜

      • Looking forward to this box. Im hoping to get the essential palette and for sure the eyeliner!!! Unfortunately the lipsticks ive gotten are not colors i would ever use

      • same here orange and reds look awful on me unfortunately

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.