Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
All subscribers will receive a Smashbox Lip Product - This sneak peek shows a lip palette, Be Legendary Lipstick, Be Legendary Triple Tone Lipstick, and Liquid Lips!
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Hey, I’m getting the mascara, so variation one. I’m visually impaired, and my boyfriend isn’t great at describing makeup colors to me 🙂 typical man. Would someone mind telling me the colors in the lip palette? Thanks so much for your help. I appreciate it!
Reply
Allison
I’m getting the lashes. I don’t wear lashes. Either I’ll give them to my mom or put them in my subscription reject box. There is nothing in this box that I like. I would have preferred the primer though.
Reply
Ash
I feel the same way… I feel like that cant possibly please everyone every month but last month kinda sucked to for me
Ugh. It looks like most people (including me) got the false lashes and nobody wanted them lol. That’s what I got for resubscribing when I need absolutely no new makeup at all.
Reply
Olivia
Ugh, I’m getting lashes. I really really hope I get a lip color that redeems this box. I’d be happy with the palette or the pink drink liquid lip we’ve seen in the box 1 and 2 spoilers and there are some other pretty colors on their website, but the way this box is going I’ll probably get something bright orange.
Reply
Danielle
I feel your pain. I’ve been getting box version #1 every month except for one in the past two years. Even when I tried ordering a second box in July I got version #1 for both. This month I would’ve actually preferred version #1 (or even #2) but for August they finally changed my variation to the one with lashes. I hope BoxyLuxe is great and doesn’t have variations, otherwise I may just give up on Boxy altogether.
Reply
Zo
I’m getting lashes as well. I think that means variation 1 with the lip palette.
I did not get a spoiler last month so am happy to get one this month.
Reply
Danielle
Actually it looks like variation #1 has Tarte mascara instead of lashes. It’s the one I always get…until now. My spoiler was lashes too and according to the versions pictured above it isn’t #1 or #2 since neither show lashes. Bummer.
Sam
How do I go about trading items? I just saw I’m getting the Barbie HOL in my box and I’m not a big fan of false lashes 😢
Reply
Sam
Bambie not Barbie
Reply
Jb
Disappointed. I just got a boxycharm email I’m getting the Becca backlight primer; of course that’s the variation I did not want! Still have one in a box from last year,
Reply
Susan Marie Ferry
I’m getting the lashes and would love to trade!!!!
Reply
Jj
Do you want to trade me for lashes?🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼
Reply
V
I just got an email saying I’m getting the Becca primer, the black one. Thank goodness!
Reply
Jamie
I also got an email and I’m getting the blue becca primer. Or is it purple? Whichever. I’m ok with that. I wonder which variation I’m getting then. I’ve never not gotten variation 1. I almost feel like there’s a system glitch lol.
Reply
Misti
Boxy sent me an email too and I am very happy I am getting a Becca primer and I really needed it my last primer was causing my face to break out a first aide beauty primer.
Reply
Jane
Ugh!! Just learned i’m getting the lashes….seriously i never wear lashes. Throwing the whole box away >.<
I get what people are saying that we should be grateful to get a bunch of full price items but if there is one thing i've learned in life is that having 6 full priced items that you are going to trash or give away even for a steal $21 is a waste of money. Would have canceled had I known what I was getting even with the luxe box coming next month
Reply
shoppeaholik
O gosh, ditto on the lashes. I don’t wear them…up for swap they go!
Reply
Irene
I just canceled after 3 years my profile and beauty quiz that shows I don’t wear fake lashes what did I get again lashes everytime there’s variations I get the one thing I don’t want won’t use so I just cancelled my sub
Reply
Kathy
I Just got an email from Boxy Charm congratulating me on getting the House of Lashes….I’m ok with that if I get the Smashbox lipstick Palette Im really wanting. Guess its time for me to breakdown and give false eyelashes a try??? I kinda wish thier were no variations, this way no one would feel a dissapointment in wanting something else available to others. However so looking forward to the BoxyLuxe.
Reply
Grace
I think I’m getting the lip palette! If you don’t get it, I would definitely trade you for the triple tone lippie
Reply
Debra
I just got the email that I am getting the lashes. I am so disappointed. I just got lashes a few boxes ago and I don’t use them. So, there must be five or six versions of the boxes. I have been subscribed for over two years and I feel as if Boxy has expanded too quickly and we are getting odds and ends! I used to get the same box that was reviewed by Liz. Pretty unhappy!
Reply
Susan Marie Ferry
SAME HERE!!! DOUBLE ON THE FAKE LASHES!!!
I DIDN’T KNOW I COULD SKIP A MONTH… PLEASE TELL ME HOW? I’VE SEARCHED THE SITE 10 TIMES OVER AND CAN’T FIGURE IT OUT.
Reply
Jamie
There’s no way to skip a month. You have to completely cancel and resub when you want the box again.
Kp
Just got a spoiler that I’m getting lashes…where do we go for swaps?
Reply
lesli
same here, the lashes are a disappointment. i haven’t even opened the ones from a few months ago. 🙁
Reply
Lauren
I’m getting the lashes too, if anyone wants to trade. 🙁 Otherwise I’ll just give them to one of my drag queen friends. 🙂
Reply
Joni
Same. I wanted ANYTHING but the lashes. Very disappointed.
Reply
Jj
I’m getting the lashes if anyone wants to trade??
Reply
Cady
I’m so excited. I got an email spoiler telling me I’ll be receiving a pair of lashes.. I love lashes !
Reply
Cassie
anyone have the Becca backlight and wants to trade me for the lashes?!
Reply
Rose
I hate the eyeshadow pallete. These colors have not drawn my attention since 7th grade. lol
Reply
liliana
Any charmers in the Los Angeles area?
Reply
Amy M
So glad I decided to skip this month. For the first time I do not have FOMO after seeing the spoilers. I am also glad to skip the BoxyLuxe upgrade too. No thank you, I got the Limited Edition box and learned the hard way.
I love Boxycharm but this month feels like a Marshall’s shopping spree. I really hope September’s box is better.
Reply
BB
That eyeshadow is hideous. Absolutely hideous.
Reply
Tracie
It’s an 80’s middle school flashback. Ughhh. I’ll try to figure out the swap site and hope I can trade.
Reply
Nancy
Halloween party!! Lol!!
Reply
Selina
I have been getting variation # 1 for the last 2 years and then suddenly I got var #2 in jun/jul! So fingers crossed that they go back to box 1 for me because I was happy with it.
Reply
Selina
Surprise, I am not getting either var 1 or 2 this time! I am getting variation from hell. Got that email that said congrats, you are getting the House of Lashes item. Well after 2 years plus and several unused lashes in my boxy collection, I am feeling that I was pushed to the bottom of the pool by boxy!
Reply
Wendi
Exciting I hope I get variation 2.
Reply
Marie
Looks like I’m getting variation #1.
Reply
Lauren
Hey, I have a question for those of you who have been subscribed for a while. I just joined in June when there weren’t really variations. In July, I got box variation 1. Based on others’ experiences, do you typically get the same variation? In other words, will I probably get box 1 again? Thanks a million!
Reply
Julie
I usually get box 1 and occasionally box 2, but this month I got the lash spoiler from boxycharm which isn’t in either of these. So, I’d say it’s mostly consistent but not always.
Reply
Toni Marie
Yes, i always get variation #1… it doesnt matter if its a boxycharm or any other subscription box… they aleays give me variation #1…i don’t know if it goes by last name or region
Reply
MzBev
I haven’t always kept track of which one I got but since I started tracking it, I always have got 1 or 2. I will be so sad if I get 1, this time.
Reply
Jamie
I always get box 1. I’ve been subbed since February.
Reply
Vicky H
I’d love to see a poll with people’s box variation numbers. I’ve gotten 1, 2, 2, 1. The months with 2 only had a single lippie brand variant. It will be interesting to see if I get 1 this month with several variations. Just curious if anyone gets 3, 4, etc on a regular basis. If so, what months?
Reply
Laura
Ok I like this box. I can handle the eleliner and the BECCA item. So this one I like. I just don’t want box 1. No way. I would love to have the triple lipstick from smashbox. But I like this box. But I will wait and see the other boxes have in them to. But this one I like.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.