Collections by Joya Subscription Review – May 2018

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Collections by Joya May 2018 Box

Collections by Joya is a monthly jewelry and accessories subscription box for women. All items offered are 100% handmade by expert female artisans around the world. Proceeds from every purchase are donated to a women’s charity.

Collections by Joya May 2018 Unpacking

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

Collections by Joya May 2018 Unboxing

About Collections by Joya

The Subscription Box: Collections by Joya

The Cost: $49.95 a month + free US shipping. Save with quarterly and annual subscriptions.

The Products: jewelry and accessories, handmade by women from around the world.

Ships to: US for free, Canada for $14.95, and International for $21.95

Collections by Joya May 2018 Review

Collections by Joya May 2018 Card

Collections by Joya May 2018 Thank You

Welcome to my favorite time of the month: the time when my Joya box arrives and I literally run into my house to open it! Lately, Joya has been including this little “thank you” card with some info about where to find them online. It’s a nice little intro to the box.

Collections by Joya May 2018 Canvas Pouch

Just like the last two months, my jewelry came in this canvas pouch. I appreciate this both because it’s an extra layer of protection in the mail and because pouches like this are great for packing jewelry when traveling or gift-giving.

Collections by Joya May 2018 Jewelry

This month’s pouch was filled with three items: a necklace, a bracelet, and a pair of earrings that I had been coveting ever since I first spotted them on the Collections by Joya website! *cue happy dance*

Collections by Joya May 2018 Tassel Necklace Collections by Joya May 2018 Tasseled Necklace

Collections by Joya May 2018 Mini Tassel Necklace

Collections by Joya May 2018 Boho Necklace

Mini Tassel Necklace — Retail Value $48.95

I think Joya does tasseled jewelry oh-so-tastefully, and I’m just smitten over this long tasseled necklace. It came in this navy blue color that I don’t see on their site anymore, which offers a beautiful contrast to the golden chain and beads. I was wearing a black dress on the day my box arrived, and I liked how the dark blue fringe looked against it—a different enough shade to not get lost, but a close enough one to not interfere with the embroidery along the neckline.

Collections by Joya May 2018 Hoop Earrings

Collections by Joya May 2018 Ayla Earrings

Collections by Joya May 2018 Earrings

Ayla Earrings — Retail Value $58.95

Eeeep, here they are! The earrings I’ve been gawking over for months! I adore their ease and simplicity, and I love that they’re hammered brass. if you like the shape of these earrings but aren’t a fan of the hammered look, you’re in luck—only one side of each disc is hammered, so you could probably wear them in a way that sort of hides that textured detail. I, of course, put this pair on immediately and wore them that day…and then again the next day! About halfway through the 2nd day of wear, I was standing on my back patio drinking a glass of water when one of the earrings randomly fell out of my ear and onto the ground. For the first time ever in my experience with Joya jewelry, it seemed like a quality issue because I seriously wasn’t moving! It was easy enough to attach the curved post back to the crescent without misshaping the wire too much, but I’m worried that if it happens again under different circumstances, I might lose the earring. Fingers crossed it was just a fluke.

Collections by Joya May 2018 Jewelry on Model

Here are both pieces worn together. I think they go perfectly with the dress I was wearing that day, as is often the case with Joya items!

Collections by Joya May 2018 Silver and Gold Bracelet

Collections by Joya May 2018 Cuff Bracelet

Collections by Joya May 2018 Bracelet

Silver & Gold Cuff — Estimated Value $70 (similar styles found here and here)

The third piece in my box this month is a stacked cuff bracelet. Again I love the hammering, and I’m also digging that it mixes silver and gold tones. If you hadn’t gathered from how casually I mixed black and navy in my outfit above, I am so not beholden to the “fashion rules” that caution against mixing similar tones. That sounds made up to me! I think everyone should just wear what they want! As beautiful as I find this bracelet to me, I have a hard time with cuffs and bangles because I have a relatively small wrist. I have a few in my collection, but I rarely reach for them because they just flop on my arm all day and drive me nuts. So, I’ll probably take advantage of this month’s gift wrap and pass this lovely piece along to a friend!

I was unable to find this exact bracelet on the Joya website but in my opinion it sort of falls in between the Cosmic Cuff ($98) and the Bayou Bracelet ($28.95) in that it’s a little less fancy than the Cosmic Cuff but a little more dressy than the Bayou Bracelet. I used these two styles as guides to help me come up with an estimated value of the cuff I received, which I named “Silver & Gold Cuff” as a placeholder.

Collections by Joya May 2018 Gift Wrap

I referenced this gift wrap above—it comes in almost every month’s box! It’s a cardstock squeezebox that arrives with a pretty piece of raffia ribbon. I always save a little bit of the sizzle from inside the shipping box to pad whatever I might put in this gift box—in this case, the cuff bracelet.

Verdict: Those who have been following along on my Collections by Joya reviews know that I’ve only ever had exceedingly positive experiences with this box. It’s given me the opportunity to mature my jewelry collection, parting ways with cheap pieces of costume jewelry that are no longer cutting it. This is the first month ever that I’ve had even the slightest issue with quality, but like I said above, I think it might have been a one-off issue with the earring. I’m still very happy with what I received and can’t wait to incorporate these pieces into endless outfits! This box costs $49.95, including shipping. The two items that I know the price of added up to $107.90, which is a stellar value on its own, but add in the estimated $70 cuff bracelet and this month’s box is a through-the-roof good deal!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No. Order by 6/8 to get the June box!

Value Breakdown: At $49.95 for this box, you’re paying approximately $16.65 per item. For such high-quality accessories with beautiful detailing, that’s a marvelous deal.

Check out all of our Collections by Joya reviews and more handmade jewelry and fair trade boxes and jewelry subscription boxes in the Women’s Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What did you receive in your May Collections by Joya box?

Written by Christen Russo

Christen Russo

Christen stepped into the world of subscription boxes by signing up for Graze. After her world was changed (for the better, obviously) by a steady delivery of amazing snacks, she realized she needed to expand her horizons to include deliveries of eco-friendly products, clothes, and beyond.

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

Posted in Australian Subscription Box Reviews, Canadian Subscription Box Reviews, Collections by Joya Reviews, Jewelry Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women, UK Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: collections by joya | 8 comments


  1. I have bought a very similar bracelet through stitch fix. with the exception that mine was entirely silver It looks exactly the same. I loved that bracelet … until it tarnished and started turning black and losing its silver coating after just a few times of wearing it. It made me sad that it turned out to be so poorly made.

    • Oh, that’s such a bummer. I think usually Joya accessories are brass, sometimes with a true gold overlay. If you need a replacement, they might have a similar one on their site that you like! 🙂

  2. Where did you get that macrame plant hanger in the background of your photo? I’ve been on the hunt for one that has some color and of different fabrics. I’m hoping globe in will sell the one they put in this month’s box individually in their shop, but I haven’t seen it yet.

    • I made it! I just used tri-colored yarn and braided strands of it together with hemp. I strung a few wooden beads on the strands and then used super-thin hemp to tie it off under where the pot goes (but you could also just knot it). It was really easy and cheap to make!

  3. OMG. BEAUTIFUL. I have been looking to buy a version of the bracelet and earrings. I was planning to sub to this after I moved, starting in June. Augh. I could kick myself for not having started this month!!

    • Oh darn it! I know that feeling. I hope you end up with it or something similar down the line!!

  4. Those are such beautiful pieces.

    • Aren’t they, though? Always with Joya! It kills me!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!