Posted by My Subscription Addiction on in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 60 comments

Play! By Sephora April 2017 Box #591 FULL SPOILERS!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We have a FULL SPOILERS for the April 2017 Play! By Sephora box ending in #591!

Box #591:

Screen Shot 2017-04-14 at 12.31.16 PM

Source: Instagram

Box #583:

Screen Shot 2017-04-13 at 12.24.39 PM

Box #575:



What do you think of the spoilers?

To find out which box you’re receiving at the beginning of each month, follow these instructions:

If you log in through a browser, not the app, and go to my account > account details > online orders and open the play! Order Details, you can see the “item number” next to the image.

If you haven’t signed up for a Play! by Sephora subscription yet, the waitlist is currently open! If you sign up now, your first box will be the April box.

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Written by My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I got box 583 and was really disappointed, probably the first time ever since I started my sub. I feel like I’ve gotten or tried all of these products already so it didn’t feel too special of a box. But I do love purity and glad to have a travel size now that I can refill. I loathe that Smashbox primer so def going to put it up in the swaps.

  2. I got my box 591, call it a box of disappointment, really another sample of Smashbox photofinish primer?? they must have a warehouse full of the stuff because it comes in everything. I did live chat and told them how disappointed I was with this box, also told them that if it was my first box it would have been my last. They credited me the $10 but that’s not really point, I like these boxes and usually for the most part I find out about new products and then buy them.

  3. I am disappointed with box #591. I was expecting to be excited but I wasn’t. the primer is great because I just got into foundation but the box is still an ugh…maybe next month

  4. Always pleased with my boxes and this months is great too!!

  5. Argh, another disappointing month. Why must you always send eyeliners when I don’t ever use one?! Finally cancelled after 3 months of disappointment.

  6. I haven’t been impressed with my bags the last couple of months. I think I’m going to open up a spot for someone else.

  7. Not too excited with my box #591 this month. I’ll give it one more month to see if I’m thrilled. This was the third box I’ve received. I’ve cancelled ipsy after 4 months and I didn’t like birch box at all, I cancelled it after 1 shipment.

  8. Maybe it’s just me, but did anyone else think the Juliette has a gun perfume sample remind you of rubbing alcohol?? LOL I have liked all the perfume samples from Sephora up until now. Hopefully next month’s is much better.

    • I love that perfume it does at first but a few seconds later it’s my all time favorite

    • it seems like a hair product to me! I said to my husband “why would I want to smell like hair oil all day?”

  9. Darn it! I was hoping for the Water Drench. I got 591. 🙁

  10. Did anyone else’s Play card have an expiration date of April 30, 2017?

    I noticed mine did, which was strange as they normally expire the last day of the following month.

    • Mine has the same expiration date.

  11. oooh lots of spoilers! but i’m sure that when you sign up now, you won’t get the April box since a rep confirmed that they bill between the 1st and the 4th of the month

  12. Got my Sephora Play ( 591) and Birchbox in the mail today. Sad to say, I am disappointed with both boxes. Birchbox didn’t include the fee palette they advertised and had a promo code for, when I re-subscribed. Not thrilled with most of the Sephora samples and that bag is the ugliest one yet! Only good items are the Ole Henriksen Truth Serum and the Dr Dennis Gross Ferulic + Retinol Recovery Peels.

    • I got both mine today too and I didn’t like either. The eyeliner was tiny! Birchbox missed my free palette too, but I contacted them and they ate going to send it. What a bummer.

  13. So disappointed with box 583 🙁 I don’t think I’ll be using anything. Was really hoping just for the Fresh Vitamin C. IF anyone would like to trade let me know

  14. I am getting 591 and after seeing the spoilers, I am not very happy. My first bag was last month and I was disappointed with all the glow items. The only thing I could use was the glam glow, even though I had to mix it with a darker sheer face tint. I hated the perfume and the dark brown, heavily pigmented eye shadow. I was really hoping this one would be better, but it isn’t. I don’t wear foundation, so I don’t use primer. I use a cream cleanser for eye makeup removal. I don’t use eye pencils ever and I cannot use a glycolic peel, because of skin reaction. I don’t like Juliette has a gun. I have tried it. So, that leaves me with the Vitamin C serum. So, it isn’t worth 10 dollars to me. I corrected my birthday year on my account yesterday. I may wait one more month before cancelling.

    • I want to add that I finally received the 591 bag and I love the vitamin c serum. I noticed an immediate improvement in my face after two uses. Guess the bag was worth after all.

    • That truth serum is worth it! Believe me you won’t regret that one. It is a top seller at Sephora and you will see why. I had amazing results!

  15. I’ve been a play subscriber for a little over a year, and this is by far the most disappointing box so far,however, I think the graphics are the cutest they have ever been though! I love the bag and the little beauty map images! Not excited about this one at all. 🙁

  16. #591 Super happy with this box, I had the Dr Gross in my shopping cart deciding. I love black eyeliner, primer & makeup remover.. save em for travel or when I run out.. so far never need to buy it so a win, now the box needs to get here!

  17. Am I the only one with #074?

    • You’re probably looking at the wrong number. It’s the last 3 numbers of the order number. Hope that helps.

    • log into the desktop version of Sephora and go to your orders. Click on the order number for play and you should see a seven digit item number. The last three digits of the item number are the box you are getting.

    • I was confused too at first when my number didn’t match any boxes and I realized I accidentally looked at the order number which is the wrong number to look at! xD

  18. This seems better than 583. I wanted to try the serum and I really like sampling peels. But nope, a much lower-end face wash… ugh

  19. I received box 591 today. This is the first total clunker I have received from Sephora. Four of the products I have previously received, do not like, and will not use. Two out of six samples are actually interesting to me. I have gradually canceled all of my other subscription boxes because they trended towards products that I will never use or repeat products. Sephora is my only remaining box. Hopefully, the next one will be better.

  20. So I have box 583. Very disappointed. Probably will not use anything. I really wanted the fresh sample. That’s about it. I’m on the waiting list for the swap. But if anyone wants to trade who gets the fresh vitamin C, let me know we can work something out:)

  21. This is my box. Not super thrilled, but everything will get used so I’m happy. I do like the Not A Perfume, so glad to get that.

    • Don’t like Juliette has a gun at all and it seems it the brand I always get in the Play box.

  22. I have box 621.
    Big variety of boxes this month!
    I’m not super into any of these so I’m going that one is better.
    And would like it to be the one without that smashbox primer. I don’t wear foundation so it’s totally useless for me. My skin also hates it.

  23. I am so happy this is my box – I love skincare. Everything will get used except the primer, which will go up for swap. Excellent!

  24. I may be mistaken, but I feel like we’re getting into repeats, aren’t we? I’m almost positive I already have received the smashbox, muf eyeliner and the eye makeup remover…and I’m now getting them again. Hmmm.

    • That smashbox primer has been in a ton of beauty boxes, I’m tired of it.

      • agreed

      • I want to write a letter to every beauty box company out there right now to say STOP trying to make us like the freaking smashbox primer! I probably have 20 of these damn things and it is not a good product, its pretty much useless. Whenever I see one included my rage monster comes out to play. I am sick of it.

        • +1 Rage Monster – I hate this product and have a ton of it for the same reason, lots of tubes in sample boxes and I just got a bunch of packets of this as samples during Ulta’s 21 days of beauty. Please please please stop giving this away. It’s the booby prize of beauty.

  25. It’s interesting I have aging skin as a concern and normal skin for my profile (I’m not oily or dry) and I got the water drench instead of the anti aging product. I’m ok with my box I just find it interesting…

    • Hyaluronic acid is actually good for aging skin. 🙂

  26. Love Dr Dennis Gross pads. Would love to swap for more. 😊

  27. That means that 609 is going to have the fresh mask I would think? That would make me SO happy!

    • Just curious – What are your skin conditions for 609?

      • In my profile I listed combination skin. And I think dullness or uneven skin tone for skin conditions??

    • Gosh I’m just glad to finally hear someone mention box #609 – I thought I was all in my lonesome over here! And I would be mighty happy to get the Fresh mask!!!

  28. Finally! I kept waiting for 591 to show up, since this is mine. I’m happy with it! As most of us with subs, I’ve got the Smashbox primer already. I like it though, so that’s fine. Everything else is new to me!
    I’ve got another of perfumes by them previously, I think from Ipsy, and liked it. Not a fan of the bag this month, but I don’t get this for the bag! Lol

    Now I just need my box to ship! It still says processing.

    • I with you 100% on all of that. My box is even still in processing too lol :p

      • Mine is also still in processing, which I found odd since I usually receive it around this time of the month. I called Sephora over the weekend and at first dealt with a rather nasty customer service person. Because of her attitude, I spoke with a supervisor, who informed me that they were temporarily out of boxes, and she was going to check with their service center to see what was going on. Because of the fact that my box hadn’t been mailed and the nastiness of the first customer service rep, she also added 100 points to my account and sent 2 deluxe samples to me. I would highly recommend you call and see what is going on with your box and make sure that they follow through on it. If you do end up getting the run-around, speak to a supervisor!

  29. I really wanted the Kate Somerville product 🙁 but since this is my box not too shabby it’s better than most I think .

  30. This is my box.

    I’m guessing that the OLEHENRIKSEN Truth Serum will be the 0.5 oz size. Love Vit C serums so this is a win for me.
    I have yet to use the smashbox primer. Have a couple of full size versions in my stash that I have not open yet, so I don’t see needing to use this anytime soon. Been on primer overkill fro these boxes like everyone else it seems!

    • Same. Anything Vit C is a great box addition.

  31. Wish I had this box. 591 is the best box out of the bunch. Hands down .

  32. I am not happy that I got box#583 I don’t need any of the products! I don’t like the primer, or eyeliner. I don’t need another Leander or moisturizer 😫

  33. I have #591 and I really wanted the water drench. Not a fan of the wrinkle peel.

  34. This is my box, and I’m pleased.

  35. I have 583 and I’m disappointed because the purity line inflames my skin. Would anyone want to trade purity for dr. Dennis gross or exfolikate?

    • I would trade you exfolikate for it! But I’m not on the swap site or anything so I have no idea how we would go about this lol

      • You can email me at jessicahapak at me dot com and we can work something out!

  36. I’m happy with this box.

    • Me too, can’t wait!!! 🙂

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!