BoxyCharm December 2017 SPOILER #2!

Does anyone know when we will be getting the third Boxy spoiler?? I just got off the waitlist and will be getting November’s box and now I’m stalking the internet to find out what’s next….

How long have you all been on waitlist. I signed up in October

You guys are very ungrateful, go to ipsy if you want something different . Not every high end brand has to be what is labeled in the stores, I know a lot of MUA’s that use brands i don’t hear of . Smh . Reply to my comment idc , I’m not going to read it anyways .

It’s a win win-the mascara alone is worth more than you pay for the box, just look at the other stuff as “free”. If it’s something I can’t or won’t use, I gift or donate. 21$ a month is not a lot at all, and for what you get? Worth it. Bigly. I pay for my sub and my daughters every month, and it’s still worth the 42$.

I usually like what I get in my boxycharm boxes each month. But I’ve only subscribed for the last 6 months and feel like I have way more than enough eye shadows. I hope they start mixing it up soon!!

P.s. double check your meta-data for this page. When sharing the link, the title is wrong.

I am going to unsubscribe from Boxycharm. In each box there is only one item I like and I accumulated so many unwanted items that it’s just driving me crazy. I will save my money and buy stuff that I actually want instead of getting tons of unnecessary items that I will never use.
I hate the hoarding tons of makeup items mentality. I have already unsubscribed from other beauty boxes.
It took me a while to decide about Boxycharm. I can’t just keep accumulating stuff just because they might or might not put a good item in a box. I can keep the approximately $240 that I spend on Boxycharm yearly and spend it on makeup or skincare items that are actually worth the money.
When I add up the amount of money I have spent on other beauty boxes, I realize I have wasted crazy amount of money.

I wish these blushes were matte (they look like they have a sheen to them) but boxy never disappoints so I’m excited! Hurry up December!

I already have a lifetime supply of blush, however these colors look great for using as an eyeshadow, especially the Unstoppable color.

Glad I got a stab at the LE boxes. I keep up on launches. I check and I check often.

I am in the minority here as I really hate this box. This is my 2nd box with BC. Am I able to pause a box? Or do I just cancel or swap it?

i love this mascara!!

Tarteist mascara is a great item…but The Real Her blush doesn’t live up to Boxy’s quality standards if you ask me. The Real Her brand is in every single subscription box and that’s the only reason we even know the brand name. Otherwise, it’s just a sticky, cheap formula with a larger price tag because it was in FabFitFun and Rachel Zoe boxes.

Not to thrilled with either…..hoping for a nice red lipstick

This blush kit looks great – the colors look like they would mix well together to create looks from bold to natural. I’m looking forward to this month’s box!

Favorite mascara, but unsure about the blush. It looks pretty, but I have hated everything I have tried from the Real Her brand. Oh, well, will probably just donate it. Box is worth it for the mascara alone

I thought we would have a boxy LE box spoiler by now. It’s been the day or two they told us to wait for one to come out. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I am thrilled that Real Her is cruelty free and made in the USA!

am i the only one to roll my eyes at most the comments below?

Even if it isn’t the best quality, as long as the colors are good you could always add a little more to your face. Blush is so easy to overdo, I’d rather do a couple swipes to get it right then have it go on like a clown and have to fix it. It pretty much lasts forever also so I never need to buy it. What comes in my sub boxes is more than enough

I don’t care for either product, hopefully I’d be waitlisted until January. Still so sad I didn’t get November’s box.

Nice!

Hi,
I’m a ” waitlister’ too. It’s my choice, as I unsubbed when they were sending out the bare tins of OFRA items..

I don’t mean this in either a rude or a haughty way at all, but does anyone know if they give maybe slightly more consideration to those who have been members before? I was a member for a long time, and cashed out my Charms for 2 nCLA nail polishes, a really nice cream blush and a lippie. ( lot of charm points there, IOW).

I know IPSY does give former subscribers first priority and I might have thought Boxycharm does because IPSY does..
I kind of ” float through” various subs every year or so until I have reached saturation point.
( I imagine a lot of us do after so many years now).

Thanks,
Mandy

Another excellent product! Thanks, Boxycharm! I haven’t tried anything from RealHer yet and I am thrilled to have the chance. They are nice colors too.

I would love this box!