P.S. I Love You Subscription Box Review – February 2017

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.


P.S. i love you is a bi-monthly fashion and lifestyle subscription service that caters to the plus-size woman. The PS stands for Plus Size! (It took me a while to get that.)


My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out our review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)


The Subscription Box: P.S. i love you

The Cost: $47 per box, one shipment every two months, with discounts for longer subscription commitments

The Products: Five items curated around a theme, specific to plus sized women from categories such as beauty, health, fashion, and themed surprises

Ships to: U.S. only, except Hawaii, for free

Good to Know: P.S. i love you currently serves women’s sizes 1x – 3x (14-24) with plans to extend sizes further in the near future.

Check out all of our P.S. i love you reviews and the Women’s Clothing Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!


This is the note that came with my package, listing the contents and why they were selected for this box.


Little Black Dress by Love Squared – Value $34.99 (originally $59)

I think it was a really bold move for PS i love you to send an LBD as their clothing item! It could have backfired so easily! Fortunately, they chose a really universally flattering dress, so I’m betting it works well for the majority of subscribers. I love it! I like the way it fits and feels (poly/spandex blend), and I think there are loads of ways I could style it.


Altoids Arctic Peppermint Mints – Value $1.75

It’s actually a great idea to include mints in a night out themed box. Altoids are pretty severe, but they get the job done. I did try one, but as is the case with Altoids, I only really tasted pain, haha. I can’t really tell much difference between flavors.





EcoTools Six Piece Day To Night Set – Value $16.99

Is it weird that my favorite thing about this set is the bag? I love the cork detail! These brushes are really nice, too. They are soft and seem unlikely to lose bristles anytime soon.


Flowery Texas 2-Step Nail Buffer – Value $3.99

This is such a cute nail buffer! I am not a pro when it comes to my nails, but it seems to work pretty well, too. One side is for buffing and the other is for polishing.

Heel to Toe Feels Like New Foot Softener – Value $2.59

I just started using this, so I can’t really speak to how effective it is yet, but I can definitely tell it is moisturizing on my feet. It has beeswax and lanolin in it, and it’s supposed to heal dry, cracked skin and calluses.


Beyond Belief Korean Skin Care Green Tea Firming Mask – Value $2.99

I am also not an expert at masks, but I tried this one almost immediately to test its firming powers. First of all, this was one slimy sheet mask. I’m not usually squeamish about textures, but it was hard to keep it on for 20 minutes! The results were great, though. My skin felt super moist and dewy, and yes, maybe even a little firmer.



Lauren Conrad Gold Bracelet – Value $8?

I couldn’t find this exact bracelet for sale online, so I’m using the value of similar Lauren Conrad bracelets. This bracelet is really pretty, and I’m so pleased it fits my wrist! (I’m wearing it with the dress in the picture above.) I think it goes very nicely with the dress.

Verdict: This was another fantastic box from PS i love you! I think this might be one of my favorite subscriptions! Everything is always thoughtfully curated, and everything always feels like such a nice treat! I think they did a great job choosing the perfect dress this month, and the brush set was another favorite. The value this month comes to $71.30, which is great for a $47 box!

What do you think of PS i love you?

How do subscribers rate PS I love you?

No subscribers have rated this yet
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to PS I love you? Add your rating now!

Written by Anna Rodriguez

Anna Rodriguez

Anna has been a fan of subscription boxes since joining Birchbox in 2013, but didn’t become a true addict until discovering subscriptions she could share with her children. Her favorites include Kiwi Crate and Fab Kids.

Posted in P.S. I Love You Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: ps i love you | 14 comments


  1. The dress looks amazing on you!

    • Thanks Manali!

  2. That dress is the best piece of clothing I’ve seen on you. Looks great!

    • Wow, thanks Ami!

  3. This was my first box by them and overall I am happy with the box. I haven’t tried on the dress yet but, it looks very pretty on you. I love the brush set since it is the perfect size for travel. I got a different bracelet in silver but I haven’t decided if I am going to keep it or put it up for swap.

    • Thanks Cindy. Yes it was a fun box!

  4. That dress is sooo cute!!

    • Thanks Sara!

  5. This was my first PS I love you box and I’m quite pleased, especially since I got for $37 with a coupon. I’m fairly tall and I wish the dress was just a little bit longer on me, but from the waist up it’s so flattering my legs won’t get much notice. I thought they did a great job of thinking through the theme and including products that speak to it. My brush set wasn’t quite as impressive — a 4-piece travel size set (also Eco Tools) but I have zero complaints. I’ll be sticking around to see what they come up with next.

    • Glad you liked it Amy!

  6. Well darn it, yet another clothing box to add to my wish list! I’m going to borrow your phrase about Altoids only tasting like pain, because I’m so with you there. I also love the brush case. I really enjoy your reviews, thank you so much!

    • Thank you Kimberley, that means so much to me!

  7. That dress is exquisite on you!!

    • Thank you Jordan!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!