Posted by on in Boxycharm Spoilers, Featured Deal, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 65 comments

BoxyCharm November 2017 Possible Spoilers!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.


Ready to help me with some Boxycharm spoiler sleuthing?

Here we go!

Boxycharm recently did a makeup tutorial video where they used some products from past boxes and some products that we haven’t seen in boxes before. And they hinted that at least one product shown was going to be in the November box.

Here are the products they used that haven’t been in past boxes:

So we know it’s at least one of those items, but we can’t narrow it down anymore, right?

Not so fast!

First, I hate to say it, but I’m guessing Fenty Beauty foundation won’t be in any future Boxycharm boxes because it is shade specific. (Fingers crossed for other items from Fenty, though!)

But, now we can cross-reference this November list with this spoiler hint we got from iluvsarahii:

So, I *think* it is safe to say that the CoverFX illuminating setting spray and/or the Tarte Tarteist Lash Paint Mascara will be in the November 2017 Boxycharm box.

What do you think of the Boxycharm spoilers? Do you agree with my conclusion?


If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more. (And sign up asap if you want November’s box – there’s a waitlist!)

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I am so excited Boxycharm is the best ! I am Loving my October box and Now November has me drooling! I Love you

  2. I would be so excited to get the Summer Solstice collection from Colourpop! But I’m also gonna be happy with that setting spray we’re getting. I’m fast running out of my current setting spray and would love to have a new one.

  3. Well you were right, we’re getting the CoverFX spray 😀

  4. Omg CoverFX please!!

    • I heard its definitely the cover fx spray. I’m so excited about!

  5. No way will they have Fenty any time soon – there’s literally NO reason for Fenty to be there. They’ve probably had the most successful launch in years of any brand. I’m betting either the brush or the First Aid beauty product.

  6. Pumped if its coverfx! Also happy about all the veronica mars pics for this spoiler 🙂

  7. I love BOXYCHARM ! They are hands down the best beauty subscription box available! They do an excellent job of sending out items for established subscription box junkies and noobs.

  8. Crossing fingers for cover fx 🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞

  9. If we get the setting spray I hope mine doesn’t leak all over the box like the last one did a couple of months ago. The bottle was completely empty and the black ink on the box was wet and got all over my hands.

  10. Boxycharm’s been killing it!

  11. Previously the CoverFX setting spray was listed as a spoiler for an upcoming box, we just didn’t know which month. Guess we do now! I’m excited for that, I’ve heard it’s pretty amazing.

  12. You also said we would be getting a pallet in the rest of our boxes for the year and look how that turned out. Really bummed out about the spoiler that never was.

    • The pallet spoiler came straight from Boxycharm-it was on their Facebook page. It’s easy enough to cancel if you’re not happy. There are lots of people on waitlist!

      • No reason to be rude Teisha. Being disappointed doesn’t mean she should cancel her subscription ffs.

    • That’s how tons of people interpreted it, until we realized it wasn’t quite right. One month without a palette and this is how people are reacting? Ok

      • Ive noticed ppl on various sites on the web mad because there’s no eye palette or mad because there’s a highlighter or mad because there’s a lippie. IDGI. Not everyone is going to love every item in every box, they can personalize each one for 21$ a month. BC does a damn good job with the high end brands they DO get, and while I’m not crazy over every single thing that comes in my sub for that month, the good always outweighs the not so great, and I can set it aside for a gift for someone or a donation. It’s makeup-not life and death and nothing to complain about really. It’s just not that serious. I’ve heard ppl say they’ll be “so mad” if the get the liquid Becca product and all I can think is-you’re getting a high end highlighter essentially for free (practically) and you’ll be “mad” if it’s the liquid? Oh. Ok then. I don’t mean to offend anyone-I just don’t get that perspective is all.

        • I’m with you Allie, I just don’t understand how people can get that upset over it, I personally would prefer the powder because I have oily and textured skin and I’ve noticed that the liquid doesn’t play nice with my skin. Even if I don’t get it though, I’ll save it for a Christmas gift for a friend or something.. Just the Dr Brandt’s is a major score for me 😊 😊 😊

          • @Lori I’m totally with you. If I got the liquid and not the powder oh well-I didn’t pay 41$ for it so I’m not out anything, and someone is going to get a fancy Xmas gift. The nail kit is a little weird, I think, personally-but hey, I’ll give it a try. The Dr Brandt is a HUGE win!!! I use the microdermabrasion we got in an earlier box religiously!

          • @Allie…yup..the nail kit is a lil weird but I guess I can use it for traveling? You never know when you will need something like that when traveling and from what they say it’s small enough to fit in your bag so I think that’s a good idea 🤔🙄😉 I think my bff will love me this x-mas if I get the liquid Becca lol 😂 but the exfoliating scrub will be used for sure! I unfortunately signed up for Boxycharm after they gave out the last Dr Brandt item but I got a sample from Birchbox or allure, not sure which one hmmmm I have an addiction 😂 😂 and it’s so nice so I’ll definitely use this full size exfoliator myself 😍

      • I hope that my post wasn’t misinterpreted. I love Boxy! I was as just trying to say it wasn’t Liz that promised a palette every month🙂

  13. I don’t know why I ever cancel this subscription. Every single time I do I come crawling back again lol.

  14. I’m guessing colour pop summer solstice. It needs to be a palette since there wasn’t one this month.

  15. Totally love the Veronica Mars gifs! 🤔😍 I’m with you Liz, CoverFX or Tarte could be both… I’m keeping my fingers crossed 🤞 for both personally 😍 I really love my Boxycharm box every month and if ever I can’t use something I have friends who would love to get a free luxe item 😏😏😏

    • Your friends are very lucky!! 🙂

  16. I really do NOT need yet another setting spray; I’ve never been on the swap boards but that may give me the push to finally sign up. Having said that, I love Boxycharm and am sure I’ll love the rest of the box.

    • Agree! I feel like setting sprays are such a gimmick, one is one too many. I am excited about the remaining contents though! I would be thrilled with a Tarte full size mascara!

  17. As much as I wish we could get the Fenty foundation (or any foundation!) that would mean having a profile or having a selection option for your shade. I was just thinking yesterday when putting foundation on how much I wish I could try a different foundation from Boxy.

    I’m cool with the Cover FX setting spray and Tarte mascara. Wishlist: maracuja oil from Tarte and timeBalm Primer from theBalm!

    • Oh yes! Maracuja oil would be awesome!!!

  18. I would like some First Aid Beauty cream, actually.

    • Same here! I LOVE that stuff!

    • Same third. I love FAB products – their coconut priming moisturizer is my favorite moisturizer ever! Love the shimmer it gives me.

  19. I have oily skin the fx sounds scary to me

  20. Love love LOVE Veronica Mars! ❤

  21. I feel like an old curmudgeon, but I prefer my spoilers in black and white….I suppose I will just wait until they are released (sorry Liz).

    • Yes, I would have to agree. That was quite a seizure-inducing post.

  22. I just signed up but I’m clueless on what to expect with the waitlist. How long are people typically stuck on it? When do boxes ship?
    I promised myself I would drop a sub before I picked up another. All I’ve managed to do today is add an extra scent each month on scentbird and signed up for boxycharm. I’m batting 1,000.

    • Also, if I just signed up tonight could I still possible get Septembers box?

      • I mean October:/

        • i signed up for boxycharm at the beginning of october and im still on the waitlist

    • A: I waited for 1 1/2 months, but these days I hear the wait is much shorter.

      • Thank you:)

    • I signed up at the end of September. Hoping to be off the waitlist soon and get the October box!!

    • Hey! I just got the notice today that I’m OFF the waitlist. Took about 2 months, but it’s worth it. So excited!! Just have patience. It’ll happen.

  23. Better than October, but I need solid spoilers before I re-commit.

    • vanessa: Really? You won’t commit to Boxy until you hear more spoilers?
      Please, what beauty box is better than Boxycharm?

      • I agree with you about how good it is and I just subbed. I keep seeing each month how good the products are and I waiting and always kicked myself. I get allure, dermstore, birchbox, and benevolent beauty. I just unsubbed glossybox. Each month I see the reviews for boxycharm and I think how much better the selection is then my other boxes! EVERY SINGLE MONTH

      • bmc3713: Not everyone thinks that Tarte products are all genius (I don’t), and not everyone wants a 10th mascara, 5th setting spray, and 27th highlighter. The point is NOT to amass every beauty item in 18 different brands.

        • I absolutely understand this sentiment – to a degree. I guess my thought process is that these are subscription boxes that are mostly supposed to be surprises. We aren’t paying a low price for all of these products to receive everything our hearts desire. Multiple products from cult brands are the risk we take. If we want to have specific products, then honestly, aren’t we better off to simply buy what we want and not try to rely on a sub box to fulfill this desire every month when it’s absolutely impossible for them to do so?

  24. I’m considering subscribing to boxycharm and I saw that last year they did a special black Friday promotion here. Do you guys think it’ll happen again this year? Should I wait? Thanks for any help/input!

    • I LOVE BOXYCHARM! It is my favorite subscription box, along with Allure. The value is AMAZING, the products are always good quality, and have been getting better, and I personally have had good luck with CS. If you want Boxycharm then sign up for it, if they decide not to lift the wait list then you are going to miss out on some great boxes. If they do a special promo then they usually do something for existing customers too. My best friend and her Mom signed up in early September and they just got off the wait list this week. My Personal opinion, if you want it, sign up. If you’re willing to pay full price then it means you want it. 😀 (I pay for 3 mo or 6 mo if available with the boxes I order so I don’t have to remember to pay 5 separate things every month, I stagger them so I pay 1longer, more expensive payment and a couple of smaller month to month subscriptions monthly, but not EVERY box, EVERY month…. hopefully I explained that so it’s understandable, LoL.) Hope this may help in some way?!?!

    • Erin, do you remember what the Black Friday boxycharm deal was?

      • Wrong Erin, but this is the only Black Friday deal I could find for 2016:

        Use coupon code MSABLACKFRIDAY to get a BONUS full-size OFRA Blush in “Paradise Pink” in your first box (the November Box. $29.95 value.) This offer only applies to prepaid 3, 6 & 12 month subscriptions

        This was the only Black Friday deal Boxy offered, but there was no wait list.

    • I first subbed around cyber monday last year. Boxy typically doesn’t do discount codes, sometimes they will have an extra item, but honestly, they don’t get into like the glossybox game of sub now deals, so I don’t think you need to wait. They are likely waitlisted now, but with the holidays, they will likely be removing the waitlist soon, so if you don’t like the guessing gamr of when your sub would start, keep an eye out. Msa does a great job of broadcasting when there isnt a waitlist

  25. Spoilers are great and all, but I’m here for the Veronica Mars.

    • Me too!

  26. Spoilers, Boxycharm, and gifs, oh my! Liz–I hope you have as much fun putting these posts together as we do reading them 😀

    • 🙂 I did have fun with this one! Anything to relive a little Veronica Mars is always good, too!

      • That is so awesome. I love Veronica Mars too, Liz!!

  27. I wish it was the foundation too but it’s not going to be so of the two most likely possibilities I hope it’s the mascara.

    • I think the first subscription box to get a Fenty Beauty item is going to get a TON of new subscribers 🙂

      • The lady at the register featured a gently item for September

  28. All of those spoilers look great. The colourpop eyeshadow set would be awesome and the cover fx setting spray.

  29. I want foundation, but since BC does not have profiles, it would be hard to match shades, and this product is out. I hope it is first aid beauty.

  30. If it was the moisturizer and foundation I’d resub.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!