Posted by My Subscription Addiction on in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 71 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have Box December 2017 Box Spoiler #2!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

We have the second spoiler for the December 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have box!

Each box will include:

Tilo Twilight Scarf – Value $98

Small sequins woven into the textured grid of this scarf give it a subtle sparkle to elevate all your looks. The soft gray color varies from piece to piece due to the hand dyeing and washing technique, making it uniquely yours. This scarf also features eyelash fringe that gives it a soft feel and look.

Here it is on:

What do you think of the latest spoiler? I’m loving how lightweight it is with just a touch of sparkle! And I can’t believe this box includes a necklace and a scarf!

And in case you missed the first spoiler:

Chloe + Isabel Pavé Bar Long Pendant Necklace – Value $42

This playful party pendant necklace is perfect to layer all year long. It features a cool antique plating and a skinny pavé pendant that looks sleek and minimalistic. The cool-girl brand was started by two best friends with different tastes but a kindred passion for style and self-expression. Enjoy this hypoallergenic and nickel-free necklace for yourself, or gift one to your BFF.

This necklace measures about 30 inches long with a 2-inch extender.


And you get to pick between silver or gold!

Here is Marne modeling both necklaces for us:

Thanks, Marne!

Here’s how to make your selection:

1. Log in to your POPSUGAR account and click the Customize button:

2. Pick your necklace color or choose to Make it a Surprise!

3. Click Continue, and grab any Add-Ons you might be interested in:

4. Then click Confirm selection:

5. All done! You’ll see this screen when your selections are submitted:

What do you think of the December 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Box spoiler? I love that POPSUGAR is letting you pick your metal choice! (Plus bonus points for this necklace coming in a beautiful box perfect for gifting!)

If you haven’t signed up yet, use coupon code MUSTHAVE5 to save $5 off of your first box! (Your first box will be the November box, but you’ll be able to make December selections now, too!)

Check out all of our POPSUGAR Must Have reviews to see what you can expect from this subscription!

Written by My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I’m soo happy they finally put a piece of jewelry in their box for us people with Nickel Allergies! I’ve been bummed each time I get cute pieces of jewelry that I have to give away because they’re silver or brass! Now I can finally enjoy one for myself. I’m excited!

  2. Love scarves, but have way too many. I live in LA, people think I’m ridiculous when I bust out my scarf. This one, although very pretty & love the sparkles, looks very snaggy.

    And Helen brought up a good point earlier – how bout a nice holiday red with sparkles or festive green, royal blue or advent purple with sparkles? All of these bold winter colours would have been so much more welcome than another boring grey.

    But either way, I bought this box (at the 30% discount) for the necklace. Everything coming in it is just gravy 😁

  3. Not a huge fan of the necklace but I love the scarf. I’ve liked almost everything from every box the past few months and had series box envy (I lucked out with their cyber Monday deal and got September, October, and November though!), so I think I’m going to bite the bullet and subscribe.

  4. They are off to an excellent start this month! I know a lot of subscribers didn’t like the Tilo scarf from February 2016, but I loved it! An understated and sweet accessory for Valentine’s Day (all February, really). It was too wide so I cut it in half, frayed the edges and gave one half to my mom.

  5. Well, I hated that necklace so much that I didn’t do a Black Friday weekend deal . Now I wish I had. Love that scarf.

    • I don’t like both but still got the Black Friday discount. Couldn’t resist 30% off plus surprise. I really hope that there will be something else that would worth it for me.

  6. Now I’m not sad I got 2 Dec. boxes coming. Both items will make great gifts, too! Fingers crossed that this whole box is a winner! I will beyond thrilled! 😉

  7. I love both spoilers so much, everything else is a bonus. That necklace in gold is going to pair well my my box of style earrings and the La Soula rings!

  8. It’s great how everyone loves the scarf. All I can think is ‘Not another grey scarf!’
    Why not red or even white for once? I look positively consumptive in grey. Surely I’m not alone in being unable to wear that colour?

    I swapped away the last one and will be swapping this too. So if anyone’s jonesing for it, you know where to come.

    • I actually love gray scarves, but I already have 2 from PSMH! So I also would have liked something different.

  9. The scarf did it for me. I’d spend nearly the box price on that no question. I can already think of multiple outfits I want it for. Easy decision to buy this.

  10. Awesome start to December!! Can’t wait to see what else is in my box!!

  11. I have 3 Tilo scarves from Luxor LE boxes. Love them & really happy with this box!

  12. love the necklace but not so thrilled with the scarf. I like scarves but this one does not look like it is worth $98. Oh, Liz you look wonderful modelling the various items in the sub boxes. Everyone is correct that the outfits and accessories look beautiful on you.

    • Thanks so much, Paula! 🙂

    • I know, Liz has great style to add to her slim figure. She makes everything look great!

  13. This really doesn’t look like a $98 scarf. Seen very similar ones at world market for cheap. Excited for the necklace though!

    • I think the very same thing.

    • Same!!

      • ditto!

    • World Market is a VERY different quality, just like Target, or H&M. Cute styles, but fabrics and products are much less expensive — a world of difference. That’s why there’s a gap in price points. All things that are made to the same style are not equal.

  14. I’ll either swap the scarf or use as a cover on my bookcase since this is prettier than the sparkly one they sent a few years ago.

    I am always hot and it doesn’t get cold enough to wear them in South Texas even if they are thin.😕

    • Marie, that is a great idea about using it as a cover on your bookcase. I think that would be very pretty. Especially when the colder seasons are done, you can really put it to good use. I live in Louisiana so scarves and ponchos are almost like coats to me because we get very limited cold weather.

  15. This box looks great. Is there a way to get a second box without starting another sub?

    • TK, I think when you are in the order mode, you can click I believe it is gift or one time gift. But make sure you click that on both screens. I notice when I have clicked the first screen, on the second screen it didn’t stay clicked so I needed to click the box again when it shows up. Hope that helps and I think it will make more sense when you actually see the screen.

      • Thank you Jeanette! I’m going to give that a try. My mom will love the scarf and my son’s girlfriend will love the necklace. Two great Christmas gifts in one box!

  16. Liz what is that Gray shirt your wearing. I need it!

  17. I need another scarf like I need a hole in my head, but——- I LOVE THIS SCARF!!!! I wear them a lot so it will definitely be used, but sometimes I glance in my closet and laugh at how many I have. Only a handful of scarves came from boxes. I purchased the rest.

    For those who do not get higher end catalogs (be glad) or ocasionally shop at very high end stores or peruse their websites for fun— yes, you would be amazed at the fat prices on every item you can imagine. They are mass produced so I’m imagining there are many people who regularly buy them. It’s a luxury for me, but I do purchase $100 scarves and $300 cashmere sweaters WHEN I can. I do try for sales though. I also shop and adore my items from Target and Home Goods, as well. As much as I love the styles, most of my Target clothes barely make it a season or two if worn frequently. So getting these higher quality fabrics and well made items in these boxes is extremely exciting for me. Agreed, when looking through the Neiman Marcus website or big book catalog, I’m truly amazed and perplexed at the prices on many of the products. But somebody buys them at regular price—just not me. Lol 😂. So, it’s not inflated by the sub brand (usually) it’s inflated by the fashion industry. And finer fabrics and dyes and metals cost more to make. I dunno, I just choose to be appreciative to receive a very high quality item at an extremely discounted price.

    Liz, lady you are rocking this scarf, your new haircut, and your cute outfit!!! I’m taking notes!!!!!

    • This! ^^^

    • Thank you for saying this! All the people complaining that they love scarves but not for $98…well nobody is asking you to pay that much!! This is why I love subs. Great quality items at a discount. I can’t wait to get this box

  18. Popsugar is already making up for November for me. Love the scarf and necklace. Can’t wait.

    • Agree. November box wasn’t a “great” box.

    • I agree! There was nothing in the November box that I wanted (well, maybe the pretzels!), so this box is looking great!

  19. Liz I am not trying to be some pervert here but your body is SMOKING!

    You are drop dead gorgeous!

    And I am so excited to get my December box! PS always knocks out of the water with their December box!

    • Haha I thought the same thing! Liz looks stunning I have to steal her style I think! On another topic how on earth is such a thinly woven scarf worth nearly $100?!

    • LOL! I was thinking the same thing! Get it Liz!

    • Haha thanks! Who knew a POPSUGAR spoiler post would turn into a Liz-confidence booster post? 🙂

  20. This scarf is lovely…. thanks to the Black Friday deal I get another December box with discount… one scarf for me and another one for my sister!

  21. If I order today, will I receive this box in time for Christmas ? Thank you 🙂

    • I believe so, but I’ve reached out to confirm and I’ll let you know when I hear back!

    • Just heard back, as long as you order by December 15th, you will get your box before Christmas!

      • Yay!! Thank you so much, Liz! You are awesome !!

  22. OOhhhhh!!! Pretty!! PS December boxes are always one of the best of the year, IMO. They just have a knack for choosing festive things that don’t scream “HOLIDAY”.

  23. Awesome thanks Liz! Where did you get your boots? Super cute.

  24. You look beautiful, Liz.

    Great photo.

  25. love it

  26. Love this and this box just keeps getting better!

  27. Your haircut is adorable, Liz! You look so fabulous!

    • Thanks so much!!

  28. I’m so glad I ordered this box! Such beautiful and perfect holiday winter gifts to myself! 🙂

  29. Ooooh Liz you look so beautiful in that picture, and that scarf looks so good on you! I just love your style! Where did you get that shirt? I want to get one so bad, it’s so cute!

    • OMG – thank you so much! The dress is from Forever 21. I bought it last year, so it is sold out, but here’s the direct link to the dress:

      They have a lot of similar styles available this year, though:

      Hope that helps – thanks again! 🙂

  30. Love, love and love the spoilers for December, glad I jumped the boat and got a box on Black Friday.

    Also very happy to see another Tilo scarf, still have and wear the one we got 2 years ago if I’m not mistaken. ..

    • Same! Looking forward to both spoilers and got my box on black friday.

      • I literally haven’t been so excited in a while to receive a sub box 🙂

  31. Liz, love the new hair!!! 💗

    • Thanks! 🙂

    • Agreed! Your hair looks great, Liz 🙂

      • Thanks so much, I thought it was time to go shoulder-ish length! 🙂

        • Love it Liz, very flattering!

  32. I love these pieces. But wow–this box is shaping up to be similar to the December 2014 box.

  33. I like the scarf…just curious about the fiber content. Also, it’s a bit strange to me that there’s two decorative neck items in this box. Very neck-centric. 😉

  34. We haven’t had a scarf for awhile, so I am glad for something that’s a nice neutral color and is also a nice touch for holiday season. As always, I think the RV is inflated, but the personal value means different things for different subscribers. I enjoy both spoilers and was glad to choose gold option.

  35. $98 RV for one piece ? That to me means the rest wont look good . Pass !

    • The necklace is $42, so that’s two high value items. I’m cool with that, I love my tilo scarf from two years ago – the quality is real!

  36. Nice!

  37. Love it! Perfect for these awful Michigan winters

  38. Whoa! Liz, you look fabulous!!

    • aw, thanks! 🙂

    • She does look great and comfortable at the same time!

  39. I love this scarf and think now I have to order the December box

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!