Facebook PixelBoxyCharm May 2018 Two Confirmed Spoilers! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm May 2018 Two Confirmed Spoilers!

MSA
ByMSAApr 16, 2018 | 158 comments

Boxy-charm-march-2017-0002

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We have two spoilers for the May 2018 Boxycharm thanks to Yosef!

The May box will include:

Source: Instagram

In case you missed the previous brand spoiler:

All subscribers will receive full-size items from ALL of these brands in May:

What do you think of the brands?

If you sign up now, the April box will be your first box - the waitlist is temporarily lifted!

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

158 comments

Lauren

Upset that we won’t be getting the Pretty Vulgar Mascara 🙁 I LOVE their packaging the floral print is so beautiful I didn’t get to try the pretty vulgar lipgloss that was in one of the previous boxes either. The gel liner looks nice though..:

Reply ButtonReply

Bobbie

Glad to see this, that means items from those brands are still coming. Hope it’s something good!

Reply ButtonReply

Kelley

Oooh! Is the bottle of whiskey included?

Reply ButtonReply

Angelica

Ditto. I’ve enjoyed the sub for a few months but it’s time to unsubscribe. The eyeshadows in last and this month’s box are very poor quality, I gave them to my niece to play. Also, I never want to see another poop colored lipstick as long as I live lol.

Reply ButtonReply

Heidi

Yaaaasssss! I know we’d be getting that pretty vulgar inkwell liner! I called that last month on one of their many posts after seeing a couple videos with Gaby using it!

Reply ButtonReply

RR

I thought we were getting jack daniels – ha i was excited but so far not thrilled at what i’m getting in the boxes. too many eye shadows and not sure what that eyeliner is but looks messy. i think i want a subscription box that has more skincare.

Reply ButtonReply

Bobbie

Same! I’m giving it another month and then I may unsubscribe. I’m not into glittery bright eyeshadow colors. Not excited about the eyeliner either for May either. I just subscribed to beautyfix. It’s mostly skincare. Their April box looks really great to me and I got a tracking notification the same day I subscribed.

Reply ButtonReply

Em

You should look into glossy box, birch box, or new beauty test tube if you want more skincare. I’ve also heard beauty fix is good for skincare, too.

And this month doesn’t look as exciting but April was. I have FOMO (fear of missing out) so I won’t be unsuscribing.

Reply ButtonReply

Redhed36

Definitely look into Beautyfix. Mostly skincare.

Nyesha

More brushes tho?

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

Gel liner is not something I’ve gotten in my box before so this is great. Those look like the Aesthetica brushes that were teased. I hope this doesnt end up as a you get either eyeliner or brushes.

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle

That Dr Brandt Stinks!! I had to wipe it off immediately and am swapping the one from my 2nd box.

Reply ButtonReply

Rhenn

I would really like to know how they decide who gets what boxes. Cause I have consistently had the lowest or second lowest value box every month since I started with this sub. I really love boxycharm, but I would really like to get the good variation once in a while, yaknow?

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

Those look like they might be those Aestetica brushes that were a possible spoiler not long ago.

Reply ButtonReply

Mommy

Anyone else try the Dr. Brandt mask and it was mostly air? For 47$, I will never buy that. Ridiculous ☹

Reply ButtonReply

Becca S

Mine seemed like it was mostly air too. It seemed like it was because it was such a small amount, and they don’t want people to know how small 1 oz is. The product worked well though!

Reply ButtonReply

KNichole

Yepp, but luckily you didn’t have to pay $47 for it. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Em

I agree! In a $21 box it’s okay. But for $47 you should get at least 3 oz! Not 1.

Reply ButtonReply

CJS

I don’t think that is meant to be a ‘full-face’ mask…just for ‘areas of concern’ 2-3 times a week. Regardless, I agree it is a very pricey product at $47. I think I saw it on overstock sites for about $26-$29.

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

Mine is about 3/4 full and the stuff reminds me of toothpaste.

Reply ButtonReply

Tracey

Its standard in the cosmetics industries that things are priced by weight. And that some packaging of certain products tends to be much larger than the volume of product to allow for expansion during shipping.

Reply ButtonReply

Lauren

I’m so excited for this box!! May is my bday month, and just hearing about the brands and seeing this sneak peak gets me so excited

Reply ButtonReply

Suzy Q

May Baby here too! Cinco De Mayo <3 <3

Reply ButtonReply

Krista

May is my bday month too! The 22nd! When is yours?

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

You have the same birthday as my middle son.

charlottewinkler

Mine is also May 22! Happy Early Birthday!

Tanya

Happy Birthday!!!!

Reply ButtonReply

justmissjamey

Yaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyy. Yaaaaaaayyyyyyy and MORE yaaaaayyyy from me!!!

I’ve never tried a gel eyeliner and have always wanted too!!! Read up on a few reviews and people saying the were dried out after 2 uses etc. And I don’t have brushes that would work, so this is exciting for me.

Kinda bummed I didn’t get the Mac lipstick and the one that was supposed to be in my box was missing, so it was a bummer.

Reply ButtonReply

Crystal

I’m hooked on gel liner. My favorite brush to use is angled liner brush. I’ve been rotating between using the brow gal brush boxy sent out a while back and my tried and true 99 cent wet and wild angled brush.
Using the right tool will make all the difference. Personally, I’m no good with the kind of brush it looks like boxy is sending this month so if you struggle with that one then I highly recommend the wet and wild one!

Reply ButtonReply

RoguesEn3D

Please don’t tease me with that liner pot and then not give it to me. I hope that goes in every box. I am tired of liquid liner pens that run out while trying to apply liner. With a pot, I’d know when I’m coming to the end.

Reply ButtonReply

Em

Yosef said every charmer was getting pretty vulgar so I don’t think it’s a variant.

I actually like when there’s a lot of variations because I love being surprised.

I can’t stop myself from looking at spoilers but I don’t want to know what’s in my box. It’s best if you’re surprised.

One of these months I will not look at spoilers. It’s not going to be soon.

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

Amen and great logic!

T.Marie

Well crap! I was about to cancel this sub. Now I can’t. Not with Pretty Vulgar and Cover FX!

Reply ButtonReply

Anya

I’m really hoping that those UGLY brushes are a variant, so I dont get them….

Reply ButtonReply

sam

everyone is getting a product from Pur, Pretty Vulgar, and Cover FX and sadly that brush set is by Cover FX so everyone will be getting that brush set

Reply ButtonReply

misfitmorgan

I believe you are incorrect. Cover Fx has never made a set like that but it looks like an exact match for Aesthetica. That brand was mentioned as a future possible spoiler here
https://www.mysubscriptionaddiction.com/2018/03/boxycharm-2018-future-box-possible-spoiler.html

Laura

Too funny – I was actually pleased to see a black set of brushes 😁 I need more brushes and I’m not into pink or white ones.

Reply ButtonReply

Kathryn

Just got my April box and I am IN LOVE, 😍 Boxy is the best value – I don’t know how they do it. But I digress …….. people!!!! I know it is your right to complain but seriously we pay $21/mo! And we get all these fab products and so what if you don’t love everything or have 843 eyeliners – if you are annoyed just cancel! As for me – I will continue to love it! Month after fabulous month!

Reply ButtonReply

Susan Marie Ferry

Completely agree too!!! The only thing I would like to know is if they are ever going to use info we all fill out in the beauty profile… I have been a subscriber for about 8 months maybe more. The variant products I get are always the cheapest offered and wrong for my skin tone. I’m not complaining. I think Boxycharm is fabulous and the deals are truly awesome. I just wonder how they determine whom gets what.

Reply ButtonReply

Lexana

Truth! I have never had a month where I only liked one product, but if I did, the $21 usually covers one product, the rest is free!

Reply ButtonReply

Tanya

I am thrilled… my box finally got here and Golden state of mind….. works for work and can still work a smokey eye… dark brown brow gal.. can use … love the liquid tarte… wow.. can use the lip gloss as a tone down day lip… I will need to use a lip brush as that youtuber was right about the brush…. and while dr. brandt tube feels a tad empty… I have used on my tzone with success before.. so I can’t believe no giveaways for my friends this month. Mine all mine… Very happy…. got my $21 worth and then some…

Reply ButtonReply

JessicaG

I agree!

Reply ButtonReply

Mindy

I couldn’t agree more!!

Reply ButtonReply

Ashleyspllife

Yes! So much yes!!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Pink5

I signed up for Boxycharm a few days ago, after kicking Ipsy to the curb.

Not sure what box I’ll get,but I’m looking forward to it.

Reply ButtonReply

Em

If you signed up in April, you’ll get the April box. Hope this helps!

Also, right now I’m subscribed to Ipsy (I have been for over a year) and Boxycharm (recently). Ipsy has been awful lately. For awhile they were on fire. In December, I got a full sized OFRA, SL miss glam brush, full size Pixi duo, decent sized Smashbox liner, and two masks from purlisse! But this month, a nail polish and a lip gloss ( which I have never had on my beauty profile as things I want), a tiny body scrub, a mascara (I’m okay with that), and an eye cream.

It’s not really that they don’t follow the profiles, it’s that they don’t have good options to give anyone.

If it’s not good next month, I’m probably unsubscribing.

Reply ButtonReply

Abbey

If you signed up in April, you should be getting the April box! If they charge you in April, you’ll definitely get that box! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Joy

The packaging is killer. I don’t use black eyeliner but that is a gorgeous pot!

Fingers crossed they send it out in brown. I would be stoked

Reply ButtonReply

Charlotte

You really are speaking the words I’m thinking in my head. But we have a very slim chance that will happen since the majority of liners send to me in a sub are black. I never received a brown one.

Reply ButtonReply

misfitmorgan

I know people get so sick of the black liner but i’m new to subs and I’m really happy to get black liner. I hope if they do brown too that i get black. I feel a bit ripped off with April since they only sent out browgal in light and brown…i have black hair.

Do love Boxy so far though, it is the best from what i have seen and gotten.

Amanda

April was my first month with Boxycharm. I was waiting for the right box to come along!
I think I’m going to grab another April box, then cancel before next month. I have enough eyeliner and brushes for a lifetime. Cancelled Ipsy and Birchbox today for the same reason.

Reply ButtonReply

Jess

New Items in the Charm room! MG blush… if you have points go take a look before the items sell out.

Reply ButtonReply

Victoria Mohammed

Have you ever ordered something from charm room? What’s the shipping like? I used my points and ordered some stuff with it and I’ve been waiting for over a month and I haven’t even gotten an email with the tracking number (i live in Canada)

Reply ButtonReply

Arya28

I ordered some charms on March 31st and got the shipping email on April 16th. I live in the US though.

Marie

But how do you redeem your charms on the new website? When I click redeem my charms it just shows me my balance and the products but doesn’t actually redeem them.

Reply ButtonReply

Victoria

I just clicked on the team I wanted then went to check out there they have a thing to use charms. It was my first time using charms and got the temptu bronzer to try.

Wendy A Phillips

Oh thanks for the heads up! I didn’t get the blush (don’t use it) but grabbed several other items! =)

Reply ButtonReply

Mommy

How do you swap? Do you have to pay? I got Tarte in sparkler and would like to trade for exposed

Reply ButtonReply

Laura

You pay to ship the items.

Reply ButtonReply

T.Marie

You can go to the forum while you wait to get a spot on the swap site. You have to sign up if you want to be an ofish swapper lol

Reply ButtonReply

C

For the April box, does anyone know what color the Adesse liquid lipstick is? I got it, but I don’t want to open it if it isn’t a wearable color for me because then I can gift it.
Thanks in advance!

Reply ButtonReply

JessicaG

Mine is a beautiful rosy nude creme finish liquid lipstick, not gloss. So, from reading the other comments, it’s safe to assume different colors (and finishes) were shipped.

Reply ButtonReply

misfitmorgan

From what i gather both Haute Cocoa and Kitten Pink were shipped…i definitely got Haute Cocoa while others definitely got Kitten Pink. I also noticed Kitten pink is now in the Charm Room.

I only do matte so mine is going to be finding a new home.

joy

Mine is a brownish that is almost the exact raisin color I used to wear everyday in the late 90’s. Like, when I put it on it gave me a flashback. I had forgotten all about raisin lipstick! I’ve been wearing it every day since I got it, though. I put on a little bit and then add other colors with it and it tones down the other colors in a nice way, on me, at least.

Reply ButtonReply

Beth

Mine is a bright pink, like Barbie 😳

Reply ButtonReply

Victoria

I’m not sure of the color but it’s not my type of liquid lipstick color is very pretty but this is more of a gloss which I don’t like glosses so now that I’ve tried it I can’t gift nor swap lol so if your not a gloss person don’t try it!

Reply ButtonReply

CJS

I’m not sure if people got different ones…Kathleen Lights has an April Boxycharm YouTube video up where she tries on the Adesse Lip product (skip to 14:14 in the video to get the full details). It looks like a rosy glossy nude on her. I tried mine on, and it looks more chocolatey on me. It is a bit thick & sticky, smells good, and definitely not a matte. Hope this helps.

Reply ButtonReply

Susan

I saw on instagram they said the color was Haute Cocoa. If that was the only adesse lip sent out than I believe that is the color

Reply ButtonReply

Julie B.

I guess I’m not just addicted to sub boxes, but also to reading MSA comments. It’s fun to see the “not another eyeliner” group vs. the “love it” groups. It must be hard to please all of us all of the time!

Reply ButtonReply

SquirrelyGirl

Yup, Totally impossible! The makeup community seems extra hard to please.

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

It’s impossible lol.

Reply ButtonReply