Posted by on in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 79 comments

Play! By Sephora November 2017 Box #957 FULL Spoilers!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We now have the box number for the FULL spoilers for another variation of the November Play! By Sephora box! (Thanks for the heads up, Frances!)

This is Box #957:

Thanks for the photo Cathy!

This is Box #973:

Sephora Play November subscription box spoilers

Source: beauty4free2u

In case you missed it, all subscribers will receive:

MARC JACOBS BEAUTY Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara

What do you think of the spoilers?

To find out which box you’re receiving at the beginning of each month, follow these instructions:

If you log in through a browser, not the app, and go to my account > account details > online orders and open the play! Order Details, you can see the “item number” next to the image.

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I am getting this. Meh, I already tried and have that mascara (yes, I like it, but would like to try something new), also tried vinosource serum. Lip gloss… hm, will see, because for me usually the problem with colors.

  2. I don’t know how to load a pic but I got a different box version.. #005
    I got a bright red sephora lipstick. Origins clear improvements charcoal mask. Mist r was hydrating hair balm.. Candalie toner marc Jacobs mascara. Burberry blush

    • Beginning to wonder if that Origins Mask was in every box number this month. This is the 3rd box (973, 957, 005) that it has appeared in, along with the Marc Jacobs mascara of course, which we were told would definitely be in every box.

      Sephora is a little off in their shipping notifications this month. My box (957) arrived yesterday; the exact same day I got the email that it had shipped.

      • Exactly the same happened with my box this month. I got the “get ready to play” email 4 hours after my box was delivered. I never get my box this quickly either and I’m also #957. It’s a strange world we live in!

  3. Got my box! (really early this month) #957, exactly as pictured. I love it! Finally. 🙂

    I am really glad I didn’t quit this month like I was going to. Usually, after an awful box or two, I get one I really like, and the dreaded FOMO is what keeps me hangin’ on, lol.

  4. be warned everyone– my account stated that i would be getting box #973 this month, but today i received my play box and it was #957. i went to sephora’s website and suddenly there my box number had changed as well.
    you may not get what the box # you’re expecting.

    • How can you tell which box you’re going to get? I’m looking in my account info but don’t see anything…

      • go to Sephora, then your account, then recent orders where your Play! parcel should be listed– you aren’t looking for your order number, you look for the item number that should be listed in the description. it will be the last three digits of your ‘item number’.
        — sorry it took me a bit to answer your question!

  5. Finally! A box I am looking forward too! Thank you, Sephora….this really *was* the month I was gonna quit, after last month’s poopy box.

    The only thing that is confusing is the charcoal mask, as I have dry, aging, sensitive skin, with nary a pore to be seen. But I love all things Origin, so it’s still a win!

    Sephora’s lip gels are the BOMB. For a cheap lip gloss, they can’t be beat, and they taste good too. I love them. And I’m a Burberry Classic girl, so finally psyched about the perfume. Caudalie is aweSOME and I’m too cheap to buy it, so yay! Mascara samples are always good. And never tried Morrocanoil, so that’s cool too.

    So glad I didn’t cancel! (unless this turns out to be a bait and switch, like last month’s box). We have a winner! 🙂

    • I’m with you on the caudalie, but in what world does anyone who has dry, aging skin (my marked concerns, as well) need with that charcoal mask!

  6. Did anyone else receive their box but still says processes on Sephora site? I’m wondering if this double billing issue they will accidentally send me 2 boxes.

    • Yes, it happened to me too and I was wondering the same thing.

    • It happened to me and I called customer service otherwise they would have sent me two of the same box according to the item numbers of the two boxes. They cancelled one of the orders and the credit showed up on my credit card.

  7. #957 box here. I’m really excited to see what I’ll be getting. I’m particularly excited about the mascara; and just a personal preference but I’m really hoping that the perfume doesn’t have too strong of a rose scent.

  8. Box 702 , I hardly ever see my boxes posted usually I get it in the mailbox the same day it gets posted , go figure

    • What products came in your box?

  9. I have in my profile that I have dry skin and don’t have acne/pore congestion/oil as a concern so how does it make sense for me to get the origins mask?! ugh. I also wish we could input our favorite lip finishes because I am 100% a matte girl so the gloss is going to get given away.

  10. The 957 is my box too. I’m betting it will be Haley’s also. We usually get the same boxes. I will eagerly await her review. Then I can see how the lipstick will look before trying it on myself.

  11. What about box 005? Anyway, I would be interested in a swap. Sephora keeps sending me products I am allergic to.

    • i’m box #005 too and have been waiting for spoilers…my box never has spoilers. i was less than thrilled with last month and i have about 900 mascaras (i feel like i get a mascara in every box!)…hoping our box at least has the perricone cloud cream…

    • I also have this box. My boxes are usually revealed quickly so this is new to me. I hope we get a Moroccan oil product. Perricone MD, Origins, and Caudalie products are also welcome.

  12. Tired of the hair masks. Thanks to play boxes don’t think I will have to buy one anytime soon.

  13. This is my variation… at least there’s Caudalie in it? I’m a bit burnt out on the Origins charcoal mask, and I have never had much luck with the lippies I’ve received from Play! Unfortunately my FOMO prevents me from cancelling 😬

    • Your comment made me chuckle. I don’t think you’re alone on your FOMO. It likely accounts for a good portion of the people who keep hanging onto their subs just for oneeeee more month……… 😉

      • Ummm, yeah. That would be me.

        Cindi (FOMO Queen)

        • Yea… Princess FOMO here.

    • I’m with you on the FOMO. I’m not thrilled by this box but it seems like every other box is good so dont want to quit. $9 away from VIB.
      I did notice that the things I wanted from the box frequently end up as rewards. Oh well, looks like I’m in for another month.

    • And FOMO was the reason I unsubscribed for all of less than a dayva few months back.

    • That kept me from cancelling it for about 6 months. Then I decided to cancel this to try Macy’s, in August. I haven’t had any FOMO from Play, after all!
      (I have since cancelled Macy’s also, October was my last box)

  14. This one is mine. I’m meh about it. I️ like the lippie and the Origins but not sure about the rest.

  15. Blah! Not a good box at all! I always get the worst variety! I hope I can swap for the perricone cloud cream!

  16. When are they going to show box #013? That’s my box number and I’ve been checking daily 😕

    • Same!!! Literally checking twice a day!

    • Yes, I want to know what’s in #013!

      • me too girls 😀

        • Same! Ugh the suspense!

          • Me tooooooo! I am literally checking every single day, multiple times a day for my box spoilers.

    • YUP!! I am #013 as well!! I really want a gloss or some type of balm and the the Origins mask!! If I get another liquid to matte lipstick Im going to scream!! My lips cant handle the dryness, they need something moisturizing, especially this time of year!

  17. I don’t like how the 957 gets a sample of the $49 cream but the 973 gets a sample of the $80 cream. If you’re gonna send me creams twice in a row I should be getting the quality cream of the two.

  18. Wow I don’t like this box at all!! I never complain because I figure it’s just $10 but it’s now been a few months since I’ve been excited about my box… I am however very anxious for the next few allure boxes😀😀😀😀 if anyone wants anything out of 957 let me know!!!

  19. I’m getting box 3013… Any information on that box?

  20. Anyone have the box 666? lol

  21. Oof. This is my box and it does not look good for me. I can’t stand Origins and that’s the only thing that’s appropriate for my profile. Not into the Moroccan oil at all. The lippies might be okay. The mascara could be good. I’ll look into the Caudalie and see if it might be good for me, but I’m not super hopeful.


  22. Meh. I’d have preferred the first box; more suited to my profile. Oh, well. Think I’ll hang in through December, hoping for a good holiday box. But then I’m just done, I think.

    • I’m doing the same thing, Play has been a huge disappointment to me.

  23. Another box I’m looking forward to for the second month in a row. I’ve been loving all the skin care samples so far so I’m looking forward to that. The hair oil I could do without but, I’ll give it a try. And I’m always down to try a new mascara. I just hope the lip shade isn’t too light for my skin tone.

    • Same on the lip product. It’s a common theme in sub boxes. Too light or way too bright.

    • Same on the lip product. A common theme in sub boxes for me.

    • I have the Sephora lip gel in Perfect Nude (the color listed above). In the tube, it looks like a decent pinky-nude but when swatched or worn on my lips it comes out basically neutral to my lip color. I’m fair/light skin with pink undertones.

  24. I have this box but I really want to try the Perricone MD cloud cream if anyone wants to swap! Literally anything in this box for it.

  25. So…I have dry, sensitive, aging skin. Did everyone get the charcoal mask? It sounds harsh and drying. Is that an appropriate product for dry and sensitive skin? I hope I’m wrong but it seems like a total miss for me!

    • It is not good for dry skin! I am getting it too and have already tried it and it makes my skin even drier! We should have gotten the perricone cloud cream. They pay no attention to our profiles at all! Terrible box for me too!

  26. Thirst quenching AND charcoal? Is that contradictory?

    • Indeed.

    • I know, right?! I thought it was odd too that they would combine those two products (Origins Charcoal Mask for Oily skin and Caudalie Serum for Dry Skin) in the same box.

      • Funny, turns out this is my box. I’m not mad st this variation though. I like Caudalie and I will always try a new mask. We will see which product works best, I guess. I definitely like it better than the first spoilers.

        If it matters:
        dark skin (but I changed my profile to olive
        Dry curly hair
        Brown eyes
        Combo skin (I guess the contradicting items make sense)

    • Well the charcoal mask will kind of dry out your skin , so you’ll need a nice skin quenching moisturizer after.

      • I have combo skin. I would use a charco mask on my nose and sometimes forehead, and then quenching moisturizer elsewhere.

        • That’s what I do with my combo skin. My cheeks get very dry in the winter but I still have an oily tzone. I just use two masks at same time in different areas.

  27. Interested in everything but the lip gel as I don’t wear nude shades, but since that’s a personal preference I’m ok with getting it,

  28. This is mine, and I’m pretty happy with it. Anything I don’t want to use ends up being swappable, so I never mind that. Also, I’m pretty sure that every Play! box always has a perfume sample, regardless of the rest of the contents.

    • How to swap?? Please tell me.

      • Sign up for the swaps on this site, but it may take a short while to be accepted. I had to wait about a month for a spot to open up.

  29. I hate variations!!! Seems there’s always a product or two in a box I’m not receiving that I’d prefer. Ugh!

    • Me too. 957 is my box. I was hoping the Perricone Cloud cream would be in all the boxes. The gel creams feel so good going on. I usually have to spray or pat on some moisture later though as their effects seem to wear off quickly.

      • That’s the exact product I was bummed wasn’t in my box, lol. One of my favorite discoveries is the Peter Thomas Roth Cloud Cream, it’s fast become my favorite. Have you tried it?

      • I’m so with you on those gel creams. I usually end up putting another moisturizer on shortly afterwards..

        • I agree. It seems like the gel based creams don’t seem to have long lasting hydration but I have found that if you apply serum underneath it, it seems to enhance it’s effectiveness.

          • I’ve also found that if you apply them when your face is still fairly wet, they work better. But otherwise, they’re pretty drying.

  30. This is my box too! Excited for the mascara and moisturizer!!

  31. Happy about the Origins and to try the mascara and maybe the Caudalie. I was hoping for a perfume-free box and not into the Moroccan Oil.

    • I don’t think there are perfume free boxes?

      • It’s rare but they did it with the September box. They sent out a hair product packet instead of the usual perfume sample. I am hoping they do that more often as I don’t wear perfume and just collect the samples in a box to give away later.

  32. This is my box! Looking forward to trying the Caudalie Serum and the Marc Jacobs mascara.

  33. Not a fan of the Moroccan oil… but other than that its a pretty decent box 🙂 Can always use more Origins and cant wait to try the Burberry.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!