Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I’m kinda hoping I don’t get these just because I’m very picky about my brushes and these just don’t look like brushes I would choose. I usually stick to Sigma, Morphe, Crown and Kevyn Aucoin. These for some reason just aren’t doing it for me. However, IF I get them I will try them out. Who knows, they might turn out to be a pleasant surprise. If I don’t like them they can be donated.
Does anybody have an overflow of Ipsy makeup bags they’re looking to get rid of? I’m going to be doing declutter in April. I donate those items and this time round they’re going to a shelter for pregnant teens. I would like to make each girl a makeup bag with the same types of items so it’s fair and I’m looking to get some bags on the cheap. If you’re interested let me know.
Reply
Angela
I have way too many Ipsy bags, Sephora play bags Birchbox boxes and BB5, and 70% of them still have every sample that came with them inside of it. I’m also on Instagram @geeiannone
I would love to help and donate also. I don’t know why I still get them there’s usually one thing I like so I’m serious when I tell you most of them still have products and them. Let me know if I can help! ♡
Reply
Shannon
If she does not respond please get a hold of me I am doing something similar for battered women and would love the bags.
Jackie
I have a bunch of empty ipsy bags! I would be more than happy to send them to you! I have like 14 or 15 bags just sitting in my cabinet. Find me on Instagram Jackiesinger89
Reply
Jade
I’d like to donate! How can I get them to you?
Reply
Maria
Yeeesss! Love, love getting NEW brushes in future boxes! Can never have enough of them. Hope to see many more blending one, too. 😁😁
Reply
Angela Iannone
This is the very first time I will be receiving this box and I truly hope I do not get these brushes I already have them and to be honest they are not worth $80 plus I have so many brushes I was hoping I was going to get some beautiful full-sized makeup I don’t want makeup tools, do they always send stuff like this or is this box really worth it? Any advice would be greatly appreciated because this is the first time I am trying out this box. Thanks
Reply
Jackie
This box is definitely worth it. We do get makeup tools, but not all the time. In the 2 years I’ve been subscribed, we’ve definitely gotten way more makeup than tools. I love getting brushes in sub boxes. I agree, I’m not thrilled with this particular brush set, but I have discovered some amazing, high quality brushes from Boxycharm!
Reply
Angela
Thanks so much! Who knows maybe it will end up being my favorite box! I honestly joined up Because I saw a photo of the February box and I thought that was what I was getting. But you never know and from what I hear everything is full size and these boxes do total way more than $21 so it’s definitely worth it but thank you so much for your response I was just wondering if brushes were an every box situation.
RoguesEn3D
I would be very happy to receive these! Perfect for travel, even if they aren’t travel size.
Reply
stacy
Meh! I’m all for nice brushes and getting them but why would I spend $80 on these when I can throw an extra $10 on the pile and get me 5 brush set from Sigma. Or an extra $8.20 and get 7 Sigma brushes. Makes no sense. I get it the fact it’s just a subscription box and I am not bitching by no means. It is still a great value for $21 but com’on now. That RV is just a tad far fetched. In that case if it were true then give us Sigma brushes next time. Sheesh!
Reply
Ambur Marie
This is a surprise!! I actually have this brush set! I got it for $3.95 on discount on hopes of me writing a review in exchange for such a good price. I never expected to see this in a boxycharm as I was never aware this was a popular ‘high end’ brand. Actually, I’ve never seen this brand ANYWHERE other than Amazon??
Reply
Julia
This set looks nice. But RV is ridiculous. I saw this kit at Marshalls for 20 and Amazon for 25. Why do they always do this, putting the highest price they can find to raise value of the box. I love Boxycharm regardless and very happy to receive so many great products for only 21, but come on….
Reply
Bella01
Yes, Oh Yas subscription box has a full set Of brushes too for April. Sign up now before the sell out again.
Reply
Liz
OMG 😍😍😍 I really hope I get them
Reply
LoriD
These seem to be a nice set for travel to go with the travel eye set from Luxie a few months ago. I don’t mind getting new brushes, especially if they’re cruelty free and synthetic. But they are kinda boring without anything pretty for my vanity or anything. And if they may or may not be in a box in the future? It’s hard to get excited about it when I’m getting a full set of vegan synthetic brushes (10 – 12 brushes I believe) in my April Yes Oh Yas box so not sure if I can get behind this spoiler, sorry boxy, I love you bunches, but please give me some great skincare instead of more brushes every month!
Reply
Kate
Agreed. Skincare would be a nice change. Personally im tired of bronzers & highlighters. Im too pale to use them, and even those ladies that can rock them, only need so many!
Reply
Laura
Would love to get skin care.
Regina
My personal opinion, just mine though. Why would boxycharm even send a sneak peak and then say it MAY or MAY NOT be in a future box. They should wait until they know for sure. It just sets people up for disappointment, if they are looking forward to it.
I am still not over the fact I got an empty z palette with one little blush pan while others enjoyed a palette full of beautiful colored holographic colors. If you’re giving palettes to one then give it to all. Especially the star item of the box.
The whole LE thing was a total disappointment too. I was really expecting something to be in it good. Kinda glad I didn’t get it even though I thought I wanted it.
Don’t get me wrong. I am grateful for everything I get. I just think a LE box would’ve been a little more show stopping. Especially since it was a first.
All in all I do love my boxy. Good quality for 21 dollars.
Reply
Jackie
don’t be too bummed. I traded my ofra palette for the highlight palette and wish I hadn’t. Its chalky and not very good pigment. Wet n Wild highlights are better than that Naked Cosmetics palette.
Reply
Selina
Yes, agreed! After 2 years with Boxycharm, I still get var #1 each month so hence, I received the empty Ofra palette, for once I would have liked another variation, but no, I do not even get my hopes up anymore, box 1 for me! Boxycharm should have sent us 2 blushes and 2 highlight pans to make up for this slight! only fair😂
Reply
Dianne
Nope, to plain I need something with rainbows, mermaids, unicorns and lots of color to make the future rock for me with Boxy. Ricky’s CC is doing that its The Balm.
Reply
Rosemary
What is Ricky’s CC? It sounds like I need to give them $$$
Reply
Beccah
Ricky’s Cult Crushes subscription box. It’s 11.99 monthly and they’ve been giving full size palettes. March is TheBalm palette and February was chi chi palette. I got the OMFG one which had bright colors you don’t usually get.
bmcd3713
Quite frankly, I don’t like these “way in the future’ so called spoilers as I don’t even know if they will be available to all of us. I think it’s a cheap tactic and one of which I am not a fan.
Wake up Boxy, you are diminishing your stature!
Reply
Regina
Nice future spoiler! Looks like a nice set for myself or to gift!!!
Reply
Laura
BC gave her a note that said:
These may or may not be featured in an upcoming box.
This could be nothing.
Reply
Izzy
I know & watch this brush set be part of a limited addition box. Not sure if I’m up for another challenge of trying to get a Limited box
Jen
They also put that little winking smile face! To me that says they will be an item!!
Jamie
So I’m brand new to boxycharm (still waiting for my first box). How do limited edition boxes work? Is it an extra box we can buy in edition to our monthly? And how often do they do them?? Thanks in advance for any answers 😉
Reply
Christy
Jamie, the first ever Limited Edition Boxy box came out in December and I think the consensus was that it was kind of a debacle. We don’t know how frequently they’ll release more LE boxes, if ever. I think in the future, you’ll buy them in addition to your subscription and priority will be given to subscribers.
Folks, feel free to correct me if I’ve misspoken!
Reply
_uff_da
As I’ve said before, I don’t need brushes but I will always love getting new ones. This travel set looks real nice (although overpriced retail value).
Reply
D
Love brushes! Thanks for the spoiler.
Reply
Laura
These may or may not be featured in an upcoming box
Reply
Katy
May or may not be featured in an upcoming box or LE box?? That’s definitely not a spoiler to sub for or stay subbed for. So thanks Boxycharm but I really don’t see the point of releasing this and I predict mass disappointment from a future box.
The set is nice. But the marketing ploy is not.
Reply
Liz Cadman
FYI – Boxycharm never mentioned LE, I just wanted to throw it out there as a possibility to make sure I don’t misrepresent anything/mislead anyone. Hope that makes sense!
Reply
Katy
I appreciate your clarification Liz. Thank you.
bruinkitty
How exciting!
Reply
Jessica
I’ve been with Boxycharm long enough that I don’t get very excited for brushes anymore. Their cryptic note cracks me up though!
Reply
stac
“may” or “may” not be 😛
Reply
Lily
I ordered the Glossy box LE which came out the exact same time as the Boxycharm LE – Glossy box LE was so much better – Happy I ordered it instead of Boxycharm
Reply
Holly
I wish I had done the same as you. I was slightly disappointed with this first LE from BC. Not sure if I will rush to purchase it again.
Reply
Liz Petrus
I REALLY hope Boxycharm doesn’t try another LE box! I’m still WAY upset about how us loyal ‘charmers’ were treated! They handled that box so very badly, no amount of apologies can make up for it!
That being said- love these brushes and hope to receive them soon!!!
Reply
Holly
Hopefully they learned from that mess! Still love BC though 🙂
Reply
Marcie
Even if it’s in a LE box, I’m excited for this!!! The Christmas LE box was a mess, but they did make it right. That gives me hope they’ll do the same for future LE boxes.
Reply
Susan
I cant even be bothered to pay attention to “potential future box” spoilers. Last time they had one of those, it turned out to be a variant item in a box. Whats the point of putting a spoiler out that much far in advance if it isn’t even something guaranteed to be in every box?
Reply
Laura
I agree. No point.
Reply
D
Yes! I agree. The tease only for the companies to change sizes or throw variations out there. They need to advertise variables. This site does awesome at trying to keep them all straight.
Reply
Christy
Agreed. I was really excited about the “future box spoiler” of the Seraphina Lemon + Sugar Lip Scrub and then it ended up being only a minor spoiler that only a few people received! There are only 5 on swaps and I can’t get anyone to swap it to me!
I have decided not to pay attention to these anymore.
Reply
D
I missed out on that too and really wanted it. Lol I guess that’s the chance we take as is s subscription box.
Kelli
I have the Seraphina lip scrub! I really don’t think I’ll ever use it, so would be open to look at what you have for swap! I’m a member of boxy babes and ipsy/boxy swap pages on FB. Look me up! 😘❤😘
Liz Cadman
Not sure if it is any indicator, but this spoiler came from Boxycharm, while the Seraphine Lemon Scrub came from the Seraphine company.
Juliya
Great spoiler! I really hope it will be in everyone’s boxes.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.