Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
🔴⚠️🔴⚠️🔴PLEASE READ!!!🔴⚠️🔴⚠️🔴
Due to all the controversy surrounding Laura Lee and her palette that came in the boxycharm Box in August…
If you email customer support at boxycharm saying that you do not want the Laura Lee palette they will do one of two things:
🔵1. Replace the Laura Lee palette 4 of the crown palette that came in the month before box. OR
🔵2. give you 1000 charms to use in the charm room.
You choose. And no, you do not have to send back the Laura Lee palette
Reply
Michelle
I think this is ridiculous. Why should Boxycharm do this? I can assure you that everyone has told an off color joke at one point or another and to hold Boxycharm accountable is dumb. I don’t like Laura Lee and I never have but to ruin this girl’s life, this mob mentality is really scary and frankly unbelievable.
Reply
Jen
For me this has been a real miss and now I am worried that with the new roll out of BoxyLuxe the quality will go down hill even more.
Reply
Svetlana7e
I am not upgrading to BoxyLux. I thought about it and all it is basically equivalent to receiving two regular boxes in one month – one for $21 and the other for $28, because BoxyLux has same brands, the product is not much different then regular box. Why stress to receive double the product.
I happy that people excited about it and I hope everyone will have a chance to sign up. To me, it is not worth it.
Reply
Nyesha
Yes the spoilers haven’t been that exciting and I have been strongly suggesting to reveal FULL spoilers before 9/1 so we can really have that option but nope no 1 will listen to 1 customer so oh well.
Reply
Michelle
Except 2 boxes would be 8 products vs 1 Lux box is 11 products, if I am not mistaken.
Reply
Laura
I agree. I was hoping for more Lux products but I think you are right about it being the same brands And it us like getting two boxes.
Reply
Misti
I am still not sure if I even want to try for BoxyLuxe
Reply
Janell
Liz…..
Why does it say we will receive ONE OF THE FOLLOWING. And then shows the palette and the 2 blushes. I thought everyone was receiving the palette and then ONE of the blushes. Can you please confirm, I was staying one more month for just the palette.
Reply
Liz Cadman
Sorry that should be “the following” not “one of the following” I’ve updated it. Sorry again!
Reply
Dani
Everyone is getting the eyeshadow palette, one of the blushes and one of the lip products. You’re safe to stay another month if you’re doing it for the palette.
Reply
Megan
Ahh y’all! Im legit low key nervous that im not going to get to upgrade to boxyluxe:( Yosef did say that how they came up with the numbers was they took the numbers from th special edition box then multiplied that number many times. I hope that most of everyone who wants to upgrade gets to and it all works out for everyone. I’ve been counting down to DDay since they released the release deets- as I’m sure many of you have lol. Fingers crossed for everyone ❤️
Reply
Mommy
Did anyone else get another email today saying they’ve unlocked boxyluxe and will be part of the elite few who get it?
Reply
Laura
Nope
Reply
Toni Marie
Hi Liz & Everyone,
I have 2 questions…
1. Will the alamar brushes be in the boxycharm box or boxyluxe?
2. Have all of the spoilers been revealed for the boxyluxe box?
Thank you so much for answering
Reply
Danielle
I can’t promise I have this completely right, but I have been keeping up with this upgrade on multiple social media sites.
1. Since BoxyLuxe is supposed to have 4 of the regular box products, I would assume the brushes will be included in both. But keep in mind the brush set spoiler was more of a hint than an official spoiler, although the pics on Instagram look exactly like the Alamar set.
2. From the research I’ve done, I believe all spoilers have been released for both boxes. I doubt they will send any others out before Saturday. But I’m sure if they do, it will get posted on MSA.
Hope that helps! Good luck with getting the upgrade. I think we’re all going to need it!
Reply
Jackie
I’m super excited for BoxyLuxe! I’m so hoping it doesn’t go the way the Limited Edition box went. I’ve been subbed to boxy for over 3 years, and really hope we all get a shot at the Luxe box!
Reply
Michelle
I am bit confused. My Boxy money will come out Sat. night so I will have the option to add the difference for the Lux box as a 2nd additional charge?
Reply
MzBev
Correct. If they can’t bill you for the regular box, you can’t upgrade.
Reply
Michelle
How does that answer my question? They can and do bill me on the 1st. I am asking if they will then email asking if I want to upgrade and if I agree the difference will then be a 2nd charge?
Pink5
Just so long as it isn’t an ugly pink or nude or brown, I have no preference on lip brand.
Reply
Sandi
That’s pretty much all color ranges…. But I get’cha…… My problem has been that dang Dookie Brown 🤮🤪💩 😃
Reply
Granny
I am excited. I just made a second sub so that I can do two Boxy Luxe! Wow…between this and 2 Ipsy Plus and 1 Ipsy regular. I will have so much stuff to play with LOL…
Reply
Bonnie
And how do you know you have two Ipsy plus? Are you some type of insider or did you get notified already about Ipsy plus?
Reply
Danelle
Definitely sounds greedy and entitled when everyone is aware that this will sell out and many will not get a chance at one. I’m gonna day the same for the Ipsy plus as well. New hype means a rush to try. So while I understand your enthusiasm and want to share with your family, not thinking of others just makes you look rude. I’m sure a great person IRL- you just want all the fam to enjoy. I get to. :).
Reply
Granny
I have 2 daughters, 2 nieces, a sister and a grand daughter that do not do Boxy and only one does Ipsy . I share my make-up! They get bags/boxes of skincare and make-up every time I see them and they enjoy not having to pay for subscriptions. I also sub to 11 other regular subs and some on/off subs. Greedy would be purchasing subs for all of us which I can afford to do. I do a lot of swaps to get multiple palettes so that they get the same palettes as me. I had one Boxy sub but swapped until I had 5 Crown palettes.
A lot of you have been putting the Boxy Luxe down and I am seeing so many posts on how unhappy you seem with what they have to offer. I think they are doing a great job putting it together no matter what they name it.
Reply
Tina Morris
Still does not entitle you to two boxes, hopefully the admins catch this as I am hoping to get a boxy luxe, so stop being so greedy, if your family wanted them they should have signed up with boxy to start with, otherwise they are not entitled to one.
Victoria
I have to agree, seems a bit selfish to do. I’m hoping you only put this as a controversial thing to get everyone going lol. If you think about it, a lot of people will be waking up Saturday morning just to upgrade and some might not even be able to due to being sold out. I’m sorry for saying this but karma does come around. Why not wait till later Saturday evening or Sunday morning if there is any boxes left 👌🏻🤗 just to give everyone else a fair shot as well. It’s what I would do, but then yet not everyone can be kind I suppose.
Reply
Jen
Two?? When it’s limited and some people probably won’t even get one! Plus two ipsy plus boxes? Isn’t that one limited too? Seems a bit selfish👎🤦🏼♀️😐
Reply
Irina
So much hate in comments.🤦🏼♀️ Girls, feel free to take my luxe box, I don’t want it at all. Planning to unsubscribe from boxy too
Krista
Why do you need 2 of each box? Legitimately wondrring..
Reply
Mel
How about you let other people get a box before you go grabbing two of both subs, when they’ve made it clear there will be a wait list and not everyone will be able to get a box. Seems a little selfish to hoard boxes for yourself, when so many others would like a chance to get one, don’t you think?
Reply
DG
No offense Granny, but hopefully Boxy won’t allow anyone to order more than one BoxyLuxe this first time around. That would be so unfair to the people that have subscribed for years and don’t even get one. They’ve been very clear that they expect to sell out. Unfortunately, with two separate accounts they probably won’t catch this kind of greedy behavior.
If your message had been posted on a LUXE post (vs this BoxyCHARM post), you’d probably anger a lot of other .
Reply
DG
*others
Victoria
I’m loving it!! I’m so excited for boxyluxe, does this theme go for both regular and luxe?
Reply
Jacki
The theme may as well be September boxy. Then I would spend less effort trying to figure out how it relates to the contents.
Reply
Cristina
This is the September theme.
Reply
Jeanette
This box has too many variants. Officially done with boxycharm.
Reply
Rosette
This is boxycharm luxe
Reply
Rosette
Oop wrong link lol
TheGirlWhoLived
The Ojitos Brush Trio by Alamar Cosmetics was shown as a possible spoiler. Was that still possible and is it only for BoxyCharm or both Boxes?
Reply
Liz Cadman
Still possible, just not sure if it’s Boxycharm or just Boxyluxe. Hope that helps clarify!
Reply
RoguesEn3D
If the theme is Wild Flower then I don’t want any brown makeup. Sadly, I lose on that one.
Reply
Apricot
Brown make-up doesn’t flatter me at all. I have no idea why. I can wear brown clothes though, no problem. *shrug*
Reply
Kathryn Dayley
Liz – I saw on Boxy’s Instagram the pic of the Pretty Vulgar palette with the message “every single Charmer will receive this @pretty_vulgar Nightingale Smokey Eyeshadow palette….. so I was thinking everyone got it – can you confirm?? Thanks!
Reply
nikkim
yes everyone is getting the palette. it was confirmed on the 1st boxy spoiler by msa
Reply
Heather
I wish Boxy let you skip a month the way Julep does. None of these products look interesting to me. Boxy has been very hit or miss lately, and this one so far looks like a complete miss for me.
Reply
Linda
That would be awesome if they let us skip a month like Julep and Ipsy. Getting this much makeup every month gets overwhelming. It’d be nice to take a break without having to cancel.
Reply
Heather
Ipsy doesn’t let you skip a month. If you want to skip, you have to cancel your sub then risk the waiting list to rejoin.
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.