Posted by on in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 55 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have Box May 2017 Box Theme + Coupon!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-04-26 at 1.13.23 PM

We have theme spoilers for the May 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have box!

The inspiration for the May box is:

Screen Shot 2017-04-26 at 1.14.40 PM

Any guesses or hopes for items based on those themes?

If you haven’t signed up yet, use coupon code MUSTHAVE5 to save $5 off your first box! 

(Regularly $39.95. Check out our POPSUGAR Must Have reviews to see what has been in past boxes!)

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Did anyone else see the email about 1 in 5 people will be receiving an extra mystery box this month? Just wondering if anyone noticed it and if their package weighs more than 2.9 like mine? Liz do you know anything about this?

    • I thought it said 5 lucky winners, not 1 in 5.

  2. Hey Liz do you know when their will be spoilers for this box?

  3. Got my tracking number today as well–no est. arrival date tho’!

  4. Got my tracking number, my box will be here Friday but still no spoilers…

    • Wow! I havent even been billed yet

    • Me too! Will be weird (not in a bad way) to get it without knowing any of the contents.

    • Please let us know what you get !

  5. Tracking came today! Feels like they keep getting earlier each month 😊
    2.9 lbs

  6. My guesses are (insert your preferred items here) so that everyone has something to be thankful for!

  7. Nothing can be more awesome than the dental floss from last month.

    • This made me laugh! I absolutely love that dental floss and would never have heard of it if it hadn’t been included in the PS box.

      • I am so jealous!! I never git mine, waiting on a replacement 😥

    • Dental floss is everything! Love it!

    • Last box from that Black Friday sale. I didn’t buy these boxes for dental care. Have lots of that already

  8. Ohhhh so excied!!! Cant wait for spoilers!!
    “Look good”= at least 1 beauty item/ accessory 😊
    The other hints can go any direction but i think PS has been hitting it out of the park (subbed since december and each time i get a box its even better than the last …which i aways think “ok this is my all time favorite!”)

  9. For the most part I love PopSugar boxes. However, I hate these super-general, meaningless theme spoilers. All they do is get everyone riled up and then people are upset when their expectations aren’t met.

    • What she said.

      • yeah, what she said too….I don’t mind a theme but give an example an I’m much more likely to buy it. For now – I’m not going to. I have all those themes in my life now.

    • Exactly

  10. My first thoughts were picture frame, thank you notes, and a journal. With Popsugar you never know what you are going to get. These spoilers or themes are so random usually. Here’s to hoping for a good surprise.

    • Oh please no more thank you notes. I have so many from sub boxes. Maybe I’m just hella ungrateful but I don’t find cause to write that many thank you notes…

      • “Maybe im hella ungrateful” that made me LOL.

  11. Does anyone know when PSMH next limited edition box will becoming out? I loved the resort box so I’m hoping for a spectacular summer LE or some other LE next month (or June).

    • I second that I can’t wait for their next LE Summer Box! I loved last years and loved this years Resort LE except for the Bluetooth speaker which barely has any range

  12. When does this box usually ship? It’s my first month and their website didn’t say when they typically ship out each month. Thanks.

    • Usually around the early part of the 2nd week of the month. However, shipping is slow so don’t expect your box to arrive quickly.

  13. Did we just skip to fall already, or what??

  14. This so does not sound like the sunglasses I was hoping for. 🙁

  15. Ughhh nooooo. I don’t want another photo album , my family is me and the bf so lord help them if I get something “family” oriented. Yeah, I’m canceling after my 6 month subscription is up if I get greeting cards , photo albums or picture frames. Just give my $39.95 to charity . I’d rather that than a bunch of sentimental crap in a box.

    • Maybe you should stick with beauty subs so your not disappointed. Lifestyle boxes usually do include those types of things.

      • Ditto.

  16. C’mon PSMH and send me some new shades! 😎😎😎😎

    • I would love some new sunnies too!

    • I would love some shades too

    • It would be nice if they did but last month had a gift card for sunnies…..Even though the gift card was less than anything listed on the site.

      Honestly I didn’t even use mine :X

      • I used mine and paid $24 out of pocket but the sunglasses are very good quality and super cute!

  17. Pretty please Popsugar, do NOT send family for a visit next month! That’s the last thing I need!

    Seriously though, I bet it’s flowers or something for mother’s day. At least, I’m hoping!

  18. maybe HGTV’s “flip or flop,” tarek and christina el moussa, will curate this upcoming home-themed box.

    • I hope it was a sarcasm 🙂

  19. Guesses- frame, journal, greeting cards. Hoping it’s none of these though…

    • What if it’s all of these!?!?!?!

      *screams and hides in the corner*

      • 😱😱😱😱😱 noooo no more paper products! More purses:)! Kitchen items! Sunglasses yesssszz

  20. I think it sounds nice. My family means everything to me and I love stuff that reminds me to be thankful for what I have. And it says look and feel good. That could be hinting at jewelry or skincare. Is this box still available or sold out like the last couple of months?

    • It’s available

      • Thanks. I just may finally cave and sub. For a couple of months at least. The March box was okay but I wasn’t much impressed with April.

    • Beautiful words! 💕

  21. Journal?

  22. We just got home decor items and the Kate Spade photo albums. I love that they finally did more home items but now I’m hoping for accessories! I have loved all their Jewelry and hope for more along with scarves too! I wonder if it’s anything Mother’s Day related but if so it wouldn’t be shipped in time

  23. I wish they would stop sending useless emails like that and actually show us a spoiler item. Half of the times, some of the items they pick don’t even fit the theme.

    • SERIOUSLY!!!

      And this specific theme collection turns me off from the box even more. Gratitude?? Sounds like more thank you cards. I’ll never run out of thank you cards… Family?? I’m a single woman… Memories?? I’ve gotten so many picture frames from subscriptions, and they never fit with my decor. And god forbid it’s a journal… I’m up to my eyeballs in journals!! And I only subscribe to a handful of boxes!

      • I SO agree!! I’m up to my eyeballs in useless creams, frames, cards….etc !! Send the GOOD samples!

      • I go through thank you cards mighty quick! I sell on poshmark, tradesy and swap on here and tend to send a thank you card with everything I mail out. Just a thought on one way to elevate something and get rid of them =)

      • Yall…what if “Memories” is one of those cute modern polaroid cameras?????

        *Wishful thinking*

    • Totally agree! And the theme and the theme words are rarely even very cohesive.
      I love love love peonies. I get so excited when I see them in a “spoiler “thinking it’s a hint to what’s in the box. But even their spoiler images rarely match what’s in the box.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!