Facebook PixelCheryl's Cookie of the Month Review - October 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Cheryl’s Cookie of the Month Review – October 2018

Jessica Hapak
ByJessica HapakOct 15, 2018 | 8 comments

Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Box Review Top

Cheryl's Cookie of the Month Club
3 overall rating
1 Ratings | 0 Reviews

Cheryl’s Cookie of the Month Club is a monthly box delivering fresh cookies to your mailbox.

Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Box Open Review Top

Cheryl’s has additional variations, including a Gourmet Brownie of the Month Club, Treats of the Month Club, Sugar-Free Cookie of the Month Club, and even a Kids Cookie and Book of the Month Club! You can also choose the 12 or 6-month plan, which would mean a delivery once a month or once every other month.

This is a review of the Buttercream Frosted Cut-out Cookie of the Month Pay-as-you-go Club with 12 cookies. 

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Box Products Top


About This Box

The Box: Cheryl’s Buttercream Frosted Cookie of the Month

The Cost: New pricing - the 6-month plan is $21.99 + $6.99 shipping. The 12-month plan is $19.99 a month + shipping.

The Products: 12 buttercream frosted cookies

Ships to: the US

Cheryl’s Cookie of the Month October 2018 Review

Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Info Card Front 1 Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Info Card Front 2 Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Info Card Front 3

Once you open the box you are greeted to a beautiful sight of cookies and an info sheet. The info sheet has details on their various clubs, a discount code, how to store your cookies for maximum flavor, and how to tell if the sender left you a gift message.

Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Buttercream Frosted Pumpkin Cookies Top Cheryl’s Cookie Box October 2018 - Buttercream Frosted Pumpkin Cookies Top 2

Buttercream Frosted Pumpkin Cookies, 12 ct – Retail Value $29.99

I love these seasonal pumpkin cookies- they even have a little green stem at the top! These have the classic buttercream flavor in their cute pumpkin bodies, and individual packaging means it is easy to toss these in lunch boxes or with a card to give a seasonal treat to a friend. The cookies are buttery and so soft, and they do pack a bit of sugar so make sure you are trying to treat your sweet tooth before diving in. I love that these can be frozen, as this means I can always have a cookie in my freezer for the times I really want one. Since this is way more cookies than I could ever eat, I took most of them to the front office of my apartment complex that handles all of the mail for residents. Since I get many packages, I thought these would be a cute way to say thank you—and I was right! They loved them!.

The Verdict:  This cookie subscription is for everyone who loves the frosted sugar cookies you can buy at the grocery store, but appreciates that these are even more delicious. The price is high when you compare it to mass-produced cookies from the grocery store, however, I think the price is fair for the quality of the cookie you get. I also appreciate that there is a discount for subscribing—these 12 cookies would normally cost $29.99 plus shipping, and I got them for $23.98 ($16.99 plus $6.99 shipping. Pricing recently increased to $21.99 plus shipping). Since this is the pay-as-you-go club, you also aren’t saddled into a 6 or 12-month commitment of cookies, making these great for special occasions or one-time gifts. Each month the cookies will be in a different seasonal theme, which you can view here. My next cookie delivery will be in December, and the cookies will be Christmas trees, snowflakes, and ornaments!

To Wrap Up:

Can you get this box if you sign up today? I believe so! Sign up before the end of the 3rd week of the month to get those month's cookies.

Value Breakdown: This box costs $23.98 ($16.99 + $6.99 shipping) and I received 12 delicious cookies. That breaks down to about $2 a cookie.

Check out more sweets subscription boxes in the Food Subscription Box List!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of Cheryl’s Cookie of the Month Club? Have you tried their cookies before?

Starting at $16.99
Subscribe Now
Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead, have a box of our unparalleled buttercream frosted cut-out cookies delivered right to your (or one of your favorite people's) door 6 to 12 times a year. Our 6-month club includes deliveries in – February, April, June, August, October, and December. Each de... read more.
Jessica Hapak
Jessica Hapak
I am a staunch believer that pineapple doesn’t belong on pizza and when I’m not working as a family law attorney I enjoy hiking the Louisiana trails (alligator sightings are a favorite!) or relaxing with Duchess, my cat. I’m a sucker for anything labeled a mystery box and I’ve never met a bath bomb I didn’t like.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Thank you for continuing to review boxes like this! It might seem repetitive to some people, but it’s good for new readers. I’ve actually never seen a review of this one before (I don’t always read here every day, so sometimes I miss stuff) Cheryl’s cookies are soooo good and totally worth the “high” price. I might just have to subscribe to this one!

Reply ButtonReply


You don’t read MSA everyday!!??!!?? Do you know how many readers you made gasp!? :O haha! 😉 😀

Reply ButtonReply


I love these types of cookies and I’ve wanted to try Cheryl’s cookies for the longest.
One of my co-workers brought some into the office which was nice but they were old. I think they’d been put in the freezer and taken out past the 6 month time period.

Reply ButtonReply

Andrea Stapp

These cookies are average at best. Very heavy on the way too sweet frosting. Think of your grocery store bakery butter frosted cookies and these are much the same. Just overpriced. Will dry out when you freeze

Reply ButtonReply


Seriously? This is still a review? It’s the same cookie every month with a different shape, people.

Reply ButtonReply


I agree same cookie, different design, nothing new to discover.

Reply ButtonReply


Lol, I kind of have to agree. If it’s the same format every month (12 cookies) and most of the designs are pre-spoiled on the website, and the flavor doesn’t change or doesn’t change much, then would new reviews really add new information? I like seeing the Gramma in a Box reviews, conversely, as they do detail different activities and designs. 🙂 But maybe there are lots of people asking for this box to be reviewed, in which case it makes sense.

Reply ButtonReply

Amy lynn

Imma have to sub to this. My 9 and 3 yr old daughters always think your reviews of them looks delish!

Reply ButtonReply