Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Getting box 1. KVD shade in Mother! I LOVE IT!!! Beautiful shade of pink! I am sooo excited!!
Reply
Natalie
Does anyone have different silhouettes on their spoiler email? Everyone seems to have the silhouettes of the farmacy cleanser and the sheet mask. If anyone has different silhouettes please lmk. Thanks a lot
Reply
h
Do we know which variation is coming, in advance, like Sephora Play! is, or used to be? Or, is it just a surprise when it arrives? Is it somewhere marked on the exterior of the box?
Receiving K-Dub. There is no way I’ll get this to work with any makeup that I own. I haven’t received my box, if someone really wanted that color, and received a more blue-red or Lovecraft-esque type of color–dusty rose or muted mauve or berry. I am dealing with shingles (immunity is compromised), so I cannot trade with anyone that has opened or tested their lipstick. It would need to be untouched and unopened, and maybe undelivered yet, like mine.
Reply
Cassie
I’m getting the KVD lipstick in Hawkwind. It looks pretty from the pics I’ve seen online. The silhouettes I had looked like a jar and a rectangle so I’m hoping that means I’m getting the Farmacy cleansing balm and the sheet mask.
Reply
SunnyT
In my spoiler email shows something in a jar not like a hand cream. Wonder what that is? Haven’t seen it in any of the spoiler videos. I guess I’m getting the sheet masks as well.
Reply
Hanna
Hi I have the same preview! I am trying to figure out what the tall jar is!
Reply
Cassie
SunnyT, the Farmacy cleansing balm comes in a jar. I got the same silhouettes so I’m hoping that’s what it means!
Reply
SunnyT
Thanks!!! Wow! That would be awesome!!! I’ll keep my fingers crossed, but not getting my hopes up!
Glitzy
Noooooooooooo no face cleaners- I only want makeup!
Reply
Natalie
This subscription is a beauty sub which means it will include skincare, beauty tools, makeup and any other covited beauty item. Skincare is very important and this may be the best box I’ve seen. Very happy this month
Reply
summersam
agreed!! this product is awesome! I travel with a mini one because these balm cleansers are so easy & will not potentially spill. this box is SUPER!
molly
Someone in wisconsin come trade with me because i got KDUB. I look horrible in that color.
Reply
Denise
So. If the people that have had boxy for a while and already got the brigeo hair mask get a repeat ?? It’s bad enough that the variants stink but getting repeats is adding salt to the wound. I didn’t get the farmacy last time, and when I saw it I just knew it wasn’t going to be in all the boxes. At this point I don’t trust any spoilers from any boxes that send variants (looking at you allure)
Reply
Lucy
Sydney from SydneySmallsBeauty got variation 3 with the hand cream and Briogeo leave in mask.
Reply
Amy lynn
I got Mother,and wanted KDUB. I’ll take it. Glad it’s not brown.
Reply
Candice
Wanna a trade?!!!!
Reply
Eliza_villa87
I am willing to swap with you! Mine is already on the swap site or you can leave your email and I would be willing to swap that.
Reply
Cassie
Amy Lynn, I’ve seen several posters say they are getting KDUB and were disappointed. Someone may be willing to swap with you.
Reply
Vicky H
I think someone mentioned it below but has anyone heard if the spoiler email placeholders for the two variant items are actually a profile of the product we will be getting or just a generic placeholder? I am curious if I am getting farmacy and the lace face masks or at risk for leave in conditioner and stinky hand cream (I got it for free from Ulta I think or else it’s Ipsy leftovers).
If anyone is curious I got KDub. I’m regifting for personal reasons to my sister and I think based on her urban decay lip color choices she will like this color or regift to her super young sister in laws who will.
Overall it’s not a bad box, but it could range from mediocre to awesome very quickly depending on variants.
Reply
Selina
Based on my latest email spoilers, i am gettting kvd in mother, a lace mask and a jar of something. I have that ahava hand cream already and hate the smell, brings on a migraine!
Reply
R
If boxycharm is FULL SIZE why we getting 2 sample sizes this month????
Reply
Natalie
What are you talking about? Everything is full size in this month’s box. There aren’t any samples. Unless I’m wrong please lmk
Reply
J
Some youtubers opened did an unboxing and there were 2 samples. Brogio and something else I cannot remember.
summersam
we arent getting any sample sizes
Reply
Chrissy
I’m getting the KVD lipstick in MOTHER. It looks super pretty!
Reply
Rach
I’m getting KDub. It’s okay. A bit over the top, but I’ll kindly accept it over brown. I got a small size of it through Sephora last year (in my play box). I saw beautiful colors in the September boxes and I got the absolute worst color. It was Grande Lips Rebel Raisin 🤢 It was ridiculously dark brown and runny. Nobody would even trade. I put a tiny bit on one lip and it smeared everywhere. That tiny bit also made me look like I was preparing for Halloween… early.
I miss the days where everyone got the same thing and it was pretty.
Reply
Jackie
Butts. I’m getting Bow and Arrow, which is gorgeous…but I already own it. I’m excited about the IT mascara though, and the palette looks pretty.
Reply
Ras
I saw two people unbox on YouTube neither one got Faramcy cleanser. They received sample size hand cream and hair mask.???
I thought boxycharm was full size???
Reply
SunnyT
I’m getting “Lovesick” and I can’t tell you how happy I am to finally not get a brown lipstick from Boxy!!! 🙌🏻
Reply
Monique E
Omg the Faramcy cleanser is so good- just ordered full size yesterday. Best cleanser ever.
Reply
Liz Petrus
I got KDUB if anyone wants to trade.
liz petrus at aim dot com
no spaces
Reply
Kelle
How do you know already?
Reply
Jackie
They sent out an email and you can check your spoilers (like ipsy does).
Lori
Yay! I’m getting Vampira. That makes up for some of my other boxes being disappointing.
Reply
Pink5
Lucky.
I’m getting Mother.
Why do box people think I like pink lipstick?
Is it because I’m 56?
GIMMEE reds!
Reply
Lauren
You can have mine hawkwind it’s a brick red.. I wanted pink so I’m happy to trade 🙂
Calbchgrl1ataoldotcom
Let me know 🙂
Natalie
All I ever get is rose colors. This time it’s Lolita. I have this shade from about a dozen other companies.
amyr
I have found out by lying about my real age I get more products I like. I don’t like to put into a demographic box. I don’t want the Old Lady box (I am 64). I want something that is modern but not too trendy. I say I am 40.
I swear some companies don’t want people my age! I guess they think after a certain age women all want to become invisible!
Chris
Me too! I’m 58 and they are sending me Lovesick, a pepto pink.
Blech! I ONLY wear reds or dark berry lippies
Stef
I’m getting the Kvd lippy in KDUB. Anyone wanna swap? I dont do pinks.
Reply
Cheyenne
I don’t think everyone is getting the Farmacy. On my spoiler page if you scroll all the way down, the jar is definitely blue and white ombre, blue top white bottom. It looks like there is a green logo on the left side of the jar. Any clues? Also, if the bold writing next to it is an indication the name of the brand is very short.
I am getting Lovesick which I think I might already have so I’m going to check. I’m definitely hoping to swap for Vampira since I was planning on buying it.
Reply
Anna
If you have any ragweed allergies the Farmacy can be a problem due to some that are allergic to ragweed having reaction to echinacea.
If you have sensitive skin you should definitely patch test first.
Reply
Hanna
I’m not sure if I would like the cleansing balm. I just ready up on the mask and I’m alll over that for my silly congested skin!
Reply
Tj
Hoping the silhouette is correct, because I love the Farmacy cleanser, I have the full size and 2 trial sizes now! The Kat von D lip will be donated or tossed, just not a fan in general of her products. But I absolutely love Farmacy, so I’m really hoping that’s what I’m getting!!!!
Reply
Momma
You’re more than welcome to donate or toss your lipstick to me lol
Reply
Cady
I’m getting Crucifix which I’m sooo happy for ! Yay
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.