Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
We now have confirmation of 3 spoilers in March 2019 BoxyCharm that EVERY subscriber will receive! (Previously, we didn't know if the Wander beauty item would only be sent to some subscribers.)
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I will be a first time user to Boxycharm! I normally get the glossybox, but i want to try something new!
Are their any promo codes I could use for extra freebies or for a first time user? Thanks!!
Becky
Reply
LuLu
What happened to the charm room?
Reply
CJ
When was the last time they added to the Charm room?
Reply
Kelly
I’m wondering the same thing. I didn’t see any charms in there and I thought it was because I downgraded to the regular box.
Reply
Rachael
I’m not excited for anything in this box this month. I love coverfx but these are both too dark for me.
Reply
pinkhoo
Horray for a peel off mask! That peeling feeling is such a sick pleasure. Every Moda brush I have is plush and lovely, if you’re not excited about it, than you should be! I’m very jazzed about the pallete, too. I don’t want any more spoilers! I can’t stop myself from looking at this site and I used to be excited to get the box itself, and I still am, but I want there to be a surprise in it!
Reply
Courtney
How sad is it that I haven’t even bothered to see if my payment went through for Boxy… but I set up a second account to get a second Ipsy and a second Beautyfix? That should tell me something… and my bank account…
Reply
Carly
I am so excited for this box! Just add a rosewater spray to go with the theme and I will be over the moon!!
Reply
Kearstin
Agree!
Reply
Jess
Me too!!!
Reply
TheOtherJulia
The brushes are pretty much the only reason I haven’t cancelled yet. They are really dragging their feet on spoilers though. I already know what I’m getting in my Ipsy plus, and it completely blows their luxe box out of the water this month. I’m definitely glad I downgraded.
Reply
Cher
Same! I wonder how many people cancelled luxe this month.
Reply
TheOtherJulia
From all the comments on this site alone, I would imagine quite a few! They also seem to be losing subscribers to the regular box as well. I almost cancelled this month too, but I wanted the brushes. I never thought I would be considering cancelling Boxycharm, but I’m just not really happy with them lately.
Amber W.
I’m so excited! This is my first Boxycharm!
Reply
Heidi
Looks like a decent box 🙂
Reply
Rachael
@Boxy We already pretty much knew this…Where’s the rest of the box? Lol… This is crazy we only have 3 items so far. We should def have full spoilers?
Ipsy plus is killing it. And boxy just looks weird they dragging thier feet on this…
Seems like they got messed up this month… A lot of ppl cancelled, but they should have a wait list to fill in for the loss?
Reply
Regina
If I’m not mistaken only three items out of the regular box go into the luxe box. The three spoilers shown, we know are in Boxyluxe. I wonder if they are trying to sell more luxe by having all of those spoilers out, before releasing all items in the regular box. The two left for regular should not be in the luxe box.
Reply
Emmi
I’m wondering if they’re dragging their feet cuz the other 2 items are items already apart of boxyluxe. I thought only 3 items in regular boxycharm were supposed to be the same as some of the boxyluxe items and we have the spoilers showing the brushes in both boxes, the peel off mask and the coverfx palette. I have a sneaky suspicion that the regular Boxycharm will have 5 items that are already in Boxyluxe and that Boxyluxe will be the extra money for 5 extra “bonus items”. I really have a feeling they’re going to screw over the Boxyluxe people. I hope not cuz I’m one of them. I’m hoping this makes sense guys lol. I have a sick kid whom I spent 5 hours at the hospital with so my mom brain isn’t putting thoughts together as well as I’d like 😂
Reply
Vicky H
One of the spoiler sites shows the 4th and 5th item to be an Ofra lippie in a dark rose color and I can’t remember the brand but a liquid rose gold eyeshadow.
julie
I canceled boxy a bit back and still get emails almost daily pretty much sayin GI can upgrade straight to luxe so I don’t know how big that waitlist actually is.
Reply
Rachael
True, I get those too
Danielle
I was already still subbed to the regular box and then resubscribed to Luxe because my sister wanted it for her birthday. I immediately got an email pretty much promising me I’d get March Luxe. All I had to do was stay subscribed, which I did. Yet somehow I only got charged for the regular box. I am LIVID. I know they had boxes available after so many people canceled all month as spoilers came out. I immediately reached out as soon as I saw my credit card charge but haven’t heard a thing. Not even one of those auto-reply emails promising to respond as soon as possible/48-72 hours or whatever.
I had a terrible experience with my box and subsequent customer service response last month and almost canceled Boxy altogether (even with the $21 in charms I can’t use). Over a week later they finally sent me what I took as a genuine apology and attempt to resolve. So I kept the regular subscription and re-added the Luxe upgrade back on for my sister. And now I’m not getting it. I’ve been subscribed for nearly 5 years. This is despicable treatment by a company that can’t afford to treat customers so poorly now that Ipsy Plus is out there and killing it. This past year Boxy has made so many promises to customers as a whole and to individuals that they keep breaking. They’re so much more focused on presenting a great image and bigger presence on social media (to get new customers I assume) than actual customer care. I’m kinda blown away at this point. And most of all very sad I have to now break my promise to my little sister.
Cady
Those brushes actually look pretty nice 👍
Reply
Mel
Ehh. I canceled on the 28th, and I don’t regret it. Not much in the luxe box intrigued me, and the regular box spoilers are not looking much better to me. Spent the money on Huda pallets in Ipsy Add on’s, instead.
Reply
Poppy
Same. Cancelled bl then bc on the 28th as well. Signed up for ipsy & loving my bag! Getting : ciate red lip gloss, slmissglam eye brush, iby eye shadow, ofra highlighter, skyn iceland berry lip fix, the makeup bag, added huda mauve pallet & youth to the people cleanser all for $25! Win win for me 🙂 so much better then a bag of average “I don’t like, not another clearanced brown lippie, wont use” full size product.
Reply
Allison
I cancelled both luxe and the regular box. And signed up for another Ipsy bag on top of the glam bag plus and another bag I’m already getting. There was only a couple items in the luxe box I wanted but it wasn’t worth the money to me. And since there are no full spoilers for the regular box, I cancelled that.
Reply
Regina
Love masks!!!
Reply
Kc
I really wanted the IT cosmetics moisturizer so I’m glad I stuck with luxe. This looks like a great box for $21 though!
Reply
Michelle Diamond
The luxe box just was not worth it this time not much of anything to exciting in it.
Reply
Jody
What a great value for the three spoilers! I love masks too!
Reply
Jessica Harrison
This was the only reason I was going to get boxy looks so as soon as I heard that it could possibly be in the regular box I canceled the Lux super happy about it I actually think the regular box is better than the Lux this month because of the price the lip and the eyeshadow super excited for this box
Reply
Heather
Awesome! This was the only thing in the BoxyLuxe box that looked good to me. Now I don’t regret downgrading at all. 😀
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.