Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Hi! I received the Bella volumizing mascara, and for my lashes I really need something lengthening. Does anyone have a lengthening one that wants to swap??
Reply
Angela Carder
I had an account but cannot access it because you say you do not have my email address; You charged my credit card $122 for a 6 month subscription; I need to be able to access my account immediately.
Reply
Teresa
You have the wrong site to complain to, this site is only showing the subscription boxes not the actual company of BoxyCharm.
Go to their site directly
Reply
Candace
Liz,
Sydney Smalls Beauty got a Bellapierre mascara in her March box. Seems there’s at least 2 mascara variants.
Reply
Carissa
I saw on (i think) a verified Boxycharm post that there are 5 mascara variations
Reply
Jo
So far I have seen Butter London Double Decker, Butter London Iconoclast, and Bella Pierre.
Reply
Victoria
I seen others on YouTube also and I’ve seen 3 different mascaras total so far and all of them had the under eye jell things so it is almost seeming that everyone’s box is almost th exact same ??? I just wish I would get a shipping confirmation lol.
Reply
Nikki
I used to be subscribed to boxy but it was so long ago when I 1st signed up, I can’t remember I just resubscribed and got billed but will I get a box for March or not till april? Thanks in advance
Reply
C
Since you were billed in March, the March box will be your first box! You should get your tracking number in your email 5-10 business days after the day the payment was taken out.
Reply
Nikki
I’ve been waiting for an answer lol thanks so much!
Angela Huston
It seems PURR eye shadow is sent out a lot and I’ve also already received a set of these brushes, it seems like boxy charm is now sending out a lot of repeats I’ve been subscribed over a year maybe it’s time to look at a new box subscription
Reply
Rashma
Try Lola beauty box.
Reply
Bobbie
I got box 2 last month which I am super happy with as I LOVE the lip scrub. Anxiously waiting to see that spoiler.
Reply
RoguesEn3D
I want this box with everything I’m looking at. The Prim blush and that double Decker mascara. Pretty please with sugar on top.
Reply
annalily5
I hope I get this variation! I want that blush shade and have always meant to try out eye masks!
Reply
KimberlyB
I’m so happy to see Pretty Vulgar in sub boxes! They’re fairly new but so far their aesthetic reminds me of Urban Decay and Kat Von D.
Reply
Jayden
Love most of the items in the box. Hopefully the eye brushes are nice! I’m really excited about the palette. I hope I get the other shade of blush. I’m too pale for something that bright and pink. It would definitely look Best on deeper skin. I like the shade of the other blush a lot though! Not sure what the other variation for the Mascara is but I think I’d prefer it because I don’t really need any mascara right now. I have several sample sizes I haven’t even opened yet and already have several started. If I get it I’ll probably either just save it for when I do end up running out or keep it to give as a gift later if I get it. Also, probably prefer the other variant for the eye masks, although I’m not sure what it is cause I already have several eye masks. But if I do get it I’ll probably just add it to my collection as well. I wish there was more than just 3 pairs too. Hopefully the other variants are nice but I’m not sure which box I’m getting but it’s shipped already. Does anybody know the weight of this box?
Reply
Carissa
In a boxycharm group i’m in, someone with a .9 box received the double decker mascara and the more nude toned blush
Reply
april
Has any received their box weighing .9lbs yet? Just curious as to what box I may get.
Reply
Jen
I’m looking for the weight too. Mine that was shipped is .9 lbs… I hope they post it
Reply
Selina
Sydney Smalls box came in at 1 lb, and she recd the bella pierre mascara! I do not like any of the Bella Pierre’s products I have rec’d so far from BC😥
victoriatimothy1989
I’ve been checking g my email like crazy waiting for a shipment notice lol! So hopefully I get one soon and they get more box variation spoilers with weights 😂
Elaine
Same! Got an email this morning.😉
Jraewebb
I’m excited for this box! I don’t need any more makeup but who cares. I love to treat myself to Boxycharm every month! I’m kinda worried about the palette because I just got a Pur palette from Kohls this week that is really similar to this one, it’s called the visionary palette. I figured they could complement each other as it has a lot of berry tones and pink shades. The colors are gorgeous but the palette has so much fallout! I was a little surprised, they’re very pigmented so you definitely have to be careful with it. I’m pretty sure this is the same formula so I’m thinking it may have quite a bit of fallout but that’s something that is not a huge deal for me. I guess we’ll find out!
Reply
Dianne
Nice month but The only thing in the box that I like is the palette. I unsubscribed after I got last month. I’m trying to cut back on spending. I’m getting 2 Ipsy bags and Ricky’s Cult Crushers and Earfleek and Enjoy Leggings. I’ve never tried Enjoy Leggings.
Reply
Amanda
I love Enjoy Leggings!
Reply
Jilli
This just doesn’t sing to me so I’m glad I cancelled my subscription. I might go back in the future but I’m glad I gave up my spot to someone who will really love this months box
Reply
nicole d
Thank you thank you thank you. lol
Reply
Christine
I appreciate how Boxy covers the spectrum of everything you need in terms of makeup. Like over the course of a year, they really make sure to include everything.
Reply
Marie
Looks great! Hope I get the eye gels.
Reply
Katie
I’m loving this variation. I’d so love to try the eye packs!
Reply
Nicole
Is there still no waitlist?
Reply
Erin
right now there is not 🙂
Reply
Nicole
Thanks!! I seriously need this like I need to gain 50 lbs straight to my butt! This is such an awesome deal though!
Cynthia
This is a great box!!!
Reply
Sjski
If anyone wants to swap the palette and/or the brushes, I’d love to swap!!! I NEED that palette!! : )
Reply
Sandra
I don’t need my brushes, so I’m up for a swap 😊 Also, anyone wants to swap the color FX? I’m notgoing to use mine.
Reply
Iggy'sRock
I will, look me up: Iggy’sRock.
Reply
Michelle Bross
I’ll be selling my palette on eBay. Bricks4Brats is my handle. I sell all my unused box stuff.
Reply
Jen
I wont use the palette at all so email me jennifersparber33 at gmail
Reply
Candace
If you can’t find someone to swap Pur has this palette on their site. It’s $38. Don’t know how you feel about the price but if no one wants to come off theirs, you can still get it.
Reply
Ashleigh
I may be up for a swap. I have a zillion palettes and won’t need this one or the highlight palette from last month.
Reply
Moriah Murray
I’d love to swap for the highlight last month or the cover fx any interest in the it cosmetic eyebrow pencil from a bit ago?
Redhed36
I hope I get the variation with the other color blush. Other than that I like the box so far
Reply
Selina
I would wish for the other color blush too, but as soon as I saw variation 1, I know that this will be my box, I have been getting box #1 the last two years without change so the bright blush for me😁
Reply
Jacki
That makes sense to send the same variation each month. They try to avoid duplicating items and that’s the easiest way… variation 1 got this mascara two months ago, so they will get the other mascara now.
Maria
How can you tell which variation you are getting? Thank you its my first box and im super excited
Lucy
That’s my box too. This blush color is going to suck, my skin has a yellow undertone…
Redhed36
I have only received two boxes from them so far and neither have been variation 1. So I am hopeful. Even if I do get this variation it’s not the end the only thing I don’t care for is the blush color and I can deal with it if I get it. I would think that anyone with fair skin (me) would not get the hot pink (weeded out in profile questions). I would think that shade is more for darker skinned peeps.
Sara
After reading your comment, I went back and checked and I also always get the box referred to as variation #1. I never realized that, so thanks for that clue! Someone said the bright pink actually goes on softer, so it might be good.
Victoria
So glad to see positive comments. I’m hoping for the mascara as a variation and the other blush color! Can not wait till my box ships!!!!
Reply
JB
Just give me the palette and I’ll be happy! I usually get Boxy at the end of the month but last month curiously got it early. Can’t wait!
Reply
Katy
This is looking good. I’m happy that I didn’t cancel this month like I had planned on doing.
Reply
Kearstin
I cancelled after last months disappointing box and now I’m regretting it a little 😅😅
Reply
Miranda
The waitlist is gone right now
Candace
I can’t wait to get my hands on this palette. I have a killer idea for a bold cut crease that I can’t wait to try. Plus many others… it’s gonna be fun to play with.
I hope the wand on the mascara isn’t janky like the one from the Tarteist mascara was. Loved the formula, despised the wand. I saved a wand from an old mascara to use with it and it’s a million times better. Those short spikey wands are not for long lashed girls. My lashes clumped so bad it took about 5 minutes to brush them out with a spoolie just so I didn’t look crazy. 😅
Reply
Sara
I do have short lashes, but I use those spiky brushes just for my lower lashes, and pretty faithfully use Lash Paradise on the uppers. So that works out for me. The wand on the Butter website does look more like a standard shortish bristle.
Reply
Rachelle
I have long lashes that can curl up and touch my brow bones (leaving black mascara dots if I don’t let my mascara completely) but I love this mascara. It takes quite a few coats to show up, which is the downside…but most importantly good me, its hard to find mascara that doesn’t make my eyes burn, and this one doesn’t!
Reply
Heather
I feel exactly the same way! I normally love tarte, but I hate those short, plastic brushes like the kind in that last mascara. They always make everything clump so terribly and it looks awful! I thought about using a different brush with it, but it just didn’t seem worth the effort and I felt I would lose a lot of product switching brushes back and forth every day.
That’s an interesting observation about how it works better for people with shorter lashes. It never occurred to me it might be because those types of brushes were designed for ladies with shorter eyelashes. I’ll be staying away from all plastic brushes like this in the future! Thanks for the tip!
Reply
Bella
I Just signed up the other day and I’m super excited! I really hope I get the double decker mascara it’s my absolute favorite!!!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.