MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyLuxe September 2020 Spoiler Round #3!

BoxyLuxe March 2019 FULL SPOILERS Box Version #2!

We have FULL spoilers for the March BoxyLuxe box! 

Box version 1:

Box version 2:

AND here’s a closer look at the color variations:

Becca Ultimate Lipstick Love – Retail Value $24 (Colors will vary)

CoverFX All in One Perfector Face Palette – Retail Value $45

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you sign up now, the FOMO box here will be your first box! (You must be a regular Boxycharm subscriber in order to upgrade to BoxyLuxe.)

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $21 a month. BoxyLuxe is a once-a-quarter upgrade option you can add to your existing $21-a-month Boxycharm subscription. So for an additional $28.99, you’ll get the Luxe items, and be paying a total of $49.99 for that quarterly box. 

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, BoxyLuxe Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 170 comments

Comments (170)

  1. I was happy with everything except the Morphe pallet dayslayer. It’s not my color. Brunch babe would have been a better fit. I got the lipstick in bare which I am fine with as I already have too many pinks.

  2. The Iconic brow cushion is fantastic. I am dark haired so am lucky the color works; I’m sure it wouldn’t on a lot of people…but it’s something I’d never have bought and now it’s a staple in my routine. Plus the FX palette is great as well. Compared to the IT cosmetics face palette we got from Ipsy, it is SO much more pigmented for me. Despite my wish to cancel Boxy to save money, the curation including the perfect shade of Becca lippie was spot on for me.

  3. Is it just me or did anyone else’s makeup bag they received in the BoxyLuxe smell like FISH??? Ive had it zipped closed with a bunch of silica bead packets for a week to try to absorb some of the smell before I wash it and it literally smells exactly the same

  4. Got my box yesterday and am relieved to get everything intact and the right shades for me. My card says Variation 1. The nail polish duo is prettier than the original photo showed, and my Becca lipstick is in Petal, which I love, but the shade is not listed on the card so it’s variable. The brow cushion looks wearable and the face palette looks lovely. I’m even happy with the Morphe palette, as I have never tried the brand. The only iffy thing are the lashes. I do wear lashes, but these are too fake looking. I wonder if I can trim them myself?

  5. I finally received my BoxyLuxe today, beat to heck and it had no Lippmann product at all, looks like they subbed in the Adesse cuticle oil from a fall box, the card even says NCLA oil, so I guess not sending the Lippmann was planned ahead of time…sadness. On the upside I did get the correct CoverFX 🙂

  6. Hello,
    I don’t think my post went through , but does anyone want to trade, I want a blonde eyebrow palette I’ll trade an Large
    Osea face wash or something else ? I really wanted that blonde eyebrow palette from boxyluxe .

    Thanks 🙂

    • I think they are only sending the medium shade (brown) for the eyebrow product. Once I get my box that will be going in my gifts for later box because I too am a blonde 😀

      • Well thanks for the heads up lol I would look like Groucho marks if I wore that palette 🙂 oh well hopefully they get better with personalization from our profiles like they promise in their emails . How can we try a product if we can not even utilize it? I’ll stick with my eyebrow routine heads up joahs line makes a nice colored taupe for blondes 🙂 thanks anyway

  7. Also for those with a bunch of charms right now, the Charm room has a couple of Smashbox lippies and a Dr Brandt no more baggage available now if any of those are your thing.

  8. Apparently this month I am one of the lucky ones. I received my box today despite FedEx’s best effort to delay it by several days.

    I received the fair-medium CoverFx pallet, the medium Iconic eyebrow, the night master Morphe pallet, the sorbet Becca lipstick, and the nail polish. Of course, the brushes, lashes, moisturizer, mask and train case were in the box too. Nothing broken or leaking this time.

    I may actually be too pale for the fair-medium CoverFx pallet. I haven’t decided if I want to take the chance to swatch it or not.

    I’m definitely too pale for the Iconic. Medium is meant for brunettes and I would look like I took a sharpie to my eyebrows if I use the medium shade on their website. The case has a little protective cover over the product so I can’t see what it looks like IRL.

    The Morphe pallet is the one I was middling about. Color-wise I would have preferred the brunch babe or happy hour. I did not care for the day slayer. I’ll probably keep it just to try Morphe’s formula.

    I’m not much of a lipstick wearer, but I’m going to keep the Becca lippie. Sorbet looks like it will work for me and while it doesn’t say it’s a plumper, it has hyaluronic acid as an ingredient so I might get a bit of smoothing which always helps.

    I was most surprised about the nail polish colors. They don’t look like they did in the online pictures to me. The paler shade is a mauve color and the darker one (which looked like a flat dark brown in the photos) has a dark rose gold shimmer to it.

    I am most excited to try the moisturizer and mask since skin care has been my thing lately. I also will be able to use the brushes and train case. However the lashes are not as useful to me at this point. I’ve never worn them so can’t even try them for the first time as I have no glue and not much incentive to buy the glue either. They do look pretty though.

    I hope everyone gets their box soon.

  9. I just got an email saying I am getting a product that I received before. So they gave me 2,000 charms anyone else? None of there products were in a past box.

  10. Did anyone else get an email saying their boxylux was running late last week? It said i would be getting my shipping info this week. Here we are half way through the week and no shipping email. Color me annoyed lol .

  11. I got so lucky, apparently. They followed my profile exactly for every single product, including the lipstick and eyeshadow palette.

    My tones are cool, fair, brunette, and I received the fair/medium face palette, lipstick in a gorgeous shade (sorbet), and a beautiful Night Master Eyeshadow palette. The eyebrow will work, too.

    Having been with them for years and always getting warm-toned brown lipsticks or palettes, I’m thrilled to finally receive a box curated for me.

    So sorry to hear that it has not worked out for so many. Believe me, I know the feeling. It’s usually how I feel every month. I feel like this is the first box designed for me. I’m hoping they make it right for everyone.

    Thank you, BoxyLuxe! I’m in love with the train case holding all of my fantastic goodies.

  12. I will trade the CoverFX Medium-Deep palette and the Becca lipstick in Souffle for the the Light-Medium palette and one of the pink/red/mauve one if anyone wants to

  13. SOMEONE PLEASE TRADE COVER FX PALETTES WITH ME?!?!?!? I was really looking forward to this but got the medium/deep and I really want the light/medium as I am very light! I have been searching high and low for someone who got the wrong color to trade and can’t find anyone. Mine hasn’t even been swatched!!!! Even if yours is swatched or slightly used as eyeshadow I will take it!! I can sanitize it!!! Thank you!!!

  14. You know, I usually defend BoxyCharm because it’s such a great deal, but I am so sick of them claiming to listen to the beauty quiz profile and then having them completely ignore it. I got products for a medium/dark skin tone when my profile states that I have extremely fair skin. Why bother having a quiz at all if you’re going to ignore it? Why send out two color variations if medium/dark skin people are going to get fair skin colors and vice versa? It’s so frustrating to throw my money at them and get a bunch of stuff I can’t use in return.

  15. Hey! I received the medium dark palette is anyone with the light medium palette wants to trade! Also revived the happy hour morphe palette and I’m looking for the brunch babe one!

    Let me know!

  16. I LOVED this box! The train case was actually the hidden gem. I appreciate something functional and that the branding was in the inside of the case.

    Very happy with the range of products. Also loved how everything fit the theme!

    • I got my box today and am very happy with the items. These will last me a long while however, so I’m gonna cancel and watch for spoilers for the next boxyluxe so I don’t get product overload. Very happy with my items though!

  17. Wow im so glad that i happen to get mi right color in the face pallet which was light with the 15b morph pallet which i luv cuz it has awsome colors i was hopi g for this one i actually got the box i wanted n im so happy finally i got one box out of so many

  18. We receive 2 Boxyluxes in our house(sisters) & today we received our first box. WE ARE SOOOO DISAPPOINTED!!. The ONLY Morphe Palette ,15D,that we werent interested in, was in the box which does not compliment our pinker tones. PLUS, we received the Med/Dark Cover FX. We are both blonde haired blue eyed!! We did not receive an email saying that they made a mistake but we will be contacting them anyway. Granted, the BoxyLuxe is a bargain but if you can’t wear the items then it really IS NO BARGAIN. It will be interesting to see what tomorrow’s BoxyLuxe holds. 🙁

  19. I received the night master Morphe palette. Would anyone like to trade me for the brunch babe palette?

  20. I will trade face palettes, lipstick, eyeshadow and brows with anyone interested. I am pale as a ghost and got medium/dark everything.

    • Which lippie and Morphe palette did you get? I got poppy lip and it’s light and bright. Also got dayslayer Morphe and I’m not crazy about it. I also got the Med- deep and I need the lighter! 😂

      Does anyone know the shade variations for the Becca lippie?

    • Me too! I reached out to their customer service. I’m hoping they respond. Why have a quiz asking for skin tone if you plan to ignore it?!

    • Which lipstick did you get? I got taupe but I like cooler pinks, like mauve or orchid.

    • I’m looking to trade the Becca lipstick in Poppy. It’s a bright pink and I like dark shades. I’m hoping yo get the Becca in the dark red shade. What lipstick did you get.

  21. I haven’t gotten my BL yet but I did get an email saying i’m getting the wrong color face palette. I am literally as pasty as they come- many foundations don’t come in shades light enough for me. Apparently i’m supposed to get some extra charms to make up for the error. I appreciate them trying to make it up but this really misses the mark for me. The charm room is just leftover stock so it’s likely stuff I already got so unless I REALLY loved it and need more what good is this going to do me?? I know they are probably still getting the bugs out of the new system but this is really disappointing.

    • I just got mine and I got the wrong color face palette and eyebrow stuff and the eye shadows are way too orange for me also and so is the lipstick. What’s the point of a beauty quiz if they ignore it? I did not get an email. Today is my birthday and I was so excited to get my box but now I’m just disappointed.

      • Happy Birthday!! Which Morphe pallette did u get?

      • I got the orange Morphe also. It looks like something to use on Halloween and is 100% not for my coloring. At all. The Cover FX was spot on but the Morphe was a huge miss for me.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.