Posted by on in Boxycharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 102 comments

BoxyCharm December 2017 SPOILER #2!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.


We have the first December 2017 Boxycharm spoiler thanks to Yosef on Boxycharm Beauties!

The December box will include:

Real Her Blush Kit – Value $32


Tarte Tarteist Lash Paint Mascara – Value $23

What do you think of the latest Boxycharm spoiler?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more. (And sign up asap if you want November’s box – there’s a waitlist!)

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. How long have you all been on waitlist. I signed up in October

    • I signed up on October 11, and I just got off the waiting list on November 14. You should be off soon!

      • Have you gotten your box for November yet or even a tracking number? I got an email on the 14th also that I was off the waiting list and they charged my card but I haven’t heard a thing from them since and I haven’t gotten anything.

        • I also got an email on the 14th and they charged my card and I haven’t received anything. Also, when I sign into my account it prompts me to subscribe. This is my first time subscribing so i am not sure if that’s normal.

          • Yes, its normal. I’ve been subscribed for over a year and it still gives me the subscribe option. As long as it says “active” under your subscription, you’re good to go. Also, it takes up to 10 business days (excluding weekends and holidays) from the time they take your money until you get a shipping notification and it can take another 5-10 business days to have your box in hand. It is frustrating but so worth it.

    • I got on the waitlist in october and signed up during september. So it shouldn’t take too long for you to get off but honestly it varies from person to person.

  2. You guys are very ungrateful, go to ipsy if you want something different . Not every high end brand has to be what is labeled in the stores, I know a lot of MUA’s that use brands i don’t hear of . Smh . Reply to my comment idc , I’m not going to read it anyways .

    • Im replying to your comment because I agree 100%! Well said ❤❤

    • There are plenty of waitlisted ppl more than happy to take the place of unhappy people subscribed to boxycharm so unsubscribe already. Being a new subscriber myself I am thrilled with what I get and if I don’t like something in my box I’m happy to give it away to someone that does want it.

    • Yes!!!! Glad someone said it.

  3. It’s a win win-the mascara alone is worth more than you pay for the box, just look at the other stuff as “free”. If it’s something I can’t or won’t use, I gift or donate. 21$ a month is not a lot at all, and for what you get? Worth it. Bigly. I pay for my sub and my daughters every month, and it’s still worth the 42$.

    • THATS WHAT IM SAYNG !! you only pay $21 for it . Get over it .

  4. I usually like what I get in my boxycharm boxes each month. But I’ve only subscribed for the last 6 months and feel like I have way more than enough eye shadows. I hope they start mixing it up soon!!

    • It’s a blush palette, not an eyeshadow!

  5. P.s. double check your meta-data for this page. When sharing the link, the title is wrong.

    • Please send us more skin care products Boxycharm

  6. I am going to unsubscribe from Boxycharm. In each box there is only one item I like and I accumulated so many unwanted items that it’s just driving me crazy. I will save my money and buy stuff that I actually want instead of getting tons of unnecessary items that I will never use.
    I hate the hoarding tons of makeup items mentality. I have already unsubscribed from other beauty boxes.
    It took me a while to decide about Boxycharm. I can’t just keep accumulating stuff just because they might or might not put a good item in a box. I can keep the approximately $240 that I spend on Boxycharm yearly and spend it on makeup or skincare items that are actually worth the money.
    When I add up the amount of money I have spent on other beauty boxes, I realize I have wasted crazy amount of money.

    • Yes! Please unsubscribe!!! I want off this damn wait list! I was subscribed for over a year and unfortunately had to miss ONE month and have been dying to get my Boxycharm back!

      • I already did. I hope you are off the waitlist soon.

        • Thanks so much!

    • Bye Felicia!

  7. I wish these blushes were matte (they look like they have a sheen to them) but boxy never disappoints so I’m excited! Hurry up December!

  8. I already have a lifetime supply of blush, however these colors look great for using as an eyeshadow, especially the Unstoppable color.

  9. Glad I got a stab at the LE boxes. I keep up on launches. I check and I check often.

  10. I am in the minority here as I really hate this box. This is my 2nd box with BC. Am I able to pause a box? Or do I just cancel or swap it?

    • No they don’t have a feature to skip a box. You either have to cancel your sub or get in on some swaps.

    • Im not thrilled yet either. Mascara is always good but i literally just got a new one on Saturday! No excitement about blush. Hopefully some other good stuff is coming.

  11. i love this mascara!!

  12. Tarteist mascara is a great item…but The Real Her blush doesn’t live up to Boxy’s quality standards if you ask me. The Real Her brand is in every single subscription box and that’s the only reason we even know the brand name. Otherwise, it’s just a sticky, cheap formula with a larger price tag because it was in FabFitFun and Rachel Zoe boxes.

    • I agree that all the RealHer products I have gotten in subscription boxes suck and are made in China. I think Boxy figured it was time to throw in a blush palette and RealHer could do it the cheapest for them.

      Boxy isn’t motivated to make the December box great. They have a huge waitlist that people have been on for months and ran out of the limited edition box too fast. They can’t keep up with their own demand.

      • Realher products are vegan, natural, and gluten-free. They are also cruelty-free and made in the US. Plus, they give 20% of their profits to AAUW.

        • Real her products are made in china. I just looked at the lip kit box from fabfitfun. They claim to be cruelty free, paraben free, uses natural ingredients but not 100% natural. Also not vegan.

          • Just a friendly, FYI:Regarding products made in China, they CAN BE CRUELTY free and still be made in China. It only matters if they are SOLD there. If you can buy a product in China, that proves its not cruelty free.

        • ALL Real Her products are made in CHINA–they are imported to the US and shipped to California.
          I will be cancelling Boxy due to the number of Chinese products and the Limited Edition fiasco.

    • I agree about RealHer-it’s not high end in my opinion and the RealHer eyeshadow palette they had sucked. I hated it. I got a lipliner and liquid lip from this brand in other BC boxes and they were just ok. Not sure why BC loves this brand so much but….
      That said, the blush palette does look pretty. We’ll see.

  13. Not to thrilled with either…..hoping for a nice red lipstick

    • YES! I was excited to see I would be getting a pretty red lipstick from Birchbox last month but it was literally a one use foil packet that you can get as a sample in a magazine! I was so disappointed!
      Sephora’s This month was pretty, but also super small. Red lipstick is so underrated anymore with all the ‘nude lipstick’ hype. I was put on the waitlist in mid-October and I’m guessing this will be my first box, or if not, doesn’t look like I’ll be missing out on too much so far.

  14. This blush kit looks great – the colors look like they would mix well together to create looks from bold to natural. I’m looking forward to this month’s box!

  15. Favorite mascara, but unsure about the blush. It looks pretty, but I have hated everything I have tried from the Real Her brand. Oh, well, will probably just donate it. Box is worth it for the mascara alone

    • I agree. Of all the real her products I’ve tried, I really dislike them all. I have two palettes and two lip kits, both just aweful quality. And ironically the lip kit I received from both boxy and fabfitfun were the same color name, but two completely different shades of nude. Go figure.

  16. I thought we would have a boxy LE box spoiler by now. It’s been the day or two they told us to wait for one to come out. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    • This!! I would love teasers of the LE box. Not to mention a hint of when they’ll ship… This month? Next month? Tomorrow? 🤞

      • LE box ships November 20th. It’s on the LE box page on the website, date was on there since it went live

      • There are 2 spoilers up right now!

        Cover FX custom enhancer drops in the shade Blossom (if I recall correctly) and a Bare Minerals lip gloss

  17. I am thrilled that Real Her is cruelty free and made in the USA!

    • SAME

  18. am i the only one to roll my eyes at most the comments below?

    • Why? They’re pretty positive.

    • Exactly. I’m so disappointed over the box crash, no hint of what they plan to do…and the spoilers for a December box don’t look so good…it’s Christmas, you would think there would be a phenomenal box this month if any.

      • Agreed!!! After not getting a chance to get the LE box….I expected more!

        • Same. An underwhelming subscribers box for December after the LE fiasco? Really?

  19. Even if it isn’t the best quality, as long as the colors are good you could always add a little more to your face. Blush is so easy to overdo, I’d rather do a couple swipes to get it right then have it go on like a clown and have to fix it. It pretty much lasts forever also so I never need to buy it. What comes in my sub boxes is more than enough

  20. I don’t care for either product, hopefully I’d be waitlisted until January. Still so sad I didn’t get November’s box.

    • Same! I signed up October 16th with the hope of getting November’s. No such luck. It would be just my luck to get signed up on a month I don’t care for though. Both of these are misses for me. They really need a ‘skip a month’ option so people who don’t want that months box don’t wind up back on the waitlist.

      • I would have actually tried reactivating again…try it near the beginning of the month (I.e. early December). Sometimes I think that they either forget about you or the system kicks you off. I resubscribed Nov.7th after canceling for Oct and I was taken off the wait list almost immediately.

    • what did you want from november’s box? I just got mine – nothing crazy special in it.

  21. Nice!

  22. Hi,
    I’m a ” waitlister’ too. It’s my choice, as I unsubbed when they were sending out the bare tins of OFRA items..

    I don’t mean this in either a rude or a haughty way at all, but does anyone know if they give maybe slightly more consideration to those who have been members before? I was a member for a long time, and cashed out my Charms for 2 nCLA nail polishes, a really nice cream blush and a lippie. ( lot of charm points there, IOW).

    I know IPSY does give former subscribers first priority and I might have thought Boxycharm does because IPSY does..
    I kind of ” float through” various subs every year or so until I have reached saturation point.
    ( I imagine a lot of us do after so many years now).


    • No- you leave, you go back to the end of the wait line. This is fair as people have been on the wait list for ages and if you choose to leave- they get to try the box. If old subs got priority- then new subs would never get a chance.

    • No, existing subscribers do not get first priority. If that were the case, it would never give first timers a shot at this sub. You have to wait your turn like everyone else.

  23. Another excellent product! Thanks, Boxycharm! I haven’t tried anything from RealHer yet and I am thrilled to have the chance. They are nice colors too.

  24. I would love this box!

  25. Awesome! I’ve been with Boxycharm almost 2 years now. I can honestly say I’ve never really had to gift anything away. I’m usually very happy with everything I received. Some of my other subscription boxes I can’t say the same thing about. And also, we receive more full sized products than others of boxes out there. Even if I receive something I don’t like or want, it’s not a big deal because with 1 or 2 of the items it far exceeds the cost of the box anyway. I’m really not losing anything. The blush palette looks pretty. Can’t wait!

  26. I’ve never heard of that brand but I was just thinking of picking up another one of the abh blush trios with basically these exact colors so I’m pretty excited that worked out haha. I much prefer face palettes to eyeshadow so I’m thrilled

  27. Yayyyyyy excited for a blush palette and Tarteist lash paint is my 2nd favorite mascara and I’m about out so perfect timing Boxy!

    • Me too! I need a new blush set. I like @real her products. First time from @boxycharm 😍

  28. Perfect timing as always from Boxycharm…I’m about out of mascara and could always use more blush in my life.

  29. Totally loving this! Was thrilled to get the mascara and the blush is making this a great box so far! I know this is strictly makeup but where are the face moisturizers in boxes this season?

  30. I still on wait list since October, I really want Nov box but still not change my status yet. So sad.

  31. So excited to be getting a blush palette! These colors look great! I just hope that the quality of blushes is better than some of the other RealHer stuff I’ve gotten this year in sub boxes. I haven’t been a fan yet, but I really want to love this.

  32. Awesome! I just recently starting adding blush back in to my routine (lots of redness in the face I felt I didn’t want to accent). Crossing my fingers I GET OFF THIS WAITLIST!!!!

  33. These spoilers are a snooze fest to me. Yawn…

  34. Love this!

    • Me too!!!

  35. Blush looks lovely. I always want to unsubscribe and I just can’t when I see these spoilers.

  36. Woahh, Boxycharm never disappoints.. I didn’t even purchase anything from Sephora VIB sale because I look at everything and go, “ohh I either have something like this or Boxycharm would send it.”

    I have been eyeing a different blush palette but held off buying because all color swatches looked pretty similar and Boxycharm just swoops in like a Genie and makes my wishes come true. Now I just hope this palette works for me.

  37. I never considered a blush palette, I’ve really enjoyed blush this last year and I’m glad it’s not a highlighter kit as pretty as those are I prefer blush!

  38. Ok I nailed it lol when people said stuff about getting palettes till December I said it could be a blush palette coming instead of eyes. Three would count as a pallets right ?? Lol

    • Yes! Good job!

  39. I like getting a blush palette but I haven’t been wowed by other real her products I’ve received in subscription boxes. I’ll give it a go. I hope it’s better than the eyeshadow palette we got a few months back.

  40. Great way to switch from eyeshadow palette.

  41. Wow, I looked this palette up on realher website and the colors look great with nice variety. I wonder if we will get a blush brush also….

    • Oooo I’d love a blush brush!

      • Me too!!!

        • Me too!!!!

  42. So gorgeous! And the first Real Her item for my collection yay! So excited! ❤️ 🤗 ❤️

  43. In love once again BC! These spoilers are amazing

  44. Nice!!!

  45. Nice boxy never disappoints

  46. I’m loving these spoilers.

  47. Ugh, loving these spoilers, Boxycharm I can’t stay mad at you.

  48. Yay happy we are getting a blush palette=)

  49. Ooooo… December is looking lie the first month where I might keep the majority of items instead of swapping them 😁

    • Girl I was thinking the same thing! I never seem to keep everything but I think this is the first time I’m like yeah I can use both of those & im excited about them too!

  50. Those colors are pretty. I’m waitlisted right now. I’ll be sad if I don’t get this month’s box but hopefully I will at least be able to get December.

    • Wow!
      There we have it ladies, this is probably the first out of hundreds of commemts where someone on the waitlist wasn’t so vicious and mean about it. 💝

    • When did you sign up?
      I submitted for mine on Oct 13th and I’m still waiting. Didn’t get off of it for November and I don’t mind since I didn’t really want that box, but I’ll be happy if I get in for December too!

      • FWIW, I signed up on Oct 2nd. I sent an email on Nov 5th just to simply confirm that I was in queue for the waiting list since I had seen so many comments about other people who signed up before me being skipped. I was finally off of the wait list on Nov 7th.

        • Does that mean you are getting November’s box? I thought you’d get November’s box if you got off the waitlist by the time they charged (1st – 3rd of the month).

          • Nope, you can be taken off the waitlist any time during the month – I’ve been taken off like on the 28th of the month before and gotten that month’s box!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!