Posted by on in Mystery Boxes, POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: , , | 138 comments


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.


UPDATE: Here is the video showing all the products:

Here is the list of items:

Girls’ Night Out:

  • Makeup Eraser – Value $12
  • Henri Bendel Umbrella – Value $58
  • Kendra Scott Gold Bracelet – Value $50
  • Stowaway Cosmetics Palette – Value $25
  • Knock Knock Mirror – Value $10
  • Lalicious Shower Oil + Bubble bath – Value $28
  • Cargo Blush – Value $26
  • Smith & Cult Nail Polish – Value $18
  • Winky Lux Lipstick – Value $14

Girls’ Night In:

  • Kendra Scott Gold Bracelet – Value $50
  • Daily Concepts Hair Wrap – Value $18
  • Goldfaden MD Peel – Value $85
  • Dean + Deluca Tea – Value $10.75
  • NCLA Mani Kit – Value $16
  • Morning Culture Rise and Shine Mug – Value $16
  • Yellow Owl Workshop Stamp Kit – Value $19.50
  • Dessange Hair Oil – Value $12

We just got the POPSUGAR Must Have two exclusive Mystery Boxes and we’re going to do a video reveal of all the items in each box at 1 PM ET on Facebook Live! (You don’t need a Facebook account to watch the video – just visit our MSA Facebook page.)

FYI – the Girls’ Night In Box has sold out, but as of right now, the Girls’ Night Out Box is still available!

Screen Shot 2017-02-13 at 11.18.06 AM

The Box: Girls Night Out Box

The Cost: $24.95

The Products: Kicking off an evening out on the town by getting glam with the gals beforehand? Ladies, we’ve got you covered. Our Girls’ Night Out box is the kit you need to sparkle from head to toe. It features our previous Must Have hits worth over $200, so you can look your best all night long.

*Orders will ship within 7 to 10 business days via FedEx SmartPost. All Girls’ Night Out boxes contain the same assortment of products.

Screen Shot 2017-02-13 at 11.18.02 AM

The Box: Girls Night In Box SOLD OUT!

The Cost: $24.95

The Products: A cozy night in with your besties can be the perfect cure for the cold-weather blues. Luxuriate in self-care at home with our Girls’ Night In box, which features our Must Have products from past boxes. Each box includes $200+ worth of products. Staying in has never been more fun!

*Orders will ship within 7 to 10 business days via FedEx SmartPost. All Girls’ Night In boxes contain the same assortment of products.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. My girls night in box hasn’t shipped yet. Has anyone’s shipped yet?

    My girls night out box shipped last week.

    • I’m wondering the same thing. Were they already sold out when we when we ordered them or are they just shipping later?!?

    • I received the other box today. I contacted them about the girls box in. Hope to hear from them soon!

      • I did email them. I got a very generic response back about it shipping in the next few days. Let us know if you get anything different!

        • The response I got was that they were sorry tracking wasn’t updated and they would check on it and get back to me. Ill let you know what they say.

          • I got tracking for night in last night. I’m getting night out Saturday, night in Monday.

    • I just received my Girls Night In Box today!

    • Still haven’t heard back. Sent another email today and they said they’ll get back to me soon 🙁

  2. Wow how did I miss this? Lol 😝 loving the items(not that I don’t already have lots of these items and multiple of each but hey I do that with fav items)

  3. So happy!!! I sold my last Kendra Scott Bracelet for more than the cost of this box and now I can keep the rest without feeling bad about extra spending. Soon happy I stuck to only getting the girls night in box. It’s exactly what I wanted and will use! <33

  4. Both boxes are now sold out 🙁

    • I’ll sell you mine for cost+shipping +PayPal fees if you’re interested!

      • I am interested depending on the cost of shipping.

        • Oh just saw this. Send me an email. Swankyfandango at and we can chat.

  5. Both boxes look great! I am most interested in the Kendra Scott Gold Bracelet and the Dessange Hair Oil

  6. That dumb umbrella though…

    • Haha…that was what I thought when I received my 2nd and 3rd umbrellas…having been in a drought for several years. But now that it has been raining practically non-stop all winter, I haven’t minded having the extras…I have them stashed everywhere…and was actually kind of happy to be getting another one! 😉

      • Yeah, this is my 5th umbrella. And I live in Southern California, where until this winter, it never rained. 🙁 I can’t believe they put the bracelet in both boxes. Still trying to unload 2 others that I have–this is also my 5th Kendra Scott bracelet.

  7. I actually would have liked the Girls Night Out box and and am really sad I I didn’t see this in time to buy one:(

    • Shayna, if you’re on the swap boards, I’m posting it right now (has not arrived yet). Could also sell it on eBay.

      • Elizabeth – I would definitely purchase it from you!

        • Southernprincess–I’m working with Emily, but if it falls through, you’re next! Please email me: swankyfandango at

          • Hi, ladies! If anybody would like to purchase either or both of these from me (price paid + shipping), please email me at natalia.baage at gmail dot com. Thank you! 🙂

  8. Goodness, how many times can they repackage the same items and give it another name?

    • agreed, but these are WAY better than any of the boxes that came out.

    • I agree. I bought both boxes…I now have 3 or 4 cargo blushes, no one wants them!!! I have also doubled up or tripled up on just about everything else. I guess I’ll throw those items in my Christmas bin haha. I am excited about the bracelet (I must be the only one who doesn’t have one, now I have 2 haha) and the bath oil, myself and my daughter love it!

      If I didn’t already have most of this, WOW what a box/boxes!!! I would be thrilled, I am happy for most things, considering they only cost $25 each.

      That’s not that acid face peel is it? If so, I have rosacea cannot use. 🙁 Anyone want it or anything else? Email me at meanmus at

    • I completely agree. It’s still a great value, but good grief. I have 3 bracelets, well 3 of almost everything from the girls night out box lol and I’m not even a subscriber!
      Oh well, I’ll put it up for one off gifts!

  9. I need the Goldfaden MD Peel!

  10. Love Smith and Cult anything!!

  11. Both boxes look amazing! Disappointed I didn’t get to order the Girls Night In in time, but si happy I got the Girls Night Out!

  12. I’m glad I skipped. The girls night in turned out to be tempting, but if I’d ordered one, I thought girls night out would be best for me. I would have been disappointed!

    • It looks like the Girls night Out is still available.

  13. I love the Kendra Scott bracelet so much!

  14. If anyone is selling their night out box please let me know!!

    • I’m selling my Girls night out box for cost + shipping + any paypal fees.

      • I’d love to buy it from you! I have Venmo though not PayPal?

        • No PayPal only

      • Ann, I’m interested in buying your box if it’s still available.

        • Hey Rosemary!
          It’s available, I should have th box by Friday and I can ship it to you Monday. Email me at attucci at yahoo . Com to work out the details.

      • I’m interested.

        • Emily, you’re next if anything falls through with Rosemary.

    • I would like to swap out my entire girls night in box for a girls night out box?

      • I’m not interested in swapping box for box

      • I’ll swap you my Girls Night Out box for your Girls Night In box. I haven’t even opened it yet.

        • Hi…

          How do we go about doing this? I haven’t ever swapped before.


        • I wld love to swap my girls nite in box for ur girls nite Out box 🙂

          • Ok my box arrives on Saturday so shoot me an email to [email protected] and we’ll get it all sordid out!

  15. Kendra Scott bracelet!

  16. oh wow I’ve been wanting the bracelet and haven’t been able to swap for it yet. I’m glad now that I bought the night out box. 😉

  17. Man im so bummed i didnt purchase the night out box. Other than the umberella i would of loved it. Its not crossed out like the in box so i thought it was available but its not on there site.

  18. Lalicious Shower Oil + Bubble bath

  19. Oh man I really regret not getting the night out box! I just requested to join the swap site, but if anyone doesnt like theirs please let me know!

    • I’m swapping or selling mine when it arrives. Find me on the swap boards and request it!

      • I will do that! I requested to be added to the swap site, haven’t been accepted just yet! As soon as I am I will find yours, thank you

  20. Great boxes! I wish I would have gotten them. Thanks for the entertaining video. It would be fun to see y’all do more videos on this site!!!!

  21. Yay! If I get all the items listed for both boxes and no variations, I’m so glad I bought both! First time ever I will be using all the items! Thanks for the reviews!

    • There’s no variations.

  22. Thanks for doing the giveaway! Most excited for the bracelet (:

  23. You missed bath product in your list?

    • Oops! Thank you! Updating now!

  24. Pop sugar!! Pick me to win a box👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

  25. Off Topic…The two of you are adorable. You are the best couple. You made my face ache from smiling while I watched. 🙂

    • OMG thank you, CeeCee! That is so wonderful to hear 🙂

      • Liz,

        How do you get in on the swap? I bought the in box and would much rather received the out box.

        Thank you,

        • I posted the entire Night Out box if anyone is interested in swapping for Night In. Just click on my name.

      • Hi Liz, I came on here just to say that same thing as CeeCee! The video was super cute, and I really enjoyed the easy vibe you & Eric have. You two seem like you truly are best friends, and I find that so endearing in couples. 🙂

        • Aw, thanks so much, Luna! 🙂

    • Lalicious bath oil and
      Winky Lux lipstick!

    • Seriously me too… I was watching at work and people kept walking by so I had to try to stop smiling at my screen so I didn’t look silly but it was difficult… 🙂

  26. Loved watching you guys!

  27. Love the night out box!

  28. Love Buckles’ ‘help’ in the video! I’m glad I held off, because I own almost everything from past boxes and mystery boxes. Great overall value, though.

  29. Damn! I was hoping for Bingo. Seriously!

    • If you’re serious, I’ve got one in dire need of a new home! Are you on the swaps board? Pop me an email – dare2smile at gmail dot com!

    • I’ve got a unused & unopened bingo if you want to purchase it.

  30. The only item I don’t want is the nail polish since I just BOUGHT the exact same one on Birchbox website 😂 I’m happy with the rest though!

  31. Wow. So glad I didn’t order. I’ve only ever ordered one box from PS and I’ve gotten almost all of those items (in the out box).

    • Same! The only boxes I’ve ever received from Pop Sugar were the Rue La La Holiday Glamour Box and the January box, and almost everything was the same! Good products though, will be fun to gift.

  32. Great boxes, but with so many repeats of past mystery boxes and their boutique sale, I’d imagine the swap site will be FLOODED with umbrellas, Kendra Scott bracelets, Stowaway palettes, mugs, manicure sets, mirrors, Cargo blush, and brown sugar oil/bubble bath. I purchased one of each and will be gifting a bunch and swappingsome as well. Happy with the hair wrap, Smith & Cult polish, and probably ma st excited about the mask – I was hoping that would be in the night in box! With 8 items in each box, it breaks down to $3.13 an item. You can’t go wrong at that!
    I would love to see photos of how others organize their “swap & gift” accumulations. Mine is starting to take over. Perhaps I need to lay off the mystery boxes for awhile! Hmm, NO. 😊

    • How do you get on the swap? I ordered the in box and would much rather have the out box.


  33. In box:
    Rise and Shine Mug
    ORB Face Peel
    Hair Oil
    Shower Hair Wrap
    Little Manicure Set
    KS Bracelet (in both)

    Out box:
    Cargo Blush
    Nail Polish
    Bath and Shower Gel
    Bunny lipstick
    Make up eraser
    KS Bracelet.

    Wish I would have gotten the out box.. would use everything in that one.. oh well still like several items in the in box.

    • THANK YOU for posting this 🙂

    • Thanks Linda!

    • You forgot the dreaded stamp set in the in box.

      I’m aware that worse things have happened to people, but I’m disappointed that all of these are repeats from the last ones. What am I supposed to do with 3 bracelets and 3 umbrellas?!

      I want my #$/%&*÷ candle!

      • Seriously! The photo had the candle in it so it seemed like a safe bet. Who uses stamps during “girls’ night in?” Not me. I thought the Lalicious would come in the “in” box over the “out” box, so that’s disappointing cause I only bought the IN box. I’m not excited about most of the items in the box and hope, though doubt, I can swap most of the items.

        • My thoughts exactly! Bought “in” box thinking bubble bath, candle. Win-some, lose-some….I’ll make the most of it!

      • I have several of those candles that I may never use.

        • Hi Jordan! Are you on the swap site? I would gladly take some of those candles off your hands! Click my name for my swap page. 🙂 I’ll post some more items later this month.

      • Speaking of the photos, I was hoping the Stowaway lipstick trio was appear, as one of the lipsticks is in the photo! Seems a bit deceptive. But it’s a mystery box, so I can’t complain too much.

    • I’m just irritated because I bought 3 of the last mystery boxes and didn’t get the nail polish or the Kendra Scott bracelet in any of the 3. I did get 3 black hats though. I assumed they were out of the polish and bracelets or I would have bought these.

      • Kate–if you are on the swap site, I have 2 bracelets already on there, and will be adding these 2 as well. I can give you my swap info.

      • Hi Brandi, I got the In box and would be willing to trade multiple items from it. You can click my name to get to my swap page, though I’ll wait to post the items until I receive them.

    • Thanks so much for the list!!

  34. I chose the Girls Night Out box, and I have 4 of those items from swapping or from their other mystery boxes/boutique sales. But honestly, I’m not mad. The items I don’t already have I’m really happy with

  35. For not being a subscriber I’m so happy with both boxes! I definitely think these ones are a little better than the last mystery boxes. I’m thrilled that a lot of stuff in the girls night in box is coming from the January box (glad I waited on purchasing it). Also the kendra scott bracelet is perfect!

  36. I was sad that I missed the Night In box so went ahead and got the Night Out box on the 14th. So happy with the one I am getting. It has more items I will definitely use.

  37. Great boxes – if anyone wants to sell theirs let me know!

    • Hi Southern Princess! I bought both boxes and wish I knew the spoilers in advance (I already own almost everything). I’m more than happy to part with them.

      • Are you on the swap site?

        • I’m already a subscriber so most were repeats for me. I’m listing several items this evening.

      • How much for the out box?

      • @Natalia – are you on the swap board? Can you post your profile link?

        • Hi Southern Princess. I’m so sorry I missed this earlier a few days ago! I’m not on the swap board, but can sell the boxes to you, if interested. Let me know. 🙂

  38. Can someone list the spoilers? I can’t stream while at work!!

    • On the live spoilers they said they would be listing on the site and giving away one of each!

  39. So glad I didn’t get either. Great items but I already have everything. No more fomo.

  40. Both are sold out now!

  41. loved the video and so glad Eric & Buckles got to be part of them.

    • Thanks, Kim! They are my video support team! 🙂

  42. Oh man! Popsugar got me. I purchased the girls night out and I should have known better. Its the same as the last mystery box and the boutique items I also stocked up on. Oh boy! I for some reason I thought it would include other past items. *sigh* I will be making gift bags for friends now.

    • Can you please list the items here in comments? I tried FB but can’t view it. Thanks 🙂

    • How do you know what’s in it ? I don’t see anything on Facebook

    • Is it already on? I’ve been refreshing their FB for almost half an hour and I can’t see anything.

  43. I know I’m going to be sorry I didn’t get the girls night in.

    • I posted the girls night in on swap site. I would like to swap for the girls night out.

  44. At work…can’t stream FB…arrrghhhh…hopefully you post some spoilers the “old school way” online after!!! 🙂

  45. I’m confused – went to the Facebook page, but didn’t see anything live?

    • Me too ! I’ve been checking for the past 5 minutes lol

      • Same here >_<

  46. I went with FFF, but I still can’t wait to see whats in the Girls Night Out. Im curious to see if that pretty Smith and Cult nail polish will be in there.

    • Yes polish is there, stowaway, cargo blush, bath and shower gel, bunny lipstick, KS Bracelet.

      • Im laughing because I predicted the umbrella in the original post. I have 5 of these things already and I would only have liked the polish and the blush and the mirror and lipstick not so much so FFF was definitely the right choice for me.

      • I feel better now about skipping… I have all of those items.

  47. Night Out is sold out?

  48. Looks like a Stowaway lipstick…most likely the trio from quite awhile ago.

  49. both shoe sold out on pop sugars website

    • *both show soldout

  50. Fingers crossed!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!