Posted by My Subscription Addiction on in Boxycharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 137 comments

BoxyCharm March 2017 FULL SPOILERS!!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-01-19 at 4.30.41 PM

We have FULL SPOILERS for one of the variations of the March 2017 Boxycharm! (Thanks to larlarlee!)

One version of the March 2017 Boxycharm subscription box will include:

Screen Shot 2017-03-05 at 5.44.22 PM Screen Shot 2017-03-05 at 5.44.33 PM Screen Shot 2017-03-05 at 5.44.46 PM

What do you think of the March 2017 Boxycharm spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers for future updates!

FYI – According to Boxycharm, if you sign up before the end of any month, that month’s box will be your first box. 

Written by My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I noticed a survey on Boxycharm. I never saw it before. Just completed it. It asks what I would prefer and my age skin color and eyes and hair color.

    • I did the survey too but it doesn’t save the preferences like ipsy does. I clicked on it again and had to redo it. Not sure if they are going to start doing more personalized boxes but I sure hope so.

      • I hope so to

    • I saw that a couple days ago, too.

  2. I got a Japonesque lipstick instead of the Real Her liquid lip. I was disappointed because the Japonesque, though valued at $20 I think, is a screaming bright Red. Second month in a row now to get unwearable clown red lipstick. Love you Boxycharm but please send nude or pink lipstick!

    • Wow that is extremely disappointing. Did you get the RealHer lipliner? I don’t understand why the popular YouTuber’s and bloggers get the matching variation and us “regular customers” get leftover crap because I know a few months ago they sent out Japanesque sp? liquid lipsticks and the other variation I’ve seen was the Ampilash or whatever the brand is, mascara and I know that’s been sent out previously as well. Its not fair that everyone is getting leftover junk.

      • Yeah, not cool. I got the red Dirty Little Secret liquid lipstick from the August 2016 box.

        • I’m sorry you got that. If it’s anything like their regular lipstick I am not a fan. The regular lipstick smells like licorice which I absolutely hate and the formula sucks. If boxycharm doesn’t step their game up and wow the crap out of me next month, I’m done. And I swore id never give up boxycharm but they are getting worse and worse. I saw a newer subscription box on Instagram that have only been around since December I believe and it’s the same $21 a month gimmick for 4-5 full sized items and it’s called Lola Beauty Box and I’m seriously considering switching. They have zero product variations (possible color variations) and since they don’t have as many customers, I’ve heard they have kick ass customer service. Might be worth a shot.

        • I saw that in some unboxings. If it shows up on my box at will be two month in a row of duplicate items from the last six months. One would hope the new subscribers who just got off list would receive items others already have.

      • Yes I did get the Real Her liner in I Am Unique which is really pretty, wish I could have gotten the matching lipstick. I wouldn’t mind the Japonesque lipstick in any other color, it seems excellent quality! But two red lipsticks in two months is too many!

        • I’m contemplating trading boxycharm for the Lola Beauty Box sub instead. Its the same $21 gimmick for 4-5 full sized products and no product variation. Which makes me sad because I never thought id think of giving up BoxyCharm but they just don’t care about their regular customers anymore.

  3. Got my box today. Very happy. The brush was much much thicker then we got a month ago. I will use it for powder. The eye shadow was much pretties in person then on the picture, the colors are intense but i have an idea how i would use it. The lip liner beautiful burgundy. The liquid lipstick is like a gloss but not that was pictured, different company and it is light red. Another successful months with Boxycharm.

    • That’s disappointing that it wasn’t the RealHer liquid lipstick. I really wanted to try it. I hope I get it :/

      • I was ok with it because I have it coming in FFF box, but I can see how it feels disappointed. I rather to get other lipstick.

        • Oh, that is not cool how their initial shipment was the matching RealHer lip kit so it would post all over social media and youtube and THEN they subsequently send out to some others non-matching sets because they ran out of supply.

          Sending some people matching lip kits and others part of the lip kit and another product is not cool. They should manage inventory better.

          • You are so right that is nowhere near fair. I will be extremely disappointed if I don’t get the lip kit after seeing so many people get it. And I am not signed up to FFF so I was looking forward to this and I’m super bummed that there are variations in the product and not just in color.

  4. I just got my box (no shipping notice) and got a variation.
    Instead of a lip liner, I got Ampilash Mascara Serum.

    • Omg that’s crazy!! I haven’t gotten a shipping notification either yet! That makes me worry because id much rather have the lip liner vs mascara 😭😭

      • The mascara is a good one, so dont be too disappointed

    • I also got a variation. I got the Realher lip liner but got a red Dirty Little Secret liquid lipstick instead of Realher lipstick. Now I have a lipliner with nothing to match it. 😐

    • I have amplilash from a previous box. I absolutley love it for when you want long, defined eyelashes, but not super caked on.

  5. All the pictures I see being posted on IG have lipliner ‘I am loved’.
    I cannot see the liquid lip color names.

    • Wait, I can see some. All the ones I can see are ‘I am a rock star’.
      So far I don’t see any variations.

  6. FINALLY got my February box today! Absolutely awesome and worth the wait! Can’t wait to get the March box!!

  7. Hey looking for advice from boxycharmers. I have a lot of charm points due to an item that was damaged and they could not replace so gave me points So total amount of points amounts to about $50 plus free shipping but I literally don’t like anything in the charm shop, which seems to have boring nail polish and leftover makeup. So how often do they put me stuff in the charm shop? I don’t know whether to wait for new merchandise.

    • Sometimes it takes a while to find decent items in the shop. I think they put a few new items in there monthly but not sure exactly what part of the month. Maybe you can email them and ask. Their email is

  8. anyone else’s box ship? mine weighs .6 – I wonder if the only variation this month will be in lip color. It seems like sometimes they run out of the item that most people get and sub in something similar, so i could see getting a different brand of liner/lip color. Like how last month it seemed most people were getting the royal & Langnickel brushes and then I got a repeat of luxie brushes.

    • Dang I would have loved to get that Luxie set again. I got a Sedona lace trio with a blending brush, angled eyeliner brush, and a spooley/angled eyebrow brush. I think the lip products are the only variations because if I remember right, in the first 3 spoilers on boxys IG, it says every charmer will receive those products.

      • I meant a bent eyeliner brush not angled lol

    • Mine shipped and it weighs .5 lbs. Hmmm. Wonder if there are other variations.

      • Hi all😃 Is there a way to see if your boxed shipped from their website?

        • Unfortunately no there’s not. You have to wait to get a shipping notification via email. I had to email them around the 17th of last month and they sent me my shipping notification because I never got one. Normally, the boxes start shipping around the 10th.

    • I’m concerned because I have not received my March box. I paid a 1 year subscription upfront. I have emailed them and gotten no response. I’m extremely disappointed as this is my favorite box I receive. Any advice??

      • I don’t think anyone received their March box yet.

      • Uh… No one has. You will get it by the end of March.

      • boxes dont ship out until at least the 10th of each month.

    • Mine weighs .6

    • My box is .6 also I wonder what the variation is I hope it is not something that isn’t shown. I just cancelled my subscription anyway because it was due to renew and after this months box I don’t think I can handle another 6 months of Boxy Charm. They need to step up their game a little and get back to what they use to be lately the boxes have been not so great in my opinion.

    • Have you gotten your box yet? I just got my shipping notification today and it says mine also weighs .6. Just curious to see what everyone is getting! I saw a box variation on IG that included a L’oreal product that I would not be thrilled to get! The anticipation is killing me!!! 😂😂😂

      • I’m dying to know too!! Just got my shipping info this morning and mine also says .6. I have a feeling getting my box this late in the month is going to be super disappointing because all the good stuff already went out. If I get a Loreal product I will be really mad because I could buy that at Wal-Mart and the whole point of sub boxes is to get to try new and different brands.

  9. It’s nice to see some different color eye shadows for a change. I love Boxycharm! Even if I don’t like a particular color, it’s always nice to try out, and if all else fails I throw any unwanteds in my Halloween costume box. You never know when you’ll need one of those off colors.

  10. How long does it take to get off the waitlist? I’ve always been able to unsubscribe whenever I didn’t really care for a month’s box but ever since boxy has gotten more popular, there’s a waitlist now and I don’t know when I’m ever getting off it!

    • I just got off the waitlist March 2nd and I went on it Feb 11. So around 3 weeks. 😃

      • I’m definitely contacting them asap because I signed up in January (around the 18th) and I’m still on the wait list 😞super disappointed…..

        • I signed up Feb 28th and was off the waitlist 3 days later. I saw from other people’s comments that it might help to email them, so the day I signed up I sent them an email asking how long the waitlist is because I was looking at other beauty boxes… 3 days later they took me off.

          • Thank you I’m definitely going to do that! I’m thinking I had to have just got lost in all the sign ups or something because this is crazy,lol 😉

        • I was only on the waitlist for 3 days. That is super disappointing – I’m sorry!

        • Just use another email address…speeds up the waitlist process with all of them that use it.

          • It’s official after a very long two month wait (signed up mid January) I’m finally off the wait list!!!!!! I’m SO excited, not thrilled about this months box,but still so looking fwd to it and months to come!!! 🎉🎉🎉😄😍

          • Yayy!! Congrats and welcome to the boxy fam 😀🎉🎉

          • Thank you I’m so excited, I get ipsy already and have been really satisfied with it, but hear boxy is so much better, it’s a nice little treat for moms that don’t usually do much for themselves and I love that it gets me to try products I normally probably wouldn’t,like the eyeshadow in this months box, I’m going to give it a try 😉

          • Yes girl you will love Boxycharm!! I too have ipsy and about a month after I started getting ipsy I had to try boxycharm and I’m in love. Sure I won’t love EVERY product, but I’ve been getting it since October and I have yet to be disappointed. As a mom of a 1yr old and an almost 7yr old, I literally never spend money on myself so ipsy and boxycharm is like Christmas twice a month in my mailbox and I get so excited to get something other than bills lol!!

  11. Is this the same crown fan brush I received in the February box? I love it but I don’t need two.

    • Its def not the same brush. This one is bigger and denser. You can use it for almost any powder. I have a similar one and I use it to set my face or contour or blush. Some people use it for highlight, but the brush is too big for my liking for highlight. There are no rules to makeup so use it for whatever you’d like 🙂

  12. I’m hoping if I get a lip color, it is something like this one. Last month I got a terrible lip color but I do like this one. I do agree that these are more fall type colors, but I’m not mad at them.

    • Last month’s lip color was awful. Mine was orangey-pink, and definitely not attractive!

  13. I am so pleased with this!! Those eyeshadows are 100% my coloursso I know I’ll get tons of use out of them, that fan brush is unlike anything in my brush collection so I’m pleased with that, happy to try the Smashbox primer, and I always like lip products… 🙂

  14. I love it! Definitely having box envy – bad enough to see if anyone who gets this variation would consider selling it to me to be honest…

  15. This is the 1st time in all my BoxyCharm boxes that the value has been below $100. If I get items above, it will be about $75. I still LOVE them but after last months whopping $155, I must say even I (Miss Positive) was a little surprised. Love the products just a bit baffled. I
    loved last months Real Her lipstick. Where else can you spend $19 & get $75? Love to all you beauties out there!

    • I’m coming up with $102 value. The eyeshadow palette is on pre sale for $39.99 + $16 primer + $18.99 brush + $15 lipstick + $12.50 lip liner.

      • The eyeshadow has been on sale for I believe $24.99 until after the 2nd spoiler. My addition may be wrong but that palette was less until second spoiler. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still happy. I may have forgot to add the lip liner but my post was positive. I was just surprised by the difference & I’m the first to admit I makes tons of mistakes.

  16. The box this month looks good! Not gonna lie, it isn’t as exciting as when I saw February’s reveal, however, I am very much looking forward to receiving that fan brush. The bristles are full and lush, not skimpy like some other fan brushes i’ve seen before. The lipkit however, looks like a repeat from what FabFitFun suscribers will be getting in their spring box, so that’s kind of a bummer. I do hope though, that I get different colors at least! Love that we’re getting a smashbox item though!

    • I hope I get different shades from FabFitFun also! I don’t mind getting the same formula as long as I don’t get repeat shades. Hopefully RealHer will keep in mind that many people likely subscribe to both boxes and send different variations for each?

  17. I wonder why they didn’t save that palette for October. It seems more appropriate at that time. Not sad that I cancelled.

  18. I don’t own a fan brush so I’m looking forward to that! Love the shade of the lip stuff in the above photo, but those eyeshadows, IDK….
    I’m super pale and I don’t think I can pull off orange yellow and red

  19. I’m super excited! I love the shadows and real her products

  20. I am super excited! The value is definitely there considering Boxy Charm only sends out full size products! The smash box primer alone covers the full cost of the subscription, considering at Sephora its $36…. and I love Naked Cosmetics!! Can’t wait to get this.

    • Dont want to be the one to disappoint you, but the smashbox primer is not full sized it’s the travel size and it retails for $16. We get 4-5 full sized products meaning we are guaranteed 4 full sized items, while the 5th item can be deluxe size or travel sized. This is still an amazing box tho!

      • I was just about to ask if we were getting the full size or travel size. Thank you 🙂 !

        I agree that is still an amazing box (although I am not as amazed when I compare it to previous months).

  21. I love BC so much! You definitely always get your money’s worth! I hope I don’t get the same lip as fff other then that…. I am stoked about this box ❤❤❤

  22. Crap. I totally regret resubbing.

    • Im willing to buy the box for cost + shipping if you are interested.

      • I’m good with that idea.

  23. Glad I’m out because this box is sort of lame. 1) shadows r hat are sooo autumn it hurts. I hate trios and palettes that aren’t a full look, making me have to pull a second palette out to complete a look. There’s no base tone or anything I’d put in my crease as they are all shimmer. 2) primer that ulta has sent maybe 10 rimes. Plus ipsy plus birchbox. And its blah smashbox has better primers why not those??? 3) brush ok so thaf would be nice but a whole box of things I’m not into for one I am is wasteful. And I have so much lipstick and liners I could open my pwn shop. Hard pass for my tastes. Still amazing value but not anything I meed or want.

  24. I signed up in Feb but was wait listed. I hope u can trade this box or sell it in eBay. I don’t need more make up -.-

    • Maybe look into Beauty Fix? Boxy is pretty heavy on makeup items.

  25. Ahhh I’m so excited! Cannot wait for this box!! Don’t knock these products til you try them ladies and gents. You might be pleasantly surprised with these items if you give them a chance 🙂 step outside your comfort zones, try something new, and have fun!! That’s what makeup and subscription boxes are all about 🙂

  26. I just subscribed and am on the waitlist. Has anyone been able to get off the waitlist the same month they were put on? As in, is there a chance I could still get the March box?

    • Yes i got off waitlist around 21st of February and received all the same great products as everyone else.

    • I could sell you mine for the $21 plus shipping if you want.

      • I would totally be interested in buying your Feb box. I really, really wanted that one but got off the waitlist too late!

        • I was talking about the march box. I swapped most of my feb box. I only wanted the dr. Brandt item, so I swapped everything else. Sorry.

    • Last month I was waitlisted in the 3rd…taken off and charged on the 15. I’m still waiting to get my February box, but it’s on it’s way to me! So to answer your question, yes it is possible to get off the waitlist and get this month’s box!

    • Yes, I was wait listed the beginning of Feb and got my box 10 days ago.

  27. Ugh! I knew last months box was too good to be true. I actually liked and used everything in it, not this months. I will be cancelling now.

  28. I love it! I was hoping for another lippie and wanted the Real Her for February but got the gloss instead. I’m happy with this box.

  29. I Love it! I Love it! I Love it! 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘💋💋💋💋💋💄💄💄💄💄💥💥👀👀💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜 My fave BOXYCHARM

  30. I love this box super happy with everything coming I considered getting fit fab fun just for the real her lip kit but $40 for a box not worth it to me boxycharm never disappoints thanks again for another great box😊

  31. I just subscribed to FabFitFun and am a little bummed at the duplication of the RealHer lip products. Hopefully I will receive different shades, if not…off to the swaps!

    • I feel the exact same way! I just subbed to FFF. I picked the color I get from them, so hopefully I get something different & wearable from boxy.

  32. I’m happy with it! I’m a 50-year-old woman with very pale skin but I figure I can use just a tiny bit of those coloured eyeshadows in my regular eyeshadow look… I’m sure a small sweep Of one of those colours would be fun. The rest looks great to me. I don’t expect to love everything in every box …the anticipation and discovery are a huge part of the fun for me

  33. I would love these lip products and colors…which means I probably won’t get them, with my bad variation luck. But I’m always satisfied with Boxycharm’s overall value. That primer size alone costs more than 75% of the box price. And the product quality is consistently high. Seriously–how do they manage it every month?!?

    • The primer is a travel size. Just a head’s up.

  34. I cancelled BC for March. I had big fan brush already and too many eyeshadows. I tried the Smashbox primer before and not a fan. I didn’t know we are getting lip products from RealHer before cancelling. Since we’re getting are RealHer lip kit for FFF, as a annual member, I can choose the color I want. I’m glad I cancelled BC.

  35. Soooo glad i cancelled Boxy before i got charged for this one. None of this stuff interests me. I also get FFF too so im kinda already getting half the box 😉

  36. Definitely not feeling Boxy this month. The primer would be nice but I don’t need the fan brush, those eyeshadows aren’t super flattering on my Casper skintone and I got that brand of lipstick in my February box and it dries my lips out horribly. This will be a pass for me. Id rather go with Beauty Fix.

  37. I was on the waiting list for about a month I got off the waiting list and I’m getting this box and im not that exited about it I’ve read previous reviews and other boxes looked better I don’t know I might just have to wait to get the box and see..

  38. This will be my third box, and I’m so excited about this one, too! The Naked eye pallet is gorgeous, even though it’s a little out of my comfort zone. However, I’m always interested in trying new things, so I’m looking forward to experimenting! I think I found the brush on Crown’s website, SS023 DELUXE FAN, which is $18.99. If I just get the eyeshadow, the brush and the Smashbox primer, I’ll be a very happy camper!

  39. I am new to the sub boxes and signed up mid feb. was hoping for that box but alas was put on wait list. When I first saw the shadow colors I was hoping I’d stay on it. No idea how I’d use them or what for. But Then i got the email stating I was off the list. Agreed that FFF has the same lip brand so hoping no repeats. Not quite getting this months theme 🤔🤔

  40. Excited for everything!. I have no idea how to use that brush anyone have any tips?

    • I have a huge fan brush like that and use it to swipe off fallout or extra powder, it also eorks for blending down the cheek, but it’s too awkward to pick up product unless you’re adding shimmer to your shoulders or collarbone.

    • I use fan brushes for applying highlighter. Not sure if that is the intended use, but it works for me!

    • I have a big fan brush like this, I use it for contouring, make everything easier. If I remembered it correctly, Nikkietutorial had used it for contouring in her videos. Maybe you can check them out to get some inspirations~

  41. I thought we were getting a sample of the smashbox primer! 😱😱😱😱

    • No samples in BOXYCHARM, always full size😀 Sometimes sample of skincare though🤔

      • It’s always 4 Full size and the 5th is deluxe or travel size. The Smashbox isn’t full sized but it’s $16 worth. Not bad.

    • It’s listed above.

    • Its not a sample, it’s a “travel size”. Either way I’m stoked to try it! I’ve heard mixed reviews about this primer, so now I can try it out for myself 🙂

  42. Finally, I’m not bummed about being on the waitlist.

  43. Not excited at all considering I’m getting FFF. I’ll give one of them away but considering cancelling both since I don’t seem to be using the products and I’m gifting a lot. Have to wait until my fall box to be done fff.

  44. Not quite sure where the “creepy cute” theme comes into play, haha.

    • I think this was secretly tje halloween box and they just found it. It’s not creepy or cute though.

    • I don’t get the theme either. Is it because the eyeshadow colors are out there? Is it because of the brush (which kinda looks like a little animal)?

      From the pics on the instagram, it looks like the lip colors match two of the eyeshadow shades in the palette (the orange and the plum). Maybe they think wild colors and fat fluffy animal-like brushes are creepy and cute?

      I’m a little disappointed the Monsters liquid lipsticks rumors wasn’t true. That would have helped the creepy cute theme. Not sure why they would repeat Real Her lip products back to back like that for those subscribers who got that variation on the lip product last month. I’m hoping there are other brand variations (and not just color variations) on the lip product.

  45. Wonder what the variations will be, as I invariably get a variation (though I am NOT complaining as I always tend to get very high RV…usually much better than the original post).

  46. I want this box!! I love that lipstick and liner!

  47. Looks good. I just hope I dont get the same colors of Real Her that I am getting in FFF!

    • Agreed. Boxy Charm and FFF are my only boxes and I am kinda bummed I’ll most likely be getting repeats 🙁 hopefully they have variations of lips!

  48. Not very impressed with the fact that Real Her is being featured in both the spring fff box (which I will get in march) and the March boxycharm. I think it’s interesting that two of the box items for boxy are the real her. That being said, the crown brush looks so luxurious and I can’t wait to get my hands on it.

  49. I hope I don’t get the same Real Her colors here that I’m getting in FFF. Does anyone have any ideas how to use the eye shadow trio? If I was trying to replicate a bruise, this would be the perfect compact, but I have no idea how to make it look good.

    • You’ll want to dip into a neutral palette and pair with some browns or golds, maybe matte or satin. I will say this feels like autumn and not spring!

    • Usually there are spectacularly talented makeup you tubers that will give tutorials on using unique colors. They’ll break it down and you’ll be shocked at what they can do with non traditional colors. If I see any using similar colors I’ll come back to post.
      There is a guy on twitter who works with makeup artists and is a bit of a guru himself. Twitter a picture of the colors to Dave Lackie and he will help.

    • These colors are outside my normal comfort zone, too–but I sort of love it! I think any of the three colors would be fun under the lower lash line, with very neutral eye makeup above. I think the green would look amazing layered either above or below a bronze colored shadow. And I think the orange would be great to pair with neutrals/golds/browns for a summery look. Hope you have fun with the shadows 🙂

      • Great ideas!

      • Or if your me, you just wear the trio together and make a sunset look! It looks gorgeous, but it’s definitely too bold for most 🙂

        • I like the way you roll. 👍

          • Why thank you! I adore color on the eyes. My taste in apparel in very simple, so I accessorize with make-up.

  50. I’m sure the lip kit will be much more exciting for those who aren’t also subscried to FabFitFun, ha.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!