Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Hmm I got the palette from box 1, but not the brushes or the MAC lipstick 🙁 I got an Adesse nude liquid lipstick, and the Tarte Tartiest Pro Glow.
Reply
JA
Right. There were several variations per all the spoilers Liz has posted. You don’t get everything – you get 5 items but no guarantee on what they are except for 1 of 5 possible palettes (all boxes), EITHER MAC or Tarte (not both but everyone gets one or the other), Dr Brandt (all boxes), then 2 other items – could be the brushes, brow gel, lippies, etc.
Reply
Hannah
AHH mine is 0.7 lbs 🙁 and I was hoping for the Tarte too! like I’m not mad, I love how the brushes look, but I really did have my heart set on the liquid highlighter.
Reply
Lindsey Withrow
I have the Tarte highlighter in sparkler, and I really wanted the brushes. If you are interested in swapping let me know.
Reply
CT
Boxycharm is amazing for what you get and the cost! I made baby shower gift bags and prize gift baskets with all the unused makeup I have=)
Reply
Lindsay
Great idea! Yeah, Boxycharm is such a good value. I’m always surprised people complain about 5 full sized items for 21 bucks. Sure maybe you won’t use everything but you can always share the wealth. My sister and daughter love getting all my cast-offs.
Reply
JA
Boxycharm could charge $5 and people would still complain. Seriously, I’ve seen people get nasty over items that are sent as freebie extras and not included in a box’s retail value.
Angela
Fingers crossed I get the brushes!!
Reply
Kailene
I’m thinking I’ll probably get variation 1 because my box is already on the way and it is the same weight as Sydney Smalls said hers was (.8). I’m really happy with this variation I wanted to try the highlighter instead of getting the Mac lipstick. More brushes would be cool but I’m getting another one in ipsy so I’m ok not getting brushes this month.
Reply
Victoria
Ok do t know why my post did not show but Sydneysmallsbeauty on YouTube also has variation #1 which is different from this she received you had me at hello pallet the target liquid highlight the dr Brandt a liquid lipstick and the brow gal micro fibers gel I believe her box was .8 weight
Reply
Sara
Oh no! Mine is .8 and literally the only Colourpop palette I have out of the variations is you had me at hello! I will be so disappointed if I receive it, but I guess I can swap. It’s just amazing I’m going to get the one palette I didn’t want.
Reply
Amy
I received my shipping email today and it included a tutorial on how to use the highlighter. I wonder if that means I’m getting one? Did anybody else get one?
Reply
Cara
I got the same tutorial in my shipping notification. I’m actually hoping to get the MAC lipstick instead of the liquid highlight bc I only use powder highlight.
Reply
Laura
Maybe try the liquid highlighter on your body for a summer glow!
She has a different variation ! She just uploaded 35 mins ago 🤗 && it is
The BrowGal Instatint is a tinted eyebrow gel !
Reply
bmcd3713
Even though there might be plenty of pieces in this months box that I don’t use, I love Boxycharm and welcome whatever they send me. Heck, if I don’t want to use something, I stash it for a friend or a donation.
In the meantime, I love me some makeup 💘
Reply
Victoria
SyndneySmallsBeauty has variation 1 and she got a liquid lipstick instead of the brushes and the tart liquid highlight check it out on YouTube I also believe she said her box was .8 size wise
Reply
Alyssa
There’s an unboxing video posted now for variation one with you had me at hello, tarte highlighter, and a liquid lipstick instead of brushes!
Reply
Cal
I just wish we could get Boxycharm in the U.K. … our boxes are rubbish by comparison, never Mac or Tarte included or palettes !
Reply
Caro
Oh God. Not only they didnt bill me this month cause of their billing processes probs. But now i see BRUSHES?? AGAIN?? Definately cancelling
Reply
Selina
Me too, love brushes and boxycharm can send me a set every month if they wish to😍😍 I tend to wash my brushes only on weekends so need a few during the week, been meaning to buy that colour switch or whatever it is called, u know, where u wipe off the shadows and then continue with same brush?
Reply
Cassie
There is a girl on YouTube who uses the foam from her boxycharm as a color switch. I’m going to try that this month. (I’ve already gotten rid of my old packaging)
Reply
Selina
Cassie, That is a great idea! Because the colour switch wheel on BH Cosmetics site used for cleaning brushes looks like a foam from Boxycharm in a container!! I am going to use an old cosmetics holder with foam cut to fit in centre. Thanks for the tip💕💕
Brook
I bought one of those from Amazon. Hands down, best purchase I’ve made in awhile. 😊
Reply
Casey
Looks like the BrowGal Instatint Eyebrow Gel
Reply
KiKi
Never subbed before, but I’m SUPER interested in this month’s box. However, I’ve noticed that the spoilers are on and off for me. For the people who are/have subbed, how easy is it to cancel?
Reply
Mayra
Very easy. Just cancel before the 1st of the month. Meaning if you don’t want May cancel by April 30th. Simple.
Reply
Christina Apple
I normally get the very first variation box. Kinda hope not this month. I dont use brow products and i have a few pallets with the same colors.
Reply
Selina
I have been getting box 1 or var 1 for the last two years now so if this method holds true, I am getting the colourpop element of surprise and the Mac lippie, cannot be happier if this happens, as I have the other color palettes except mlp!
Reply
AmandaDR
Reason why I signed up for Boxycharm was because anytime that I would see on Instagram a picture of someone getting their Boxycharm it looked pretty cool!! I was with ipsy before I switched over to boxycharm. The reason I switched was because Ipsy would non stop send me brushes and now boxycharm!:( I like brushes dont get me wrong but omg I have so many brushes already.
Reply
Kaleigh
I am so excited for this! I missed out on the eyeshadow brushes last month so I am glad there are some more in the April box – now if only I can get the Tarte highlighter variation instead of the lipstick I’ll be all set!!
Reply
Jody
I am guessing brow gel.
Reply
Janell
It says boxycharm on the brushes, unless it’s a collab
Reply
Kristy
it looks like a Luxe/boxycharm Collaboration!
Reply
Tanya
I was thinking cover FX boxycharm collab on brushes but Luxiw is probably right . I love them and love adding to my brush collection. Hiw do they do it! I’m so happy to spend a year with them. Seriously! Nothing goes to waste. And whom ever I gift is thrilled 😁 Boxycharm slays
Reply
Dani G
This is the variation I usually get. I’m pretty happy except that I really wanted the Golden State of Mind palette instead of Element of Surprise. Maybe someone will want to swap. I’m also happy to be getting the MAC lip versus another highlighter I probably won’t use.
Reply
MzBex
Just because MSA posts this as #1, doesn’t mean it’s Body’s version 1. It’s just the first full box that’s been posted, so far.
Reply
Maranda Walker
Browgal Instatint eyebrow gel <3
Reply
Angie
I want the my little pony eyeshadow palette the most but I’ll be happy with whatever I get honestly bc between the mask, the palette, I’m good! Everything else is just an added bonus 😍
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.