Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I am getting really sick of getting lashes. Really hope that’s a variation and they don’t send me more. I haven’t used the last 2 pairs they sent me or the other 2 pairs from other boxes. And tweezers? I won’t mind if they are an extra item but not if they are taking the place of a full sized item. What’s up with this box?
I like the palette and cover fx drops and maybe the brushes because I’m still working on building my brush collection.
I’d say it’s a bit disappointing.
Reply
Victoria Smith
It is way better than this months box though and hopefully does not change like this months
Reply
Barbara
I can not believe the Cover FX Glitter Drops cost $44! YIKES! I’m also not so sure I will be using this stuff anytime soon. At 67, glitter is not my friend, but I suppose I can give it to a friend or add it to the donation box. (wow…that box is growing!)
Reply
Sarah
Honestly I am so excited for November!!! I got the Ace Beaute paradise collection and the formula is amazing! Also, I have never tried the cover effects drops but have always been curious so I am glad we are getting them in a box.
Reply
Susan
Can anyone say if it’s been pretty easy to sign up for Boxy?? Are there still waitlists? I myself may cancel. I love Boxy and the stuff is great but I’m starting to get a little tired of it. This clearly is one variation but I don’t need lashes and I don’t use the liquid highlighter and don’t need tweezers (if that is part of the box) the shadow colors are beautiful but not for me. Just wondering if I do cancel how easy is it to start back up??
Reply
Jessica
I really have loved being a part of BoxyCharm but between Kat Von D and now the Kardashians I’m on the verge of giving up. These are just not brands I particularly want to support.
But also… NO MORE LASHES UGH. That’s 3 in not very many months of boxes and I don’t wear lashes. I’m allergic to adhesives so it’s not an option even if I wanted to buy my own glue (because it also irritates me to be sent something you can’t use without buying something else).
Reply
Sam L
Is it normal for Boxycharm to send out eyeshadow palettes almost every month? It would be nice to see some skin care, hair care, or even some brush/sponge cleaner in our boxes. I don’t mind the makeup brushes, you can never have too many and sometimes I’m lazy and don’t feel like cleaning my brushes so having extras is awesome!
But I’m getting so overwhelmed with these eyeshadow palettes. I own 13 eyeshadow palettes and only use 6 of them… the ones I don’t use I have stashed away as Christmas presents. Heck, if Boxycharm went the route that FabFitFun does that would be awesome too! Mix it up a bit.
Reply
Pink5
So far, I’m going to say yes.
I like palettes because that way you’re not stuck with just one shade you might hate.
Reply
Maribel Rodriguez
Luxy brushes they mentioned it on their Instagram story
Reply
Lynn I. Poor
Could those be Vasanti brushes?
Reply
Debbie
I’ve been thinking of cancelling for a while and this might be the push I need.
Reply
Becky
I’ve been thinking of canceling & if this is the box then I definitely will be
Reply
Allie
The brushes are Luxie. They had something on IG about it, it’s the Luxie 4 piece Luminous Eye Set.
Those lashes are pricey!!! Even more than Lilly Lashes!
Reply
Angel
I guess my whole box is going to be a variation because the spoiler I got from Boxycharm she 3 things so far and it was a Pür palette, superhero masacara, and a kat von d everlasting lip? That’s weird
Reply
Del
The update you got is for the October box, this I for November …does not seem that good ..
Reply
Jennifer A Vaughn
This is for November not October. We’re all getting the Pur palette, it mascara, kat von liquid lipstick and the last 2 items are variations.
Reply
Cady
This is for November.
Reply
Jill M
I am getting the shade Crucifix for my KVD lippie! It looks like the perfect fall shade. Deep chocolate brown. I love tye formula of the one I got from Allure, but I never wear it because the color, bow n arrow, washes me out!! So I’m excited for this months box and I’m happy for the skincare too. As far as this Nov variation goes, I think its another good box. I just hope they start using our profiles so I wont get a lash variant. I dont even know anyone to gift them too and I’m 37 yrs old so I’ve calmed my makeup look down a bit. I use lash serum and my lashes are great the way they are.
Reply
Christy Woods
How did you find oit which lippie shade your getting?
Reply
clusby75
How do you know which color lipstick you’re getting? Thsnks!
Reply
Kittybaby
Boxycharm sent out emails letting you know what shade you’re getting.
JCN
I like the colors of that palette.
Reply
Rachel
So this is another of those throw away boxes that you are required to get to qualify for the luxy box? I’m not impressed, hope this is revealed to be something else instead.
Reply
MzBev
I stayed for the August box, since they said that was REQUIRED to upgrade to Luxe. Little did I know that wasn’t true. I didn’t want the August box then tried for hours to upgrade and couldn’t even get on the waitlist for it. (after 4 hours of trying that day) I’m going to cancel before Nov. Nothing in that looks appealing to me.
Reply
Ingrid
I been with boxycharm a little more over 3 years, Boxyluxe is every 3 months, I couldn’t get the first box so I put myself in the waiting list, as far as I know I will be getting in December the boxyluxe, to be honest, they are great, great products. give it a chance and you will love it.
Nicole
Ugh my feelings exactly! Stayed for July and August to get boxy luxe and now I’m trying to hold out for December and then take a break! I’m sure January will be amazing! 🙄. Glitter drops? Not for me!
Reply
KW
How do you guys know which color you’re getting in the KVD lippie?
Reply
Susan P
I am getting KDUB. My friends are getting Mother, Bow n Arrow, Vampira and Lovesick. Lots of variations of this lippie.
Reply
Dina
Boxycharm will send you a email.
Reply
Jenn Johnson
It’ll be sent to your email!
Reply
Jill M
I got an email from them with the spoiler of what will be in my box. When I clicked on it, it went to the screen with the palette, lippie (with color name) and full size It mascara. The only two that are blocked out is the mask and the cream. I think you have to be signed up for emails from them.
Reply
Jennie
Luxie Beauty commented on Kim K’s post saying “Thank you for loving our Luminous Eye brush set”
Reply
Tanya
Omg I sure hope it’s a luxie product… I loved the tiny luxy brushes we got earlier from Boxy. They are my absolutely favorite. I looove soft, fluffy brushes! Please tell me it’s that.
Also, the palette looks a lot more interesting than the Pretty Vulgar palette we got… basically a naked palette.
I don’t wear lashes… I tend to tear my own off with the falsies. LOL… but staying subbed for the brushes, unless otherwise noted. lol
Reply
Denise
Ahhhh. There it is…
Reply
amyr
I am getting the October box but I cancelled. After seeing reviews I am sticking with Ipsy Glam Bag Plus.
After seeing this spoiler I am happy I cancelled.
Some boxes are better than others and it all depends upon the person.
Reply
Kathy
Looks like its the Luxie Luminous eye set!
Reply
Chrissy
I was so confused when I saw this and then realized it’s for November… how the heck did we jump so far ahead, lol?
Anyway, I love that eyeshadow palette. I love pinks and reds.
Reply
Chrissy
Also, I guess the tweezers could just be there to reference putting on the lashes? Like added decoration?
Reply
amy
so Octobers box has 2 skincare items and novembers will have tweezers as one of our items im kinda sad.. even more sad that there are those dreaded lashes i hope i get a variation without lashes i wish we could tell them things we dont like.. the beauty quiz only asks what you like. id like to tell them what i dont want also
Reply
Courtney
What is with Boxee charm sending me Brown Lippi’s I got the gross brown Smashbox Libby and I’m getting the Kat Von D bow and arrow which happens to be the same exact one I got from Allure….love to trade for just about any other color
Reply
Andreane Rajotte
I have vampira? Brand new
Reply
Mary
I’ll trade you bow and arrow for KDub
Reply
Sheila Wood
Im getting Mother and i just got a color almost like it would you want to trade. Id take bow and arrow
Reply
Justine
want lovesick? I love bow n arrow!
Reply
Lauren
I’ll trade you bow and arrow for lovesick!!
Lenae
im getting k-dub, ill trade ya lol
Reply
Irina
Boxee always sends me one shade – poo like brown shade what is absolutely disgusting on me. I use only pink or mauve. I’ll get hawkwind in that box
Reply
Sara
The palette looks prettier on the brands website, more vibrant. But I’ve never heard of that brand before. I unsubbed for October cause I didn’t want another Pur palette I wouldn’t use and November doesn’t look exciting either. It’s really funny they’re already showing a variation for November and it’s the beginning of October. Also wonder about this whole Summer’s Eve deal going on, how many people are submitting receipts, will they get November’s box or a special promo box?
Reply
cookie
Ace BEAUTE is an excellent brand. Its not cheap and the shadows are highly pigmented. Im very excited to get this. I have their pallete Quintessential. Its amazing
Reply
Terraenea
Ace beaute just came out with a huge 4 palette launch that was all over the Internet (mainly insta) for a few months. They look gorgeous and rival all sorts of popular palettes out there.
Reply
Jamie
The brushes r Luxie brushes they posted this pic talking about they’re as excited as kim is that shes excited for their brushes lol!! Or said something like that but almost all the brands in the pic r posting stories and posts about them being in the box with swatches an all!!!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.