The Better Beauty Box Subscription Review – September 2016

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.


The Better Beauty Box is a natural and organic beauty box geared for tween and teen girls. There is a box option which includes age appropriate makeup items or a makeup free box which includes no makeup at all. This review is for the box with makeup included.

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)


The Subscription Box: The Better Beauty Box

The Cost: $20 a month + free shipping, with 3-, 6- and 12-month subscription options. The Make-up Free box is $16 a month.

The Products: 5 natural, safe and/or organic products geared for teen girls (a mix of full-sized, travel and trail sized)

Ships to: US

Check out all of our The Better Beauty Box reviews and the Beauty Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!


The information card was pasted into the lid of the box. The products and their corresponding values are listed on the card.



Cirque Colors Mini Nail Lacquer – Value $5.00

This Circque Colors Nail Lacquer is a mini and I don’t see that size for sale on their website so I linked to the full size. The color is XX which is a fun polish made with 20 different types of holographic glitter. It’s also a 3-free polish meaning it doesn’t contain toluene, formaldehyde or dibutyl phthalate (DBP). Circque recommends using this glitter polish over another base color, but I used it directly on my bare nail with two coats so you could see the true glitter effect.


Moody Sisters Organic Mascara (full size!) – $12.50

This mascara is organic, vegan and water resistant. I received a matte black color and it gave me a very natural look. This wouldn’t be the tube I’d reach for to give me dramatic going out long lashes, but it’s perfect for a daytime casual look. I think it’s great for a teen (the intended box demographic) because it doesn’t look like falsies. It also had a very pleasant smell.


Malibu Soapworks Brush Wash – $10.00

What a great idea to include brush wash in a tween/teen beauty sub. It’s so important to teach girls just starting to use makeup the importance of keeping their beauty tools clean. This brush wash is organic and vegan. Instead of a liquid brush cleanser, it’s a solid cake. You wet your brushes then swipe them back and forth over the brush shampoo to create lather. The wash is made with coconut water, olive oil, coconut oil, avocado oil and kosher food-grade sodium hydroxide. It’s safe for synthetic and natural brushes.


E.L.F. Shine Erasers – $1.00

These blotting sheets help absorb oil without having to apply powder. This slim pack fits nicely in your bag without taking up much space and contains 50 sheets.


Keeki Pure & Simple Organic Lip Balm – $3.49

Keeki is a new brand discovery for me. This lip balm is 100% organic and 100% edible (makes sense for something that we end up ingesting!), soy free and gluten free. There may be variations on the flavors received in the box since the information card didn’t specify. I got Rootbeer Float which is okay, but not my favorite. I might have to try out the Lemon Meringue Pie though, because I love citrus flavors and this formula was very moisturizing. The cap has a clip making it easy to attach to your backpack.

Moody Sisters Pore Refining Facial Scrub – sample

This coarse facial scrub felt had a wonderful minty fresh smell. It’s organic, vegan and handmade in the US. I can’t attest to the pore-refining claims from the small sample, but I liked how it smelled and left my skin feeling cleansed but not at all greasy. Moody Sisters also recommends using this scrub on rough hands, feet or elbows.

Verdict: I’m so happy with my The Better Beauty Box again this month. I love how this box aims to introduce tweens and teens to natural beauty alternatives and isn’t too heavily based on make-up. I also think this box is great for adults who are more natural in their beauty routines. The value this month came to more than $32 (including the sample) which I’m very happy with.

What do you think of this month’s The Better Beauty Box? If you’ve tried the The Better Beauty Box I’d love to know if you ordered it for yourself or for a teen/tween.

How do subscribers rate The Better Beauty Box?

2 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to The Better Beauty Box? Add your rating now!

Written by Jessica Telesmanich

Jessica Telesmanich

Jessica’s addiction started off slowly enough with Birchbox, but it has grown and grown over the last three years. An elementary school librarian and mom of two she loves boxes that are child-centric. But she’ll never turn down a good fashion, beauty or tasty treat subscription.

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Makeup Subscription Boxes, New Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women, The Better Beauty Box Reviews| Tags: the better beauty box | 6 comments


  1. Great review.

    • Thank you! ?

  2. I haven’t been a teen in awhile, but I just started a subscription to this box. The brush cleanser is fantastic. I plan to order several to add to upcoming birthday and Christmas gifts.

  3. This is a great little box. Introducing teens to nice, clean beauty products is a great idea!

  4. Ooh, Cirque is a really nice brand to see in a box! I’m also impressed by the inclusion of two different products Rom a company like Moody Sisters.

    • I agree, they’re sending some great brands and products.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!