BoxyCharm November 2017 SPOILER #4!

I was on the wait list since September 25th till today (November 1st).

i signed up september 22 and i am still on the waitlist. such a bummer.

Since boxy is gaining popularity like crazy, it may take up to a month. Last year, I think I signed up around June/July and I was on the waitlist for a couple weeks. It’s worth the wait, I promise. There really isn’t a set time for a waitlist.

I was on the waitlist for almost a month. I was charged on Sept 26th and I got the Sept box. So there is a chance you will get the nov box, when you come off they charge you right away and you get 2 emails one saying you are off the waitlist and the other saying your order number

For the most part, yes. If they are an item that wont be in every box they usually say that’s the case.

Ikr..got enough lippies,liners and hilighters..I need primer! I’ll still gladly take what they give me but a primer would be nice.

Sometimes in the boxes they will have two products where someone may get lets say, a mascara, while another may receive an eyeliner. For instance, Octobers box variance was a nail kit and an eye chubby stick. I received the chubby stick while others got the nail kit. It’s all randomized but I do wish there wasn’t that variance. I think it kind of takes away from the review process of the box overall and the products you receive in the mail.

With that being said, I generally love the subscription. It’s the first and only one that I ever truly intended on trying and I’m SOOOOO happy that I did. I’ve only gotten Septembers and Octobers boxes, fingers crossed that they get better. I have a lot of palette’s though already, so I’ll likely gift the kitten palette if I get it, same with the mascara.

There are different variations of the boxes, but most probably yah.

Fenty is so new I kinda doubt it. They showed the Tarte mascara in that video I belive. ..thiNK the rest was just filler. But? Ya never know? They have had better and better and better bra ds and boxes each year and month so may e they will have Fenty?

When they do pallets everyone gets them. And unless it’s a variant item,like some dinky lippy or liner,we all get pretty much the same thing.

I love this setting spray! Definitely keeps my makeup looking fresh and glowy for hours. I sometimes don’t need to touch up if it’s not humid.

Me too!!!! I’m thrilled we are getting these. If we get that mascara I deeply excited!!!! But the brushes definitely are a gift this makes leaving for budget reasons especially hard. Perhaps if I get a raise. Trying not to be weak!

For a fab cruelty free beauty box I highly recommend Benevolent Beauty Box! It’s all full sized items & always a great value; it’s essentially the CF equivalent of boxy! Their customer service is very impressive too, which is an added bonus!

I believe these are all guaranteed items. They will usually disclose if something is a variant item. 🙂

There isn’t any actual glitter in the setting spray. It just gives a subtle glow.

I’m with you, Denise. I never got into the highlighter thing. I must have a hundred of them now! I’m too old for sparkle, shimmer, glow, etc. I like matte powders, thanks 😉

I hear you. I’m almost..cough..40 and as much as the little girl in me loves shiney things,I’m starting to get some fine lines near my eyes and shiney and sparkles and shimmery doesn’t help at all and just starts looking sorta dumb the older u get. Yet I’ll still use it. Lmao.

No i totally agree with u enough of glittery glowy makeup belongs on eyes and lips only. Like to see more matte blush bronzers powders and sprays. The only thing they do matt anymore is lips which makes them look like 90 yr old ones. They meed to make the box more geared to 30ish that way the young and older girls wld be able to use most of the products right now it seems like its geared to 18 year olds

Yes I must agree on this one. Please everyone, don’t take this as complaining; I have been a loyal subscriber for four years and I love Boxy. But I too am patiently waiting for this shiny glowy trend to fade away. I am over 40 and the sparkly stuff just makes me look wet and brings out the lines. I really don’t think it’s that attractive on youthful skin either. It looks unnaturally shiny. In my opinion, nothing beats fresh, natural, velvety soft skin. Sometimes less is really more.

I so agree. I don’t know why it was decided we need to make our faces look dewy or glowing, yet our lips should be matte and dry. Call me old fashioned but these looks don’t make a person look healthy, just weirdly shiny in the wrong places.

I am with you 100%! I don’t like glowy, mica laden, shiny makeup on my late 40s combination skin. Too many sparkly eye shadows and highlighters lately.

Oh man! I didn’t read the reviews… I have been dying to try a setting spray too! But I would have loved a matte version also! Well at least now I know not to try it and swap instead! Bummer!

Liz, I’d love a detailed review of this item!!! Prettyyyy please!

No, I agree. The glow trend just makes it look like everyone just finished working out, lol. It doesn’t look dewy on women who are over 40, it just makes us look mid hot flash in my opinion. On the other hand, for a holiday party, I will go all glitzy and sparkly so at least I can get some use from the spray and highlighters, just not an everyday thing.

I sooo agree, sick of highlight, shiny, sparkly, illuminating etc.

You can always use it to wet your eyeshadow brush for shimmery shadow to help with fallout or even spray it on a beauty blender so you can apply it only to your cheekbones. I’m not a huge fan of the sparkle either, these are just some things I plan to try!

I try to do that with my black Friday hauls for Christmas. It hasn’t worked a single freaking time, I tear into those packages as soon as they hit my mailbox lol