Facebook PixelButter London Mystery Bundle Review – September 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Butter London Mystery Bundle Review – September 2018

Jessica Hapak
ByJessica HapakOct 1, 2018 | 8 comments

The Holo Hookup
5 overall rating
4 Ratings | 1 Reviews

Butter London is a makeup company that originally started exclusively with nail polish before branching out to cover eye, lip, and face products too.

They recently offered a $25 mystery bundle that is still available for purchase!

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out our review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Butter London September 2018 review

About This Box

The Box: Butter London Mystery Gift Bundle

The Cost: $25 + $6.99 shipping

The Products: 7 products with a $101 value

Ships to: the US only

September 2018 Butter London Mystery Bundle Review

Plush Rush Satin Matte Lipstick in Thrilled,

Plush Rush Satin Matte Lipstick in Thrilled, Full-Size! Retail Value $22

Right off the bat, I fell in love with the gorgeous floral packaging of this lipstick, and I wasn't disappointed once I opened up the box! The lipstick is closed by a magnet lid, and Thrilled is a such a gorgeous shade of pink-toned mauve. I wasn't expecting it, but this lipstick also has some plumping ingredients that caused some lip tingling. It didn't hurt (some plumping lipsticks do), and this lasted up until my next meal before needing to be reapplied.

Glazen Eye Gloss in Moonshine, Full-Size! Retail Value $24

This is actually the first time I have tried butter London’s eye gloss, and it is a product I was excited to see when I opened my box. The texture is really like a thick pudding, and I think applying this with your finger is the way to go. The end result was a gorgeous shimmering taupe that was super comfortable to wear!

Here it is swatched above the lipstick.

Stroke of Wow Volumizing Mascara, 0.14 oz

Stroke of Wow Volumizing Mascara, 0.14 oz –  Estimated Value $10 (based on the price of other mini mascaras from Butter London)

This mascara brush reminds me a lot of the benefit Roller Lash mascara because it has a tiny baby comb that you use to literally comb your lashes to build up length and volume. On my lashes, I noticed that my lashes were way longer, but not necessarily more volumized than any regular mascara. I am still a big fan, however!

Patent Shine 10x Nail Lacquer in Yummy Mummy

Patent Shine 10x Nail Lacquer in Yummy Mummy, Full-Size! Retail Value $18

Yummy Mummy is one of the OG shades from Butter London (I had a bottle in the same packaging as Ruby Murray!). It is a gorgeous cool beige shimmer that makes for a great neutral nail color, and this specific formula comes with a dense, curved brush that covered almost my entire nail in one swipe. At first, I didn't realize what the "patent shine" claim of this polish meant—on first application it was just as shiny as Ruby Murray, but not any shinier. It turns out that this is formulated differently with products like diamond power, with the goal actually being to make the shine last longer.

Trend Nail Lacquer in Ruby Murray, Full-Size! Retail Value $15

This nail polish is the OG Butter London packaging and comes with a longer brush that's on the narrow side. I was able to control the polish application with easy, and I absolutely love this deep berry red. And like Yummy Mummy, this polish is vegan and 8-free!

Signature File & Buffer,

Signature File & Buffer - Retail Value $5

There is no such thing as too many nail files in my book, and I adore the signature floral design. The grit on the file is only 180, which is great for gentle shaping without being too rough.

Nail Scrubbers, 5 ct – Estimated Value $5 (buy a pack of 10 for $10)

I love pre-moistened nail polish removing wipes like these ones! They make removing nail polish so convenient and easy, and I don’t have to search my apartment trying to remember where I put the cotton balls. Unfortunately, I will say that these did not live up to the claim that one wipe removes the polish from all ten nails—I ended up using two to remove the Ruby Murray on my left hand and Yummy Mummy on my right. Once the wipe finished the fourth nail it really lost steam, and removing the 5th nail was a challenge.

The Verdict: I loved this mystery bundle! For $31.99 ($25.99 + $6.99) and a promised value of $101, I got to try an estimated $99 worth of products from the entire array of offerings available from Butter London. I am always happy to own more Butter London nail polishes, and I am impressed with the shine and performance of the eye glaze. All of the other items were of good quality and will be used—I am a happy camper!

To Wrap Up:

Can you get this box if you sign up today? Yes, this mystery box is still available!

Value breakdown: This box costs $31.99 ($25 + $6.99 shipping) and I calculated a total value of $99. That means you are paying approximately the following per item:

  • Lipstick: $7.11
  • Eye Glaze: $7.76
  • Mascara: $3.23
  • Yummy Mummy: $5.81
  • Ruby Murray: $4.85
  • Nail File: $1.62
  • Scrubbers: $1.62

What do you think of the Butter London Mystery Bundle?

Starting at $40.00
Active Deal
10% Off
Use Coupon Code THHNYSTERY
Subscribe Now
The Holo Hookup is a monthly pre-order all holographic, exclusive (limited edition) box. The 3 main contributors are Cupcake Polish, DIFFERENT dimension and Glisten & Glow. Each month there will be a special guest maker as the 4th polish. Each month will also have a theme.
Jessica Hapak
Jessica Hapak
I am a staunch believer that pineapple doesn’t belong on pizza and when I’m not working as a family law attorney I enjoy hiking the Louisiana trails (alligator sightings are a favorite!) or relaxing with Duchess, my cat. I’m a sucker for anything labeled a mystery box and I’ve never met a bath bomb I didn’t like.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Buying this today and gonna spend 50$ so I can get the bonus as well! Can’t wait to try the eye glaze!!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I got this exact box too – so no variations.

I absolutely loved everything in this box. The lipstick was my fave! Normally mystery bundles come with old stock and ugly colors (my last experience just like this was with Ofra – NOTHING was usable – I got a dark shade of foundation with the lightest shade of powder, for example!)

This box had all the BEST colors and the BEST products. I LOVE Butter London, and their polish is my favorite – and has proven to stand the test of time (I have years-old polish that still looks great when I wear it)…this just proves that they’re a classy business, as well!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


This box is a mystery bundle- do you know if there are variations, or will everyone receive these same products?? I love your box, but am concerned that’s not what I would get if I ordered.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I received the same things, and I saw someone else did as well. I ordered a second box as a gift, so we’ll see if that is the same too. I love bL mystery boxes. They always contain great, useable products in “normal” shades. Also be sure to check out the bonus gift with $50 purchase (code BONUS50). The polish topper in that is gorgeous. Free shipping at $50 as well.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Wonderful box!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Not a fan of this box other than the mascara I would want… maybe next time. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Use promo code 20WELCOME18 to save $5 on this and get it for $26.99. I didn’t need to buy this, I have so much stuff. I am so terrible, but it was such a nice review.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Nice box!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike