Facebook PixelThe Filthy Mermaid Subscription Box Review – October 2018 | My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Filthy Mermaid Subscription Box Review – October 2018

closed The Filthy Mermaid box

The Filthy Mermaid
0 overall rating
0 Ratings | 0 Reviews

“The Siren Swag Bag from The Filthy Mermaid is a monthly surprise subscription for grown mermaids, swimming wicked merbabe goodies straight to your doorstep!  It's the freewheeling mermaid lifestyle - in one kickass package.”

open The Filthy Mermaid box

My Subscription Addiction paid for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

The Filthy Mermaid October 2018 review

About This Box

The Subscription Box: The Filthy Mermaid

The Cost: $29.99 monthly + free US shipping. Save with 3 and 6-month subscriptions.

The Products: “Each delivery includes 3-4 treasures hand selected from mermazing vendors from around the world. You can expect quirky gifts, party supplies, bath and beauty products, jewelry, accessories, themed mermaid products, and got-to-have goods by The Filthy Mermaid™.”

Ships to: Worldwide

Good to know: Sometimes there will be sized items, and you can choose from XS (sizes 0-3)  to 4X (sizes 26-28)

Also good to know: This box promises excitement and scandal, so future items may be NSFW, which means future reviews may be, too!

October 2018 "Mermaid’s Trick or Treat" Review

The Filthy Mermaid offers fancy pink-and-black inner packaging, plus a card detailing the enclosed items. This month’s theme is “Mermaid’s Trick or Treat,” which sounds like my new life motto, so let’s check things out!

Mermaid Scales Tattoo - Listed Value $3.25

The card lists this item as a “teaser-tat,” which I think is an adorable phrase - and it’s true! This li’l piece is a smaller version of the big tattoos sold by this company and is a great way to test out what a similar, more permanent tattoo would look like on your skin (or even more temporary ones, if that’s your thing). My permanent tattoos are black, so this is an interesting option to see what colored ink would look like on my skin. I thought this was a really pretty interpretation of mermaid scales, and I was happy I got the cheerful pink version - there were a few other colors I could’ve received! I also really appreciated the tatt-application directions on the back - they were really well designed visually and crystal-clear.

Mermaid Body Butter, 1.5 oz

Mermaid Body Butter, 1.5 oz - Listed Value $4.25

Since the fake tattoo was this month’s trick, the treat requirement falls to this body butter! I love that this formula from SD Mermaid Beauty is all-natural, and I found out that interestingly, it contains something called gemstone elixir, which is made by one of the company’s co-founders, a specialist in the properties and energies of stones. My butter, the lavender-vanilla version, seems the closest to their “Sleep” formula, containing the two named ingredients as well as hematite as one of its gemstone elixirs. I can smell the lavender, but it’s a bit on the medicinal side, and sadly, I don’t smell the vanilla at all. It is softening though, so I might use it on my cuticles as the weather starts to make my skin drier.

Shelleton Hoodie - Listed Value $34.95

And now we’ve come to The Filthy Mermaid “house” item if you will - this absolutely fin-tastic hoodie (I’m not even sorry about that pun, either)! I am obsessed with this design, and I even got a matching sticker! I was actually quite worried that this box included a hoodie as the sized item. I’m a bit of a hoodie-snob, dear readers, and I’m super-picky about fit when it comes to sweatshirts, but all of my fears instantly disappeared once this slipped over my head.

The XL size I chose for my subscription is a perfect fit! The sleeves are nice and long, which is a personal preference of mine, and it’s oh-so-slightly cropped on the bottom. Cropping a hoodie could go very, very wrong, but it’s not too short to negate the point of having a hoodie on in the first place, it rather offers a more trendy fit with the shorter, rolled hem. I like that there’s no tight band at the bottom like some hoodies have! The inside of this is buttery-soft and warm; I imagine some of the “fluffiness” inside will disappear with a few washings but it seems like it will still be a warm layer, especially with another shirt underneath. This baby is just begging for a vintage-washed tee, some distressed black jeans, and my favorite quilted combat boots!

Verdict: This first The Filthy Mermaid box knocked my scales off! I am 100% into that mermaid life, and it didn’t hurt that the first box was Halloween-themed: it’s my absolute favorite holiday. The theme was really clever when you think about it; there was a trick, there was a treat, and let’s be honest - I kind of want to be buried in that All-Hallows mermaid hoodie! The listed value of the hoodie alone was higher than the price of the box, so a $29.99 price point to receive a $42.45 listed worth of items feels like a good value to me. The only thing that struck me as odd is that the valuation of the hoodie was so much higher than the other two items. It made the valuation feel a little lopsided, though I suppose that’s not necessarily a bad thing. The hoodie is by far my favorite item, after all! I am curious, however, to see if future boxes will contain items more similar to each other in value. As for the items themselves, I really think that this box will offer a high variety of item types, and I love that they’ve taken the not-so-sweet, edgier path, design-wise. Who says mermaids can’t have some teeth?  

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Sadly, no! Sign up by midnight on the last day of the month to get the next month’s box. According to their website, the boxes usually ship around the 4th-6th of every month.

Value Breakdown: This box costs $29.99 + free shipping, which means that each of the 3 items in the box has an average cost of $10.

Check out all of our lifestyle subscription box reviews!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

Tell me: has The Filthy Mermaid awakened your inner merbabe?

Starting at $29.99
Subscribe Now
The Filthy Mermaid delivers got-to-have goods for mermaids gone bad. Our monthly Siren Swag Bags are filled with 3-5 pieces of siren swag for women who love all things mermaid - with an edge. Each month features a unique mermaid-centric theme.
Laine Wooliscroft
Laine Wooliscroft
Laine is a life-long movie enthusiast who loves YA novels, estate sales, and hikes that make her legs hurt the next day. Her subscription journey started in 2014 with Ipsy, and now her favorite boxes contain craft beer, horror/spooky items, and toys for her beloved lab mix, Archie.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



November is their last box.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I’m really tempted by this one, partly to give them my business as a THANK YOU ZOMG for going up to size 4x! It’s so hard to have to gift all my 3x Pusheen shirts.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Ooooh, intriguing. Any chance MSA can turn up a discount code? I need another sub like I need a… but this one is awesome! Lol.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


That’s a grest sub name and the hoodie is adorable! Definitely will have to keep my eye on this box 👀

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


How fun!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike