Facebook PixelThe Organic Bunny Box Natural Beauty Review - May 2019 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Organic Bunny Box Natural Beauty Review – May 2019

Marne Orenich
ByMarne OrenichJun 5, 2019 | 8 comments

The Organic Bunny box

The Organic Bunny Box
3.5 overall rating
4 Ratings | 0 Reviews

The Organic Bunny Box is a monthly offering of the best organic, non-toxic, clean beauty items from skincare to makeup and even snacks and home goods from beauty blogger Amanda Jo (aka The Organic Bunny). You'll get a great bang for your buck since there are 6-8 organic items included in this $59.00 subscription. I always discover a lot of great brands that are reasonably priced through this box and the mix is super varied each time.

The Organic Bunny box in mailer

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

contents of organic bunny box

About This Natural and Organic Beauty Box

The Subscription Box: The Organic Bunny Box

The Cost: $59.00/month with free shipping. Save with longer subscriptions.

The Products: 6-8 medium or full sized non-toxic, natural, and organic beauty products.

Ships to: U.S. only.

Organic Bunny Box May 2019 Review

The Organic Bunny box

You get a really nicely designed and sturdy reusable gift box each month that houses all of your organic goodies. It seems to change every so often as well, so you can amass a collection of different designs. This month has cute illustrated bunnies all over it.

open Organic Bunny box

The lid stays put with magnets so you can use it again after you've raided it. It reads: "For the glamorous girl with a green heart." The Organic Bunny Box doesn't include an info card but normally has all the items listed on their website by the time it arrives.


100% Pure Sheet Mask in Wrinkle Smooth - Estimated Retail Value $5.60 (Buy a pack of 5 for $28.00)

I can appreciate an all-natural sheet mask and this one came in a few variations. I received the "Wrinkle Smooth" one which speaks to my 39-year-old skin. Those crows feet and forehead lines are creeping in, so let's see what we can do. The mask itself was a soft and delicate bamboo cloth with a slightly yellowish tone. It includes hyaluronic acid as well as green tea which will both plump and perk up your skin. I kept this on for over 15 minutes and wasn't actually super impressed once I took it off. There was leftover essence to massage in (per usual) but it left my face feeling a little sticky which I didn't love. For me, this mask isn't one I'd seek out again.


Tosi SuperBites in Blueberry - Listed Value $3.00 (Buy a pack of 12 for $36.00)

Oh my goodness gracious, these were SOOOOO delicious! I"m kind of hit or miss with liking granola bars but these are simply wonderful. Though a little messy with their crumbliness, they have a flavor that compels me to gobble these down quickly and effortlessly. I actually looked for them at my local Co-Op recently and was sad to not find them there. Will definitely be ordering these online.


Joan’s A Keeper Blackberry Lemonade Soap, 3.75 oz. bar - Retail Value $5.00

This soap smells magical! Like many yummy soaps, I want to eat this, but I know I cannot. They really captured the freshness of blackberry lemonade though! It's made with all natural ingredients like honey, beeswax, shea butter, olive oil, and more to leave your skin feeling moisturized and smelling tasty. I've been slowly hoarding bar soaps so that once I use all of my liquid soap pumps, I can ditch plastics and go zero waste (at least with cleansing my body and hands). Like always, bar soap is the best way to travel so you don't have to worry about TSA liquid quantities.


Leefy Organics Prana Dietary Supplement, 2 oz (30 day supply) - Retail Value $30.00

This item has brilliant timing since I just recently found out I have pre-arthritis in my knees which prompted me to start taking turmeric and glucosamine/chondroitin supplements every day to try and help with inflammation. This liquid supplement contains turmeric and ginger to help with just that and it actually tastes really good too! The directions say to put two droppers-worth under your tongue for up to three times a day. I've been carrying this around with me to do so anytime I remember. So far so good- I've been noticing knee pain less with the help of this as well as my other pill supplements.


ORGANIC Bath Co. Zesty Morning Organic Body Butter, 6.2 oz. - Retail Value $29.00

I've been overloaded with body oils lately and while this is a "butter", it's basically a really whipped solid version of all organic argan, jojoba, sunflower seed oils, shea butter, and essential oils. It smells very orange-y to me which I think is where the "zesty" comes from. The label notes that a little goes a long way and they aren't lying. It is indeed really hydrating but also leaves a bit of a greasy feel for some time until it soaks in. I'll probably stick to lotion, but this full-size jar will make one of my friends very happy.


Sanari Mini Plant Based Candle in Sanam, 2 oz. - Estimated Retail Value $3.32 (Buy a variety 3-pack for $9.95)

This mini candle is only available in a sample pack of three but is such a cute little thing. I'm really into the Sanam scent which is made up of pomegranate, rose, and jasmine. I think the fruitiness of the pomegranate is most prominent so it doesn't smell too floral. The burn time is 3-4 hours which is ideal for a bathroom or small space.


Erth Minerals Eye Shadow in Nectar, 0.04 oz - Retail Value $10.00

Wow, I am really impressed with the rose/champagne-like pigment of this shadow. It's intensely sparkly so it works for a night out when you really want to shine. In the swatch below, I laid it on thick, but you can really blend it out for a less sparkly day look as well. Very pretty!


Korento Vitamin Infused Lip & Cheek Tint in Raspberry - Retail Value $37.86 USD (34,00 €)

I love the idea of a makeup product that is double-duty but I often feel let-down by one or the other use. This raspberry color is perfect for my cheeks and I love how easily it blends to a powdery finish, but that means I don't think it really works for me as a lip tint. I needed so very little to give my face a little bit of color that this pot is sure to last me quite some time. Bonus: it's from Finland (a place I'd love to someday visit) and is packed with "free radical fighting antioxidant and vitamin-rich arctic berries such as bilberry, lingonberry, and seabuckthorn". Ooooh- arctic berries!


Here are swatches of the eye shadow and lip & cheek tint.


Kiss Me Honey Lip Balm in Strawberry - Retail Value $4.99

This lip balm reminds me of a strawberry lip balm I had as a kid (in the '80s) that featured an Easter bunny on it. My mom sold Avon so I had a pretty decent collection of cute things like that and loved it so much. This balm is made with USDA certified organic ingredients which is nice and I can have this in one of my many lip balm hiding spots that I've mentioned before so that I am never in need.

Verdict: The Organic Bunny Box for May had quite a lot of different products so I think there's definitely something for everyone here. This month's value totals $128.77, more than double the $59.00 plus free shipping cost. I didn't love the mask and body butter, but pretty much everything else I was loving. The supplement drops came at the perfect time and the soap smells good enough to eat while I enjoyed actually eating the super scrumptious SuperBites snack.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Unfortunately no, but sign up today to get the June box.

Value Breakdown: At $59.00 for this box, here's what you're paying approximately per item:

  • Sheet Mask: $2.57
  • Snack: $1.37
  • Bar Soap: $2.29
  • Dietary Supplement: $13.75
  • Body Butter: $13.29
  • Mini Candle: $1.52
  • Eyeshadow: $4.58
  • Lip & Cheek Tint: $17.35
  • Lip Balm: $2.29

Alternately, you are paying about $6.56 per item.

Check out all of our Organic Bunny Box reviews and keep track of your subscriptions by adding this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

If you want to know more about other natural beauty boxes, check out our best niche & specialty beauty boxes list!

What did you think of May's Organic Bunny Box?

Starting at $59.00
Subscribe Now
"Once a month The Organic Bunny Box delivers Non-Toxic, Natural and Organic beauty products conveniently to your door. Each box contains 6-8 products in medium to full sizes, some smaller samples may be included as extra goodies. We are not fans of small samples so rest assured, the items in this bo... read more.
Marne Orenich
Marne Orenich
Marne is a lipstick connoisseur, record collector, and twice over cat mom. She loves discovering new clean beauty brands and has quite the collection of beautifully packaged serums and moisturizers.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I would love to get this sub, but I would have to give up a couple to make up the cost. I try to limit how much I am willing to spend each month on my addiction.

Every month I love reading the reviews, the curation looks great! Perhaps when I am bored with some of my others I can drop them and try this one. It really does look to be outstanding.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


If anyone else has bad knees (I do!) get a joint supplement that also has MSM in it.
(glucosamine/chondrotin/msm), that was the turning point for me. After about a month
my pain was greatly reduced, and it also helps your hair grow.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marne Orenich

Oooh- thanks for the hot tip, Marie! I’ll look out for MSM the next time I buy supplements.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


The price point seems really high. I do get the concept, I think it’s well curated, but I wouldn’t based on the price :/

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Agreed. The value you get from this sub is decent considering it’s price, but I feel maybe they should drop the price by $10-15

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I loved how beautiful that bar soap smelled. I COULD NOT stop smelling it!!!! It almost pained me to put it away until I get the chance to use it. lol

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marne Orenich

H O N E S T L Y !

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


This sub is so cute starting from the box it comes in. Not sure about the price

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike