Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Mine is 8X5X2 and .7lbs. I so want the You Had Me at Hello or GSofM palette 😫 anyone with these dimensions get their box yet??
Reply
Michelle
So excited as I am getting 2 boxes this month and I really hope each one is different.
Reply
Rhenn rainbow
My box is .8, which looks like I’m getting the I you had me at hello palette. Which of course was the only one I really didn’t want. I hate neutral and brown palettes. 😒 I was pretty optimistic this month, as I would have been happy with four out of the five palettes. Pretty good odds, I thought. Guess not. I’m getting less and less happy with boxy every month. This used to be my favorite, but idk anymore.
Reply
BranLee
My friends was .8 too n she got golden state of mind
Just checked my shipping info and my box says it weighs in at 1.5lbs!! Totally off from the .7-.9lbs I’ve been seeing. I’m wondering if this potentially means I’ll get a GSoM or SP palette?
Reply
Alyssa
New unboxing video with th my little pony pallette weighing in at 1 pound!
Reply
Victoria
Lol seems your like me and checking YouTube regularly for the unboxing !!!!
Reply
Alyssa
Lol yes very frequently checking for unboxings
Victoria
Liz Rachel Marie posted a unboxing on YouTube she got the MLP pallett
Reply
Tracey
I’m excited for this months boxy.
The only thing I’m hoping for, is that given the amount of potential variations that exist, my two boxes will be different from each other. 🙂
Reply
Crystal
I’d be happy with anything but the highlighters, I have too much texture and dark spots on my skin it’s just not flattering. My box is .7 🙂
Reply
BranLee
So is mine n its 6x6x6, waiting for it now!!! I just don’t want the golden one!! But im def swapping if i get it….lol
Reply
Stef
Mine is .7 too….cant wait to see what it is. I dont want highlighters either
Reply
Leah
My boxycharm weighs in at 1lb! Anyone else have the same total? I honestly have no idea what I’ll be getting.
Reply
Marie
There’s an unboxing video on YouTube by Rachel Marie oc a 1 lb box.
Reply
Cachet
I already own the MLP if I get it I would be interested in trading for a different palette. Makeupartistcash is my Instagram name, you can contact me there if you are interested. Also if I get the MAC lippie I would love to trade for the tarte highlighter! 🙂
Reply
MeowKitty
I don’t think the weights mean anything because mine keeps changing. It was 0.7 yesterday and 0.8 today.
Reply
Taren
I absolutely love PÜRS color range and payoff, but I have several of their palettes now and I’m wondering if I’m the only one who finds their shadows to have a ton of fallout? I never read about anyone bringining it up, so it might just be me, but all the their palletes I’ve tried have soooo much fallout and it’s always such a mess to clean up.
Reply
Candace
I don’t find that Pur has any more fallout than any other good palette and I have a few good palettes that actually have more kickback than any of my PUR ones. Fallout is usually a good sign as it means the shadows are soft. The only time you should really be worried is if it’s an ABH Subculture type situation. I have the original Subculture and that thing is a friggin mess. You barely touch the pan and it rains eyeshadow. I would consider Pur pretty standard in the fallout catagory though.
Reply
Selina
Taren, u are not alone, I tend to stay away from the Pur palettes on the days that I am in a hurry to get out the door, so messy if I do not remember to tap the brush really hard before applying! On the other hand, Colourpop is better in terms of fallout.
Reply
Sandy
Yes!!! I love the pigment and how well they blend but Geesh that fall out is terrible!! You’re deff not alone
Reply
Southernprincess
I got the .9 lb box yesterday and it’s totally different:
Pur #purbabe Eyeshadow Palette
Butter London – Stroke of Wow Mascara
South Man Beauty Under Eye Gels
The Vintage Cosmetics Company Smokey Eye makeup brush set
Pretty Vulgar – Make them Blush in a bright pink
Reply
Jessica W,
This sounds like last months box to me. Did you only recently sign up? Because thats everything I got last month.
Reply
Sherry
I do believe that is your box from March…Did you recently sign up?
Reply
Kellie
Sounds like you got the March box a little late. That’s what I got for March, only you got a way better mascara!
Reply
Lori
That’s the March box not April.
Reply
Danielle
That’s the March box
Reply
Southernprincess
Well they are pretty dang late :-/ it just arrived yesterday lol
Cha Cha
That was March’s box.
Reply
Denise
Is there any credence to the shipping notice with the how to use liquid highlight heading. Does everyone have that on theirs ? Or does it mean that you are getting one ? Anyone ? Anyone ? Lol
Reply
L
I thought I posted but I don’t see it yet. Anyway I had the same message in my shipping notice too. I’m in WA state, weight 0.9 and it will be here in about a week.
Reply
Laura
My email says the same thing. My box weight is .09 and will be here in a week – WA state. Really don’t want the box with the brushes.
Reply
BranLee
I’ll swap u if u get the brushes 😊 I REALLY want them!!!
Susan
I was wondering this exact thing! Any input ladies (or gents) who’ve already received their box?
Reply
Kirsten
It was on every shipping notice. It was on my notice for a charm shop purchase.
Jacki
I got that email and I always get box 1. I assumed they sent it to everyone. You will definitely get a liquid highlighter sometime, if you don’t already have a few.
Reply
Candace
I got a shipping notification for .1 lbs and a 6x6x6 box. Not sure if it’s my box or my charms order. Hmmm…I’ll find out when I get home I guess.
Reply
Alisha
April’s box just gets better & better . I’ll be happy with any variation. You can’t beat this box for $21 !!! Each item in the box is close to that price or more .
Reply
Kearstin
That’s what I was thinking… I actually resubbed because I’d be happy no matter what lol 😃
Reply
DocNoa
I didn’t get a shipping address notification. Anyone else on the same boat? Is this normal? I only subbed in March.
Reply
Rachelle
I would recommend signing up for a FedEx account. You can get shipping notifications automatically without waiting for boxycharm emails!
Reply
Nicole
My shipping emails usually show up around the 9th or 10th of the month. It’s perfectly normal for you to not have gotten yours yet.
Reply
Becca S
I didn’t either. I think they are shipping them in batches.
Reply
Selina
Becca, u are correct! I have been with boxy for two years now and I usually get my shipping notification on 10th of mth or so. With delivery on 16th etc. Def in batches.
Victoria
I have not either , this will only be my third but it seems I usually am one of the last to get shipping notifications and last time I received it after I emailed them.
Reply
Starlet
BC is the best bang for the buck where beauty subs are concerned. I have subbed to this for 3 years and have decided to cancel. I own enough palettes to outfit an entire office and neighborhood after 3 years. This sub is continually excellent in what it offers and I have discovered amazing products. It is time for someone else to receive a plethora of goodies. I keep looking at boxes month to month hoping for something different and exciting. I haven’t seen anything lately.
Reply
Candace
If I get a palette I already own, I’m good with that. I can stack it. Colourpop makes fantastic shadows and they’re so affordable. I have $85 Tom Ford quads that don’t perform half as good as my Colourpops. People seem to equate price with quality but sorry, that’s just not the case. Especially when it comes to makeup. A lot of the time with high end products you’re just paying for the name.
Reply
Rosamunde
Candace, I agree with you 100%! Many times the name is what you’re paying for & not necessarily quality. All that marketing, advertising & in some cases, endorsement cost $$$. This is true whether it’s cosmetics, clothing or accessories. I’ve learned to pay attention to details & not the hype.
Reply
Denise
You are so right. And not just price but I go by what I will actually use. One month I got the lowest value item in the box but I use it all the time so to me that’s a win. It doesn’t matter to me if it’s 40 dollars or 10. If I can’t use the 40 dollar item and it’s going to someone else then it’s a waste for me. Value isn’t always about the price and neither is quality 👍🏼
Reply
Bailee
Mine is .8 so likely the one from the video?! 😍
Reply
Selina
It is a shame that with the 5 colourpop palettes, BC did not take the opportunity to send out texts or emails to their customers asking their preference on the box variation! Somehow missed the best chance to make their customers happy. I would love MLP, but there is a slim chance of this happening!
Reply
Candace
They probably got a certain amount of each palette, so there’s really no way to do that. They risk angering their customers if a bunch of people want a certain palette, as they might not have the amount they need to give everyone what they want. It’s probably smarter not to do that.
Honestly, all subbers need to read about the logistics of a sub service. A lot goes into this. If you’ve ever wandered why there are variations and why customization is such a problem you’ll find the answers if you just do five minutes of research.
Reply
AmandaT
I’d love to learn more, do you have any links?
Shaina
The only palette i dont want is mlp. I get 2 boxes if i get it maybe we can swap
Reply
Selina
Okay great! I will be in touch, the only items I really want is the mlp and the brushes! Maybe Element of surprise as a second.
Lauri
I don’t even care about the palette – I just want the brushes! I get 2 boxes, and will still be trading for all the brushes! LOL – I am ALWAYS searching for a clean blending brush!
Reply
Bushra
I would love to trade anything for there palettes..if I get the brushes, I can trade with you and anything else you want from the box. Look me up on instagram :bushra_khan19
Reply
Bushra
You can trade with me.. I don’t have any of the palettes and would love to have hands on all .. if I get the brushes would trade them to you.. IG me : bushra_khan19
Reply
Moonjock1
I love this box! My friend and I have been with boxycharm for 2 years in August, we are both in makeup overload and weren’t super impressed with the last few boxes (although we did love the pur palette we got last month.) We decided to cancel if we weren’t wowed by this month and we’ll obviously we are sticking around for now lol. I don’t use highlighter and I have literally dozens so I’m hoping for the Mac lipstick and the brushes. I’m also hoping for either the had me at hello or element of surprise palettes.
Reply
koma
I got variation#1 all the time… (==) and 0.7 lbs. I checked palette weight from colorpop site. so….. I guess that I gonna get tarte, lippy, and my little pony palette. ( because this one is most less weight one.)
Just try to guess…. It’s fun!
Reply
mako
Nooooo! I forgot it! her palette has mirror! It’s mean mine is not my little pony….. may be ELEMENT OF SURPRISE one??? my little pony one is may be 0.6lbs….
I’m a little sad…. I got Flashy pink all the time! I don’t need like that hot pink! This is why i think unsubscribe boxycharm.
Tooooo much unuseful hot pink!
Reply
Dana
I have .7 as well….
Reply
Rashma
😁
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.