MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

POPSUGAR Must Have Mini – December 2016 SPOILER!

Screen Shot 2016-03-22 at 1.11.05 PM

We have a spoiler for the December 2016 POPSUGAR Must Have Mini box thanks to the Smith & Cult facebook page! (Thank you to andreagullett for the head’s up!)

Each December Must Have Mini box will include:



Smith & Cult 1972 Nail Polish – Value $18

What do you think of the POPSUGAR Must Have Mini Box spoiler for December 2016? I LOVE the Smith & Cult nail polish formulas – so I’m thrilled with this spoiler! (Plus, it already covers the cost of the box!)

More info on this box:

The Box: POPSUGAR Must Have Mini Box

The Cost: $15.95

The Products: Introducing a smaller version of our box of curated, full-sized products including the best in fashion, beauty, and home for only $15.95, shipping included. Your subscription will auto-renew, so you get a little present every month!

Check out all of our POPSUGAR Must Have Mini box reviews!


How do subscribers rate POPSUGAR Must Have?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about POPSUGAR Must Have!

Enable notifications () to get the latest POPSUGAR Must Have spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in POPSUGAR Must Have Mini Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 54 comments

Comments (54)

  1. Doesn’t make me want it. I’ve had their polish before and hated it. Maybe I used it wrong? =)

  2. Not the same but “similar” Sally Hansen”Raisin the bar” is on sale right now for 3.99 on amazon, the 2 week gel version. I have the origional 3 free version and im pretty sure its a 100% dupe.
    But i think these 2 are more of rose “platnums” , while juleps May is more of a rose “gold”….
    Sorry, i sound like a polish snob but im not…i promise im not….someone help me 😣😋

    • Ain’t nothin’ wrong with being a polish snob. 🙂 Now that I’ve seen swatches, I do agree that this is quite pretty. But I’m still surprised at how many people are swooning over this when there are *so many* gorgeous polishes out there in so many different finishes.

      • I’m a polish addict (and at times a polish snob) with around 200 Juleps and a 3-foot chest of drawers converted into a polish station with everything from indies like Enchanted Polish, ILNP, Vapid, Square Hue, Rainbow Honey, Glisten & Glow, Llarowe, etc. – to drugstore like Orly, SH, and Sinful Colors – to high end like Louboutin, Marc Jacobs, Dior, and Burberry – and everything in between from Zoya, to Nails Inc, to Urban Decay, NARS, Butter London, Deborah Lippmann and MAC. I use and love all of it for various reasons and nail art. (All this doesn’t even take into account my nail wraps.)

        I signed up for this box for the ’72 polish because I love the color and I love the brand. I also really like the formula. S&C’s Suburban Warrior is one of my favorite hot pinks ever. And the bottles are nice to display (and heavy / sturdy with little risk of falling over).

        And for any of you old-skool’ers out there, the owner of Smith & Cult (Dineh Mohajer) founded Hard Candy (back in the day of department stores and plastic rings on top. She sold Hard Candy in ’99. OG! 🙂

    • Gorgeous!

    • Thank you so much for sharing this. After seeing the color I think I will be ordering! You were very helpful.

    • Wow! Thanks so much for the link to the swatches, Patricia!

      It actually looks quite different than what I was hoping for- so you saved me some extra $ and a bit of future disappointment 😉

      Thanks again & Happy Holidays!

  3. I’ll pass. Polish is one thing I can live without. I wouldn’t wear this color on my nails either. Not my style.0

  4. Does anyone have experience ordering this box? I will definitely bite if this item is guaranteed to be in every single box. I’ve been eyeing this polish for a while, this almost seems to good to be true…

    • Hey! It is guranteed to be in every box 🙂

  5. If y’all are this excited about this polish, I don’t know what you would do if you ever saw an indie brand polish or a holographic polish. This is pretty enough, if you like plain.

  6. The only time I have been tempted to subscribe- and, yes, I gave in!!!

    • Oof, same, I couldn’t resist! I made it a one-time gift subscription, though, so that I can’t forget to cancel after I snag this polish. Between this, the MSA discount on the regular must-have sub, and the mystery boxes, popsugar is getting all of my money this month!

      • Me too!! Nice to learn I’m not alone in my popsugar addiction 🙂

  7. I had to resubscribe!! 👏🙈🙉🙊 I was born in 1972 and tomorrow (11-30) is my birthday!! Totally meant to be! 😄 The color is beyond gorgeous!! 💅 I’m sooo happy I did the 6 month upgrade and now I’ll have my Mini Box back! Happy Birthday to me!! 🎂

    • That’s perfect – happy birthday!!

    • That’s why I signed up – I’m Nov 28 ’72! Happy belated birthday!!!

  8. Now that’s the wow factor I expect from a spoiler!

    • RIGHT? Let’s hope they keep this up…

  9. This is so pretty. I surprised myself when I caved on the fashion and beauty mystery box last night. Now I want to try this.

  10. That would be nice if it is in the main box, but it sounds like it’s not. That’s definitely something i would use. I’m always happy to get something i can use. I still have the bingo box telling myself to take it up to the senior center.

    • That’s exactly what I did! My mom runs the senior center in our county and they were more than happy to get my “extra” bingo boxes 🤗

    • That’s so funny! I hear so many people complain, and I was one of the people that wanted that box. I thought it would be fun with the kids on game night. Instead, I got 2 with the charger and necklace… that I already had. Now I have 3. I figure the stuff makes for great gifts, since everyone likes different stuff. If you have a friend with kids, consider giving it to the family for Christmas!

  11. I love this polish but need to quit buying things before Christmas because I won’t even be here to receive them! Might start this subscription up in January though since I dropped BB.

  12. I’ve been wanting the mini ever since the August box with the lined notepad. I’m a sucker for pens and paper. I was hoping for special on the mini but it didn’t happen so I finally signed up with this spoiler. I’m going to have to start sending subs to work to hide my addiction, haha.

    • That’s a good idea. I think my hubby is starting to get annoyed… and I got a few new ones with the deals last week… eek!

  13. Thanks to subscription boxes, I have completely fallen in love with Smith & Cult products. I don’t need the mini, or more nail polish, but that color is gorgeous!

  14. I LOVE that color!! Can’t wait to get it 🙂

  15. man, they love rose gold

  16. Just checked and my PSMH Reg. December box has already been charged and is processing.

  17. How many other items come in the mini boxes, usually?

    • Usually, it’s one other item. Occasionally they’ve included a 3rd bonus item. Hope that helps! 🙂

      • Very much, thanks! I have a hard time justifying even a $10-12 bottle of OPI or Essie because I know eventually they will go on sale and I already have so many! But rose gold…

      • Hi liz! Could u tell me do they bill on dec 1st or around the 20th before the box ships? Thanks in advance!

  18. Liz, your description of the box has the old cost. (:

    • Oops! Missed that one! Thanks! 🙂

  19. Even though I don’t need more polish this is so pretty and I have never tried this brand.

  20. Glad I passed! I’ve been thinking about the mini, but I don’t need more nail polish. I had a horrible allergic reaction to the Smith & Cult lip gloss I’m too afraid to try anything else lol.

    • The lipgloss is one thing that sold me on this. I don’t usually like it, and that one looks so great on me, and my hair doesn’t get stuck in it! 🙂

  21. Looks good but I’ll hold off for the full spoiler in case it’s decorative toothpicks or something.

    • LOL- I’m with you!

  22. Well, that was a no brainer. I have been searching for this exact polish and it truly is sold out everywhere. Nicely done PopSugar! And now I feel even better about my decision not to buy mystery boxes this time around.

  23. I really am not a fan of the mini, especially after getting such great black friday deals and getting the regular box for $20/month but that Smith & Cult polish was too much to pass up. I am weak 🙂

    • Same here. I’ve never been tempted by the Mini and the regular deals are so much more cost effective but I love this polish (suddenly after seeing this picture) and I can’t get it anywhere else based on my quick research. WEAK!

      • Me three! I love this formula and it looks like a great color and the cost of the box is less that the cost of the polish so the other item is just a bonus, but I’ll definitely be cancelling after the one box.

      • Ditto! The price on the Mini has always seemed too high for the contents especially compared to the regular box but this spoiler got me. Such a beautiful polish and perfect for upcoming holiday events! Went ahead and cancelled right after purchase so I wouldn’t forget!

      • Can I do that already? I don’t want it forever, I just wanted this polish! If I cancel now, will I still get the box or will they refund me? Thanks!!

      • Can’t you just do it as a one time gift and it won’t renew. It should just be the one box.

      • I cancelled two minutes after purchasing and it shows my account as still having one “credit.” It said I won’t be charged for any future months but that I would receive boxes until my existing credits run out. My money was not refunded. I’m just so forgetful, so I chose to do it this way. Hope that helps!

  24. So pretty

  25. The spoiler got me! I don’t normally get the mini box and it’s never seemed like a good deal to me, but I love Smith & Cult and can’t resist rose gold.

  26. Gorgeous color!! Perfect for the holidays.

  27. MMM. I almost bought this polish. Glad I held off! Nice!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.