Posted by on in Boxycharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 41 comments

BoxyCharm September 2016 Spoiler #2!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.


We have more spoilers for the September 2016 Boxycharm subscription box!

Each September 2016 Boxycharm subscription box will include:

Screen Shot 2016-09-02 at 4.41.39 PM

STUDIOMAKEUP On-The-Go Eye Shadow Palette in Warm Up (Not available for sale yet)

AND the following brands:


What do you think of the latest September 2016 Boxycharm spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers for any future spoilers, too!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Sorry if this gets posted twice, but I am not seeing my original comment.

    New spoiler on the Boxycharm Instagram.

    Boxes will contain either a brush from Vasanti, a polish from Butter or a Lippie from Butter.

    • And of course the original comment is there now. Sorry folks! ?

  2. New spoiler on the Boxycharm Instagram.

    Each box will receive either a Vasanti brush, Butter London Polish or a Butter London Lippie.

    • Thanks for letting us know!!

      • ?

  3. I love Boxycharm!! And i love eyeshadows and makeup. I just wish to see some color , i am tired of warm and nudes.
    I also wish to get foundation and powder. I am overstocked with eyeshadows and always lacking this

    • I suppose it would be difficult to do foundation considering the box is not acustomize box for each customer and there are so many different skin tones. They did send a concealer sometime last year and so many people were angry because it was not a color that would twork for them. We did receive a pressed matifying powder from Ofra Cosmetics. It was recently, I’m thinking June or July.

  4. When do they usually reveal what’s in the box? It’s my first month with boxycharm 🙂 ! I was with ipsy before. Do they usually reveal the box at the beginning of the month?

  5. I love Boxycharm. Allure is a great box also. I think those two, Sephora play, Ipsy, Walmart and target is enough for me. My gosh, I have boxes full of stuff that I haven’t even tried yet! ?

    • I have the exact same subscriptions!

  6. I’ve been thinking about signing up for BoxyCharm for a long time. The values are always so high compared to the cost of the box. And now that I’ve quit Birchbox I have the money to spare. The eyeshadow palette sealed the deal. I love a neutral eye with a lot of mascara. Can’t wait to get this box! ❤️

    • Yes! I have had this box since May and it’s my fav. I also get Ipsy and Sephora play, and even though this one is more, boxycharm blows both out of the water. Hope u like boxycharm as much as I do!

      • Boxycharm is by far the best subscription box I have tried…. And I have tried A LOT…….. ?

    • Try allure! I love their stuff

  7. I really loved how boxycharm spoilers were released early! Kind of bummed that this is all the info we have gotten so far :-/

  8. I love the first spoiler even though i barely wear make up anymore. Getting to be too old to feel like getting Purdy up lol but the value. Lol I hate being one of those that base on value but it makes it so tempting

  9. I really like their palettes, but does anyone else think the colors look a little…drab?

  10. I am excited about the palette, I love them! This box is always worth the money.

  11. I can’t say exactly why I think this, but I feel like the vasanti product is going to be their brighten up exfoliating scrub. Doesn’t BoxyCharm usually do at least one skin care item? (I’m new so I’m not sure), and the exfoliating scrub has been in a few other sample boxes before so…who knows, I could be totally wrong, but it will be interesting to see if my guess is correct!

    • Oh that would be nice. I’m just about to run out of my scrub so I need a new one!

  12. So are we only receiving 4 items this month?

    • or we are getting two things from the same brand?

      • I know I’m wondering? Well the month we got the Z pallet I think was July, we only got 4 items but I think they concidered the z pallet an item which I’m all for because I loved it but hmmmm their must be another spoiler ?

        • I really hope we get more spoilers soon or even the box reveal would be nice!!! It’s already sept 3!!!!

  13. I love the palette!! But I absolutely don’t need anymore palettes or eyeshadows and don’t want to sub to boxycharm again. But I love the palette!!

  14. I think Boxycharm is being very coy and mysterious this month. Grrr! I do love the eyeshadow palette. But I need more details.

  15. I contemplated cancelling since we just received the ofra shadows a couple months ago in basically the same shades and I don’t really do much eye shadow. BUT even though it says it’s not on sale yet, the same looking palette is on the site for sale for $49.95. Don’t know if it’s exactly the same or not but it looks to be about the same.

  16. Haha, I went on a Butter London binge a few months ago (there were a lot of good closeout sets from Beauty Bar on Amazon) so hopefully it will at least be a different color of polish/lippie/eyeliner than I bought back then.

  17. Yay so happy I resubbed yesterday =D I hope the nail polish doesn’t get taken out of my box at customs again and replaced with another item.

  18. Sounds sweet!

    • I think the PUR product is ‘Lip Lure Hydrating Lip Lacquer’ – it says on their site “as seen in Boxycharm”. 😀
      I like it – now if only I could get the beige color — not another red or peach!!

      • I don’t think they took down the BoxyCharm thing. I went to check the product out and didn’t see that anymore. Which just makes it more likely that’s what we are getting. Guess they jumped the gun. Good thing you caught it in time!

      • Lol! So much for them being mysterious! i hope to get Belle or Mystic from the lip lure colors. Looks good!

      • You are a super sleuth! I would also totally dig a beige color.

  19. Anyone know the latest date you can sign up to get the September box?

    • As long as you sign up in September before the last day of the month you will get September box 🙂

    • All of September

    • You can receive a September box anytime during the month of September right until the 30th, unless they have sold out of the box before the last day (30th).

      • I’m so not used to beauty boxes being like that, so when I ordered last month I assumed this month would be my first. But I ended up getting last month’s box after all, which is unfortunate because there wasn’t anything I wanted. But oh well, live and learn!

    • as long as you sign up in the month of September, you’ll get the September box.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!