Facebook PixelYes, Oh Yas! Makeup Subscription Review - November 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Yes, Oh Yas! Makeup Subscription Review – November 2018

Tiffany Waldorf
ByTiffany WaldorfDec 14, 2018 | 9 comments

package outside

Yes, Oh Yas!
3.6 overall rating
15 Ratings | 3 Reviews

Yes, Oh Yas! is a monthly beauty subscription box. Each box includes 3-7 full-sized beauty products with at least an $85 value.

fragile sticker on package

Hmm...fragile? I'm thinking a palette...

package contents

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

all contents outside of package

About Yes, Oh Yas!

The Subscription Box: Yes, Oh Yas!

The Cost: $14.99 per box + shipping. Discounts are available for longer commitments.

The Products: 3-7 full-sized beauty and makeup products each month with at least $85 value. There are often bold colors and unique formulas included. 

Good to Know: Complete 1 year of Yes, Oh Yas! active subscriptions and receive a FREE limited edition box worth $200-$400!

Ships to: US for $3.99 and Canada for $9.03

Yes, Oh Yas! November 2018 Review

This month includes two different types of highlighters, a lip palette, a brush, and a brow product:

info front info back

The included info card lists names and values for each item and gives you an idea of the theme "Girls Can". Just a note: I found some discrepancies between the values listed online and on this card. I included the current listed value online for you below. Here's what YOY says about their listed values:

What is the retail value and how is it calculated?

Yes, Oh Yas subscription retail value is based ONLY on original retail pricing of the items included for the month. Retail value prices are given to us by the company partners of the month and does not reflect price reductions, sale, or clearance. Original retail value pricing may not be displayed on the company's website. Retail value pricing are subject to change and Yes, Oh Yas has no control over decisions made by the company partners of the month.

mirabella highlighter box mirabella highlighter mirabella highlighter open

Mirabella Brilliant Mineral Highlighter in Swirling Pearl, 7.5g - Retail Value $42 (found here for $10)

Oh no! Maybe this is why the fragile sticker was on the package. The pressed powder was broken when I unboxed it but since it wasn't shattered, I was able to fix it with the alcohol trick. It performed the same before the fix and after so I don't count this as a loss. Anyway, this highlighter has shades of shimmering pink and champagne swirled together with a buttery, almost creamy texture. It goes on intense and can be blended out as much as you like. I think it's probably best suited for light skin tones as a face highlighter.

Sorme brow highlighting pencil Sorme brow highlighting pencil detail

Sorme Brow Lift Highlighting Pencil in No. 30 White - Retail Value $15.99 (found here for $12.45), Listed Value $22

I'm a huge fan of highlighting the inner corners of my eyes for a quick pick-me-up. I've been loving pencil formulas lately since they are so easy to apply and then blend either with my fingertip or a brush. The soft white pencil applies smoothly and the cream-to-powder formula blends well. It doesn't last very long, but it's easy to touch up throughout the day.

liquid highlighter bottle liquid highlighter dropper

Beauty Creations Unicorn Tears Liquid Highlighter, 15ml - Estimated Value $2.50 (buy a 6-bottle set for $14.99), Listed Value $17

I don't think I'd actually use this to highlight my face since it has such a pink tone to it, but it looks lovely as a liquid eyeshadow and lasts all day without creasing. The dropper is a little gunky but I just drop some on my palette and then use a brush to pick it up and apply.

I'm not really sure what's going on with the pricing on this, but it looks like a 6 bottle set (of varying shades) is sold on the website which breaks down to $2.50 per bottle even though individual bottle isn't available.


Here are swatches of the highlighting products this month (from left to right): Unicorn Tears liquid highlighter (swatched and blended out), Sorme Brow Lift, and Mirabella Mineral highlighter.

Oval shadow brush Oval shadow brush detail

Crown Deluxe Badger Oval Shadow Brush BK40 - Retail Value $2.99 (found here for $2.09) Listed Value Value $19

So, I talked about applying the liquid highlighter to my lid using a brush. Conveniently, there is the perfect brush for the job included this month. The badger bristles are soft, short, and domed making it perfect for applying large washes of color to the whole lid. It would also work well to blend out the crease or to apply an eyeshadow primer.

This is another big value difference. The retail value is what is on the Crown site, so I went with that.

lip palette box front lip palette box back lip palette box contents lip palette info sheet lip palette open lip palette open detail lip palette swatches

Aesthetica Lip Contour Kit Palette - Retail Value $40, Listed Value $45

Oh, la la! A lip contouring kit is something I do not own...until now. This is quite the package, complete with 4 shades of lip liner, 5 lip crémes, a lip highlighter, a lip brush, and an instruction booklet with lots of lip tips. While this is a little more extravagant than my everyday lip process, I'm actually really enjoying this palette. There are so many looks, from nude to bold, I can create. The lip pencils are creamy and long-wearing and the lip crémes are super pigmented and lightweight. I love that even as the créme wears off, it leaves a stain behind so I have color on my lips all day even if I don't reapply. The lip brush is even great! It has a nice size and a pointed shape to help achieve sharp lines.

makeup look makeup look eyes closed close up of eye look

I love the look I was able to create with the items from this month's Yes, Oh Yas! Let's start with eyes: I used the Crown brush to apply a wash of the Unicorn Tears liquid highlighter to my entire lid, diffusing the color toward the brow. Then I dusted a light layer of the Mirabella highlighter on top to set it. I swiped the Sorme Brow Lift under my brows and into the inner corner of my eyes and blended. I then hit the high points of my face with a fan brush loaded with some more Mirabella Highlighter. Lastly, I used the lip palette to create a subtle ombre lip look.

Verdict: Let's overlook the pricing weirdness for a second and recognize that this month of Yes, Oh Yas! is just downright fun! It has an estimated value of $103.48 which is great for a cost of $14.99 +$3.99 shipping. Now, even though the listed values and retail values I found were sometimes very different, I still think the value is great and the products are nice. It's disappointing that my highlighter was broken, but I was able to fix it and it is beautiful. This is a fun and inexpensive makeup subscription to choose if you like to be totally surprised each month.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No. Subscribe now to get the December box. From Yes, Oh Yas!:

Deliveries are sent out on daily basis depending on the queue of your order. Once your box is shipped, you will receive an email with its tracking information. The carrier will deliver your box with no need of signature confirmation.

Value Breakdown: At $18.98 for this box (including shipping), here’s what you are paying approximately per item:

  • Mirabella Highlighter - $7.70
  • Sorme Brow Lift - $2.93
  • Beauty Creations Liquid Highlighter - $0.46
  • Crown Shadow Brush - $0.55
  • Aesthetica Lip Kit - $7.34

Check out all of our Yes, Oh Yas! reviews and the Beauty Subscription Box Directory for more makeup boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of this month’s Yes, Oh Yas! box?

Starting at $14.99
Subscribe Now
"Discover new makeup and beauty brands and products with our subscription service. Receive 3-7 full-sized products every month. Yas! It's never been this easy."
Tiffany Waldorf
Tiffany Waldorf
Tiffany found out about subscription boxes from a friend who followed MSA. The curiosity started with mystery beauty boxes and grew into an addiction from there. Beauty, clothes, home...she loves the sight of a subscription box in the mail.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


Marissa Demarco

I love your branch necklace! Where can I find it!???

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


It was in the penny and grace subscription box a few months back. Either October or November 2018. They might have it for sale on their website as a stand alone.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


They need a better mailer for the make-up other than a bubble mailer…unless it is rigid? Can’t tell…

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I keep hearing they list way higher prices all the time. And it doesn’t make much sense as to why? And for that reason, I will not be subscribing to this one. I also heard of really bad customer service.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I love my yes oh Yas box!! I’ve had this subscription since they 1st started out!! January will be my one year anniversary with them and for being with them for a whole year they are supposed to send out a box with a value of $200-$400 as a gift for being with them for a full year!! So I can’t wait to email them and tell them my year is up, they also send out a gift for every 5 month’s you’ve been with them too!! So I know they do send out a gift for being with them bcuz I’ve already emailed them once for my 1st 5 month anniversary!! Yeah so it pays to be a subscriber to this box and the subscription for whay you get is well worth the money!! They send out 3-7 full sized products for under $20 bucks a month you can’t beat it, you can’t even compare Ipsy to them!! Great subscription!! I highly recommend!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Rachel L

When was your 5 months? Mine wa sin October. I reached out about it and they told me they no longer do the 5 month gift. Just the 1 year one 🙁

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I never got my 5 month gift and they ignored every message I sent about it. That was this past summer. I don’t have high hopes for the one year gift either.

Like This CommentLike

Rita Tripp

I just started getting these yesoyah bags I’m in love with my bag can’t wait to get dec I love everything

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Brittany Bolton

I use to love this subscription absolutely love it but the values really erk me! why list them so much higher than what they are?! like even if they lost them as what their sale price is its still a great value so why Jack up the price?! so i have paused this subscription for now…..

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike