MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Postmark’d Studio PostBox “Be-Witching” Review + Coupon – October 2018

Postmarkd Studio box

Postmark’d Studio’s PostBox delivers a monthly subscription box to your door featuring a curated collection of greeting cards, postcards, artful doodads, and beautiful paper products and always includes the postage to mail everything.

Postmarkd Studio unboxing

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

This review is for the PostBox, which costs $25.00 per month + shipping. 

Postmarkd Studio unboxing and review

About Postmark’d Studio PostBox

The Subscription Box: PostBox by Postmark’d Studio

The Cost: $25.00/month + $5.00 shipping. Save with 3, 6, and 12-month subscriptions!

COUPON: Use code MSAFS or MSA404ME to get free shipping on your first box (MSAFS) or save $10 off your first box with a 3-month subscription (MSA404ME).

The Products: PostBox comes with greeting cards, postcards, postage, and a fun artsy doodad such as a pen, pencil, or knick-knack gadget based on a theme.

Ships to: the US only

Good to Know: You can also purchase “Special Delivery” boxes without a subscription for various prices.

Postmark’d Studio “Be-Witching” PostBox Halloween Stationery Review

Postmarkd Studio bright blue envelope with seal

Postmarkd Studio note

Postmarkd Studio handwritten note

I love this itty bitty note from the curator of the box! It’s barely the size of a business card, but it comes in a handsome, wax-sealed envelope!

Postmarkd Studio bow package

The packaging of this box is so thoughtful! I love this spooky black ribbon.

Postmarkd Studio silver pencil

Postmarkd Studio silver postmarked pencil

Every box comes with a pencil. This month’s pencil is a shimmery silver color.

Postmarkd Studio blue card

Postmarkd Studio envelope

You also always get a blank postcard. I’m not sure if I’d use this card, just because it feels a bit promotional with the logo there on the front. It’s a cute idea for a promo item, though!

Postmarkd Studio product list

Postmarkd Studio orange box card

The info card for the box lists the theme (“Be-Witching”) as well as the featured items inside. There are also some details about wax seals. Why? There’s one in the box!!! How cool!

Postmarkd Studio orange pumpkin card

Postmarkd Studio pumpkin card back

Pumpkin Witch Card by E. Frances Press – Retail Value $4.50

The watercolor pumpkins and delicately drawn witch on this card feel like something out of a Halloween children’s book! I like how the pumpkins are sort of abstract as if they’re just big polka dots floating across the face of the lightly textured card.

Postmarkd Studio witch legs card

Postmarkd Studio back of witch legs card

Postmarkd Studio info card

Witches Legs Card by Twin Ravens Press – Estimated Value $4.50

I found this same design online but in a slightly different colorway, but I estimate that the value is probably about the same. I like how sassy this card is! It reminds me of the witch’s legs sticking out from under the house in The Wizard of Oz, except with a sultry twist!

Postmarkd Studio halloween greeting card

Postmarkd Studio back of greeting card

Witches’ Brew KB Paperie Card – Retail Value $5.00

This card is so cute! I love that the “witches’ brew” actually looks to be a few bottles of champagne and some beautiful bottles of spooky spirits 🙂 I’m not a huge fan of creepy things, so I appreciate the cute, cheeky spin that this card gives the holiday.

Postmarkd Studio witch crow greeting card

Postmarkd Studio crow card from behind

Cackle Grackle by Burdock and Bramble – Retail Value $5.50

Aw, this blackbird card is actually pretty cute! I like how the hat is juuuust a smidge too big for this bird. It’s also neat how the design wraps around the edge of the card.

Postmarkd Studio witch on broomstick card

Postmarkd Studio back of halloween card with witch

Witch of the West Card by Rifle Paper Company – Retail Value $4.50

Ugh, I am just smitten with Rifle Paper Company! Each time I see another one of their designs, I fall even more deeply in love. This card is equal parts classic and quirky. I love the inky texture of the drawings and the green accent in the center. The flying monkeys around the edges of the card are super sweet, too!

Postmarkd Studio spooky stamp seal set

Postmarkd Studio old fashioned seal set

Postmarkd Studio witch seal

Sealing Wax Kit

There’s something about a wax seal that makes an envelope feel all the more austere! This kit includes black wax and a brass seal with a witch design in it. It’s shockingly simple to do—just melt a bit of the wax by warming the end of the bar, and press the seal into the drop of wax to create the design. The kit includes some black and white twine, too, which you can seal down around packages!

Postmarkd Studio packet of ephemera

Postmarkd Studio halloween spooky stickers


The best part about this box, in my opinion, is that it includes stamps! I’m always scrambling for a stamp, and the ones I end up with are usually pretty boring. These stamps are so unique! The style is crisp and modern, but the subject matter is whimsical and fun!

Postmarkd Studio spider ring

Postmarkd Studio black plastic spider ring

Bonus: Spider Ring

I also got a spooky spider ring. This little guy reminds me of the favors we’d get this time of year in elementary school!

Postmarkd Studio kisses candies

Bonus: Hershey’s Kisses Candies

I even got a handful of candy, and I didn’t even have to go trick or treating to get it! Ah, the joys of adulthood…

Verdict: This box is so much fun! I love that it’s a mix of cards and fun desk surprises, rather than just one or the other. I don’t typically send out Halloween greetings, and this box has me asking myself, “Why the heck not?” It’s such a fun holiday, and these quirky, playful cards rise to the occasion. The little extras, from the pencil to the candies, help make the experience feel even more like a special gift for myself.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No. Sign up by October 31st to get your November box!

COUPON: Use code MSAFS or MSA404ME to get free shipping on your first box (MSAFS) or save $10 off your first box with a 3-month subscription (MSA404ME).

Value Breakdown: This box costs $30.00 after shipping. While I couldn’t find a value for every item in the box, the estimated value for the cards alone is $24.00. The average cost of each of the 7 featured items via the box is $4.29.

Check out all of our PostBox reviews and more stationery boxes in the Artisan Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this subscription to your wish list or subscription list!

What’s your favorite item from this month’s Postmark’d Studio Postbox?

Written by Anna Reilly

Anna Reilly

Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she’s swooning for all things kawaii!

Posted in Postmark'd Studio Reviews, Stationery Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: PostBox | 8 comments

Comments (8)

  1. I cancelled all my boxes months ago. This is the first review I have seen for this box! Where have I been? You got me, I think this may be my new favorite thing. Gotta go…I am running to sign up! Love this box!

    • Corally,

      We are so excited to have you join our snail mail revolution! Welcome!

      We love making noteworthy gestures of kindness commonplace!


  2. I finally subbed after looking at it for a few months. Next month will be my first month and I am so looking forward to it!

    • Jess,

      We are so excited to have you join our snail mail revolution! We are packing November PostBoxes now and so excited to get them to our subscribers.


  3. I’ve been eyeing this box for months! I just cancelled 3 subs this week, so maybe it’s time to take the plunge?

    • You wont be dissapointed! Everything is so well thought and packed with such attention to detail its a delight to unbox (:

      • Anie,

        Thanks for your kind words! We so appreciate your support.
        Hope all is well with you!


    • Pam-

      We’d love to have you “dive in” and join our snail mail revolution.
      Try us out for a month; free shipping on your 1st box! MSAFS.

      We also are offering 40% off your 1st PostBox when you sign up for a 3 month subscription. Use the code MSA404ME.


Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.