Facebook PixelEarFleek Earring Subscription Review - January 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

EarFleek Silly & Fun Earring Subscription Review + 50% Off Coupon – January 2018

Anna Reilly
ByAnna ReillyMar 1, 2018 | 10 comments

earfleek packaging

EarFleek
3.8 overall rating
58 Ratings | 14 Reviews

EarFleek is a monthly earring subscription that delivers a new pair of earrings each month to your door. Choose from three recently-updated subscriptions, called "Minimalist but Groovy", "Boho Babe", and this one, "Silly and Fun". If you want a mix of all three, choose the "I Don't Give a Hoot" subscription!

earfleek january 2018

A little backstory on this particular pack. I typically review the Silly and Fun subscription, which costs $3.49 a month.

Unfortunately, my January earrings ended up being the identical pair that I got in December! I reached out to Earfleek, and they offered to send along a replacement pair. That pair, which we'll be reviewing today, came right alongside my February Earfleek order in the last week of the month.

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

earfleek in plastic packaging

earfleek replacement pair

About EarFleek

The Subscription Box: EarFleek

The Cost: $3.49 + free US shipping

The Products: “Every month EarFleek will personally style cute and trendy earrings and deliver them to your home! You’ll receive the ultimate accessory that can pair with your outfit or perhaps you can show off to your friends! Shipping is FREE! and if you are not thrilled you can always return them!” 100% nickel-free.

Ships to: Worldwide

EarFleek Silly and Fun January 2018 Review

earfleek info card

Here's the info card from this pack.

moon earrings

pearlescent moon earrings

crescent moon earrings on model

Sky Candy Earrings - Retail Value $5.99

You might recognize this pair from Marne's November EarFleek "Boho Babe" review. I'm signed up for the Silly & Fun style of subscription, so it was a little surprising at first to get a boho pick. That said, the earrings I got in December had a slight boho vibe about them, so I'm not sure how sharp the line is between genres. I really do love these dangling earrings! The pearlescent moons are a little over an inch long, so they're noticeable, especially against my dark hair. They're also really lightweight. I feel like I could spend a whole day wearing these, no problem.

earfleek hairtie

Bonus: Blue Hair Tie

These little hair ties are becoming regulars in my orders! I have a nice rainbow of 'em sitting on my vanity now! I like how soft and comfy they are. The 90s flair is fun, too!

The Verdict: I'm happy with the replacement pair of EarFleek earrings I got! They're comfortable, neutral enough to pair with lots of different looks, and despite being from the boho category, pretty quirky and fun! I'm a big fan of star and moon shapes, so these crescent moons are going to be worn often!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today?: Since stylists choose the pair for you each month, it's hard to say that you would get these specific earrings if you ordered today. However, monthly shipments go out on the 15th of each month—if you're curious about this subscription, sign up soon to get the upcoming set!

Value Breakdown: There's just one pair of earrings in each Earfleek monthly shipment, so these earrings are at least worth $1.75 (the cost of the subscription after our MSA50 50% off coupon). They retail for $5.99.

Check out all of our EarFleek reviews and more jewelry subscription boxes in the Women's Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add EarFleek to your subscription list or wishlist!

Have you subscribed to EarFleek yet? What earrings have you gotten so far?

Starting at $3.49
Active Deal
Get your first box for $1.75!
Use Coupon Code MSA50
Subscribe Now

Receive fun and stylish earrings every month! Every month EarFleek will personally style cute and trendy earrings and deliver them to your home! You'll receive the ultimate accessory that can pair with your outfit or perhaps you can show off to your friends! Shipping is FREE! and if you are not t... read more.

Anna Reilly
Anna Reilly
Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she's swooning for all things kawaii!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

10 comments

Aimee

I just got my first pair today and I am in love!!!! I subbed to Minimalist and Boho and was on here to see if I wanted to go all in with the Silly as well since it’s such an affordable sub. This would be a great sub to get as a gift which may be my Christmas gift to the girls in my office. Even if you don’t love every single pair it’s still worth the money to me. When I go to Walmart the cheapest pair of earrings is $4.00 so to me this is really fun and worth it.

Reply ButtonReply

Shelly

I keep getting ugly wooden ones. Please stop with the wooden earrings! Thanks.

Reply ButtonReply

Tammy Haley

…i get the “minimalist” option, & to my surprise, i got 2 pair of hoops…one pair, a rather enormo-sized pair–think “gypsy costume”, & another, way-more-wearable size hoop

huh…sooo, no hair tie, no tattoos…but an extra pr of earrings…

this sub is quirky, & i like it

Reply ButtonReply

Kathy Stone

I have three subscriptions with them, and while some are similar I have not received a duplicate.

Reply ButtonReply

justmissjamey

I can’t complain about price, because it seems really good, but when they first started out not all that long ago, wasn’t it only like 2.99 or something like it for the full price??

Reply ButtonReply

Anna Reilly

I remember when we first started reviewing them, I couldn’t find the value online anywhere to work off of, so we just had to assume the earrings were at least the cost of the subscription.

Recently, EarFleek has opened up a little boutique online where they list their earrings along with prices, so I’ve been referring to that price for retail values. It’s a little more expensive to get them directly from the site rather than the subscription (probably because the subscription is random).

I think that’s probably the change you’re seeing? Hope that’s helpful! You can check out the EarFleek store here: http://www.earfleek.com/shop/all/

Reply ButtonReply

Kristin

Hair ties = best cat toys!

Reply ButtonReply

Elena

Mine will eat it right away. So be careful.

Reply ButtonReply

Redhed36

My February earrings are the same as my January’s, I contacted them and they are sending me a new pair. I wonder how many other people received identical earrings.

Reply ButtonReply

Pris

I received duplicates on 3 different occasions. Customer service was quick to send a replacement, but that replacement was a duplicate of what I had gotten the month prior. Once, I was subscribed for BoHo, and received microscopic, cheap-looking flamingo studs. It’s a great concept, and maybe it’s changed since January, but IMHO- it’s not even worth the money.

Reply ButtonReply