Facebook PixelRobb Vices Subscription Box Review - May 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Robb Vices “Classic Vices” Subscription Box Review – May 2018

Anna Reilly
ByAnna ReillyMay 29, 2018 | 15 comments

robb vices may 2018 box

3.2 overall rating
53 Ratings | 11 Reviews

Robb Vices is “a membership program centered on a monthly delivery of storied treasures.” Each month, they send a collection of curated products and/or experiences.

Subscribers should expect boxes to include “vices” like “exceptional wines and spirits to enjoy, foods to taste, tools, toys, accessories, and gadgets.”

robb vices may 2018 unboxing

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

robb vices may 2018 all items

About Robb Vices Subscription Box

The Subscription Box: Robb Vices

The Cost: $99.95 + shipping (For reference, shipping to PA is $7.95.) Save with longer subscriptions.

The Products: Each box contains a curated selection of products and experiences and provides subscribers with a taste of the good life!

Ships to: Robb Vices ships to all states except ND, UT.

Robb Vices "Classic Vices" May 2018 Review

robb vices may 2018 martini splash

robb vices may 2018 editor notes

robb vices may 2018 intro to box

One thing I like about this subscription is that it always comes with a very thorough booklet of information about its curation, the featured brands/artisans, and how to use the products themselves.

robb vices may 2018 brand feature

robb vices may 2018 page in mini magazine

robb vices may 2018 dirty sue sauce article

robb vices may 2018 cigar humidor info

robb vices may 2018 article in booklet

robb vices may 2018 essay in mini magazine

robb vices may 2018 brands featured

This month, the subscription is turning back to its roots with "classic vices" that feel as refined as they are indulgent. The mini magazine highlights each brand in the box with lush photos and thoughtful essays on what makes them unique.

robb vices may 2018 bbq info

robb vices may 2018 discount card

One of the featured brands in the booklet is New York Prime Beef, though there's no actual product from them in the box. There is, however, a coupon for 25% off their meats. I eat a mostly vegetarian diet, but I know a few folks who would get some good use out of this coupon!

robb vices may 2018 alcohol bottle

robb vices may 2018 fancy alcohol decanter

robb vices may 2018 clip on top of alcohol bottle

robb vices may 2018 cork in alcohol bottle

Glass Vodka, 750 ml 

This unique vodka is made from grapes from Washington state. It's naturally filtered and arrives inside this distinctive glass bottle! I couldn't find a reliable price for it online, as it looks like something that's only available locally in Seattle. I'm not an expert in vodkas, but I can attest to its smooth finish and that it has an intriguing note of something sweetly floral.

robb vices may 2018 knife box

robb vices may 2018 knife set box

robb vices may 2018 knives in box

robb vices may 2018 knives in wooden box

robb vices may 2018 silver knives

robb vices may 2018 nice knife blades

Zwilling 8-Piece Steak Knife Set and Presentation Box - Retail Value $79.99

I don't think I've ever owned a nice set of really good steak knives (though I don't really have the occasion to use them very often, haha). These will be handy if I have guests over and serve up meat for them, though. Or, because these high-quality German-made knives are packaged so nicely, they'd also make a snazzy hostess or housewarming gift for a gourmand in my life.

robb vices may 2018 cigar three pack

robb vices may 2018 cigar set

robb vices may 2018 three cigars

robb vices may 2018 ends of cigars

3 Carillo Cigars (Natural, Oscuro, and Core Plus) 

Something about cigars feels inherently Robb Vices, haha. It's just so luxurious! These cigars come from Carillo, which is a famed brand of Dominican cigars. I'm less well-versed in cigars than I am vodka, but I can say that each of these cigars smells rich and earthy. I picked up a slight fruitiness from the "Natural" one that I found the most intriguing. The other two are denser and more reminiscent of coffee or very dark chocolate in my opinion.

robb vices may 2018 cigar packet

Boveda 2-Way Humidity Control 69% Pack - Buy 10, 8 Gram Packs for $12.99 here

One of these little packets was included with the three pack of cigars to regulate their humidity. These packets use a patented film that regulates humidity with zero maintenance or activation required. I thought it was interesting that they offer packets for a bunch of different products, from cigars to musical instruments!

robb vices may 2018 humidor bag kit

robb vices may 2018 humidor bag for cigars

robb vices may 2018 bag for cigars

Boveda Small Humidor Bag - Retail Value $5.99

This little bag works like a mini humidor. It's technically a "high-barrier laminated cigar storage bag" according to the website, and it comes pre-loaded with a 69% Boveda packet. Apparently, this bag can keep your cigars in solid shape for up to a year. Not bad!

robb vices may 2018 dirty sue sauce

robb vices may 2018 dirty sue sauce label

Dirty Sue Premium Olive Juice, 375 ml - Retail Value $8.99

UPDATE: I was so excited to get this review up that I forgot to mention the olive juice! This bottle of premium olive juice is made in California and ready for your next dirty martini. I have to say, I am NOT a dirty martini fan, as olive juice is just a bit too briny for my taste. So this ingredient? Eh, not the most exciting thing for me to see in a box. But I do think it makes perfect sense that they'd include it to complement to the vodka!

Verdict: I feel like when I first heard about Robb Vices, this was exactly the kind of stuff I pictured. Unique alcohol, fancy cigars... it's upscale and very vice-y! I will say that it's hard for me to speak to the quality of these items for that very reason—I don't frequently indulge in vices like these, so I can't speak very well to how the cigars stack up to other types or brands, but I can say that I feel super fancy with all of these treats in my kitchen. Even the knives, which were one of the few products I could find a reliable online price for, seem to be super high-quality. The three items for which I could find individual prices for added up to $94.97, which is about 84% of the cost of the box. That value doesn't include the bottle of vodka, nor the cigars, so I feel like there's a good chance that the box is worth at least it's cost (though I can't say for certain).

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No. Sign up by the 1st of the month to receive that month's box.

Value Breakdown: This box cost $112.90 (cost + shipping to us in PA). The three products that I found individual retail values for totaled $94.97, meaning the remaining items (the humidor packet, the three cigars, and the vodka) must have a retail value of at least $17.93 to make up the remaining cost of the box. Another way to look at it is that going by the cost of the box, each item has an average value of $18.82.

Check out all of our Robb Vices Reviews and find other specialty boxes in the Artisan Subscription Box Directory!

Keep track of your subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription box list or wishlist!

What do you think of the May 2018 box from Robb Vices?

Starting at $129.95
Active Deal
Save $50 off your first subscription (LUXURY50) or receive a FREE Altec Lansing ALT-500 Bluetooth Turntable valued at $149 (TURNTABLE.)
Use Coupon Code LUXURY50 or TURNTABLE
Subscribe Now
The Vices membership program delivers high-end items specially curated by luxury tastemakers and delivered to your doorstep. Boxes will include wines or spirits, gadgets and accessories with a booklet describing the story behind why each item was chosen for the box.
Anna Reilly
Anna Reilly
Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she's swooning for all things kawaii!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



We’ve gotten that brand of vodka before, just for the cool bottle! I didn’t realize they were local–we found it at Total Wine though.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


For those that got the cigars, if you’re not going to light it soon, don’t take it out of the wrapper. Better yet, put them inside the humidor bag to maintain the freshness. If you going to swap that, place them inside the humidor bag. Best if you have humidor box itself. If keep properly, they should last months.

I have the same set of steak knife (not from this box), all I can say is that use it!!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Great box but happy I skipped! No one I know drinks vodka or smoked cigars and we just got a new knife set and that’s less than the cost of the box anyway. Great box just not for me, yay! Money saved for now lol. Next month hear I come

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Henckels knives are fantastic! Definitely top tier at least among popular knife brand. Those are gorgeous!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Almost screwed up to the tune of $110 or so. lol I went to order the box thinking I would get this one BUT I got distracted and left the window open. I want the knives, and the vodka would be an absolutely awesome gift for a friend of mine who is a bit of a vodka snob. hehe

I’m on swaps so if anyone wants to do a swap or box split let me know. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Interested in the Cigars if you still have them!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Did you forget the olive juice?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Anna Reilly

I totally did, Lawden! Can you tell that I’m not a big fan of dirty martinis? Haha! I took that olive juice bottle out of the box, set it aside, and totally forgot about it as I focused on the other items! My bad. All is updated – thank you for noticing 🙂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


This is absolutely the best luxury subscription. It offers a lot of exclusive and rare finds. It is such a unique experience.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I definitely think this is what Robb Vices should be about. A good drink and a good smoke.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I definitely liked this box. It’s th e first one I have really enjoyed receiving in a while. And I definitely think the value was there. The vodka retails for about $50, the 3 cigars would sell for about $25-$30 if bought individually, and the olive juice is about $9. So that brings the total value of the box to about $175. Plus the 25% off coupon to boot. And it’s hard to argue that at least the knives and vodka don’t have pretty wide appeal.

All in all, I give this box an A.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Keri S.

I didn’t even notice the olive juice. Good eye! 😉

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Anna Reilly

Olive juice is in there now! Thanks for the heads up 🙂

Like This CommentLike


I was very happy with this box and I don’t even smoke cigars, but I had no problem gifting them to my cousin. She will smoke them every once in a while. This definitely feels like what Robb Vices was originally about. The vodka is so good and I will be trying the knives out soon.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Anna Reilly

Gifting the cigars is a great idea, Adele! Especially over the summer wedding season, I bet they’d be a fun little gift for a bride or groom before the big day! The fact that they provide a humidor bag to keep them in helps, too – they should stay fresh for awhile, so you can pull them out whenever the right occasion strikes 🙂 Thanks for sharing your take!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike