Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
The theme is alter ego…. does that mean my alter ego has aspirations of being a 90s street walker? Those colors on the palette are something else.
Reply
amyr
LOL! Funniest comment ever!
I agree. That palette is hideous. This will be my first and last Boxycharm!
I am not interested in brown lipstick or that palette!
Reply
Ashley
😂😂 when i think of alter ego i think of dark and Smokey
Reply
Vicky H
Boxypreview (boxycharmpreview) has full spoilers for one variation posted.
Looks like it includes: Kat von d liquid lip, it superhero mascara, pur midnight mascarade palette, dermovia lace a peel mask (2), and farmacy green clean (makeup remover balm)
Reply
Rebecca Boerigter
The palette is the Pur Midnight Masquerade palette, now available on their website.
Reply
sandra
I think they palette colors are pretty awesome! I like the KVD liquid lipsticks. Looking like a pretty good box!
Reply
Sandra
Since when did makeup become soooo serious!?! It’s makeup, it’s suppose to be be fun. Who cares about their political or personal feeling. People are allowed to disagree with one another. Just because you buy their makeup doesn’t mean you follow or agree with their views! How many things do you use 10 items day that you get from a company or a person that has a messed up view of the world or you don’t agree with their moral compass or political stance that doesn’t publicly voice their views for the whole world to know. You probably buy things from those type of people and don’t even know. She just has the balls to voice her opinion. You don’t have like it. I could care less about Kat Von d’s view on life of politics.. her makeup is bad ass that’s what I’m judging. This is America we have free speak and God gave us free will. Why can’t we all just get along!?! Just stop the hate.
Reply
Maha
She has her opinion and she is entitled to have one. But she has been very rude to her followers and I don’t think that’s cool. I own a few of those liquid lips and they are amazing. After I saw a post when the told fans to F.. off because of their opinion on vaccinations I stopped buying her products. I don’t hate her.. I just didn’t like the way she handled it. And like me I am sure they are a lot of people who think that way, it doesn’t have to be necessarily because of her life choices, but then again we all have a right to not support people that stand for stuff we don’t like either. It’s not about the makeup, it’s about who is making profit out of it.
Reply
Regina
Anyone else sick of pur?
Reply
Michele Winter
Yes!! They really need to partner with another company. PUR IMO isn’t all that great. I guess they get good deals by collaborating with them but gee whiz enough with PUR already!!
Reply
palmer220
ME TOO! I’ve given away my last 4 Pur palettes. The idea of the box is to try various brands & products… The colors are so redundant, I’ve gotten about a dozen orange shades. And then that Crown palette of browns, it’s still in the box under my sink. I would prefer to try new Indie brands over the Pur products, can you imagine getting a Juvia’s Place palette? How great! imho
Reply
Rasheeda Triplett
Very much so…
Reply
Anna
Not really? I know this is an unpopular opinion, but it’s a solid brand, right in the middle-high-end range between drugstore and luxury, and I feel the quality is solid. I really love that eye palette of sparkly coppery neutrals we got last year. And the little bronzer palette from a couple of months ago was an MVP for me this summer when I was traveling and counting every ounce in my suitcase. Also liked the lip scrub.
Now if it was a bunch of Crown stuff …? That brand I don’t like so much.
Reply
Rose
Me ! it seems like they give out more pur palletes then anything.
Reply
Michelle
Yes!!!
Reply
Tanya M.
I am so feeling this palette this month. Oh, can’t wait. Signed back up after skipping September… No waitlist… i’m so lucky.
Reply
Kiersten
Just saw swatches of the kat von d lippies… and there are a lot of browns 😕
Reply
palmer220
Haha! When I saw the pic of his hand holding them I immediately thought “Oh no there are a lot of those blah browns in there…”
Reply
Madison MacDonald
I’ve tried almost all of the ones included (Lolita is my FAVORITE) but the others aren’t overly brown in my experience. The formula is my absolute favorite.
Reply
Tanya M.
Yeah, I got one of her brown ones in something else. i saved with a red liner. Don’t try a purple one thought. Made a color like mud after a day’s rain. Ugh. Blue red pencil worked well though.
Reply
Michelle Stromberg
I love Boxy – some months more than others. I don’t really ever get a sense Boxy relates with it’s themes. But I love the product. Wish it would curate per profile when it comes to lip colors.
Reply
Snowhitetwin
Is it just me or do the themes have nothing to do with anything. I could assign a random “theme” to any makeup and it would make sense.
Reply
Jessica
Yeah, I don’t feel like Boxy has quite gotten the hang of themes. Ipsy’s bags always feel really curated to the theme they have that round.
Reply
Shawna
Are the beauty profiles being implemented this month? Hoping to avoid another brown lippie.
Reply
dkla_diann
Oh goodie. yet another palette and this one looks unwearable. I was holding on to get off waitlist for LUXE in Dec., but may not be able to contain my joy until then.
Reply
Tracie
LOL sameeee.
Reply
Cynthia D O'Connell
Lol same
Jessica
Love the theme… still really unhappy about the KVD lippie, though. The PUR palette helps because it looks really pretty. Hope the rest of the box is better so it makes up for them partnering with a racist, anti-semitic, anti-vaxxer.
Reply
Bree
Why don’t you like the kvd lipsticks? They’re by far my favorite, super curious what about it didn’t do it for you
Reply
Jaime
I had to cancel. I understand her concern about her baby, but anyone with Google and modest brain capacity would understand that vaccinations are worth the risk. Autism is not a death sentence. Vaccinations are our best defense against diseases that ARE a death sentence. Autism can be beautiful. There are worse things out there than autism. It is not caused by vaccinations – I blame puppies. Dang cute puppies! Feck them!
Reply
Net punk
There is no relationship between Autism and vaccines. None.
Chris
Autism is beautiful? Tell that to my sister in law who would give her life for her autistic child to be able to speak a word… I can’t belive you even said that.
Cindy
🤯
Michelle
Oh gawd
Reply
Snowhitetwin
Wow I’m sure receiving a kvd lipstick in a sub box will not do you any harm.
Reply
Barbara
Hear, Hear Jessica!
Reply
Angie
Yesss boxy is being so stingy with the spoilolers
Reply
Nicole
There was a sneak peak of im gonna guess a spoiler on Yosef’s snapchat on Friday that I think some missed. Well he didnt really say it was a spoiler but he kept snapping and making sure the pallet was visible trying to make it obvious of the Violet Voss eyeshadow pallet. Gorg pallet!!! Hopefully he was trying to give us a hint!
Reply
Irina
We’ve seen that many times. We want more item spoilers;)
Reply
Regina
The theme was the spoiler. I’m sure the rest will be coming soon!
Reply
JCN
I see white flowers… could it be something white or a scent?
Snowhitetwin
Is it just me or do the themes have nothing to do with anything. I could assign a random “theme” to any makeup and it would make sense.
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.