Facebook PixelRicky's NYC Cult Crushes Beauty Review - June 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Ricky’s NYC Cult Crushes Beauty Review – June 2018

Marne Orenich
ByMarne OrenichJun 15, 2018 | 42 comments

Rickys Cult Crushes box

Cult Crushes
3.4 overall rating
30 Ratings | 6 Reviews

Cult Crushes is a monthly subscription box from Ricky's NYC that gives you the chance to test their hottest brands and products – both classic and new – and learn how to optimize them through exclusive online tutorials lead by influencers they love.

Reviewed by popular demand!

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes). 

contents of Rickys Cult Crushes box

About Cult Crushes

The Box: Ricky’s NYC Cult Crushes

The Cost: $14.00 per month + free shipping

The Products: Each month, subscribers receive a themed selection of handpicked products in cosmetics, skincare, haircare, and fashion.

Ships to: US

Good to Know: The price just went up from $11.00 to $14.00 starting in June.

Ricky's NYC Cult Crushes June 2018 Review

info card list of items on info card

First, you'll see an info card that lists all of this month's Cult Crushes. This month's theme is "The Prep Steps".

gulsha ultimate rosewater ingredients for gulsha ultimate rosewater gulsha ultimate rosewater with cap off

Gülsha Ultimate Rosewater, 0.67 oz. - Estimated Retail Value $1.98 (buy 6.76 oz for $20.00)

I've gotten really into toners lately even though I've heard conflicting opinions on if it's really needed. It sounds like most modern products contain whatever toner was originally intended for back in the day, but a lot of women enjoy the ritual and feel of it and my facialist says it's a must. I happen to enjoy it so I was pleasantly surprised to find this in Cult Crushes this month. Although they call it a spray on the info card, this is just a bottle that is the kind you'd find essential oils in. I just shake it over a cotton ball to swipe over my face. It smells really nice and leaves a squeakiness begging to then be moisturized. I couldn't find this smaller size anywhere online so I estimated the value based on the larger one.

Murad clarifying cleanser back of Murad clarifying cleanser

Murad Acne Control Clarifying Cleanser, 1.5 oz. - Estimated Retail Value $6.75 (buy 2 oz for $9.00)

Even though I'm lucky to not have a problem with acne, I gave this clarifying cleanser a go. The clear gel smelled nice and had a tingling effect as I swirled it around my face. After rinsing my face felt insanely clean and fresh. More about the ingredients:

Encapsulated salicylic acid provides a sustained release of acne medication to allow for hours of acne treatment. Silver citrate provides antibacterial protection to inhibit blemish formation.

Since I don't need a high level of acne fighting ingredients, I'll pass this on to one of my girlfriends who is always looking for a solution to her breakouts.

iroha foil tissue eye patches back of iroha foil tissue eye patches

Iroha Nature Gold and Collagen Foil Tissue Eye Patches, one set - Retail Value $3.42 USD (€2.95)

I was excited when I first saw these because I wanted to put thin foil onto my face, but once I opened them I saw that the gold foil never actually touches my skin. It's on the back of essence soaked black cotton patches that you place under each eye. I left them on for about 15 minutes and they stayed put really well. My eyes did feel refreshed and hydrated and there was no irritation at all. It says that the gold foil technology "enhances the effect" of the collagen and other ingredients but who really knows. It does look luxe though! Haha.

hairfinity healthy hair vitamins back of hairfinity healthy hair vitamins bottle hairfinity healthy hair vitamins pouring out of bottle

Brock Beauty Hairfinity Supplements, 14 ct. - Estimated Retail Value $5.83 (buy a bottle of $60.00 for $24.99)

I find this to be a pretty unique item to receive in Ricky's since it's usually all makeup, but I don't mind at all because I will do anything to try and make my thin limp hair stronger and fuller. I know there are a lot of hair vitamins out there and am unsure if they really work, but I'm down to give these a go. This trial size bottle come with 14 capsules that is a week supply since you are supposed to take two a day. I'm on day two now and of course, there's no way I'm going to expect any results yet and who knows if I will even within a week. Like most hair vitamins, this one includes biotin but also has "exclusive capilsana complex that provides the hair with it’s naturally occurring building blocks through the strengthening amino acids in Hydrolyzed Collagen, sulfur-containing MSM for vitality, and hair-boosting horsetail with silica". I gasped for a second, but don't worry, horsetail is a plant! Ha. Only time will tell. 

avatara even out face mask back of avatara even out face mask

Avatara Even Out Face Mask - Retail Value $3.00

I used this first of two masks from Avatara included in hopes of evening out my slightly reddish skin in spots and reducing my pores. This hibiscus mask comes with the backing you have to peel off (which I personally don't find all that helpful) and it's loaded up with essence. I plastered it on my face for 10 minutes and once I took it off, I had a ton of extra product that I massaged in, but ultimately did towel off a bit of. Once left with a more manageable amount, I let it soak in. It felt a little sticky but eventually absorbed. While it didn't give me immediate results on my red patches, it felt nice and left my skin soft.

avatara shape up face mask back of avatara shape up face mask

Avatara Shape Up Face Mask - Retail Value $3.00 (found here for $2.05)

I'm going to save this one for a later date but the second included mask is called Shape Up and is made for more delicate skin. It includes energizing ingredients like orange and lemon extract with gingko, aloe, and licorice root to restore elasticity in your skin.

Suva Beauty shimmer eyeshadow in package Suva Beauty shimmer eyeshadow Suva Beauty shimmer eyeshadow swatch

Suva Beauty Shimmer Eyeshadow in Empire State - Retail Value $11.00

While I'm not crazy about getting pans of shadow, it's only because I don't have a magnetic palette. They seem to be really popular though so I'm sure this is a big win for those who can add it to theirs. This is a really lovely metallic shimmery rose color that is flattering and subtle on my pale skin but I can see it being a really fun pop of contrast on darker skin tones as well. This is a full-size pan that has 0.14 oz of product in it.

Verdict: Cult Crushes sent a collection of items I found to be pretty interesting and fun. I like getting a wide variety of products so the rosewater, hair vitamins, eyeshadow, and masks covered a lot of ground. Though it was a little mask-heavy I do like keeping them around as a light "self-care" or something to do when girlfriends are over just hanging out. Overall, I received 7 items that I estimate to have a value of about $34.98 while the cost of the box is $14.00. Many had to be estimated since the specific sizes weren't easily found online, so keep in mind that it's not exact.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No, but their subscriber list is now open so sign up now to get July!

Value Breakdown: At $14.00 for this box, here's what you're paying for each item:

  • Rosewater: $0.79
  • Cleanser: $2.70
  • Eye Masks: $1.37
  • Hair Vitamins: $2.33
  • Even Out Face Mask: $1.20
  • Shape Up Face Mask: $1.20
  • Eyeshadow: $4.40

Check out all of our Ricky's NYC Cult Crushes reviews and more beauty reviews via our Beauty Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What did you think of this month's Cult Crushes?

Starting at $11.00
Subscribe Now
Ricky’s Cult Crushes subscription box gives you the chance to test our hottest brands and products – both classic and new – and learn how to optimize them through exclusive online tutorials lead by influences we love.
Marne Orenich
Marne Orenich
Marne is a lipstick connoisseur, record collector, and twice over cat mom. She loves discovering new clean beauty brands and has quite the collection of beautifully packaged serums and moisturizers.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

42 comments

Deon

I’m just depressed! This is my first month. I tried to cancel the minute I ordered, but my messsges were ignored.

Reply ButtonReply

Barbara

I just received my June box and was NOT impressed…and it is now $14? Heck, Ricky’s is now in competition with Allure and the like and quite frankly, doesn’t have the product lineup that seems to warrant such a hike.

I canceled…

Reply ButtonReply

Tiffany

I just joined and I feel the same way. I had canceled my Birchbox to try this one out because of all the hype! I’m giving it one more month and if it’s not any better I’ll cancel. Oh, and their shipping isn’t very great either, hopefully that’s not an ongoing thing and just with my first box.

I’m also signed up with Ipsy, Play by Sephora, and a new one called Boxycharm. I’m an HUGE fan of Ipsy! You should definitely try them out, I think you’ll be happy with them.

Reply ButtonReply

Vicky H

They posted a July spoiler. LA Splash lippie.

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

Thanks so much for the heads up! Can you let us know where they posted it? I’m not having any luck finding it on Instagram or Facebook. Thanks!

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle

They have July to wow me again or I am canceling. Raise the price then send a sub par box? Not good. I had to throw the toner away I couldn’t deal with the smell. Swapped the masks just this morning. Last time I tried a “gold” mask the mess was not worth it and I don’t put random pills unsolicited from the mail, in my body.

Reply ButtonReply

Jen

The two masks EXPIRED IN 2009 and 2004. I just canceled that’s my breaking point

Reply ButtonReply

Cris

Why doesn’t this seem to bother many ppl? I’m so confused….? WAITED X3 MOS TO GET ON SUNSCRIBTION*BA..HA.HA. HA.HA
NO 25% APPLIED
DAMAGED PRODUCT AND IT SMOTHERED OVER EVERYTHING *
2 EXPIRED MASK
1 OIL/SERUM SMELLS NOTHING LIKE ORIGINAL PRODUCT!
FAILED X3 CALLS TO CUSTOMER SERVICE
2 FAILED EMAILS HOW DOES ONE GET A ISSUE HANDLED?
😟🚫😖😜🤔😕

Reply ButtonReply

Barbara

Jen: I hadn’t noticed the expiration date….THANK YOU for bringing it to my attention. Even more of a reason justifying my cancellation this month. That is positively disgraceful, especially after that price hike!

Reply ButtonReply

JessicaG

No they didn’t. These particular products didn’t even exist until 2016. The EXP dates on the masks are in the YY/MM/DD format.
My Shape Up mask reads EXP191116. (19/11/16=Nov. 16, 2019).
My Even Out mask reads EXP200928. (20/09/28=Sept. 28, 2020).
You should research/double check things before making an accusation like this.

Reply ButtonReply

JuJu

Yep. Especially one this magnitude of unlikely.

Emmy

Jen might be right. I’m not sure how to read the expiration dates, but one of my masks shows the expiration as EXP200928 and the other reads EXP200410. And sheet masks have been around a few decades at least, but they have become incredibly popular in the past few years, thus why so many companies are producing them.

Reply ButtonReply

JuJu

I am sure that means year 2020 September 28th and April 10th, respectively.

JuJu

I am not defending this month’s poor curation, but still, I really doubt that.
I don’t think sheet masks were even a thing back then.

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa

I paused for next month and ordered mystery bag from Ofra with code summer40 it is only $15 and suppose to have $107 worth of products. Although with my luck it will probably be skin heavy too!!! Lol.

Reply ButtonReply

Beccah

Oh thank you. I got one too!

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa

Yay!! At least we will get moneys worth!!

JessicaG

Did anyone else get charged already for next month? I just got my June box a few days ago and then the very next day, I have a $14 charge from Ricky’s on my account. Just wanted to ask other subbers before contacting them. Thank you!
PS: This box was just kind of blah for me. If next month isn’t better, then I’m sad to say I’ll be cancelling.

Reply ButtonReply

Sandi

yep I wanted to CANCELL but dammit they beat me to it…. If we’re gonna cancell we gotta watch spoilers for Aug!! I think there running out of product or not enough people to help get boxes out… There is something up… Sketchy… Yanoe?? I subscribed cause of past boxes they had bomb ass stuff pallets, name brands I knew.. Good stuff not this crap there dealing out now…. Yes they beat me to the bank… But not next time….. Keep eyes wide open for Spoilers (I never hardly see any!! U?? )

Reply ButtonReply

JessicaG

No, I don’t see any until AFTER my box usually. I’m kinda salty about this charge, I don’t know why it came so early. The account I use for online stuff only keeps what I need in it, since I wasn’t expecting a charge, there was only a few dollars; hello overdraft fee of $34. So basically, July’s box better be DAMN good because it cost me $48…

JuJu

Gah, so they raised the price while lowering the value.

Glad I unsubscribed.

Reply ButtonReply

Melissa W.

So happy I cancelled.. for a $14 box, this doesn’t even come close to the Allure box. The value isn’t there for me.

Reply ButtonReply

justmissjamey

This is my second month. While I really e joyed last month, this one is kinda meh for me. I’m going to give it another couple months and see how it hoes as well. At least it wasn’t cheap plastic press on nails no one wears anymore.

Reply ButtonReply

JSo

Of all the reviews I’ve seen that rose gold shadow is the one I want. Fingers crossed.

Overall it’s a nice box. It just doesn’t measure up to say allure. Plus it doesn’t have the edge I thought cult crushes had

But I’m not going to be mad. 7 items for $14. I’ll stick it out another month.

Reply ButtonReply

Dea

This was a great box. Everything is usable and will be used up. I like the variety and trying out brands that are new to me. These were all brands that I had never tried before. I like that Ricky’s is different from ipsy and Allure. I love it.

Reply ButtonReply

Z

You kinda sound like a spokesperson for Ricky’s tho lol. I don’t mind this box, but doesn’t really compare value wise to allure or boxy. It’s better than Ipsy probably yes. But I don’t think it’s better than allure or boxy. Samples in rickys are just way too small

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa

Ipsy is definitely better than this box!! And Ipsy only charges $10 for stuff like this not $14. If they are going to charge $14 they need to send full size toner and vitamins at least.

Michelle Bross

Man I cancelled after last month but I really want that Murad 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

lisa

This month made me so angry I immediately paused my sub but I will probably cancel. It is not even the fact they sent skin care which I am not a fan of using. But there was no reason to send samples. They are in same price bracket as Allure and Allure sent out full size items that retailed for $25 and $20 so we should have received full size toner and full size bottle of vitamins at least. This looks like a $10 sub box. I was not a fan of May either but at least May was only $11 and had decent size stuff . For $14 you need to have most of the box be full size or expect to lose subscribers.

Reply ButtonReply

JuJu

Agreed. If a toner (not that I would use something fragranced, but just making a point) is $20 for a big bottle, why on earth would you send a sample 1/10th of the size.

Reply ButtonReply

bmcd3713

This will be my second month with Ricky;s and to tell you the truth, I’m not sure I will continue. I suppose I will wait until next month just to take a look at what they are planning ahead with this price increase. At this point, my faves are Boxycharm and Allure (shh, getting 3 boxes a month), so for me to pay out more $$$ for something like this? Well…not gonna happen. We will see…

Reply ButtonReply

Cynm

I finally cancelled at $11 it was a fun novelty but at $14 I can easily spend the money elsewhere on items I will actually use. It also left a bad taste in my mouth that they did not grandfather in old members like lots of sub boxes.

Reply ButtonReply

LA

I do like Ricky’s because they send some out of the ordinary stuff, but Nylon Box was $1 more and they sent more premium product (RIP Nylon Box, I am still in mourning). Ricky’s often sends similar items such as fake eyelashes a few months in a row which is strange to me. I am not sure if I should keep Ricky’s either… I want to, but Allure has been sending great boxes lately too. Do I cancel both and go back to BeautyFix? I do prefer higher end acids and skincare. Decisions. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Mallory

I’m still mourning the Nylon box too!!! I loved that subscription box and was basically my gateway into my addiction of sub boxes lol (I was only getting the sanrio box before, but that was because I’ve loved sanrio since I was little lol). I keep hoping that they realize there’s many people missing them and that by some miracle they bring it back! Although I don’t really need to spend anymore than I already on boxes hehehe 😉

Reply ButtonReply

Beccah

For the year I was subscribed the value of the boxes was around $100, sometimes more. Needless to say I am happy i unsubbed. It definitely is not worth $15 a month anymore.

Reply ButtonReply

JuJu

Yeah, the value of this particular box was never $100. But it was still a good beauty box some months.

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa

I think they were talking about Beauty fix being worth over $100 in past.

Aarjullor

MSA has been reviewing this box since 9/17. 7 of the boxes reviewed had a retail value at around $50. There was 1 that was more ($75) and 1 that was less ($35). Was it worth more before 9/17? If so, I’m sorry I missed it! I like most of the items Ricky’s has sent, but still canceled. I’m drowning in product!

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle

This box was the worst, for me so far. If you step up your price you best be stepping up the box. This was a bunch of cheap junk. They are on the chopping block next month.

That toner smells really bad, too much rose and I know that is the fragrance but it’s too much. I tossed it this morning after 2 uses, I can’t do it. The only thing that I kept is the Murad, the rest minus the toner went on swaps.

Reply ButtonReply

Emma

I quite agree. This is not a good box. I started my subscription last month, but I’ll give it a three-month run before deciding to continue or not. I’m an older adult so I can’t even use the acne cleanser, and Zi’m so tired of cloth face masks that have little impact.

Reply ButtonReply