MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

POPSUGAR Must Have Fall 2019 Box Spoilers + Customization Time!

We have THREE spoilers for the Fall POPSUGAR Must Have box! And all three of them are selection items! If you are already a subscriber, you can log in to your account to select which options you want. And if you are a new subscriber, you’ll be able to pick your items after you subscribe!

New subscribers can use coupon code MSA20 to save $20 off of the Fall POPSUGAR Must Have box, too! (Regularly $75 a box.)

FYI – past boxes have sold out before full spoilers were available, so if you want a Fall box, I recommend subscribing very soon. UPDATE – the fall box may have already sold out. I’ve reached out to POPSUGAR to confirm, and will update this post once I have more info.

UPDATE – The fall box has sold out, but if you sign up now you will get on the waitlist.

Here’s the first spoiler:

The Cambridge Satchel Company Push Lock Purse 

Your choice of Putty, Dapple or Stone

Your most versatile accessory is here: this 100 percent leather push-lock crossbody bag, handmade in Great Britain. The modern design can be easily dressed up or down, so you’ll find yourself reaching for it all season long. Choose from three different Fall-inspired shades — Putty, Dapple, or Stone.

Putty

Dapple

Stone

Here’s the second spoiler:

Tai Jewelry Adjustable Ring with Labradorite and Dark Blue Opaque Stone

Your choice of Gold or Silver

Add a touch of metallic to your outfit with this chic ring, handmade in Thailand by skilled artisans. The featured stone is Labradorite, which is thought to protect against misfortune and negativity. We love that the design is adjustable, so it can fit any finger. It’s the perfect addition to your jewelry collection.

Gold

Silver

Here’s the third spoiler:

Charlotte Tilbury Matte Revolution Lipstick

Your choice of Pillow Talk or Walk of Shame

All beauty-lovers should have a Charlotte Tilbury Matte Revolution Lipstick in their makeup arsenal. The smooth formula never dries your mouth out; a blend of oils, triglycerides, and waxes glide long-lasting color onto the lips. Choose between celebrity favorite Pillow Talk, a cult classic, or Walk of Shame, the bestselling berry-rose hue from the brand.

Walk of Shame

Here’s Walk of Shame shown on different models from Charlotte Tilbury’s site:

Pillow Talk

Here’s Pillow Talk shown on different models from Charlotte Tilbury’s site:

What do you think of the spoilers? Which items are you picking? Let me know if you have any questions about the items – I have them all in hand!

And there are Add-Ons available, too! If you aren’t familiar, you can log in to your account and select any/all of these to add to your box at a discount:

Shashi Bengali Headband

Ettika Lots of Love Resin Heart Hoop Earrings

Shashi Set of 2 Triangular Grey Lucite Hair Clips

Ettika Split Heart Sparkle Earrings

One Love Organics Skin Savior Balm

One Love Organics Botanical E Youth Serum Roller Ball

Let me know if you have any questions about the Add-On items or the spoilers!

New subscribers can use coupon code MSA20 to save $20 off of the Fall POPSUGAR Must Have box, too! (Regularly $75 a box.)

Check out all of my POPSUGAR Must Have reviews and POPSUGAR Must Have Box spoilers to see what you can expect from this women’s lifestyle subscription box!

POPSUGAR Must Have

How do subscribers rate POPSUGAR Must Have?

Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about POPSUGAR Must Have!

Enable notifications () to get the latest POPSUGAR Must Have spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in POPSUGAR Must Have Box, POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 368 comments

Comments (368)

    • There won’t b anymore spoilers they said. N boxes are already shipping. 😍
      Mines due on the 9th. Im so excited! ❤

  1. Still no shipping notification for me and it’s going to take at least a month to arrive after it does ship. 😭
    Stupid slow FedEx and APO address.

  2. My box has shipped, and should be here Wednesday! I’m so excited to see the rest of it, and kind of like that it will be a surprise.

    • Just got my shipping notification too! Whoohoo! But not due to arrive till the 10th. But at least it’s shipped! Cant wait to see the remainder of the box! Finally, a surprise! 😍

  3. So disappointed. I signed up for the Wait List a long time ago. A week and a half ago I signed into my account and it said it was time to customize my Fall Box. I was so excited thinking I’d been moved off the wait list. I made my selections and they saved. I went in yesterday and even though it shows my customizations for the Fall Box, I noticed it said in small letters at the top that my first box would be the Winter Box. I emailed their CS and they said it’s a glitch in their system that’s allowing people on the Wait List to customize the fall box and my first box will be the Winter Box 🙁

  4. Ugh, anyone else DYING for more info on this box?? Website says shipping is supposed to begin at the end of August. Anyone know what their shipping methods are or what the window is like? My curiosity is KILLING me!! Wish they would drop hints about the other box items.

    • I contacted popsugar on Facebook yesterday inquiring about more spoilers & shipping times. Was told there will b no more spoilers for this box, that they want the remainder to remain a surprise. 😝. They also said they will start shipping out boxes in 2 weeks. So no shipping until about mid September.

    • Ships Fedex Smartpost. Mine shipped out today. No more spoilers willb given they said

  5. I just realized I ordered walk of shame and not pillow Talk if anyone is interested is a straight trade if they don’t like the pillow talk in person once they get it I’m open to a trade… I’m too fair for such a beautiful color so pillow Talk would be better for me. I remember I switched it before I read this article and unfortunately it was too late to change. The other website I looked at the colors gave me a different color when I saw how I believe it was Liz who posted the different skin tones with the dif colors I noticed realized that walk of shame wasn’t going to work for me.. just throwing it out there if anyone is interested. I found out that they’re mailing out the boxes in mid September, which I’ll probably get my fall popsugar box before my edit sale from FFF summer first lol….

  6. Hi Liz,
    Just scrolling through all the comments hoping there were more spoilers lol, I complain when there are no surprises in sub boxes yet look for more in boxes that only offer a few.. anyway I am a subscriber of almost every sub box, it gets addictive.. even FFF Which was a total letdown this year considering I already received my fall box yet still waiting on my summer edit orders I guess if you order a lot ($500 plus this last time) it gets harder and harder for them hopefully this move changes that in the very near future (winter box and edit sale is my last chance I’m giving them to fix this ongoing issue before I stop for awhile).
    But my entire point was if anyone is looking for anything particular from sub boxes (Summer Popsugar 2019 box included) is there any forum on here that people can switch or sell something from a sub box they don’t want??
    Just asking because there’s a lot I love about every box, but I’m also a realist and realize that each season of each box is not going to be a winner for everyone, but I also don’t want to start/stop, start/stop w/sub boxes b/c there’s other smaller items (possibly not the box front runners for that season) that I usually do want. But, I’m also against waste. Yeah, some things do get gifted or my daughters want them but I’ve noticed the more popularity these subs get there’s more duplicates of the same product. And lately I’ve noticed there’s a few that have been offering the same items, same season, etc…I am in business so I 100% get the MSRP markup and also not sure how if not already available some type of service will benefit you Liz, maybe keeping prices at a flat rate plus a shipping fee will help more people keep current subs and also allow them to get things from different ones that will eventually lead them into subscribing…. idk… maybe that could benefit you not sure??? but I think something like that might benefit the community of sub box buyers and it’s an awesome thing you provide for people who are wondering about the particular box and offer a discount for them….maybe the sales could be used towards an already subscribed box so we could get a ‘discount’ towards the ongoing sub. Just a thought… sorry if I happened to leave out a portion of this I was interrupted by something that always throws my thought process off track, taking care of my mother, she’s not elderly (which I’m more used to taking care of and understand much easier) my mother has a really difficult mental disease, wanting one that doesn’t exist. Therefore she’s been hospitalized for her behavior and is currently in the hospital for this and she just threw my entire idea behind writing this off track.. I scanned over it and it made sense to me but it usually will considering… anyway have a wonderful day everyone and I have summer popsugar items brand new unused/unopened if interested (without me having to list on Poshmark or Mercari).

    • Hi Amanda, sign up for the MSA swap site. There is a waiting list, but once on you can list your items up for swap.

  7. I signed up on 8/10. I may not get the fall box. Popsugar knocked this one way out of the park!!! This is a fantastic curation😊😊💕💕

  8. Anxiously awaiting for the full spoilers or the review of the box.

    • Same!!

    • Same here! I took a look at past season spoilers, and generally there was another spoiler a month after the first. So maybe we’ll get something soon! This round of spoilers was three items, though, so that may be it for the season!

  9. I tried to sign up for the wait list but I noticed that Popsugar requires pay for the box immediately upon waitlisting. Does anyone know if I will be able to customize the box if I’m able to get one off the wait list? Or will they just send me a random selection? I have really specific color choices for this one, so my ability to choose them kind of determines whether or not I want the box. I’m a little wary to pay upfront. Any experience with Popsugar waitlist?

    • You will get to customize once you are off the waitlist.

      If you have not checked that you are off the waitlist, be sure to log in on the app/website. Like others, I did not get an email when I moved off the waitlist.

      • Thanks for the info! 🙂

    • You will get to customize but sometimes certain colors sell out and are no longer available when you get off the waitlist.

  10. I feel like I’m never getting off the waitlist. I was trying to resist temptation and finally gave in on 7/31. Probably too late. Oh well.

    • Don’t give up! I signed up on 7/31 and got off the waitlist, I Just checked. As other people said in the comments, I didn’t receive an email. (And thanks to those who shared their experiences, without them I wouldn’t have checked.)
      This is my first time subscribing, I was able to proceed with customization and all the options appeared available – unless I messed up.

  11. FYI: I signed up in the am of Tuesday the 30th and just got off the wait list today.

  12. Signed up on the 30th. Got off waitlist today (no emails but I’ve been checking once a day since I bought the box)

  13. Just an update for everyone on the waitlist, I signed up on Tuesday morning last week around 530 AM and I got off the waitlist today! I didn’t get an email, just saw it when checked my account!

  14. An update for those of you hoping to get off the waitlist – I signed up at 12:30 am on Tuesday, July 30, and I just got taken off the waitlist and given my customization options! 🙂 I didn’t get an e-mail; I’d just been refreshing the page a couple of times a day out of sheer hope!

    (I’ve also been refreshing this page, hoping for new comments about people getting off the waitlist, which is why I’m posting now. If there’s anyone else out there like me, I hope this is helpful!)

    • Thanks for sharing! I signed up sometime in the morning on that day but nothing yet…

      • Here’s hoping you’ll get off the waitlist, too! 🙂

      • I got off the list! 🙂

      • Oh, good! I was hoping you would! 🙂

  15. Tried using the coupon and it doesn’t work. 🙁 Is it no longer valid?

  16. This spoiler convinced me to sign up. I hope I make it off the waitlist. 😬

  17. I am very confused about the “wait list.” How do you know if you are off of it? Why is there one to begin with? Anyone have any insight?

    • The Fall box sold out so you’re put on the waitlist. As people drop their subscription in the coming weeks, the first person on the waitlist then gets the newly freed up box, and so on. It’s only early August, so I imagine quite a few people will cancel, so it’s worth a shot if you really want it. If the Fall box never becomes available for you, then you’ll automatically get the Winter. It doesn’t sound from the others like PSMH notifies you when you’re off the wait list, so just periodically check your account I guess? HTH.

  18. I signed up Monday evening, July 29th… checked my account this morning and was able to customize for the Fall box. YAY!

  19. These are the best spoilers ever. I m loving the bag and the ring. I cant wait to get the box.

  20. I’m definitely signed up for fall. However, my account online shows nothing at all. CS confirmed to me that i have an active sub for fall.
    Anyone else having this issue?

  21. Signed up yesterday morning and still not off wait list. Fingers crossed! I will update if I do end up getting the Fall box but wanted to alert others who haven’t signed up yet.

    • I did the same thing on the morning of the 30th and they said would maybe get the fall box, but I’m thinking I’m going to be getting winter because haven’t got any notifications and still says winter on my account!

    • Just got off the wait list today. Yay! I am so excited for this box!!!

  22. The darker lipstick, “Walk of Shame”, was in the 2018 CT Advent Calendar, I realized, which is why I chose “Pillow Talk”. Just wanted to remind anyone that might have it and might have forgotten that it was included.

    Also, when does this ship? It’s probably on the site, but I don’t know where to look.

  23. It’s really interesting to see everyone freaking out about the wait list. It’s a marketing tactic. Three years ago it seems the forums were full of people complaining that it’s misleading, and it really is. They used to use it as a fine print method of getting rid of extra boxes… now it seems like they’re using it to get people to sign up early.

    • There are lots of boxes that sell out. Beauty fix used to sell out and test tube. I’ve missed out on many sold out boxes so that when MSA offer a few good spoilers and a coupon, FOMO is enough to make me sign up. 🙂 Popsugar is new for me – I dropped beautyfix and FFF and Ipsy Glam bag+ on hold (product overload)

    • Boxes have sold totally out before in days. The last Neiman Marcus did not last long at all.

      It isn’t always a marketing tactic. In 2017 I could not get to a PS box fast enough and lost out.

      • Eh. I stand by my original comment. The Neiman Marcus box was an LE. They didn’t even do waiting lists for LEs back in the day. But here we are, over a week later, and I’m still seeing new comments from subscribers who are signing up for the Fall box and getting it, so….I will never believe PS really sells out a box the same day spoilers are released. They are capitalizing on your FOMO.

    • The spring box with the gym bag sold out.

  24. I signed up and paid on Monday after hearing some got off the waitlist. I checked my account this AM and was shown the fall box and able to customize!

    * I didn’t get an email – so be sure to log into your account if you signed up for winter.

    I choose Dapple bag, gold ring, walk of shame. I really haven’t been this excited for a bag in a while.

  25. Liz- do you Pay now to be on the waitlist? Or once there is a box avail (either fall or when winter comes out)

    • I signed up last night and just got billed this morning. Says winter is still my first box

  26. I’m so digging this PSMH box so far! I have two accounts & chose the Putty & Dapple bags & each metal choice for the rings.
    Initially I was also going to get both the CT colors, but realized Pillow Talk will wash me out/ I love a dark lipstick, so am receiving two of the Walk of Shame lipsticks. So excited!!

  27. It’s already sold out!!!!! ;0

  28. I saw it was on waitlist this morning, but signed up anyway. I checked my account a couple hours later & it said I could customize my fall box 😃

  29. Does anyone have any idea on how likely it is to get off the waitlist?

    • I was wondering the same thing. I canceled FabFitFun and then saw that it was a waitlist 🙁

  30. Liz,
    Is there more information on the material of the ring? Are they gold plated brass/sterling silver plated brass etc or something else altogether? Is there nickel in them? Appreciate your assistance. Thank you

    • I’ll reach out and ask!

    • The gold ring is Gold plating over brass. Waiting to hear back on silver ring materials. I’ll keep you posted!

  31. Didn’t we get this same Cambridge satchel in the very first ever Rachel Zoe box? They can’t even come up with a new bag? 😛 Glad I cancelled. At least this has a better RV than last time, though.

    • The bag is different. The RZ had an annoying clear pocket on the back and was stark optic white. This one does not have that thing on the back thank heavens and is not bright white.

  32. Hey POPSUGAR, how about stocking more boxes in the first place?? The demand is obviously there. All of your quarterly boxes and the Neiman Marcus box have sold out, and most pretty quickly. The Fall box sign up started on Friday, and the box was sold out by Monday morning, or possibly Sunday based on some comments I’ve seen. Now you have A LOT of unhappy potential customers. Is that really your business model?

    • But how would you know how many they stocked? Obviously this one was extremely popular, and PSMH wouldn’t necessarily know that prior to releasing spoilers, so it is what it is. You get to have FOMO. I keep my sub active and would cancel if I didn’t like spoilers, so you could always do that to avoid your disappointment.

      • Actually, I got the Fall box on Saturday so I don’t have FOMO. And I’ve been able to get the boxes I’ve wanted. My comment was directed to PSMH because ALL of their boxes have been selling out, and I’ve seen the comments from disappointed potential subscribers. Clearly there are more interested buyers than available boxes. If they were able to stock more (and maybe they can’t because they can only get a limited number of discounted items from the vendors), they’d easily sell them, and they would have more happy customers. That was my point.

      • I think part of their strategy is for it to sell out every time. It drives the FOMO for the next box.

      • They had a few do really poorly (I snagged at least two on MAJOR discounts) and this feels like an overcompensation. I’d imagine that they intentionally majorly understock so that they can easily brag that the boxes are sold out…especially because those of us signing up for the waitlist have a good chance of forgetting to cancel if we don’t get the box we wanted, and then being easy sales for the future.

        That said, hey, it’s working haha. And this curation is UHM-azing so… 🙂

      • You’re so right. I remember Fall 18 hanging around for a while. Winter was overstocked also.

  33. I haven’t been interested in a Popsugar box in years, but this one is tempting. If I hadn’t received that same handbag in a rachel zoe box a few years ago, I would def buy this. I hope next season is as good so i can resub

    • I am surprised people are so excited this time. I remember people were very meh about this bag in the RZ box. Maybe the color choice helps. I am still meh however.

  34. I was going to get a second box to use as Christmas gifts, but the PSMH site says the Fall box is sold out. Wow – they knocked it out of the park with these first three spoilers. Can’t wait to see the rest of the box!

  35. Liz, I have a question regarding the ring – what sort of packaging does it come in aka would you say it’s giftable? Thanks!

  36. I just subbed the other day (first time!) Will there be more spoliers? Or just the products shown? Thanks!

  37. I am sooo glad I didn’t hesitateon purchasing this box. I was initially gonna wait until later this week but for whatever reason just jumped in and pre-paid. Now I see it may be sold out already. Wow! That was FAST!!!

  38. I just went to get it and it’s sold out!!! Arg!!

  39. I should always read the lastest post from box lovers because i went and grabbed the box around 5ish and i couldn’t customize my picks only to come on here to see that i had signed for for winter instead. I was very sadbut in checking the newest post i read that some peoples boxes changed back to fall so i went back and i am getting fall and i did get to pick my options. Yeah so happy again. So all in all i should read before i jet off and spend lots of money. 🙂 Thanks peops

  40. I just signed up for the fall box but cannot find where to customize and make my selections. Can someone help me!? 🙁

    • Same here. It says my first box is the winter box and when I ordered it said pre order fall box. I am very confused. I do not want it if it is the winter box I signed up for the fall box.

  41. Fall is my fave time of year and I seem to really like fall and winter boxes over the spring and summer ones. I ordered pmsh and fff so far- we still haven’t found out about causebox and box of style and happy rebel- I may be in trouble!

  42. These spoilers are amazing! And by far the best of any box so far since PS went quarterly. Small crossbody bags are my jam! I started with stone and then switched to dapple, because I thought the darker color might show less wear, but stone is calling my name again and I think I’ll be switching back. Also, I love blue stones and silver rings, and I’ve really been wanting to try a dark lipstick, so Walk of Shame it is! Yay I win!!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

 
 

Two Days Only: Create Your Own Tarte Beauty Box!
7 Full-Size Products, Just $63