MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

2019 Subscription Box Awards: These Are Our Readers’ Favorite Boxes of the Year!

2019 subscription box awards real subscribers

Every year, we ask our readers to name their favorite subscription boxes across a number of popular categories. We want to know which boxes real subscribers can’t wait to see sitting on their doorstep—the boxes with the best value, the coolest brands, and the biggest wow factor.

This year, we tallied over 4000 votes from subscription box fans just like you to name the top subscription boxes for beauty, fashion, and more. Now, we’re ready to announce the winners!

The Best Subscription Boxes of 2019 According to Our Readers

See which popular subscription boxes nabbed the #1 spot in the categories of…

The Best Subscription Boxes for Women

Outstanding beauty, self-care, style, and home products to get or gift.

The Best Women’s Clothing Subscription Boxes

Personal styling services and trend-savvy clothing rental programs that let you shop (or swap) ’til you drop.

The Best Beauty Subscription Boxes

Makeup, haircare, skincare, even nail products—these boxes connect you with the best the beauty world has to offer.

The Best Makeup Subscription Boxes

Try the hottest new products and hues, plus up-and-coming and vegan brands with cult followings.

The Best Skincare Subscription Boxes

Experience the best serums, mists, moisturizers, masks, and K-beauty secrets for complexion perfection.

Browse subscription boxes for the whole family…

The Best Subscription Boxes for Men

Gifts, gadgets, and other awesome accessories guys will ACTUALLY enjoy.

The Best Men’s Clothing Subscription Boxes

These boxes make it easy to build a hip, well-fitting wardrobe faster than you can say “Tan France.”

The Best Subscription Boxes for Teens

Age-appropriate boxes for every interest, from makeup to Marvel.

The Best Subscription Boxes for Kids 12 and Under

The coolest new ways to help kids learn, play, and look their best.

The Best Kids’ Clothing Subscription Boxes

Skip the trip to the mall—these services make shopping easy, affordable, and fun.

Subscription boxes for different budgets…

The Best Cheap Subscription Boxes (Under $15)

You know we love a great deal, and so do our readers!

The Best Luxe Subscription Boxes (Over $50)

Upscale subscriptions that promise the most bang for your buck.

And subscription boxes for popular interests…

The Best Snack Subscription Boxes

Don’t read this list on an empty stomach…

The Best Meal Kit Subscription Boxes

Yes you CAN make fast, delicious meals at home. Here’s how.

The Best Wine Subscription Boxes

Like having your own personal sommelier (but way easier on your wallet).

The Best Book Subscription Boxes

Stock up on must-read titles for every genre, budget, and reading level.

The Best NSFW Subscription Boxes

These flirty boxes are 50 shades of GREAT.

We also have 3 NEW categories for this year!

See which subscription boxes our community named as…

The Best Subscription Boxes for Discovering New Products

When every box makes you say “how did I live without this?”

The Best Boxes for Subscription Box Newbies

Never tried a monthly box before? These subscriptions prove that the hype is real.

The Best Subscription Box Loyalty Programs

Awesome monthly boxes are great. Savings and special offers in addition to awesome boxes? Even better.

Did your favorite subscription box make the list?

Tell us which other boxes you’re loving right now! See all of the 2019 winners here, and don’t forget to see how this year’s winners stack up against our 2018 and 2017 lists.

Written by Anna Reilly

Anna Reilly

Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she’s swooning for all things kawaii!

Posted in Uncategorized| 15 comments

Comments (15)

  1. Oh look all the big boxes won since there were zero categories for smaller boxes to be in.

    Looks like a paid ad and not an actual award of anything. Disappointed.

  2. Thanks for the list!
    It’s a reference to try new subs!

  3. Any boxes to do with women, we got pretty much the same results, just in different orders: fff, popsugar, boxy, Ipsy, rzbos… I had hoped to get one or two suggestions for a different box. Oh well.

    • I feel like next year there needs to be a “Best Box No One Knows About” category to highlight some under-the-radar options. 🙂

      • Love this idea!

      • I actually recommended they do an under-the-radar category on their survey last year! Hopefully next year they’ll include that category. 🙂

  4. Really disappointed in FFF right now. My box should have shipped by the 15th and I was sent an email saying it was delayed with no definite timeline on when it might be coming. This was my first and will likely be my last time getting this box. There are just too many other options out there.

  5. Disappointed that FFF is first. After subbing to multiple boxes (all the ones listed) for several years, I’ve come to resent FFF for their deceptive advertising and low quality lifestyle items.
    MSA has blown up…hopefully they can use this data to increase revenue with their affiliate programs 😊 I find their ever improving site and content valuable!

  6. I’m struggling to remember all of the categories we voted on but wasn’t there one like “My one and only” as in the one sub box you would keep if you had to cut them all down to only one? I think it was the last one we chose in the list. None of the ones listed above look that that….??

    • Hi! There were two of these categories, “one and only” and also “your first subscription box”. You are right that they’re not included in the awards posts linked here, but we still plan to share those results with everyone for fun! 🙂 Coming soon!

      • Cool. Thanks for the update!

  7. I love Fabfitfun. I have been a subscription box enthusiast for years, but this one is truly a joy! It’s a nice mix of lifestyle and beauty with quality products. Blows the socks off Box of Style.

  8. Glad to see FFF IS #1🥰
    To bad new beauty test tube didn’t make the list they’re awesome 🌺

    • It’s on a few of the other lists. I like that one too, seems like recently they have upped their game with the rebranding and serums! 🙂

      • I see that they’re on the other lists! Yes I agree they have become incredibly awesome!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.