Facebook PixelPennie Post Subscription Review – February 2019 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Pennie Post Subscription Review – February 2019

Carol Castaneda
ByCarol CastanedaFeb 10, 2019 | 2 comments

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Envelope Front

Pennie Post
4.5 overall rating
8 Ratings | 0 Reviews

Pennie Post is a monthly stationery subscription service by indie stationery company, Elsie J. Prints and is all about the fun of sending and receiving mail. Each month, you will receive a new assortment of unique, quirky items that could include notecards, cards for all occasions, postcards and other products to help you up your greeting game. These cards are typically blank inside so you can customize your message!

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Envelope Opened

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- All Products Front

About Pennie Post

The Subscription Box: Pennie Post

The Cost: $11.63 per month + free shipping or purchase a one-time pack for $12.50.

The Products: At least 3 stationery items a month which may include cards, notecards, postcards and more!

Ships to: U.S. and Worldwide

Pennie Post February 2019 Review

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Information Card Front

Every month we receive a paper that gives us the month’s theme and the name of all the cards we receive. This month’s them is “Sprinkled.”

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Donut Sprinkle Card Front

Donut Sprinkle Card

It’s raining sprinkles! I feel like this donut got up, spread some frosting on and stood under a sprinkle cloud. I liked the colors of the card, they really go together well. This card was paired with a white a-style envelope.

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Happy Birthday Sprinkles Front

Happy Birthday Sprinkles

This card is super cute with the multi-colored sprinkles. I especially love the bright yellow a-style envelope it is paired with. Such a bright, pretty set!

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Congratulations Confetti Sprinkle Front

Congratulations Confetti Sprinkle

If I had to choose a favorite card in this month’s subscription, it would be this one. It is printed on a really shimmery paper.

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- White Sheet Top

You can sort of see the shimmer in this image. I received a similar card in my October review, but a different design. I just recently tried to gift that card and found that a lot of pens didn’t write on it, which stunk because I essentially ruined a beautiful card trying to write on it with multiple pens. I finally wised up and grabbed a thin Sharpie, but it didn’t hide that the card was ruined. Just in case anyone else comes across this issue, have a Sharpie on hand for your message on the inside of this beautiful card.

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Donut Stickers Top

Donut Stickers

The final item we received are these adorable donut stickers. There is one for each envelope to seal in the card for delivery.

PENNIE POST SUBSCRIPTION Box – February 2019- Donut Stickers On Envelope Top

My favorite part is that the center of the donut is an actual hole. Here they are against the yellow envelope. So adorable. And now I am off to find an edible donut….

Verdict: Pennie Post always delivers magnificent, original cards and I am always looking forward to the ones sent each month. The quality of these cards is amazing and so lovely. One of my favorite things about Pennie Post is that it doesn’t send cards centered around a particular holiday for the month. I am glad I didn’t receive just pink, red and white Valentines Day cards this month.

To Wrap Up: 

Can you still get this box if you subscribe today? No, you will get the March subscription.

Value Breakdown: This subscription costs $11.63 a month, which means each card is worth about $3.88 each, counting the stickers as a bonus item.

Check out our Pennie Post reviews and the Paper Subscription Box Directory for more stationery boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think about this month’s Pennie Post?

Starting at $11.00
Subscribe Now
Pennie Post is a monthly Stationery Subscription. Subscriptions are available in one month, three month, six month and twelve month increments with shipping included in the cost. Receive at least 3 stationery items monthly. For example items include, but are not limited to greeting cards, postcards... read more.
Carol Castaneda
Carol Castaneda
I am a mother of 2 going on 3 soon and enjoy the little things in life, especially in surprise form! Monthly subscription boxes give me that surprise every time I see the mailman delivering them! My favorite boxes include beauty boxes, lifestyle boxes and anything pregnancy-related boxes; my all time favorite is my FabFitFun subscription.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I am bummed, as I have been with them for years, I think from the very beginning, but with a two or three month lapse one time. It’s such a good subscription! I am wondering what I will be able to replace it with. Any suggestions?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Just got an email this morning that subscriptions are coming to an end – March will be the last month. Really bummed since I only just got the Black Friday deal last November, and January was my first shipment! :/

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike