Facebook PixelPlay! By Sephora December 2018 FULL Spoilers for All Box Variations! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Play! By Sephora April 2020 FULL SPOILERS!

Play! By Sephora December 2018 FULL Spoilers for All Box Variations!

MSA
ByMSADec 6, 2018 | 251 comments

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

Play! by Sephora
3.8 overall rating
564 Ratings | 55 Reviews

We have the FULL spoilers for all of the December Play! By Sephora variations! You have until 12/11 to sign up and get the December box as your first box.

FYI - The sixth product in each December box will be a mystery sample!

Box A:

Box B:

Box C:

Box D:

Box E:

Box F:

Box G:

Box H:

Box I:

Box J:

Box K:

Here are the mystery item samples that may be included in your box:

What do you think of the spoilers? 

Play! by Sephora is $10 a month. You have until 12/11 to sign up and get the December box as your first box.

Plus, all Play! Smarts boxes are on sale for $15 (Regularly $20) and Play! Luxe Vol 2 is available for $20! (Regularly $25)

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Starting at $10.00
Subscribe Now
PLAY! by Sephora is a monthly beauty and makeup subscription box. Each month, Sephora sends you a mix of six samples (including cosmetics, haircare, skincare, fragrances, and other beauty products) personalized to match your preferences and a PLAY! BOOK of tips and tricks.
MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

251 comments

Olga

I have unsubscribed from Sephora Play. I am kind of annoyed and frustrated by them.

This whole box this month was flat out repeats.

I am looking past what seems like they tossed in some items that were leftovers. It is just everything I got was a repeat!

I would have been happy with a Fresh lip scrub/balm or the Wander Beauty highlighter because I never received those!

Reply ButtonReply

Ella

I emailed Sephora to complain about how my box doesn’t fit my profile at all and not only did they refund me but they are sending me a different box! I’m pretty impressed with their customer service!

Reply ButtonReply

Ella

I have box i #599 and my mystery item is the Dr. Brandt Luminizer Primer. Sigh . . . yet again another product I can’t use because I have oily skin.

Reply ButtonReply

Olga

I was mad, too. I got the same mystery item! It is a repeat for me, as well.

Reply ButtonReply

Julie

Just received box K, mystery item was Stellar face powder. THIS close to canceling.

Reply ButtonReply

samantha9831

I got Box K and my mystery item was a tiny sephora waterproof eye makeup remover, so you did better than I did!

Reply ButtonReply

Olga

I would have been happier with the Steller face powder, at this point. Everything I got was a repeat!

Reply ButtonReply

tammy g

I DID….I’VE GOT 2 IPSY’S ACCOUNTS NOW..

Reply ButtonReply

Julie

I did it! I canceled!

Angela Domenico

I had Box H and I’m very happy. My surprise gift was actually one of the ones listed above. I got the SUNDAY RILEY C.E.O. Rapid Flash Brightening Serum.

Reply ButtonReply

Jessy

My box #330 and my box is E , the mystery item was Origins charcoal mask 😒

Reply ButtonReply

Marie

I got box G and my mystery item was a cream from the Sephora collection, which is pretty disappointing. I’m curious to see if anyone actually got any of the listed mystery items?

Reply ButtonReply

Cindy

I got the same thing Box G – #482. What a disappointing mystery item.

Reply ButtonReply

Karen

I have box K coming for December. I’m happy. I wish I knew what the mystery item is.

Reply ButtonReply

Leni

I got box D today and my mystery item is Lancome mascara base. That’s the best thing in the whole box.

Reply ButtonReply

Aileen

Box I, 599 — my mystery item was the Becca first light primer and the Trestique shade is Paris Pink.

Reply ButtonReply

Beccah

I got box C (Horrible!) And didn’t even get a mystery item!!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Angela Domenico

So my box is 581 aka H. I just got my email saying what’s in it other than the surprise and i’m happy I didn’t get an obnoxious bright red for the Trestique. I got the pop of perfect pink. I’ll let everyone know what surprise item I get later this week when it arrives.

Reply ButtonReply

GrannysHouse

New subscriber here. I finally got a shipping email! Which do I go by, my order number #694 or my box #334? TIA

Reply ButtonReply

Jan

Welp, I got my box 599 today. All of these are items I haven’t tried before, so at least I get to experiment with some new things. The Trestique lip color is not one I would wear, but it says it’s a smoothing balm, so maybe I’ll use it that way instead of as a lip color. I’m eager to try the Tarte mascara and the apple cider hair rinse.

A lot of people here are mentioning that their ‘surprise’ item was a disappointment. Mine was a Dr. Brandt Luminizing Primer, which I’m pretty happy with! Love me some primer!

Reply ButtonReply

Elaine

I also got 599, with the IGK Rich Kid Coconut Oil Gel as my mystery item. This is my 2nd play box and I’m not sure how I feel about it, but I am interested in trying everything, and really excited about the ACV hair rinse.

Reply ButtonReply

GrannysHouse

Some say it the last three of the order number and some say it’s the item number. My order #694 (which I haven’t seen or I am overlooking) and my item #334.

So box B?

I NEED primer for face and eyes.

Reply ButtonReply

Brenda Rodriguez

For anyone that received Box 581(H), what was your mystery gift?

Reply ButtonReply

missann

I cancelled this sub and another today. Just want to change things up. It seems like noone who has posted got any of the great mystery items listed, as I did not either. That bothers me. Anyway, Sephora sent me a link to a special survey for insiders and gave me an additional 100 points on my account. Weird.

Reply ButtonReply

Tracy

I was pissed off that I got box A and my mystery item was a weird waxy pink Trestique lip crayon (I have no idea what it’s purpose even is because it’s sheer, poor quality, and underwhelming). I would have been OK with the box if I had gotten one of the mystery items actually shown. I like sugar balm but the box was very blah. Quality seems to be getting worse over time… I think it might be time for me to cancel!

Reply ButtonReply

Gigglez

I got box B
….sad sad little.box…all the slections this month are sad.sad….I agree, seems to be an end of year dump

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa Bryson

Has ANYONE who received their boxes received ANY of the mystery samples that were on this posts list/pics? Where did those possibilites list come from? I am curious since I have not seen anyone mention any if those. I received the Shiseido lipstick. I would have much much rather had anything on the list/pics shown here of possibly mystery items.

Reply ButtonReply

SD

I am still livid about my box, which is box b. Look at the contents of that box compared to all the others! Low end products compared to all the other box variations packed with high end such as Tarte, Briogeo, Fresh, Shiseido, Buxom. Blatantly obvious this box b has a much lower value and that’s totally unfair! They should’ve spread the wealth and not put all the low end products in one box for all the suckers that got box b! I called and got the runaround as usual and all they would do was front me a few points. So for everyone who got this crap box call and complain and maybe they will get their act together.

Reply ButtonReply

DrDeux

This is the worst subscription box in more than a year. I got Box B. I guess I’m OK with the Belief cream, but the rest is pretty crummy. And my mystery item is a Sephora gel glass in Perfect Nude. It’s crap, tbh.

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa Lewis

I got B and it has only 1 item I’m even remotely interested in. I got a sephora brand mystery item, so yeah it totally blows and I’m not happy at all, especially considering I’ve been a subscriber for over 2 years now.

Reply ButtonReply

Melissa

I got mine yesterday, #367 box D. My bonus was Clinique mascara, which I like ok. So out of the whole box I will use two items 🙁 I’m giving them one more month and then cancelling if it doesn’t get better

Reply ButtonReply

Anna

I was mistaken earlier. Lol I’m getting box 581. Anybody know which letter box that is? How does everyone seem to know which letter is their box? And why would they switch it up and do letters all of a sudden? Annoying!!

Reply ButtonReply

Angela Domenico

Box 581 is H. My surprise was the Sunday Riley serum

Reply ButtonReply

Anna

581 is box H. Im not too thrilled about the box. I guess I was really hoping for that Clinique moisture surge or that Fresh lip product. Hopefully the mystery item will be good.

Reply ButtonReply

Ella

I’ll trade you my Moisture Surge for your Too Faced primer!

Anna

Does anybody know which one is box 623? That’s the last 3 numbers of my order number. Thanks!

Reply ButtonReply

Angela Domenico

You need the last 3 of the item number not the order number

Reply ButtonReply