Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I’m glad I received The Offra Pop-Up Palette. While it’s not as fun looking at as the pretty highlighter palette I’ll actually get more use out of it. I have an assortment of little pans from Ipsy and Colourpop that now have a home. I was also pleasantly surprised with the PUR Lips Plumping Exfoliator, it works well and left my lips feeling soft and moisturized. Yay!
Reply
Deonna
Any wanting the Ofra i am willing to trade for the Naked my box arrives 2/14. Feel free to email. Deonnayoung at gmail.
It sounds as though I have the Ofra box weight is .08
Reply
Tonia Taylor-Zornes
My shipping notice from fedex says .5lbs in a 7x5x2 box. I’m sure I won’t be getting the Ofra magnetic palette that I had hoped for. I’d like to trade the naked highlighters for the the Ofra items if anybody is interested.
Reply
Sav
Crazy my box sounds bigger then most peoples boxes mines 16x10x1and weights .6 so does I think I’m not getting what I want this time 🤦🏻♀️
Reply
Alexia
Sorry, I meant that mine’s coming on the Wednesday the 14th. I’d love to trade. My birthday is the 9th of February, and I was wishing for my birthday month I’d get the Naked highlighter palette. Birthday wish did NOT come true lol. My email is crawford_x (yahoo email address).
Reply
Tonia Taylor-Zornes
Mine will either be here today or tomorrow so I will check back. My birthday is the 17th of Feburary and I’d hoped for the Ofra so maybe we both can get our birthday wishes.
Nicki
TONIA, omg, omg pick me, PLEASE. Pretty sure I’m getting the ofra mine was 6x6x6 @ .8lbs. Should be here Tues the 13th.
Reply
Alexia
I’m interested! I was so looking forward to the highlighters, but am getting the Ofra palette instead. My box will arrive Wednesday the 13th.
Reply
Molly
I got the Ofra empty palette variant and I’m not thrilled with it. I don’t think it’s fair to give some subscribers a highlighter palette with six shades and give others an empty palette (well, with one measly blush). Obviously people are going to be disappointed. Otherwise the brushes seem decent and the cover fx item was good quality. I think, surprisingly, my favorite item was the Pür exfoliating lippie. Boxycharm is usually on point so I’ll let this slide but hopefully they will be more fair in future boxes.
Reply
Stella
I’ll trade for the ofra!
Reply
Nicunta
If you have the Naked and want to trade, hit me up! nicolemariefaith at g mail is my contact info 😊
Mary
I totally agree. How do they justify comparing the 2. I always love boxy and maybe if the variants weren’t so different I wouldn’t be so disappointed. But a small little blush and a empty cheap feeling palette compared to a 6 shades palette, to me is not equal value. I usually don’t complain bc I know it’s a sub box but when there is such a big difference in items people get , it makes me disappointed.
Reply
Redhed36
I agree. I am new to the sub box world and the minute I seen the mostly empty pallet container I knew people were going to be mad. An empty container can’t be worth more than a few dollars. I hope I don’t get it.
Tj
I had the 6×6 box and received variation 4. Super happy, minus the bellapierre product. I’m not a 13 year old girl so loose glitter isn’t my thing 😆
Reply
Nicki
What were your dimensions? ??
Reply
NikitaMarie
And what was variation 4?
Nicki
Sorry, scatch that… I meant weight. Ha. Mine is 6x6x6 @ .8lbs watched an unboxing and it was the dang ofra z… and I’m beyond disappointed cause hers was same weight & dimensions which means I’ll get that too. 🙁
Kearstin
Please please someone trade me! I think I’m getting the Ofra palette and I’m literally annoyed.
Reply
Sara
Ill trade with you because i already have the anastasia beverly hills glow kit with the same exact colors
Reply
Jackie
Sara, if she ends up getting the highlight palette, I’ll trade you! I got the ofra
Kearstin
Awesome, thanks! I’ll reply again when mine arrives. It’s supposed to be Tuesday
Alexia
How do I swap? I wanted the highlighter, but ended up with the Ofra palette.
Reply
Rebecca
I have 2 otw that are 8x5x2 and .8lbs. I always get the crappy variations it seems. I even tried getting 2 subscriptions and I still always get the same in each box. Just wanted different variations with 2 subscriptions
Reply
Kearstin
That’s terrible! You’d think with two subs you’d at least get ONE with the variant you want 😔 I’m really bummed about the empty ofra palette and I think that’s mine. I would end up throwing that away. I do sub boxes because I don’t have the cash flow to fill an empty palette and that blush is just like the last hundred we’ve gotten. GRR.
Reply
Redhed36
Rebecca
Have you tried making the profiles completely different?
Apricot
Just got mine, Variation #1, it was listed as 7x4x2 and .8lbs. I have been wanting a pan palette and have been considering getting one so I am pleased with that but damn, the OFRa branding is so unappealing, seriously. I’m going to find just about anything cute in my scrapbooking stash to cover it up.
Reply
Sharon
I received mine today. I got variation 3. The weight was .6
Reply
Kim
For those monitoring weight/shape I got the box with the lemon lip scrub (yay!) and my box was .6 and 6x6x6
Reply
SunnyT
That’s exactly what my box measurements and weight is… Here’s to hoping I get the same box! Your’s is my favorite variation!
My dimensions don’t match, but the weight does, so that really gives me some hope! I’m really hoping for that highlighter! 🙂
Reply
Julie
On you tube the blush looks super orange which is unwearable for me.
Sad I’m not getting the highlighter and probably won’t get seraphine either 🙁
I’m going to take a break from boxycharm. Starting with the le box, I’ve had a series of bad experiences. So yay for the next person on the waitlist.
Reply
Lucy
You can trust what you saw on youtube. My box just arrived and the blush does look horrible on my pale skin. It’s a miss for me. The cover fx is a dream! ❤
Reply
Lexi
Based on the weight/dimensions of my box, it looks like I’m getting the Z Palette. I’ve never gotten a chance to try any unique colored highlighters, and I don’t wear much blush. The only 2 things I wanted were the lip scrub and the highlighter and I get the one box that has neither. So disappointed. Does anyone want to trade, or does anyone know where I can go to do a trade??
Reply
Rusty Gayles
Hi, I will trade the z palette and blush for a highlighter. Don’t get my box until the 15th. I am thinking I will get the highlighter.
Reply
Lexi
My email is niclm09 at gmail.com (it’s an L not an i in the adress).
Layla Moore
How do you find out which box your getting?
Reply
Lexi
If the weight of the box is .8, it’s the Ofra palette variation.The dimensions of the box will help you determine which of the other variations you’ll get. People have been posting theirs as they get them, so I’d search the comments. You can find the weight and dimensions on the same page that has your tracking information.
Jso
I will trade with you if I get the highlighter. I have so many highlighters I can’t possibly get through them. And based on my box dimensions I’m getting it. If what people are saying is correct.
Reply
Alexia
That would be wonderful, thank you. Just let me know. And my box is also arriving Monday, the 14th.
Jso
My box is coming on Monday btw
MzBev
Wet n Wild has some unique colored highlighters. They are pretty inexpensive and actually quite good!
Reply
Mary Fowler
Yes! Wet n wild has awesome highlighters!! Comparable to Anastasia Beverly Hills!!!
Alexia
Thank you for the info, I’ll check it out!
Allie
I really really REALLY don’t want the blush/z palette. I’m already getting a blush from Ipsy that I don’t want because I’ve already gotten it from them once before, and I never use empty palettes. At least the brushes, coverFX and other things are stiff I can use. I have a 33% chance of getting the Ofra, I suppose. Nooooo!!! 😂
Reply
Mary
I just got my box in. Dimensions was 6x6x6 and .08 I got the ofra. Ughh so didn’t want this. I would of preferred and of the other variations . I don’t know how they compare giving a highlighting palette with 6 shades to an one shade blush.
Reply
Nicunta
This is only my second box, and such wide variation is kind of off putting.. I really hope I don’t get another magnetic palette. I already have more than I use, and that blush is not a color I’d normally buy… Fingers still crossed…
Kearstin
Same!! Fingers crossed because I really want the highlighters and REALLY dont want another blush I won’t use 🙄😅
Reply
Allie
So mine is .7 lbs, and 16x8x1, and my daughters is .9 and 5x2x2 I just don’t think the weights and dimensions are that accurate in predicting what you get. Because hers weighs more, but according to the guesses here isn’t big enough for the z palette. So I just wonder how accurate that all is.
Reply
Nicunta
The ofra palette is a ‘mini pop-up palette’ and is smaller than the one listed on the ofra site.
Reply
Redhed36
I think the weight would be more accurate than the dimensions. Depending on who stuffed the boxes and how they stuffed them could change the dimensions (size of box they use), but all the items should weigh the same. I have seen numerous dimensions but mainly .6, .7, and .8 weights. There are three different variations and three main weights. I am guessing, but if your box weighs less than .6 I wouldn’t be surprised if you are missing something from your box. LOL. Plus I think accurate weight is more important with shipping companies than dimension at least when the boxes are close in dimensions, but you get a ounce off on a box could cost you more money or less. This is just my opinion.
Reply
MzBev
Before FedEx got my box it said 8x5x2 and .6 lbs. Now that tracking has updated and FedEx has it the weight stayed the same but now it has 16x10x1. That’s a big box for them.
Jackie
My box is 16x8x1 and weighs .09. I have a feeling its the Ofra palette. Someone PLEASE trade me! I want the pretty highlights!!
Reply
Melissa
I just seen a pic of a girl her box was 8pnds and she got the ofra pallet
Reply
Jackie
Got my box today 2 days early and I got the ofra and the pur lip exfoliator. Blehh.
Jilli
Mine is the same dimension but .8 hmmm
Reply
Allie
Mine is the same dimension but .07 🤔
Reply
sylvia
May be time to cancel… I’m not feeling any of it . Don’t care which box I get
Reply
Nicole
Omg I hope I get box 3!!! It’s exactly what I want! I wish we could choose to guarantee a good box! 😭😭😭😭
Reply
Lindsay
I am hoping for the Ofra palette. If I get the other one, I’d be glad to swap for it if anyone is interested.
Reply
Deonna
Lindsay I did get the Ofra palette. If you would like to trade email me at. Deonnayoung at gmail. I can get it sent to you this week
Reply
Nicki
I would LOVE to swap if you get the highlighting palette. My shipping notification said weight was .8 and I read below that means the ofra : /
Reply
Rhenn
If I get the ofra pallet I will swap with you. I really really want the naked palette and have no use for the ofra.
Reply
Deonna
Lindsay HI. I believe I’m getting the Ofra palette. So if you get the Naked palette I am definitely willing to trade with you. Let me know.
Reply
Rhenn
I think I’m getting the ofra palette, and I really want the highlighter, so if anyone is interested in trading, send me a friend request on facebook.com/rhennrainbow
AmyM
Based on weight, it looks like I’m getting the version with the Ofra palette. Definitely not my first choice, but we’ll see. Likely will end up swapping it, but maybe I’ll fall in love.
Reply
Selina
I think that Lola Beauty does not have variants, but the Feb box is sold out!! Oh well, i may cross over to Lola soon but I heard that they are sister company with Boxy 😀
Reply
Redhed36
I would be happy with variant 2 or 3.
Am I the only one that doesn’t know the weight of their box? Mine hasn’t shipped yet.
Reply
Lindsay
I haven’t received a shipping notification yet either 😑
Reply
Redhed36
I just got my email this morning. Yay! It’s .6 hopefully the highlighting pallet.
Laura
I am going to quite irritated if I get both the cheaper product variations (has happened before). I would much prefer the the Seraphine lip product to the Pur plumper – I guess I wouldn’t mind the z case or the palette. My box is .80 though which may end up having both of the cheaper product variations. If they are going to do variations they should be still the same price (or close).
Reply
Linz
I am so excited about the coverfx shimmer veil. I love the stila liquid eyeshadows, and the reviews seem to be pretty similar! Yay!
Reply
Alexandria
I’m really hoping for box 2!!! the other boxs are not bad just not what I want.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.