Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I got:
1. Prep + Prime Coconut Mist 1 oz ($12)
2. Instacurl Lash Mascara ($24)
3. Retro Matte Liquid Lipcolour in Pearl Punk ($21)
4. Retro Matte Lipstick in Flat Out Fabulous ($18.50)
5. Matte Lipstick in Kinda Sexy ($18.50)
6. Lustre Lipstick in Touch ($18.50)
7. Eye Shadow in Aqua ($7)
RV $119.50. I’m very happy with everything but mascara (I’m going to swap it because I have very sensitive eyes). Otherwise, it was a perfect Mac mystery haul for me. I’d love to swap for more Prep + Prime Mist. Just click on my name. 😉
Reply
Jana
So many lip products! My favorite is the Amplified Lip Creme in Mmmmmm. The Pro Longwear Lip Pencil In Anticipation is also a nice shade. I also got Dazzleglass in Dressed to Dazzle, Matte In Kinda Sexy and Aim for Gorgeous and a Creme Sheen in Shy Girl. Also received the 30 mL Prep + Prime Fix Spray and a 6 mL Strobe Cream. I won’t need to buy lip products for years.
Reply
Michele
I got mine! I got an awesome makeup brush, three lipsticks (one in my favorite color), a lipglass, a pretty light base eye shadow (that I needed), and lavendar setting spray. About $140+ value. One of my lipsticks was green too but my teenage daughter and I have been playing around with it tonight and having lots of fun so it’s all good. I loved everything I got and I am excited to try it all out!
Reply
LM
I got mine today and loved it, but I love their lip products so that affected my response to it. I got four lipsticks in different formulas (one deep blackish color that I can wear when I have extra feelings, two nudes, and a sheer pink), a lipglass in a pale peachy pink, and a dazzleglass in a neutral color, as well as the lavender prep and prime. I’ll use them all.
Reply
Jana
So many lip products! Just what I didn’t need – but at least they are all colors I can wear. Got the 30 mL Fix + Prep + Prime Spray, 6 mL Strobe Cream, Pro Longwear Lip Pencil in “In Anticipation”, Dazzleglass Dressed to Dazzle, Creamsheen in Shy Girl, Amplified Creme in MMMMMM, and two Mattes – Kinda Sexy and Aim for Gorgeous. I will never have to buy lipstick again! I think the Amplified is a Rihanna Colaboration. All the shades are good for my light to medium skin tone and blond hair. Probably wouldn’t have purchased this if I knew it would be So lip heavy, but it will be fun to try these out.
Reply
Nika
There’s a decent variety here, color-wise.
I got:
– Prep + prime fix mini in lavender
– Brush #234
– Liptensity lipstick in Dionysus
– Matte lipstick in Kinda Sexy (pinkish nude)
– Matte lipstick in Lust Extract (real dark cobalt blue)
-Retro matte liquid lipcolor in Moon Landing (dark bold blue w. shimmer)
-Eyeshadow in Mythology (copper toasty shimmer)
All were full-size minus the prep+prime fix, so a great value overall. I don’t typically wear unusual lip colors but the blue intrigues me to try it and I wouldn’t have picked it myself (I tend to stick to “safe” colors). It’s a good opportunity to try something fun. And the eyeshadow and other lip colors I can easily add to my regular rotation as they are shades I would pick but don’t already have.
I can see how some would be turned off by the mystery part of this but I’m very happy with my box.
Reply
Melissa
Lipstick heavy (3 Matte & 1 Lustre) but 3 of the 4 are very wearable colors for me.
Matte in Mehr (Warm Mauve)
Matte in Instigator (Deep Blacked Plum) – Pretty but not for me
Matte in Modern Temptress (Warm Brown)
Lustre in Touch (Peachy Cinnamon) – My Favorite
Prep + Prime in Coconut (1 oz)
Eyeshadow in Yogurt Matte (Cool Pink)
Eyeshadow blending brush #234
Reply
Lindsay
….I got green lipstick. GREEN.
Full contents:
Retro matte in Meteochrome
Matte in Into the Madness (seriously y’all. Green).
Matte in Kinda Sexy
Liptensity in Dionysus
137H brush
Prep + Prime
Shadow in all that glitters Veluxe Pearl
Reply
Rugby
I got mine last night. I received 3 lipsticks, 1 liner, one makeup brush a fix spray and a cosmetic bag with 3 mini lip glasses. I would say a pretty good deal.
Reply
Jessy
This is still showing as available to me. I can add it to my cart am probably not going to since it’s lip product heavy.
Reply
jackie
I got the BB cream ($31),
234 eye shadow blending brush ($22.50)
a lip glass ($17.50), and 4 lipsticks ($18.50 each = $74). 3 of the 4 lipsticks are pretty wearable for me, one is too light. $145 RV
Reply
Marian
I didn’t look at spoilers and waited patiently for mine. I don’t own any from the brand so i figured i couldn’t be disappointed . I got four lippies,one that is white so that will help time down the colors I’m not so crazy about, even with other brands . I got a mascara,a brush and the prep and prime spray.im satisfied but hoped there was more variety like an eye pencil or blush. I may purchase again simply because these are the only items I have of them .
Reply
JustJese
I just got mine today and i’m super happy. I received:
Fix+ Rose spray (mini)- $12
Lipstick in Kinda Sexy (full size) – $18.50
Lipstick in Breathing Fire (full size) – $18.50
Amplified Creme Lipstick in Stylist’s Tip (full size) – $18.50
MAC 159 brush (full size) – $35
Lip Glass in New Galaxy – $17.5
Instacurl Lash Mascara – $24
The RV alone is $144 and I’ll get use out of just about everything in this box. From what I’ve discovered the brush, lip glass and the creme lipstick are the only items that have been discontinued
Reply
Jana
You got a great box! You scored!
Reply
Rugby
You got a lovely box
Reply
Julie
And an FYI for those who got the B.B. cream variation like me, even though it’s shade is Medium, I tried it on my light skin and it worked just fine. I really like it.
Reply
Sarah
Not a huge deal but it says 7 full size products and the Mac fix plus is not full size lol
Reply
Jackie
There was a disclaimer that some people might receive the little MAC (small) setting spray.
Reply
Binta
I got something similar. 5 lip products, 4 of which look terrible on my medium brown AA complexion, same green eye shadow, which also looks terrible on my skin tone, and the setting spray, which I already have a full size of. This was my first and last mystery box. Complete waste for me. Now I have to figure out who to give these to otherwise they’re going in the trash. Complete waste of my money.
Reply
Paula
$50 is too rich for my blood, especially for a mystery. I’d much rather go out and spend $50 at MAC on stuff I actually want. And then just fulfill my mystery bag needs and get the $18 Ofra Mystery bag!
Reply
Redhed36
Happy I did not jump on this. Possibly four lip items… I would have been peeved. LOL.
Reply
Renee
Ugh, variety in product would have been nice.
I won’t purchase again if I get 5 lipsticks.
Reply
Rugby
Im still waiting on mine. I hope there are lots of variations
Reply
Sneha
I got something different! I got four lipsticks, three of which I love, a contour brush, a dark brown matte eyeshadow and the rose setting spray!
Reply
Marissa
Liz will these be able to go on the swap site? Would love to swap for a nude or peach lippie If anyone is bummed about getting them
How long does it take to get off the swaps waiting list? I would love to participate!
shari
Once again my comment disappeared SIGH
Reply
Liz Cadman
Hi Shari,
Both your comments are showing up for me. Can you try refreshing the page and see if it shows up? Sorry!
Reply
shari
If you use Mac cosmetic’s this is not a bad buy 7 products works out to a little over 7 dollars a product. Yet, if you would not buy these colors it is kind of like just throwing money out the window. Glad I did not bite.
Reply
Michelle Bross
So glad I didn’t bite either! I was on the site credit card in hand!
Reply
Nikkim
I know their lippies are pricey. But 50 bucks!? Come on mac lol
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.