Facebook PixelThe Crafter's Box Subscription Review - March 2017 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Crafter’s Box Subscription Review – March 2017

Emily Cosnotti
ByEmily CosnottiApr 3, 2017 | 7 comments


The Crafter's Box
4 overall rating
1 Ratings | 0 Reviews

The Crafter's Box is a box for people who love to make. Each month, you'll get unique crafting supplies and tools along to make an artist-designed craft for your home. In addition to the physical items in the box, membership includes access to an online community and an online workshop taught by an experienced maker.

My Subscription Addiction pays for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

The-crafters-box-march-2017-0002 The-crafters-box-march-2017-0003


The Subscription Box: The Crafter's Box

The Cost: $65 a month, or $60 a month with a 3-month subscription.

The Products: A curated box of craft materials and specialty tools assembled in collaboration with an artist/maker.

Ships to: US (for free), $10 to Canada and $20 everywhere else.

Check out all of our The Crafter's Box reviews and the DIY + Crafting Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!


Each Crafters Box is accompanied by online support in the form of a video tutorial, forum, and  Maker Chat.


This is always very Instagramable box!


This month's project is chunky crocheted baskets.


Every month, The Crafters Box chooses a maker, crafter, or artist who curates the box and teaches you how to complete the project. This month's artist is Jessica Carey.

Welcome to our workshop with artist Jessica Carey. In this project we are exploring basic and intermediate techniques to learn how to crochet with an emphasis in creating chunky knit baskets for the home. Jessica's workshop reviews the tools and materials included in her curated kit, introduces basic crochet stitches, teaches crocheting 'in the round', and explores different pattern and building ideas for basic to advanced

Jessica Carey is the owner and designer behind The Hook Nook and has been desiging and releasing her own finished work and patterns for six years.


This month's box includes seven skeins of bulky weight yarn. The yarn is a synthetic and wool blend to add a bit of structure to the baskets. The box also includes a wooden 10mm wooden crochet hook, a stitch marker, a tapestry/yarn needle, and a stitch glossary with basket patterns.


The card also tells us more about the wooden crochet hook included in the box. I love that The Crafters Box collaborates with small business makers whenever possible and worked with Woolaty in Kiev, Ukraine for this tool.


The Crafter's Box included a printed stitched guide that helped me learn crochet stitches. I really appreciated the printed guide vs. an online guide so I could work on this project without a screen in front of me!

The-crafters-box-march-2017-0012 The-crafters-box-march-2017-0013 The-crafters-box-march-2017-0014 The-crafters-box-march-2017-0015

There are photos for each step for each stitch as well as finished product photos that helped me pick which basket I wanted to make.


At the end of the booklet are patterns for 3 baskets along with a quick stitch key. As a knitter, I'm used to seeing patterns written out this way but for someone new to yarn crafts and patterns, this may have been trickier. The Crafter's Box website had a video from this month's maker where she talks about products in the box and goes over basic stitch techniques. Watching this video and seeing how to get started with this project was a HUGE help for me, and I'm so glad videos are part of this crafting subscription.

The-crafters-box-march-2017-0017 The-crafters-box-march-2017-0018

The box included all the notions needed for the project in a nice cotton drawstring bag. I like that this box always goes with reusable materials wherever possible instead of plastic.

The-crafters-box-march-2017-0019 The-crafters-box-march-2017-0020

Here's a look at the wooden crochet hook. The hook was easy to use and felt good in the hand. Wood tools like this one can be harder to use for beginners because they grip the yarn fibers a bit more closely than plastic or metal tools do.


I'm glad they included a yarn needle for weaving in ends. I have one somewhere but it would have taken me forever to find it!


A stitch marker is really helpful when working in the round, as it can be very hard to tell where your last row ended and just where you should start your next one.


So much yarn! I'm impressed that they included so many skeins so I can make a lot of baskets for my home. I like the neutral color choices of off-white and almost-black charcoal. The yarn is a wool blend with synthetic mixed in for structure.


Here's a look at the white yarn. It is a nice, natural looking white.


I like this dark, not quite black yarn a lot! The stitch glossary shows mixing the two colors for a striped design on the baskets but I like each color by itself.


Here's my finished project! I made the small basket with handles because I like small things. I taught myself to knit as a teenager but could never quite handle crocheting. For some reason, crochet was a yarn art that eluded me and I've always been so frustrated that I couldn't seem to wrap my mind around it! This box and the project inside forced me to really sit down and figure out this whole crochet craft and I'm so glad I did! I think the little basket I made is so cute and will hold tiny craft supplies so well.


I like those tidy stitches all stacked up! I made this basket in only a few evenings, it was very quick and fun to make. It took less than one skein of yarn to make this basket, so I have so much more to make from this box.

Verdict: I really love The Crafter's Box! I am grateful to this box for finally forcing me to learn to how to crochet, I'm so glad to have been able to tackle this new skill and make something useful for my home. The materials, design, and packaging for this box are always thoughtful and well done. I have very specific taste and this is exactly the crafting box for me. This is not a box for those looking for high value for a low purchase price but is instead for those who love design and crafting and who want to make something new for themselves or their home every month. I like that they often include enough materials to make multiple items, so you can even make more as gifts.

What do you think of The Crafter's Box?

Starting at $65.00
Active Deal
Get 25% off your first box!
Subscribe Now
The Crafter's Box is a membership community for those that love to make. Monthly we send a curated box of specialized tools & carefully sourced materials (everything needed) to build a beautiful, grownup craft project and to master a new artistic technique. Our projects are hosted by an expert a... read more.
Emily Cosnotti
Emily Cosnotti
Emily is a design enthusiast who loves beautiful objects. She's really into vegan snacks, corgis, home goods, and minimalist makeup. She is currently fostering a healthy subscription addiction.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I really like the style of this box, and that the end product is something substantial. It seems like a lot of craft boxes involve making really tiny items. And sometimes even if the supplies are worth the price, the end result isn’t something you’d actually pay anything for. These baskets are lovely though and would be something I’d be proud to have made, if I ever managed to make one as nice as yours.

Any guess about the value though? I don’t do yarn crafts, so I have no idea. I know this box isn’t about value, but it would make a difference to me to know whether the supplies were premium quality or if it’s more that you pay for the instruction.

Reply ButtonReply

Emily Cosnotti


Value can be a little harder for boxes like this because I’m not sure where all the materials are from. To me, the yarn seems most similar (and maybe even is) Lion Brand Wool-Ease Thick and Quick yarn which you can get at Jo Anns for around $9.99 full price. However, like most things, the price of will vary depending on where you buy it, somewhere like KnitPicks has cheaper pricing for pretty good quality but you’ll pay a lot more at a local yarn shop.

If I go with Jo Ann’s pricing I would guess the value of materials at around $78.
Here’s my breakdown:
7 Skeins of Super Bulky Wool-blend Yarn – $69.93
Pack of stitch markers (you can’t buy just one) – $2.49
Woolaty (etsy shop) wooden crochet hook – $4.35
Pack of tapestry Needles – $1.49

Aside from actual materials, if you shop for individual crochet patterns on Etsy, you can find patterns around $5.00 each. And most stitch techniques can be looked up online for free once you know what you’re looking for from the pattern.

I’ve always found the quality of the materials in The Crafters Box to be better than average so I think the overall value is a combination of quality of materials, instruction, and curation. As you said, they always send substantial crafts that have value and that I want to display in my home.

Hope that helps!

Reply ButtonReply


Thanks Emily! I think I’ll give this one a try. It looks like the crochet box is waitlisted, but subscriptions for the next box will open on the 10th.

I subbed to For the Makers for a long time – it was actually my first ever sub! – but the items didn’t hold up, and then they went out of business awhile back. I’ve been looking for a good craft box, but none of them really felt like ‘me’ until this one.


I still can’t do crochet. I have tried a dozen times. I am OK at needle knitting and pretty good at loom knitting but crochet is just not something I seem to be able to grasp. So of course I am impressed with your basket!

Reply ButtonReply

Emily Cosnotti

Thanks! I had pretty much accepted the fact that I would never be able to crochet – I can usually figure out any craft if I put my mind to it but not this. I threw several fits getting this thing started because I just couldn’t tell if I was doing it right. I watched the video a ton of times and once I got it started, everything made sense. I still prefer knitting but I like how fast crocheting is in comparison.

Reply ButtonReply