Foodstirs Baker’s Club: Monster Cookie Bash Kit October 2018 Review + Coupon


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Foodstirs is a baking subscription box that ships baking mixes kits to your door! Co-founded by Sarah Michelle Gellar, this subscription is all about high-quality, pre-made mixes with no preservatives or artificial ingredients. They feature ingredients like organic heirloom flour, all-natural food dyes, and fair trade chocolate.

We received this box for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

About Foodstirs Baker’s Club

The Subscription Box: Foodstirs

The Cost: $18.99 plus shipping, every other month. Discounts on 3, 6, and 12 box prepaid plans. 

COUPON: Get 20% off site-wide with code MSA20!

The Products: High quality, pre-made mixes with no preservatives or artificial ingredients. 

Ships to: United States, but they have an international waitlist, so be sure to sign up if you’re interested!

Good to know: Foodstirs ships bi-monthly. You should get your first box right away when you sign up, then they ship in August, October, December, February, April, and June.

Foodstirs Baker’s Club: Monster Cookie Bash Review

I love that Foodstirs decided to conserve paper and make things fun by including a word search and connect the dots activity on the back of their Nutritional Facts sheet. This is cute and it even goes with the theme!

This is the included recipe card with a photo of the finished product for reference. It also tells you how long it will take and everything you will need from home. They provided all of the dry ingredients, but we needed to provide eggs, unsalted butter, and plain yogurt. Luckily I had the butter on hand since I do a fair amount of baking, but I did have to run to the store for yogurt. This recipe makes about 6 cookies sandwiches.

The directions are broken down into six steps with pictures to go along with them. They were very clear and easy to follow, but this recipe did call for a lot of chilling and wait time. This is probably fine for older kids, but since mine are four and two, I opted to do the majority of the baking solo!

The cookie mix and frosting mix came packaged in bags labeled with “best by” dates which is helpful if you aren’t able to get to this box right away.

This recipe called for 9 TBSP of room temperature, unsalted butter. Since I only had one stick unfrozen, I opted to use 5 TBSP of unsalted butter and 1 TBSP of salted butter for the cookies, which didn’t seem to affect the flavor at all!

Before stirring our organic chocolate chippy cookie mix in, we had to take out 10 chocolate chips to use for later. Then we added the mix slowly making sure to stir it well in between. It was a bit dryer than I’m used to, so it definitely made more of a mess and took me a while to get it all mixed together.

I lined a pan with parchment paper and then added my cookies (2 TBSP of dough) to the pan and then flattened them out a bit. In retrospect, I didn’t flatten them quite enough as you’ll see later. There was enough dough to make twelve generous cookies.

Next, the cookies went into the fridge to chill, so I decided to get started on the frosting. I used 3 TBSP of unsalted butter that was softened a bit in the microwave and added my TBSP of plain yogurt. Then I slowly added the organic vanilla frosting mix until it was all combined and I had a nice thick frosting. I took half of the frosting and put it in a separate bowl for our next step.

This is where things started to feel a bit different in my baking. Instead of traditional food coloring drops, the frosting got its color from these packets of powdered food coloring. The interesting thing about these is that these are made with plant-based dyes. They worked really well to add some nice vibrant monster color to our frosting. These then went into the refrigerator as well.

While the cookies baked, I got the decorating set up so it would be ready for the kids. We received 5 Dandies All Natural Vanilla Marshmallows , two bags of Yum Earth Candy Corn  (both were surprisingly delicious, by the way!) and used the 10 chocolate chips that we reserved from the cookie mix. I cut the marshmallows in half with a knife which was really easy as these were a bit stiffer (not in a bad way) than traditional marshmallows.

To create the eyeballs, we just stuck the pointed end of the chocolate chips into the sticky side of the marshmallow and they stayed put while looking super cute.

Once the cookies were baked and cooled we were supposed to use the included cookie cutter to cut them into perfect circles. As you can see, our cookies were pretty thick and all of them were much smaller than the circle, so we didn’t really have to do this step. Oops!

We set up our cookies by laying them with the flat side up and then I placed a dollop of frosting (a TBSP and a half) in the center and then we placed another cookie on top to create our sandwich. I didn’t press down too much so that we could see the icing in the center.

Next, I placed two little dots of frosting on the tops of the cookies and we added our monster eyes. My daughter was in charge of this while my son took care of adding the candy corn teeth. They worked really well as a team and had fun doing this part!

We ended up making five monster sandwich cookies, so we had two plain cookies left over. This was the perfect treat for the kids while we placed our sandwiches back in the fridge to firm up a bit since they were starting to get a bit messy after having them out and adding teeth!

I think they turned out great! I was worried it would be a ton of icing since that’s what they show in the picture, but we were able to still make them look like monsters without that huge layer of frosting. They were still incredibly generous portions and not something you could eat in one sitting.

Verdict: This was my first time trying out Foodstirs Baker’s Club and I was impressed with the taste and how generous the servings were. I definitely had to do most of the baking since my kids are younger, but they were happy to help with the decorating, and of course the eating, so it was a fun family activity for a rainy day. The cookies were so rich and since the frosting wasn’t overly sweet, it made for a pretty balanced treat. I do think that maybe smaller cookies might have been a better option for us, and if I had thought about it, I could have easily modified the recipe to accommodate this, but then again, watching those large cookies bake was pretty satisfying! Overall, I thought it was a fun and tasty experience for $26.98 ($18.99 + $7.99 shipping)!

Also worth noting: Foodstirs has gone back down to a more reasonable shipping rate since past reviews (currently $7.99 vs $14.90).

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes, this box is still available!

Coupon: Get 20% off sitewide with coupon code MSA20!

Value Breakdown: For one premium baking kit shipped every other month, the price is currently $26.98 ($18.99 + $7.99 shipping) or $23.19 with our 20% off coupon code ($15.20 + $7.99 shipping).

Kits typically have anywhere from 6 to 12 servings. This box had enough ingredients to make 6 giant monster cookie sandwiches which means each would be about $4.50.

Check out all of our Foodstirs reviews and the Food Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of Foodstirs

Written by Brandi Dowell

Brandi Dowell

Brandi has loved the idea of subscription boxes since joining Birchbox in 2013. Finding new products to test out and possibly fall in love with has always excited her. Now, as a mother of 3, she loves discovering new products that can help make parenting a little easier! Her favorites are FabFitFun and Target Baby boxes.

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

Posted in Food Subscription Boxes, FoodStirs Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: foodstirs | 7 comments

7 Comments

  1. Sooooo happy they sent dandies marshmallows and yum earth candy corn! Halloween was always a huge bummer to me after I turned 9 and became a vegetarian since gelatin seems to be in everything including my favorite candy corn! Now I just ordered these from target and the marshmallows are a staple In my house already. 10yo me would have killed for this box lol

  2. Just a quick baking hack — If you need room temperature butter but all you have is frozen (like mine) or it’s too cold, portion out the amount you need and use a cheese grater and grate your butter. It will be at room temperature by the time you are finished grating. I used to microwave cold butter for a few seconds, but that seemed to make the butter oily.

    • Ooh great tip! I have never tried that! Thanks for sharing, Pat!! 🙂

  3. They sent me the August kit by mistake, but I contacted them and they are supposed to be sending me this one. I hope they do because my daughter is dying to make it! It looks like a lot of fun.

  4. Adorable! Are most months somewhat kid friendly or is it generally for adults?

    • Hi jennifer! This is actually my first month trying it, but if you check out past reviews, they seem to be pretty kid-friendly! 🙂

  5. Oh how cute!!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!